The problem with aerospace is that it has a very high barrier to entry, so consolidation ends up hurting the consumer more often than not. Same as other infra related industries like telcos and civil engineering work that require fairly massive upfront capital and regulatory investments to operate.
Better to leave a hole in the market to encourage new entrants, even if it means consumers suffer in the short term.
We shouldn't prioritize shareholders over the general health of a marketplace
Nobody is clear about the right move on how to deal with this problem. There's no sure fire conclusion.
[1] Once you account for the padding, the angle you have to sit at, etc. Even if you aren't unusually tall, it is noticeably awkward and cramped.
Another important item from the trial - only 1/3 of Spirit customers pay the low fee without add-ons. The rest go for something more Jet Blue like anyways.
The precedence that the judge set here is more important than the actual merger. If any tiny subset of customers are harmed the deal cannot go through. I was really surprised to see this from a judge appointed by President Reagan. This could really crush M&As in America.
The same cannot be said for JetBlue
> “If JetBlue were permitted to gobble up Spirit — at least as proposed — it would eliminate one of the airline industry’s few primary competitors that provides unique innovation and price discipline,” Young wrote. “… Worse yet, the merger would likely incentivize JetBlue further to abandon its roots as a maverick, low-cost carrier.”[2]
> This could really crush M&As in America.
That's a bit hyperbolic. If it does crush anti-competitive / anti-trust mergers, that's a win in any capitalist's book
[1] https://money.usnews.com/investing/news/articles/2024-01-16/... [2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/transportation/2024/01/16/jet...
> That's a bit hyperbolic. If it does crush anti-competitive / anti-trust mergers, that's a win in any capitalist's book
The judge literally ruled here that a very small market (1/3 of customers on a small airline) would be harmed. JetBlue was also willing to discuss divestures & the government refused because they didn't care about competition or working with JetBlue. They have been doing weak cases for the past few years in hope to get any precedence set that makes M&A harder.
The judge uses the DOJ's expert witness's findings even after agreeing with JetBlue's team that the witness's model was completely broken.
This was a pro-competitive merger in my opinion because it created a stronger rival for the big 4, albeit still roughly half the size of most of them.
> ...the government refused because they didn't care about competition or working with JetBlue.
I take it this is your opinion based on your perception?
However from the U.S.News link I posted above
"The judge, who had questioned whether further asset divestitures could make the deal work, said, "The courthouse doors remain open, should the defendant airlines decide to try again."
You can also read the actual ruling [1] which states:
> _"Throughout June 2022, JetBlue made a series of revised offers to acquire Spirit, with increases in per-share price, increases in the reverse termination fee, and commitments to divestitures. Spirit continued to resist, citing continued concerns about the anticompetitive nature of such an acquisition. On June 6, 2022, Mr. Christie received an email from Mr. Hayes with an attached new, revised offer for Spirit Airlines. On June 27, 2022, JetBlue made a further amended offer to purchase Spirit; the Spirit Board did not view this amended offer as better and did not accept it. Instead, Spirit issued another press release on June 28, 2022, reaffirming its commitment to the transaction with Frontier and noting that the “[l]atest offer from JetBlue does nothing to address our Board’s serious concerns that a combination with [JetBlue] would not receive regulatory approval.”_
So even the Spirit board did not prefer this acquisition, even with the divestitures, but acquiesced to expected shareholder concerns on value maximization
[1]https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/24362262/jetblue.pdf
In the end, Spirit should have stayed with their Frontier merger though the DOJ probably would have tried to block that as well.
Today Spirit is saying they will be looking at restructuring. Every analyst seems to be saying they are going to declare bankruptcy.
I have no idea how the DOJ or the Judge sees this as increasing competition, which I'm all for by the way. Even if Spirit doesn't go bankrupt they cannot compete as a low fare provider anymore. They will just slowly bleed for the next several years as they sell off and are unable to grow. Same with JetBlue now as well.
In the new era, practices, perceptions and mission statements have to also be up to a standard, not just statistics. I wonder how long this could go on for.
Really? How old is he, 80? Why do Americans insist in having such geriatric leaders, they're starting to make Iran look normal...
The best argument I see for allowing the merger is that Spirit has been consistently losing money since the pandemic and may no longer have a viable business model. If they're destined for shutting down in the long run anyway, then you may as well let them attempt to merge, that'll probably lead to less of their market share winding up with the 4 biggest than them simply closing up shop will.
At least in my anecdotal experience.
That lends more credence to the comparison against Dollar General and similar discount stores. Dollar stores generally charge a higher price relative to quantity, but they offer smaller quantities than big box stores which allows their customers to spend less (but also get a lot less). Wendover on YouTube did a video on this recently [0].
The last time I did they canceled my flight overnight at 2:30am and forced me to rebook my ~$300 flight at twice the cost -- and it was leaving the same airport at the same time to the same destination.
And it was a miracle that I woke up to the email alert and was able to rebook my flight before it sold out anyway.
It does seem like post-Covid all of the airlines are racing to the bottom for quality.
I've had canceled flights before but no other airline has ever forced me to rebook effectively the same flight at double the rate and wait the 8-10 days for the refund on my original flight to my credit card. Back when I was a brokie (you know, Spirit's main customer base) that kind of shit would have been trip-ending.
I've never felt jerked around with any of the majors when it came to rebooking travel. They can't conjure up an empty seat that doesn't exist, but I've also never been required to pay a higher fare for them to take me on the itinerary that I originally booked.
Delta in particular I think is quite good at recovery from irregular ops (at least for their higher tier frequent fliers), but on the few instances with other carriers, I expect (and have received) decent and fee-free service when the airline cancelled a flight or missed a connection due to airline fault. I fully expect to have a crappy experience on Spirit whether or not they cancel the original flight.
As a lite traveler Spirit fits my needs and I have more money in my pocket for my trip(s). As well I'm off the plane with my book bag and out of the airport quickly! I always get an aisle seat up front.
Of course, I wouldn’t fly spirit if I had a complex flight itinerary or needed to be 100% sure I would arrive when expected. Then again, I’ve had more issues with other airlines (looking at you Alaska) as well, so go figure.
All that being said, the invisible variable most of us miss is plane maintenance. I don’t know what spirit’s record is in particular on this axis, but some airlines really skimp on maintenance costs, sometimes leading to entirely preventable disasters ([0] to name one of many)
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alaska_Airlines_Flight_261
He said straight up that Spirit Airlines is aiming to be the Dollar General of the skies. If you want something luxurious, go elsewhere. But he called out the other airlines who pretend like they are the Nordstrom of the skies, but don’t actually live up to that.