It does not matter if fusion reactions last microseconds if they generate more energy. Using optimistic, but not unrealistic assumptions, it appears feasible for electricity costs to reach $25 per MWh[1] with ICF. With the most important factors driving cost being achieving high gain and yield per shot
[0]https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/650904/
[1]https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsta.2020.005...
https://www.statista.com/statistics/263492/electricity-price...
1. Move to supercritical Co2 turbines (lower mass —> lower cost), need RnD on corrosion resistant alloys
2. Move to thermoelectric or photovoltaic generators
3. Use aneutronic fusion
Directly use the charged particles
2. photovoltaic generators seem popular, but the don't require spending money on a fusion core.
3. The problem is hard, so let's replace it with a harder one?
Here's a NYTimes article[1] about various companies attempting laser fusion for power production. One of them has an approach very similar to NIF's, and a couple others are similar but do away with the need for a hohlraum by using a different type of laser. They also say:
"A decade ago, a report[2] by the National Academy of Sciences found much to like in the energy potential of laser fusion but recommended that the United States hold off major investments until ignition was achieved. That time is now."
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2023/11/13/science/laser-fusion-ener...
[2] https://nap.nationalacademies.org/catalog/18289/an-assessmen...
Is what they did interesting sure, but alot of people who actually follow fusion development know that this was a PR meme that some news stretched.
Fusion has always been 20 years away its a literal meme....and yet we are making good advancements in the field but I think anyone with a basic understanding or those who realized this was so short lived results time wise realised it was an overhyped thing by media from this group.
Fusion is important to the government because they can theoretically squeeze more power out of nuclear weapons, but due to the difference in timescale zit just dosnt translate across domains of military to public energy that well
The Desert Storm conflict cost something like $1T (yes a Trillion dollars) just for gasoline.
There was on this site a description of a military effort to create a low-yield fusion generator that would fit on a military truck. It only had to fuel a mobile camp, not a city. If I recall, it was something like the Lockheed plan, to create a vortex (not a torus) to stuff the fuel through a constriction and get some kind of fusion yield. Wasteful, but not as wasteful as $1T
Here's an estimate of the costs of air conditioning tents in the mideast conflicts: https://www.npr.org/2011/06/25/137414737/among-the-costs-of-...
Large scale facilities really are not all that interesting. They concentrate cost, danger and impose lots of logistical limitations.
I've never heard of them looking into similar fusion reactors. Why would they? Nobody expects to build any kind of production fusion reactor for decades, much less one that could be operated by infantry soldiers and in very difficult conditions - e.g., explosions and people shooting at the reactor.
another word for that is "drone target."
Generators are cheap and replaceable, and they can keep spares in the depot.
A fusion reactor sounds like big bucks to me.
Do you mean researchers and other experts, or people who follow it? And does that include you? Are you a researcher?
I'm just a guy that like to follow the research in hopes of clean cheap energy...the cheaper the better
We already have fusion weapons that work very well, there is some valuable data that can aid weapons design I don't believe that to be a primary goal here. Looks like they did shift to plutonium targets for a while about a decade ago focusing more on weapons research but then shifted back to trying to work toward controlled ignition for power generation.
Still a long way to go but the first step is getting more energy out then in on the main reaction without using fission bombs and destroying the device. Then figure how to scale up to get more energy out than in when considering the apparatuses efficiency, then getting more out than in when considering heat engine efficiency.
Both valid points of discussion, but different ones.
I think you answer your own question.
NIF does a lot more than weapons. Ignition is also a different problem than sustaining a fusion reaction, but both are important aspects of the fusion energy generation problem. You can think of this like the difference between static friction and kinetic friction. You would never try to generate power by performing tons and tons of ignitions. You generate power by doing the ignition and then sustaining the reaction. There's even people working on setups just like this. You can see how ITER works here[0]. You can modify this procedure to have laser based ignition (or some other form) and then feed this into the toroidal reactor. There's a bunch of ideas out there but I think this is the most straightforward.
As to a more systematic approach to answering "why" and why this type of language is pervasive regardless of the domain, is because a lot of people have a difficult time differentiating TRLs[1]. Or maybe even more bluntly, research from products. I think it won't be hard to find high rated HN comments on research works that come out of universities who's critique is that the process is expensive and doesn't beat current industrial processes, but this is a grave misunderstanding of how technological progress happens. It's overly dismissive. Technology often progresses by iterative discontinuous S-curves, which at a zoomed out level looks more smooth. So new technology often starts off way worse but the key part of this is the theoretical maximum. A good example of this might be in batteries or solar panels. People are highly dismissive of any technology that is yet to become a product (TRL 6-7-ish). Which it is good to not jump to assertions that a low TRL result means new products, but it's the same type of error, just in the other direction. Either way, critical context is being ignored.
I think if we more appropriately contextualized technological development then we wouldn't have these issues. I don't like them either tbh. I'd rather be honest. But truth has bounded simplicity and lies don't. Since a lot of people ignore nuance it creates an incentive system to exaggerate or leave out important details. Frustrating, but understandable. Hopefully understanding can help us to disrupt this systematic incentive system and instead promote more nuanced and honest discussions. But I think we need to recognize expertise does not transfer between domains well and discourage claims and comments that lack nuance. But nuanced and accurate comments require more words, so we might just be fucked and this is just a pipedream. Some people think we can't rely on humans being nuanced and intelligent creatures but I'm not convinced and more convinced these are just products of environmental pressures. I guess we'll see.
[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5tH4obUsY64
[1] https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/somd/space-communications-...
"months to load up" is even a euphemism - IIRC they have to repair parts of the lasers which are so overpowered that they damage their guidance optics with each blast. So the cost for one shot is even higher than the $100,000 for the fuel pellet and the cost of the energy consumed by the lasers. I wonder why everyone skirts around the obvious here: the NIF's task is weapons research, and for that, fusion reactions which last nanoseconds might be enough, but there is no way this method can be scaled up so it's actually a cost-effective way of producing electricity...