News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by carom on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:55PM (#39124813)
At some point, yes. They are aren't playing by society's rules (committing three felonies) and should be removed. If you have two felonies, perhaps don't rob trains?

Most three strike laws have to do with violent crime though.

Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by annoyingnoob on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:23PM (#39125032)
Who gets hurt? Would you consider this train robber a danger to society?

25+ years is way out of proportion for the offense. Long sentences as a form of deterrence are not as effective as things like the likelihood of getting caught. https://www.ojp.gov/library/publications/five-things-about-d...

Incarceration without rehabilitation does not solve the underlying problems and leads to recidivism.

Ruining someone's life over a few Amazon packages makes no sense, ethically or financially.

Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by Georgelemental on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:00PM (#39125362)
> Who gets hurt? Would you consider this train robber a danger to society?

By unjustly appropriating the fruits of other people's labor, thieves make it harder for all honest citizens to support themselves and their families financially. Of course they are a danger to society, and only someone in a position of extreme financial privilege could possibly think otherwise.

Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by mulmen on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:51PM (#39125703)
Sure, theft is bad. The question is how do we disincentivize it. Risk = punishment * probably of being caught. If the probability of being caught is low then the risk can be justified. If the probability of being caught (and successfully prosecuted) is 1 then even short sentences become effective.
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by anigbrowl on Thursday January 25, 2024 @01:16AM (#39126735)
Great, lets starting by jailing everyone who commits wage and hour theft, which exceeds the cost of all theft and robberies combined, but which gets little news coverage because it doesn't have dramatic video footage. IT's logical to start with the biggest thieves, no?
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by ExoticPearTree on Thursday January 25, 2024 @01:50AM (#39126937)
So why doesn’t it happen considering there is ample evidence of this?
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by anigbrowl on Thursday January 25, 2024 @05:29PM (#39136295)
Because prosecutors don't find it sexy, pundits whine about federal enforcement as government overreach, and corporate lawyers often make allegations go away by offering a settlement without an admission of liability.
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by c22 on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:00PM (#39125370)
Everyone gets hurt because prices rise to cover losses.
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by roywiggins on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:28PM (#39125553)
If you're running numbers you do have to account for the costs of incarceration, too. If 25 year sentences don't actually deter more than 10 year sentences then you're just paying for more prisons for no reason.
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by hackernewds on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:54PM (#39126317)
they most definitely do though
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by topaz0 on Thursday January 25, 2024 @08:13AM (#39129217)
I'm sure you believe this, but the evidence doesn't support it.
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by ExoticPearTree on Thursday January 25, 2024 @01:49AM (#39126928)
So its ok to steal then? Because hey… its just a few dollars? Are you serious right now?
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by annoyingnoob on Thursday January 25, 2024 @09:44AM (#39130068)
I'm saying that the punishment needs to fit the crime. People need rehabilitation and opportunities. Check recidivism rates and ask yourself if the system is working.
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by HenryBemis on Thursday January 25, 2024 @03:43AM (#39127513)
> Ruining someone's life over a few Amazon packages makes no sense, ethically or financially.

Heh really? Have you read Les Miserables? If one is hungry, go ask and SOMEONE will give you a loaf of bread (I cannot count the amount of times someone approach me/the queue in a food court of a mall asking for money and I've bought them some nice soup - and they actually sat down and ate it).

Who gives anyone the right to steal something I purchased, and I am expecting it for personal or business purpose? How would you feel if I come to your house every day and steal something - whatever I want and sell it on eBay?

Yes you are annoying :)

Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by red1reaper on Thursday January 25, 2024 @08:25AM (#39129313)
Yes, really. It is not even a point of someone stealing because they are hungry, even if they did it just for the sake of stealing or some shit, it still would not be ethical to kill them because of that.

Essentially, the life of a robber is immeasurably more valuable than your amazon box, so unless they are a threat to human lives, you do not kill them to defend property. Arresting them is fine, but killing because of stealing is a nono.

Other thing would been if the robbers were armed and thus dangerous to the conductor and the like, in those cases, lethal action may be justifiable as a form of self defense.

Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:00PM (#39125368)
If they keep doing crimes you can lock them up again, you know.

Very few crimes should be able to get you more than 5 years at once.

Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by mulmen on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:47PM (#39125677)
I agree with you but I’m honestly curious why you say 5 years. It seems like overkill for what is basically a reset on life. Anything over a few weeks means you lose your job. Anything over a few months means you lose your residence. So what’s the difference between one year and five? What do you lose in those four years other than opportunity?
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by adrr on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:12PM (#39125441)
Two violent felonies and the third strike is any felony.
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by ls612 on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:23PM (#39125520)
Sounds OK to me don’t commit violent felonies.
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by mulmen on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:44PM (#39125659)
Don’t get caught* committing violent felonies. Harsh consequences don’t actually prevent the offense. There’s an equally important chance of being caught.
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by nostromo on Thursday January 25, 2024 @01:52AM (#39126945)
> Harsh consequences don’t actually prevent the offense

But they do protect the public.

Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by mulmen on Thursday January 25, 2024 @03:24AM (#39127419)
Do they? There’s an overwhelming amount of unprosecuted petty crime in my city perpetrated a handful of known individuals. Harsh penalties protect the public from people who get caught. But that’s no consolation when my gas tank gets drained or a window gets busted out to search an empty backpack.
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by Broken_Hippo on Thursday January 25, 2024 @04:10AM (#39127655)
They don't even necessarily protect folks from those that get caught.

We sit there and put folks in jail or prison for an offense, where we might hold them in solitary for months - and if they aren't, they are in a system where people *assume' they are going to get raped by another inmate (it is a common joke, after all).

And then we let them out, put them on probation with a bunch of fees that need paid, a record that makes it difficult to find legal work - especially the sort that will pay bills plus probation - and might exclude them from public housing. And when I say exclude, I mean they might not be able to stay with family for a week if their family lives in public housing.

Harsh penalties do not protect the public. Harsh penalties are the result of a system meant to extract misery, sometimes for fairly minor expenses. If we (Americans) cared about protecting the public, we'd house people, feed them, make it so crimes of desperation are fewer. We'd treat folks well in prison, treat pre-trial folks like they are innocent, and focus on integrating folks into society in ways that few would mind a felon for a neighbor.

Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by ponector on Thursday January 25, 2024 @04:49AM (#39127836)
Consequences are not harsh if criminals are not caught. The issue is in the lack of enforcement. Punishment for any crime should be inevitable. But proportional to the type of the crime.
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by mulmen on Thursday January 25, 2024 @06:21AM (#39128390)
Right. A lack of enforcement can’t be counterbalanced by harsh sentencing.
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by mulmen on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:43PM (#39125649)
Why three? Because baseball? It seems so arbitrary. Recidivism is a real issue but what’s so magical about three strikes? Why not five, or one, or 47?
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by lmm on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:39PM (#39126257)
Do you think it should be five, or one, or 47?

It is kind of arbitrary, there's nothing so magical about it. Two or four would be just as good or at least not a whole lot worse; one seems overly harsh, and five seems overly lenient. Social policy is not an exact science, and we make these decisions democratically; most people seem to have a sense that people should get a few chances, but there should be a point at which they get the book thrown at them. Better to try and draw the line in a place that makes sense, and tweak it if necessary, than to be paralysed by indecision because you can't decide exactly where the line should be.

Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by mulmen on Thursday January 25, 2024 @03:29AM (#39127440)
> Do you think it should be five, or one, or 47?

No. I don’t have a preference for the specific number.

I am asking by which reasoning we decided on three. If it is just “baseball” then I think we can do better.

In other words do we have a framework for deciding on additional punishment for repeat offense?

Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by lmm on Thursday January 25, 2024 @05:56AM (#39128252)
> I am asking by which reasoning we decided on three. If it is just “baseball” then I think we can do better.

If you think we can do better then what's your concrete proposal for doing better. 2? 4? Paying a philosophy department to crank out papers until we spot one we like?

Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by mulmen on Thursday January 25, 2024 @06:26AM (#39128418)
Well, I don’t think there’s a one size fits all number. I’m not even convinced previous convictions should be considered in sentencing.

I am not asking for answers from philosophers. I am asking for a description of the reasoning behind the existing three strikes policies.

A philosophy is just a framework of thinking. It doesn’t have to be created by intellectuals.

Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by DiggyJohnson on Thursday January 25, 2024 @10:29AM (#39130543)
Three seems like a reasonable number. Not too high and not too low. Like a more relaxed version of "fool me once, shame on you...".

I'm surprised by your second line because it seems like you're the one philosophizing. I bet nobody has ever written down a "reason" for three strike policies for criminals/sentencing/etc. It just seems like a reasonable number, and we have the baseball metaphor to back it up.

How are we supposed to answer your question if you're not interested in philosophizing?

Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by mulmen on Thursday January 25, 2024 @01:01PM (#39132432)
I… am interested in philosophizing which is why I specifically asked for the philosophy.

“Seems reasonable” and “baseball” aren’t compelling reasons for harsher punishment.

Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by DiggyJohnson on Thursday January 25, 2024 @01:37PM (#39132981)
Apologies for misunderstanding.

Do you think recidivism should ever result in harsher punishments? If so, do you think this should be codified in sentencing policy?

These questions leave aside the question of "how many strikes".

Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by mulmen on Thursday January 25, 2024 @05:20PM (#39136197)
> Do you think recidivism should ever result in harsher punishments?

They don’t seem to work so… no?

If you are convicted of a crime the individual offense and circumstances should be considered. Adding more punishment because someone failed to be persuaded by punishment seems ineffective at rehabilitation. “The definition of insanity is doing the same thing and expecting different results.”

Maybe it makes sense to give up on a person and lock them up forever but if we are going to do that we should be honest and thoughtful about it.

“Well baseball” doesn’t seem sophisticated enough to address what should be an exceptional action in a nuanced situation.

> If so, do you think this should be codified in sentencing policy?

This is a good question. I guess my real objection to three strikes is that it seems both arbitrary (still willing to be wrong here but so far it’s just “baseball”) and mandatory. Similarly I’m also not a huge fan of minimum sentences. Let the judges… judge.

Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by lmm on Thursday January 25, 2024 @05:38PM (#39136416)
You said "If it is just “baseball” then I think we can do better." So suppose for the moment there is no fancy philosophy and the number is just some vague, messy human sense of how many chances someone ought to get before we throw the book at them. What, concretely, is your better proposal?
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by feetsoup on Thursday January 25, 2024 @07:11AM (#39128684)
> In other words do we have a framework for deciding on additional punishment for repeat offense?

Yes, and you should be able to find how it's handled in your state fairly easily. The fact that you don't know that, and that you're generally focusing on the rhetoric rather than ideas, makes me wonder if you're interested in the subject or just arguing...

Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by hackernewds on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:52PM (#39126312)
how could one ever reach a number? because let's say after 7 issues there's a 80% chance they won't reform. so then why 80%?

it's a good chance, don't worry too much about where the line in the sand is drawn. I've seen multiple teams at work also bogged down by this. if there were a name for this phenomenon, I'd love to know

Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by mulmen on Thursday January 25, 2024 @03:32AM (#39127460)
Well 7 and 80 are both mare up numbers. I think details matter and that reality is messy. So I don’t think an arbitrary number that feels good is the right way to go.
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by oliv__ on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @10:55PM (#39126021)
One can be a mistake. Two is recidivism, it's bad but we can give you another chance. Three: you blew it. Do not pass go, go directly to jail
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by mulmen on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:01PM (#39126056)
Go directly to jail. Like… Monopoly? It still feels arbitrary to me. If two is recidivism then so is three right? So is three be life? That doesn’t seem right. Shouldn’t we be trying to minimize recidivism?
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by philwelch on Thursday January 25, 2024 @12:21AM (#39126449)
If you wanted to minimize recidivism you’d have a life sentence for every crime.
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by mulmen on Thursday January 25, 2024 @03:33AM (#39127468)
Only if we ignore crimes committed in prison.
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by philwelch on Thursday January 25, 2024 @12:02PM (#39131800)
Solitary confinement and/or death penalty then.

Obviously, minimizing recidivism isn’t our only requirement.

Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by concordDance on Thursday January 25, 2024 @09:56AM (#39130182)
I think the idea is that a "good" person can still have a (small) rate of criminality. If you kill after one crime you'll kill many good people, if you do so after 2 you'll still kill good people. But the odds of a good person committing 3 crimes are low enough to go for it.
Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by KennyBlanken on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:56PM (#39126327)
Property crime is predominantly driven by poverty / wealth inequality.

I'd like to see you, with a conviction for a nonviolent drug crime and no college degree or tech experience, try to get a job and provide for a family.

The "rules" of the US are intensely stacked against poor people while allowing the wealthy to almost fail upward.

Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by ExoticPearTree on Thursday January 25, 2024 @01:47AM (#39126921)
Do you have a solution for this? And consider tyat being poor that does make it ok to steal.

It wouldn’t be that hard to stop emoloyers from asking if you served time and do background checks for this. In theory, you did your time, you’ve paid your debt to society. I feel like, at leastbin the US, you’re pretty much screwed if you were ever convicted of anything.

Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by DiggyJohnson on Thursday January 25, 2024 @10:33AM (#39130580)
I would re-up my forklift cert and go do construction. This would be difficult work, but would keep you gainfully employed with a roof over your head almost anywhere in the United States.

It would not be hard to find a job in construction even with a drug offense and no degree.

Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by nobody9999 on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:59PM (#39126342)
>At some point, yes. They are aren't playing by society's rules (committing three felonies) and should be removed. If you have two felonies, perhaps don't rob trains?

It's been argued[0] that most of us don't commit three felonies in a lifetime, but three felonies a day.

While that may be somewhat hyperbolic, it also points up something important about our society. If I were you, I wouldn't be so excited about sticking "three time losers" in prison for decades. It could be you -- for what you did yesterday.

[0] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/6611240-three-felonies-a...

Re:Train Robbery for Amazon Packages? More Common Than You T... by philwelch on Thursday January 25, 2024 @02:22AM (#39127102)
People don’t typically get “three strikes” sentences for committing obscure white collar federal felonies. They get them for felonies that people are generally aware of, like armed robbery and domestic violence.