News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by juujian on Thursday January 18, 2024 @08:23AM (#39041363)
If Boeing was a student, they would be the kind that does the bare minimum in every class just so they don't fail.
Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by danparsonson on Thursday January 18, 2024 @08:36AM (#39041508)
And if they were an SV startup, they'd be receiving abundant praise for rapidly disrupting their market...
Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday January 18, 2024 @12:27PM (#39044620)
> if they were an SV startup, they'd be receiving abundant praise for rapidly disrupting their market

If Boeing were developing radical new designs, I’d be with you. I might even be with them. But they’re not. The 737 Max 9 isn’t revolutionary in any capacity; the newness is practically all in the engines.

Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by dotcoma on Thursday January 18, 2024 @09:55AM (#39042396)
I am not so sure I want an airplane manufacturer to disrupt much of anything, especially if it involves cutting corners…
Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by jetbalsa on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:13AM (#39043535)
Well... SpaceX did it with rockets :V
Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by dotcoma on Thursday January 18, 2024 @12:35PM (#39044735)
I’m not going to board a rocket anytime soon :)
Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by jacquesm on Thursday January 18, 2024 @09:20PM (#39050857)
But not while carrying passengers.
Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by lebean on Thursday January 18, 2024 @08:58AM (#39041710)
They really are building the airplane while it's flying.
Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by foofie on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:08AM (#39043462)
> And if they were an SV startup, they'd be receiving abundant praise for rapidly disrupting their market...

I don't think that's a valid comparison.

For a startup to disrupt a market, it should have some semblance of a win.

Boeing is doing all this to avoid a major loss.

Fighting to stay afloat is not the same as disrupting a market.

Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by danparsonson on Thursday January 18, 2024 @09:52PM (#39051050)
You're right - it was a lazy swipe at 'move fast and break things' culture but it didn't really land (pardon the pun).
Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by throwawaaarrgh on Thursday January 18, 2024 @08:42AM (#39041569)
That's not a great comparison though. Commercial Airlines are known for safety and reliability, startups are known for being tire fires
Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by cqqxo4zV46cp on Thursday January 18, 2024 @09:27AM (#39042023)
Yeah I get that dunking on Boeing is the cool new thing but realistically the amount of caution they take with things almost certainly dwarves whatever most of us software gardeners do.
Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by FredPret on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:45AM (#39044015)
Yeah but most software bugs aren’t life or death
Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by danparsonson on Thursday January 18, 2024 @09:54PM (#39051058)
Indeed; it was intended as a joke about 'move fast and break things' culture but didn't pan out very well.
Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by ramijames on Thursday January 18, 2024 @08:36AM (#39041507)
This seems to be the core reason why pure capitalism is a failed concept. There must be regulatory oversight to ensure that what is done MOST RIGHT and not CHEAPEST.
Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by stef25 on Thursday January 18, 2024 @08:46AM (#39041595)
Thinking that "fuck it, we'll risk loss of human life and possibly having to shut down the company" isn't due to capitalism, it's psychopathy and I'm fairly sure that never happened.

Anything that goes wrong is due to dysfunctional management, not greed.

Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by cqqxo4zV46cp on Thursday January 18, 2024 @09:30AM (#39042069)
Don’t make excuses. Putting psychopaths in the drivers seat is a precipitation of capitalism. Capitalism decides the ultimate KPI, and eventually things shake out this way. We don’t just get to say, yes, there goes another psychopathic executive, and wash our hands of the whole thing. Christ. We all make systems for a living. Look at indirect consequences.
Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by stef25 on Thursday January 18, 2024 @10:45AM (#39043154)
Even psychopaths don't want to end up disgraced or in jail. So maybe it's the lack of punishment we dole out to these kinds of people.

Nowadays companies can seriously suffer by mishandling their "attitudes" over social justice issues, my gut reaction was that if that's true how could they get away with a plane falling out of the sky. Still a bigger deal than dozen people dying in cars with faulty fuel systems, perhaps just because of the optics.

Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by feoren on Thursday January 18, 2024 @12:09PM (#39044344)
> Even psychopaths don't want to end up disgraced or in jail. So maybe it's the lack of punishment we dole out to these kinds of people.

You're describing effective regulatory oversight. That is a manual control on capitalism, and something capitalism inevitably fights against. Psychopaths exist and look for ways to exploit capitalism, including "fuck it, we'll risk loss of human life and possibly having to shut down the company", which you said isn't due to capitalism. But it is: it's due to the combination of capitalism and human nature, but we can only control the former. The solution is regulatory oversight, as you just pointed out.

Also: realize that psychopaths will absolutely risk shutting down the company if they think they can exit with a personal profit before that happens. CEOs routinely fuck over the longevity of the companies they lead, knowing they won't be around for the fallout. In fact it's hard to find situations where this doesn't happen -- it's almost always private companies or companies where the CEO is completely entrenched.

Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by foofie on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:13AM (#39043525)
> Don’t make excuses. Putting psychopaths in the drivers seat is a precipitation of capitalism.

That's a disingenuous take. There are plenty of examples where psycho apparatchiks of anti-capitalist regimes made decisions "for the common good" that resulted in loss of life and even genocide and still they hailed those results as a win.

Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by feoren on Thursday January 18, 2024 @12:13PM (#39044402)
GP said "System A doesn't work without controls" and you replied "that's disingenuous: System B also doesn't work without controls". Okay? That has nothing to do with it.
Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by foofie on Thursday January 18, 2024 @12:16PM (#39044461)
> Okay? That has nothing to do with it.

You missed the whole point. The point is that having psychos in charge is not a characteristic of an economic system. It's a characteristic of forming organizations manned by human beings.

It's terribly disingenuous to use that as a pretext to bash an economic system as if you don't have the exact same problem affecting organizations that are not ran based on that economic system. It's like claiming that the fact that water is wet is a precipitation of capitalism.

Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by masklinn on Thursday January 18, 2024 @09:02AM (#39041752)
Ford literally did a cost/benefit analysis for fixing the Pinto versus societal costs of injuries and deaths, and went with the cheaper option. They actually put it to paper and sent that to the NHTSA to argue against fuel system regulations.

“Dysfunctional management” is a direct function of managerial incentives, which is generally capitalistic greed (aka “obligation to maximize shareholder value”)

Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by gnfargbl on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:19AM (#39043626)
They thought they went with the cheaper option, but in fact they only considered the value of a life as estimated by the NHTSA ($0.2M). In reality, the damages that juries tended to assign for each needless loss of life turned out to be more like $100M.

If Ford had accounted for those punitive costs in their calculation, then the outcome of the cost/benefit calculation would have overwhelmingly favoured a fix. The real business problem was not the empathy-free approach, but poor mathematical modelling.

Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by meigwilym on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:51AM (#39044114)
I think that deciding to go with the cheapest is an empathy-free approach, regardless if the maths were off.
Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by masklinn on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:33AM (#39043840)
> They thought they went with the cheaper option, but in fact they only considered the value of a life as estimated by the NHTSA ($0.2M). In reality, the damages that juries tended to assign for each needless loss of life turned out to be more like $100M.

That was in large part due to the disgust over the report they had penned.

> If Ford had accounted for those punitive costs in their calculation, then the outcome of the cost/benefit calculation

Would still have been a cost/benefit calculation rather than a moral or ethical one, aka capitalistic greed.

Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by nradov on Thursday January 18, 2024 @10:52AM (#39043238)
Every auto manufacturer does the same thing. The Ford Pinto case was particularly poorly handled. But for any given car design, it's always possible to further improve safety by making it more expensive. A Mercedes-Benz S-Class is far safer than a Nissan Sentra by any objective standard. Should we tighten safety requirements so that every car is as safe as the S-Class, and costs about as much? Where do we draw the line on safety regulations?
Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by yawpitch on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:22AM (#39043668)
If we tightened safety regulations so that every car was as safe as the S-Class then cars as safe as the S-Class would dramatically drop in price, simply by virtue of there being more of them.

As for where you draw the line on safety regulations, the optimum answer is always “considerably past the point that business owners start complaining about excessive regulation”.

Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by kube-system on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:54AM (#39044149)
The S-class is a bad example, because it is expensive for other confounding reasons.

However, all else equal, a vehicle with more active and passive safety features and more safety engineering is more expensive. Even after you account for economies of scale.

For example, airbags are extremely mass produced and have just about as much economies of scale as possible. But, in countries where they are not mandated, you can still find cars offered without them, because they are cheaper. The same is also true for vehicles without UHHS safety cages, ABS, stability control, etc. All of these things cost money.

Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by yawpitch on Thursday January 18, 2024 @07:21PM (#39049958)
Take all the safety items that do actually contribute to the S-Class sticker price, now mandate them in all cars. The price of all cars goes up, sure, but also the cost of a car that’s as safe as the S-Class is goes down. What you’ve done is decreased the cost of having the more safe option while eliminating the less safe option, precisely because most of those currently premium / luxury items simply haven’t benefitted at all from economies of scale. The airbag example proves the point, inside any country that mandates them. Are there cheaper and more dangerous cars available without them? Sure… but not inside the borders of any country that cares about the survival of its citizens.

We should all live in countries that mandate extremely high safety standards and spend their time worrying about how to raise the average income to compensate, rather than in a country that accepts unreasonable risk just to keep wages unreasonably low.

Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by FredPret on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:49AM (#39044071)
You don’t think the input costs have something to do with the price of an S Class?

Pricing is due to both supply and demand - there can’t be a sustainable supply of a expensive-to-make cars at loss-making prices

Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by tgv on Thursday January 18, 2024 @08:33AM (#39041472)
And then complain all the way up to the provost when they do fail.
Re:Serious incident to the 777-300ER on 5 April 2022 at CDG ... by lotsofpulp on Thursday January 18, 2024 @09:17AM (#39041915)
Crazy how many titles there are in academia. What is the distinction between provost/dean/chancellor/president/etc.