You can’t be serious
Tab indentation has no bugs or corner cases.
Sure, if people would only ever use tabs for indentation and spaces for alignment, things could be good. But this almost never happens, instead:
... some lines start with spaces, some with tabs. This looks fine in someone's IDE but the moment you use "diff" or "grep" which adds a prefix, things break and lines become jagged.
... one contributor uses tabs mid-line while other use spaces. It may look fine in their editor with 6 character tabs, but all the tables are misaligned when looking in app with different tab size.
Given how many corner cases tabs has, I always try to avoid them. Spaces have no corner cases whatsoever and always look nice, no matter what you use to look at the code.
(the only exceptions are formatters which enforce size-8 tabs consistently everywhere. But I have not seen those outside of golang)
People using tabs for alignment can happen when you've got a tab-camp-person who hasn't yet realized how they're terrible for alignment.
But "some lines start with spaces, some with tabs" happens for precisely two reasons:
* you have a codebase with contributors from both camps
* people thought in-editor tooling was the solution (now you have two problems)
> Spaces have no corner cases whatsoever
This is tooling and (as you realized) stop preference dependent.
Some detail about the corner cases you've run into would be great, if they're happening constantly I can see how it would be a bugbear.
if True:
# Two space indent
And continue to add another if block in that, the autoindent will give you four spaces: if True:
# Two space indent
if True:
# Four space autoindent
And if you make a new line after the last row there and hit a backspace, it'll erase one space instead of four, giving an indentation of 3 (+2) spaces. And if you start a new line after that, you'll get an indentation of 8 spaces in total. Ending up with: if True:
# Two space indent
if True:
# Four space autoindent
# Hitting backspace gives this
# Hitting a tab gives this
This is just a one case, but things like this tend to happen quite often when editing code. Even if it's been originally PEP-8 indented. Usually it's not what the Tab does, but what the Backspace or Autoindent does. I'm not exactly sure what exact Tab/Backspace/Autoindent rules underlie the behavior, but I can imagine there having to be quite a bit of hackery to support soft-tabs.For me this kind of Tab/Autoindent/Backspace confusion is frequent enough that I'd be very surprised if others don't find themselves having to manually fix the number of spaces every now and then. And when watching over the shoulder I see others too occasionally having to micromanage space-indents (or accidentally ending up with three space indented blocks etc), also with other editors than vim.
if !exists("g:python_recommended_style") || g:python_recommended_style != 0
" As suggested by PEP8.
setlocal expandtab tabstop=4 softtabstop=4 shiftwidth=4
endif
So if you use "set sw=2" then it leaves tabstop and softtabstop at 4.You can set that g:python_recommended_style to disable it.
Also sw=0 uses the tabstop value, and softtabstop=-1 uses the shiftwidth value.
I agree Vim's behaviour there is a bit annoying and confusing, but it doesn't really have anything to do with tabs vs. spaces. I strongly prefer tabs myself as well by the way.
Even when you DO use tabs Vim will use spaces if sw/ts/sts differ by the way. Try sw=2 and using >>, or sts=2 with noexpandtab.
The nice modern twist is .editorconfig files and the plugins that support them including for vim. You can use those to set such standard language-specific config concerns in a general way for an entire "workspace" for every editor that supports or has a plugin that supports .editorconfig.
With Tabs we wouldn't have this yet another papercut to tool over.
(It is one of the arguments for using hard tabs instead of soft ones in the eternal tabs versus spaces debates because editors can show hard tabs as different space equivalents as a user "style choice" without affecting the underlying text format.)
Vim has no autodetect by default. (I'm sure there's a plugin somewhere.)
Another comment suggests it's using 2 and 4 for different settings and that's causing problems.
Backspace doesn't unindent in vim by default, it removes spaces one at a time. That's a difference between the ts=4 (tab stop) and sts=4 (soft tab stop) is sts also applies to backspace. But the default is that it doesn't because the out of the box default believes that backspace operates on physical characters (spaces) not soft/fake ones (tabs expanded to spaces) by default.
I don't know if that is the right default, and it is definitely a baroque exercise to get all the settings right for some languages, but there is a consistency to the defaults even if those defaults don't meet some modern expectations from newer code editors.
(Also, I just realized above I confused tw [text width] and ts [tab stop]; my vim skills are rusting a little.)
I haven't used an IDE in years.
And the double nature of the spaces makes it hard to see when you have an odd number of spaces when you reach deep indenting levels, which counts as the lesser number of double spaces in Python.
IMO it would be ideal if tabs would be displayed as a block, and you could resize the width of that block on the fly <3
https://askubuntu.com/questions/40732/how-do-i-get-spaces-in...
Yes, it’s not exactly the same due to alignment, and yes you have to repeat it after using the clipboard for other purposes, but it’s good enough for that occasional use.
I always reformat all my code before all commits. It's just good hygiene.
The funny part is the fussing and the answer they get.
I'd just autoformat the area of my patch and send in the patch that way, maybe plus some autoformatted blocks here and there, slowly fixing the stuff as I go.
If something is too bothersome, first try doing something, and figure out the rest of the process as you go.
Edit: blocks became blogs without my knowledge. Maybe I should write a blog post about it. Don't know.
However, Eclipse is formatting C++ code with a simple hotkey and without breaking it and understanding the language for the last 15 years as far as I can remember. It's instant, too.
Because of that I feel a bit surprised when younger people look it like it's black magic. It's neither new, nor unsolved in my conscious experience.
I think I've even seen this employed on C++ codebases with clang-format. Conceptually, it's like `git diff | clang-format`, but there are more flags and scripts involved: https://clang.llvm.org/docs/ClangFormat.html#script-for-patc...
The majority of editors can be configured to use tab to insert the appropriate number of spaces. Many will automatically detect the correct configuration.
Literally 100% of editors support tabs.
There are rich-text editors that increase the margin on Tab rather than inserting a tab.
Spaces aren't a problem.
What is a problem is not picking one or the other. There's arguments for both sides but it is critical to just take a side. I'm sorry your side lost but it makes everything better to just go along with the consensus.
10 IF A=1 OR Z=2 GOTO 30
20 GOTO 50
30 PRINT "HELLO WORLD"
40 GOTO 10
50 GOTO 30
I would have given a lot to have the environment people have today to do science.
Are you sure about that?
Python is actually flexible in its acceptance of both spaces and tabs for indentation.
Maybe you were thinking of Nim or Zig? Nim apparently supports an unsightly "magic" line for this (`#? replace(sub = "\t", by = " ")`), and Zig now appears to tolerate tabs as long as you don't use `zig fmt`. I haven't used either yet because of the prejudice against tabs, but Zig is starting to look more palatable.
True, I'm using it too when I have no other choice.
> Python is actually flexible in its acceptance of both spaces and tabs for indentation.
True but it does give constant warnings then which is annoying. And I was worried about it dropping support in the future so I didn't want to waste time learning it.
Especially if something is 5 levels deep, it's really hard to see if you have 12 or 11 spaces (so 5 levels + 1 space or 6 levels) indentation.
Any editor used for programming needs to be capable of this.
This isn't a tabs or spaces issue. This is a "your editor is bad or configured wrong" issue.
Now excuse me while I duck under this table.
Not if your editor can be configured to interpret a Tab keypress as the appropriate number of spaces. AFAIK all common text editors, at least in the Unix world, do this.
I actually like tabs for indenting levels especially because I can configure how far they indent on the fly.
Not if your editor automatically indents and dedents with spaces. I find that to work just fine when editing Python code, for example. Tab is interpreted as "indent" and Backspace if you're at an indent stop is interpreted as "dedent".
Their argument is that tabs are shown differently in every editor which is actually something I like. When you're looking for something deeply nested you can reduce the tab distance a bit, when that's not needed you can increase it to improve visibility of nesting levels.
And forbidding it makes a one-keystroke action a two or four one.
I really don't understand the python/Yaml hate for tabs, and as a result I don't really use either.