News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by paulddraper on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:02PM (#39149211)
> We are still reviewing the technical details but are extremely disappointed with Apple’s proposed plan to restrict the newly-announced BrowserEngineKit to EU-specific apps,” DeMonte says. “The effect of this would be to force an independent browser like Firefox to build and maintain two separate browser implementations — a burden Apple themselves will not have to bear.”

I guess they were hoping that the EU's rules apply everywhere?

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by rideontime on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:07PM (#39149276)
EU's mandate of USB-C on phones is resulting in benefits for the rest of the world too, it's understandable to hope for the same in this case. Apple must have a lot to gain from keeping the other markets locked down if they're willing to invest the necessary time & money to maintain different guidelines like this.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by hellotomyrars on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:26PM (#39149572)
The impact to Apple’s bottom line is very different. Maintaining regional SKUs for hardware would be much more expensive for Apple than just acquiescing to the mandate. Software doesn’t have nearly the same issues as physical goods when it comes to splitting feature by region, especially considering the goal will be to keep things more advantageous for apple in as many regions as possible for as long as possible. They can always flip the switch if/when they have to.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by alphabettsy on Friday January 26, 2024 @11:21PM (#39152534)
They already have different SKUs. US iPhones lost the SIM tray a year or two ago while it still exists in Europe.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by burnte on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:35PM (#39149720)
The cost of maintaining the restrictions in the EU are minimal, while it's trivial to buy phones in the EU and ship them out, and each additional hardware SKU is expensive. It's effectively "if location = EU then (features) else (lolgtfo)".
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by bloppe on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:34PM (#39149705)
The regulatory process is focused on outcomes. Here, the desired outcome is fair browser engine competition. If Apple's rules appear unfair to the EU (as they probably will, since they probably will not create robust competition), then the directive will adapt to make that shortcoming clearly prohibited. Apple can kick the can down the road a couple times, but this process is not finished until browser competition on iOS is deemed fair.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by darklion on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:57PM (#39149963)
> this process is not finished until browser competition on iOS is deemed fair.

But, by the same token, the laws as put into place outline none of the specifics of how that should actually function. All the EU did was wave its hand, say “browsers, please” and assumed that magically a perfect outcome would occur.

Well, now that lack of clarity is biting the EU in the ass, because it left Apple a ton of wiggle room. What Apple has announced of 17.4 changes is essentially a lawyer’s answer to the actual legal requirements imposed on them, not the ones the EU were implying.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by floydnoel on Friday January 26, 2024 @10:57PM (#39152382)
> lawyer’s answer to the actual legal requirements imposed on them, not the ones the EU were implying.

do you think that the regulators did that on purpose, or are they simply not competent enough to understand the implications?

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by turquoisevar on Friday January 26, 2024 @11:35PM (#39152603)
It’s mainly on purpose.

The more specific they get and the more prescriptive they are in how a business should do business, the easier it is to get it overturned in court.

That’s also the reason why the DMA doesn’t contain price regulation, because the first question a judge will ask is why is necessary and how they landed in the price.

The inverse is also true though. By using vague terminology like “reasonable”, they have more wiggle room to argue one way or another once it gets before a court.

At that point you then have to cross your fingers that the court not only finds that your reading of the vague language is the one true reading, but also that the reading itself is in line with the rest of the laws.

Contrary to what people seem to think about the EU, it isn’t some benevolent dictatorship that can put a wishlist to paper and then it’s some law of nature that can’t be contested.

The makers of the DMA are legislative bodies and the EC that enforces it is an executive body. Both need to work within the limitations of the law and the European courts will be the arbiters of that.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by paulddraper on Friday January 26, 2024 @06:08PM (#39150086)
The complaint: Apple can use its own browser in non-EU markets, but Firefox cannot use its own browser in non-EU markets.

That gives Apple an "advantage"...but the nature of the advantage originates outside the EU.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by dmz73 on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:28PM (#39149627)
Since anyone could travel to EU at any time and then the EU rules apply, either Apple must allow all their phones to follow the EU rules if user says they are in EU jurisdiction, or Apple should get a fine for non compliance.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by St0n3d on Friday January 26, 2024 @06:44PM (#39150484)
That’s not how international laws and customs work. Besides, be careful what you wish for since if they’d follow that line of thought you’re in for a 20-25% tax plus an import fee for importing electronic devices from a different jurisdiction. (Also, the non-compliancy would be your doing as importer; not Apple’s.)
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by kmeisthax on Friday January 26, 2024 @07:54PM (#39151119)
The current word on the street is iOS has a daemon that checks Wi-Fi, cell carrier, and GPS data to determine if the user's in the EEA or not, specifically so they can gate these profit-diminishing features to the minimum possible jurisdiction. Ergo, if you fly to the EU, you can install all this shit, and presumably it disables itself the moment you fly back to the US.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by albert180 on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:04PM (#39149233)
Well if the EU manages to hold a hard line against Apple, other big markets will surely follow.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by nickthegreek on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:07PM (#39149274)
I feel like ‘surely follow’ will be measured in many years. The idea of not allowing competing browser engines on iOS has struck me one of Apples more egregious sins. Ideally I could be running Firefox prior to 2030 in the US, but I don’t trust our government’s pace to bet on it.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by albert180 on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:12PM (#39149358)
Well if Safari wouldn't intentionally suck, more people would choose to use Progressive WebApps instead of going through all the hassle of creating a dedicated iOS App
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by threeseed on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:22PM (#39149518)
Progressive Web Apps have been around for nearly a decade.

Every year there is some excuse (usually missing API X) why they aren't a success.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by blueelephanttea on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:55PM (#39149951)
Also I have been testing out PWAs in various different browsers (non-Safari) this last month and...ahem...I have been unimpressed.

I also think ad tech companies will prefer native apps for major markets (iOS) because it is tougher to block ads. PWAs tend not to support content blockers at the moment, but there certainly can.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by Terretta on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:23PM (#39149528)
I do Xbox Cloud Gaming in a PWA on iPad with my Xbox controller.

What does your app do that's so special it needs more than a console game?

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by scarface_74 on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:20PM (#39149484)
You mean like all of the people who choose to use PWAs for Android?

I’ve never once heard anyone say “you know Electron is such a great experience on the desktop, I would love to have all my mobile apps to be web based too”.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by albert180 on Friday January 26, 2024 @06:04PM (#39150041)
App Development for Android is much easier. No Bullshit recurring Fees, no need to buy specific Google Hardware etc...
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by scarface_74 on Friday January 26, 2024 @06:19PM (#39150223)
How many different Android devices does a serious developer need to buy to ensure their app works well across the spectrum from the top end Android phones to the sub $100 Blu R1 phones?

How many different versions of the operating system do they need to support because of how soon Android phones are abandoned by the manufacturers?

But this still doesn’t answer the question, if PWAs are so great on Android, then why are the same companies who are making iOS apps making Android apps instead of just telling Android users to use the web version?

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by albert180 on Friday January 26, 2024 @07:04PM (#39150657)
None, there is a decent emulator included with Android Studio
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by scarface_74 on Friday January 26, 2024 @07:14PM (#39150765)
And you think the emulator actually takes the place of real live hardware, the quirks , the performance, etc?
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by johnnyanmac on Saturday January 27, 2024 @02:27PM (#39158921)
depends on the complexity of the app. An app that can reasonably be a PWA (e.g. it is more or less a webpage wrapped in an APK) can probably be tested well enough on a dozen emulator pofiles and a few physical devices you have lying around.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by scarface_74 on Saturday January 27, 2024 @04:29PM (#39160026)
And those are the very apps that are going to run worse on low end devices with poor rendering performance…
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by alphabettsy on Friday January 26, 2024 @11:22PM (#39152542)
Can guarantee you’ve never shipped an Android app at any notable scale. You need many more devices to validate Android apps.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by paulddraper on Sunday January 28, 2024 @11:27PM (#39172677)
You need only one, to run the emulator.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by albert180 on Friday January 26, 2024 @06:17PM (#39150201)
South Korea already forced Apple to allow other payment processors, I guess China will follow surely suit if the EU is successful. If that happens, it doesn't matter that much anymore if the US follows or not
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by Terretta on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:22PM (#39149519)
You say "browser engine" Apple says "surveillance engine".

Only one of these definitions just cost Google $5 billion settlement for tracking Chrome incognito mode users.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by turquoisevar on Friday January 26, 2024 @11:38PM (#39152619)
Many years would be an understatement.

From investigation to enforcement to adjudication all the way to the ECJ you’ll be looking at roughly 10 years.

Once all of that has played out, maybe some other jurisdiction might then decide to copy some parts.

We haven’t even entered the pre-investigation phase in which the EU will wag their fingers.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by yreg on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:09PM (#39149314)
That won't help with the inconvenience of having to maintain two apps.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by staplers on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:27PM (#39149608)
California in particular could quickly force their hand on this.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by nonethewiser on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:24PM (#39149542)
Regulation is OK at prohibiting things. Its very bad at willing things someone’s preferred version of the world into exist.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by numbsafari on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:15PM (#39149397)
Doesn’t Apple have to bear the burden of dealing with different laws in different jurisdictions just like everyone else?

Agree or disagree with the changes, but this is a non-sensical line to take. If you want to play on the world stage, this is how it goes.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by viraptor on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:25PM (#39149557)
Yes, they have to deal with laws of different countries that apply the same to everyone. In this case Apple creates their own rules that do not apply the same to everyone, and are purely for malicious compliance.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by Waterluvian on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:21PM (#39149491)
Yeah. It feels kind of petty and weak to be like, “we were hoping they’d just apply these regulations internationally!”

It’s up to Apple to decide how it complies with the rules of each market it does business in.