News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by sparker72678 on Monday January 22, 2024 @05:40PM (#39096542)
Just about every proposed regulation in this article would dramatically increase the selling price of nearly all goods, and dramatically hinder new entrants from selling new products by increasing the burden to get started.

If that's the set of tradeoffs you want to make, ok, fine. But be up-front about it.

Consumer goods, by and large, are not markets with massive profit margins. They're markets of incredible scale with slim margins that generate large revenue as a result. You're not going to get better, more repairable products out of this. You're going to get fewer, more expensive products.

Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by WWLink on Monday January 22, 2024 @06:04PM (#39096823)
> dramatically hinder new entrants from selling new products

Armchair product engineering thoughts: A lot of kickstarters seemed to set themselves up for failure by trying to make a hermetically sealed apple-style product and have it produced in china without ever considering if they could build it locally, if they could get it produced in smaller quantities - if at all....

I get the whole "it can't be made at a competitive price if you don't build for an economy of scale" - but what seemed to happen is a startup would attempt to sell a widget with a design that was all hopes and dreams, immediately fly out to china, and spend a whole bunch of time and money coming up with something that looked great on paper.... but then had a fundamental flaw that required them to throw away all of the initial batch of products - maybe even the first few batches, burning up every penny they gathered in their funding campaign.

"Hold on there cowboy" is my take on this - it's easy to throw a design together that looks slick and ends up quickly becoming ewaste... startups (and startup-like projects) are usually some of the worst offenders. Think of things like Ouya or (lol) Google Stadia or any of a plethora of IoT crap that sounded cool, didn't quite achieve the desired results, and ended up in the landfill.

I'd argue that all this "bureaucratic red-tape" would help limit how much ewaste gets produced, at least a little bit.

Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by jkestner on Monday January 22, 2024 @08:22PM (#39098209)
I’ve made a conscious effort to build our (Kickstarted!) stuff domestically. With the exception of one product in China, which was still an educational PITA. Can’t claim the things are Made in America when a critical component is fabbed overseas, but it’s great to talk with people in my time zone. Going to be even better to drive over to the injection molder to dial in fit and finish.

OTOH, the examples you cite and many more are junked not because they’re made in China but due to a lack of software support/remediation. I’m not sure if there’s a business model that incentivizes this, so I’m rooting for the regulations that are slowing coming along on this.

Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by WWLink on Saturday January 27, 2024 @03:22PM (#39159446)
Ah, software is a big one but I was thinking of a few products that involved no software at all. Stuff like mechanical keyboards, that one PC case that looked like the current Mac Pro, there was some other hardware widget or two that I can't quite remember right now. They all had these neat ideas, spent a lot of money getting it engineered & produced, and oops... the end result wasn't what we hoped it would be......

In some cases they actually shipped the defective product out, because hey, getting something is better than nothing. But it fell pretty far short of what people were hoping they'd get lol.

Edit: But I do commend your efforts! Great job!

Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by Aurornis on Monday January 22, 2024 @08:10PM (#39098064)
The real impact would be that those products wouldn’t be offered in those markets. It’s a big world with a lot of customers out there.

If one region demands a substantially higher bar for entry with only marginal increase in customer base, it gets delayed for a later revision.

We already saw this happen with a lot of GDPR regulations and sites that decided it was easier to block those regions than spend all of the money to confirm their products didn’t put them at risk of violations.

We’re also seeing consumers make these decisions in real-time with things like Amazon knockoffs. I know a lot of people who swear they’re “buy it for life” people but will buy tools from Harbor Freight and get cheap knockoff things from Amazon all the time.

It’s easy for all of us to say we’d gladly pay more for extra quality or upgrade ability, but when it’s time to get the wallet out the decision criteria change.

Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by sokoloff on Monday January 22, 2024 @09:42PM (#39098927)
I am “buy it for life -or- buy it for this one job”. I’ve got both SnapOn and Pittsburgh (HF Brand) tools in my tool chest.

“After a year, every Harbor Freight tool is a hammer” is less true than it used to be, but even when it was, there are times you need a tool for one job and if it isn’t in the trash bin afterwards, that’s just a bonus.

Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by shiroiuma on Monday January 22, 2024 @11:06PM (#39099526)
>I know a lot of people who swear they’re “buy it for life” people but will buy tools from Harbor Freight

Have you bought any tools from Harbor Freight in the last 5 years or so? Their hand tools (socket wrenches, etc.) are quite good, and are made in Taiwan. They're actually quite fantastic tools for weekend mechanics and an excellent value. I can't think of anything that's better for a home mechanic if you live in the US.

Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by stavros on Monday January 22, 2024 @06:05PM (#39096842)
> You're going to get fewer, more expensive products.

That last much longer.

Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by crazygringo on Monday January 22, 2024 @08:09PM (#39098052)
But that's not always a good thing.

People's needs for products change, and products themselves improve to gain features, become more energy efficient, etc.

I do not want to be running the air conditioner I had from thirty years ago. It used tons of energy, was noisy as hell, was ugly, didn't have a thermostat or timer or any other features we take for granted today.

Same thing in the way all my lamps have been replaced with LED's, televisions became HD and then large screen and then 4K, office chairs got better ergonomics, and so forth. Making a CD player that lasted 4 decades would have been a total waste of resources.

I honestly think we're at a pretty good balance point today. When something breaks, more often than not it's the case that the new version is a significant upgrade that was worth getting anyways.

Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by ehnto on Monday January 22, 2024 @09:13PM (#39098674)
Our needs don't change, our expectations change, often due to marketing. Especially true for widgets that don't serve base needs. That's fine, we do want progress. But we should have the choice.

Wouldn't you want to be in control of the decision? If your air conditioning cools you and you are okay with it's current efficiency, you should be able to repair it. It's not like corporations are building short lived products out of environmental concerns about efficiency. If you leave it in their hands, then the consumer loses control, and companies do the obvious.

It also reduces competition and innovation in my view. Why try hard to R&D products people want to upgrade to, when you can just wait for their unit to break and sell them a mediocre upgrade.

Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by sokoloff on Monday January 22, 2024 @09:39PM (#39098903)
Don’t we already have that right to repair in practice for ACs and related?

In the last 3 years, I’ve repaired 1 window AC (bad bearings on the motor shaft), 1 free-standing AC (bad bearings on the motor leading to motor failure), and 2 portable dehumidifiers (low refrigerant charge).

None were particularly difficult and I could source a used motor ($18.50 shipped from eBay), source the bearings by measurement (under $16 shipped for 8 bearings though I needed only 2), and R410a is a commodity ($300 for a 20# tank, used about 1.5 pounds total).

Would it be easier if Fuji and Samsung and LG and others ran a parts depot that I could buy from? Maybe, but I’m probably not going to buy new parts from them anyway.

Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by ehnto on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @12:46AM (#39100037)
Yes certain commodity parts are pretty easy to get and replace, in fact the wear items I usually find are quite available on big appliances in particular. But getting a replacement circuit board or perhaps a proprietary bracket is often not possible.

I don't think manufacturers should have to offer support in perpetuity though so it becomes an interesting problem. Like samsung shouldn't need to stock the front face of a washing machine for 15 years. Perhaps a better approach is making items that aren't possible to stock long term be made out of repairable materials so at least it can be repaired by a repairman.

Repairmen are expensive now because the skillset disappeared, when everything became so cheap that it was easier to buy new. But I think we can and should bring local repair services back.

Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by PeterisP on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @09:40AM (#39103891)
Repairs are expensive because of extreme economies of scale. The marginal cost for Samsung to make another injection-moulded plastic front face for a washing machine is literally a few cents, including both material and labor; the cost for repairing it (no matter how repairable the materials are) or making a single new one in any other way than a mass-produced injection mold is easily at least 100 times more expensive, simply because it takes uncomparably more labor. This is a part where making and storing a huge excess of stock for the next 50 years is still cheaper than repairing even a tiny fraction of the parts.

Perhaps requiring the manufacturers to provide either spare parts or if they are out of stock and no intent to sell them anymore, then requiring to provide STLs to 3D-print them could be a reasonable option. It still would be an order of magnitude (or two) more expensive compared to making the original parts (due to the immense economies of scale for plastic manufacturing), but it would still be cheaper than custom repairs locally.

Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by crazygringo on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @11:22AM (#39105439)
> Wouldn't you want to be in control of the decision? If your air conditioning cools you and you are okay with it's current efficiency, you should be able to repair it.

The point is, I don't want the things I buy to be 1.5x or 2x the price to ensure greater repairability than they have now. That's the conversation we're having.

> It also reduces competition and innovation in my view. Why try hard to R&D products people want to upgrade to

All available evidence points to the contrary. That might be true if there were only one manufacturer of an item, but competition ensures a constant stream of R&D and improvements. Which is precisely why I don't want to use my AC from 30 years ago -- the improvements since then have been massive.

Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by ehnto on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @10:24PM (#39113236)
The 30 year number is a bit disingenuous, appliances are conking out in 3-5 years which is why this is a conversation at all. In that time frame, innovation in most appliances is frivolous extras. Nothing fundamental about toasters has changed in decades. Fridges are adding TVs on the front because fridges are all the same technology and it's impossible to differentiate.

30 years for sure, that is a totally reasonable amount of time for an appliance to last. If it genuinely lasted that long I bet you actually did a few repairs in there too. Living the dream, actually even 10 years would be amazing. We could cherry pick examples of long lived products but the point for me is that people don't pay for longevity like you said, but we need it for other reasons. Reduce waste, improve consumer choice and power over their own objects.

In regards to efficiency, it's definitely more efficient not to produce a society worth of new appliances ever 5 years or so. Improved repairability aldo means improved recycling of the components too.

Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by herbst on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @05:03AM (#39101494)
Not sure I can agree. You would replace your air conditioner once options with way less power usage or more comfort are available, but your still good machine will make someone else happy.

I still replace some older lamps with LEDs when they die. TVs just go on a rotation, replace your bedroom TV, make your grandmum happy, it is going to make someone else happy. People still look for quality CD players (especially AMP combis) in second hand shops around here.

Someone must be buying new devices so the second hand market can work. Without well working second hand market you need cheap china devices so people get access to technology. It's no problem for this approach if YOU want to buy new things.

Another example might be cars. Someone must have the need/enjoyment to drive a fully new car so I can buy that same car a year later at a much more reasonable price.

Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by financypants on Monday January 22, 2024 @06:38PM (#39097139)
Problem is sometimes you can get by with an off-off-brand product (it’s hit and miss). Many folks don’t buy the “spend more and you will get something MUCH better that will last you for years!” sales pitch. Also a lot of people wouldn’t be able to start fronting (or financing) more money for a better, more repairable product.
Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by Brian_K_White on Monday January 22, 2024 @07:11PM (#39097476)
Yes they would, because there would be a lot of used items that fill the exact same role as a new junk item.
Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by financypants on Monday January 22, 2024 @09:31PM (#39098840)
Good point. The used market would likely be much more active and valuable.
Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by herbst on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @04:55AM (#39101457)
Swiss here. I would argue we have a big 'buy good, don't buy twice' community because a high percentage simply can. Can confirm that our second hand markets are filled with great, high quality, often well taken care of, products.
Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by sparker72678 on Monday January 22, 2024 @06:44PM (#39097197)
Possibly!

I just think we should be clear about what tradeoffs are being proposed. This isn't all fairy dust and magic, and the average person doesn't have the background to understand the impact of proposals like this.

Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by mistrial9 on Monday January 22, 2024 @06:59PM (#39097351)
> the average person doesn't have the background to understand

yes agree - so there must be manufacturing standards and product testing. Similarly it is established law that some products are inherently unsafe. The law must always adapt to new techniques, materials and chains of distribution.

Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by trey-jones on Monday January 22, 2024 @07:14PM (#39097506)
Any system of standards and testing can be gamed. It's better for the average person to better educate themselves on purchases. I don't know how realistic this is. Additional difficulty is added by the amount of (mis/dis)information available to consumers. Very few sources are trustworthy and your mileage may vary of course.

Adjacent to this issue is the broader issue that rampant capitalism encourages rampant buying of stuff - often stuff that we don't need, and surprisingly often stuff we don't even want. Think Gift Giving culture nowadays. With fewer things to purchase, more effort could go into the important purchases, I would think.

Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by throwaway15858 on Monday January 22, 2024 @08:12PM (#39098079)
I've thought about this and there's no way to condense a multivariate notion of product quality into a scale. The best I've come up with is that all products should have to prominently advertise their years of warranty support. This creates an incentive for products to last longer than the warranty and makes comparison shopping easy.
Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by pas on Monday January 22, 2024 @06:07PM (#39096862)
It should be tied to market share or revenue. Apple and Bosch and others are not small sweatshops barely scraping by.
Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by sparker72678 on Monday January 22, 2024 @06:47PM (#39097220)
That's certainly one way to implement it, no doubt.

I have my doubts that unrepairable, failing products are produced by few enough manufacturers that holding a handful of large ones to these rules would make a big dent in waste. But, maybe I'm wrong!

(Also, good luck convincing people to spend 4x on a vacuum because it's "repairable" when the no-name brand is not. Most people will roll the dice and save the money today.)

Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by plagiarist on Monday January 22, 2024 @09:30PM (#39098831)
One of the largest failings of the market is everyone refusing to act in their own long term best interests if there is a short term cost.
Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by Lio on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @03:31AM (#39100849)
If repairable was mandated by law the price for it would fall fast. Desktop PCs, for example, are both cheap and repairable because of standardisation.

People will happily roll the dice on dangerous products if they’re only slightly cheaper. That’s why we have regulations, to stop bad products using price to drive good products out of the market.

Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by m463 on Monday January 22, 2024 @08:28PM (#39098262)
market forces can help too.

If the OEM doesn't provide parts, they should provide specifications for aftermarket parts to be created and sold.

I believe I read somewhere that after 13 years car parts become available from third parties.

Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by lnxg33k1 on Monday January 22, 2024 @09:22PM (#39098751)
I mean there has been a new entrant in the past few years, the fairphone, which arrived with a vision and an ethics, and is slowly getting market share, and better products, that are repairable, or new entrant like frame.work, which arrived with a vision, ethics too, and is slowly improving and getting market share. I am not sure why as a society we need to accomodate small vendors who arrive without a plan or anything selling shit shipped from China that is going to last 30 days and just become e-waste, like PinePhone or Librem comes to mind, I am not sure why society needs to accomodate any cowboy who wants to become a manufacturer to sell low effort china phones
Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by AnarchismIsCool on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @12:36AM (#39099982)
That's a feature, not a bug. If we build things to last a bit longer at the expense of a slightly higher cost we can save massive amounts of waste from being produced and use fewer materials. We don't need to crater everything but we also don't need as much -stuff- as we currently buy. Yes there are implications for lower income folks but that's a symptom of a problem that cheap plentiful flimsy shit isn't going to fix at the expense of the planet.
Re:Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right by herbst on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @04:40AM (#39101366)
> You're going to get fewer, more expensive products

At this point researching a single electronic device you never looked into before can easily take hours. For example kitchen electronics was a topic for me recently.

I honestly would be happy to have way less choice, may even pay more in general, but can be sure that these products fullfil all EU standards.

My mini Ofen with crazy good isolation, according to recent EU standards, that preheats in less than a minute, will surely pay for itself in power cost :) that's the hardware I want to choose from, f* those 200+ throwaway, mostly relabelled china brands, products in the same category.