One clue for future reference - the linked article had to clarify the meaning of the word _in the title_. That strongly indicates to me that, even if in certain areas the word is well understood, the author expected there to be confusion.
- succinct
- also applied to governments
Misleading title indeed.
This makes sense. It’s not about how much you make, it’s about how much you keep. Someone making $5m/year can still spend more than that.
If drawing down on investments counts, I suppose the baby boomers are going to skew this number for years to come as they shift from saving for retirement to spending in retirement.
> Personal income as defined by BEA differs substantially from adjusted gross income (AGI), the principal income measure used by the Internal Revenue Service.
So it explicitly is not the same as the IRS definition of income.
> For the measurement of personal income, employer contributions to pension plans are counted as part of supplements to wages and salaries. Employee contributions to the plans, capital gains of the plans, and payments of benefits by the plans are not counted as part of personal income.
I believe they consider a 401k to be a defined contribution pension plan. I know normally you wouldn't call a 401k a pension and you wouldn't talk about "payments of benefits" from a 401k, but in context (page 32) I think that is what they mean. So it seems like the amount your employer contributes to your 401k counts as income for that year, any additional voluntary amount you contribute doesn't count, and when you withdraw money that also doesn't count. Maybe I'm misunderstanding but that is my reading.
> Personal Income isn’t the only source of household assets. The two big missing pieces are holding (capital) gains on assets, and borrowing (which adds both assets and liabilities, in equal amounts, to household balance sheets). Adding these two additional measures does shift most bottom quintiles from spending deficits to asset surpluses in most years.
> While many have suggested that borrowing is what explains households’ ability to keep spending (it is, some), overwhelmingly it’s holding gains that “fund” the perennial dissaving of the bottom 80%.
So this is actually mostly explained by richer people who have significant investments in addition to their normal income.
Edit: The BEA says Personal Income "does not include realized or unrealized capital gains or losses." So if you sell stocks, a house, pull money out of a 401k, none of that is included in Personal Income.
Also, I think like ~20% of Americans are retired? Presumably most of them would be considered dissavers here, except for those who retired with almost no savings and are living solely on Social Security.