News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by stephengillie on Saturday April 28, 2012 @02:19AM (#3902195)
The news media is obviously trying to fan the controversy, as that's their business model. Hopefully the almost-visible flickering in movies at theaters will disappear when we switch to higher framerates.

"You can not get a more genuine, realistic viewing experience than this unless you are watching a performance live," wrote About.com's Rebecca Murray, though she noted that it takes your eyes a moment to adjust.

"You're right there and it's breathtaking," noted Hollywood Elsewhere's Jeff Wells. "No strobing, no flickering, pure fluidity and much more density of information...It's the best 3D I've ever seen and probably ever will see in my life. 48 fps 3D is so much easier on your eyes than 24 fps 3D."

http://www.eonline.com/news/hobbit_controversy_peter_jackson...

Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by blackhole on Saturday April 28, 2012 @02:10AM (#3902182)
"Guys this new technology looks weird, we should just stick with what works! There's no way this has anything to do with me not being used to it!"
Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by shock-value on Saturday April 28, 2012 @03:33AM (#3902302)
It has nothing to do with not being used to it. TV dramas could easily have shot at 60fps starting a decade ago (or more) but none do (aside from some daytime soaps). Even most comedies are 24-30fps these days. The reason is that higher framerates cheapen the look in exactly the way the author of this article describes.
Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by demallien on Saturday April 28, 2012 @01:51AM (#3902150)
Peter Jackson's right you do get used to it after a while. I Bought a Samsung LED television that runs at 60 frames per seconds a couple of years back and it took me three months to get used to it. But now when I look at screens that run at slower frame rates, they just look dull and flat.
Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by shock-value on Saturday April 28, 2012 @03:40AM (#3902310)
I don't know of any tv ever produced that is less than 50-60fps. Do you mean that it interpolates lower fps content to bring it up to 60? If so all I can say is, I am surprised you like that effect. I can't stand it and always disable it.
Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by demallien on Saturday April 28, 2012 @04:03AM (#3902356)
Yes, I do mean interpolation. Just for the record, in the parts of the world where I have worked (Australia and France), a typical video stream, be it broadcast/pay-tv/dvd runs at 30fps or less. Recent televisions will interpolate to display frame rates up to 120fps.

Like you, I hated the effect at first, but I left it running because I do STB user interfaces for a living, and I need to know what people that don't fiddle with their television are seeing. It's jarring at first because for reasons that I don't fully understand, you are able to discern where the light sources are in a scene when using this technique. You can see that big reflectors have been used for outside shots, or that there is a spot shining just off camera. This is what gives it that cheap video effect, because as anyone that works with video for a living can tell you, the crappy quality of home videos is mostly due to poor lighting.

Cinematographers are going to have to work harder in the future to assure a more even light field in their shots. In the meantime, I have found that after using this type of display technology for more than a few months, you start to prefer the high frame rate to older technologies.

Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by Turing_Machine on Saturday April 28, 2012 @07:53AM (#3902729)
You may be thinking of fields per second rather than frames per second.

Classic NTSC (used in North America and some other countries) runs at 30 frames per second. Each frame is made up of two fields, consisting of the odd and even-numbered scan lines respectively (this is called "interlace"), thus there are 60 fields per second.

The PAL and SECAM systems (used in Europe and some other countries) run at 25 frames per second and 50 fields per second.

In both cases, this was done because the power line frequency provided an easy-to-use reference signal for frame timing (the North American power grid runs at 60 Hz, most (all?) European countries use 50 Hz).

Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by zoul on Saturday April 28, 2012 @01:55AM (#3902157)
Do you play media with high framerate on the TV? Because the display's framerate does not matter much if you still feed it 24-fps signal.
Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by twiceaday on Saturday April 28, 2012 @02:05AM (#3902173)
It actually does, I believe those TVs interpolate the missing frames.
Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by taligent on Saturday April 28, 2012 @02:12AM (#3902185)
I have the TV it is a setting IIRC called Auto Motion Mode.

It does indeed interpolate but there is an uncanny valley effect to it. It reminds me of movies where the audio is ever so slightly out of sync. You notice something is wrong but can't perceive what it is.

BTW this setting is not what Peter Jackson is doing and should not be used as a comparison.

Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by shock-value on Saturday April 28, 2012 @03:51AM (#3902333)
Actually I think it is useful to compare. Based on what I've seen, the interpolation tech is actually pretty good as long as there isn't too much movement on screen. And yet, in dramas especially, it still severely cheapens the look and makes everything look "unnatural". (Even when there is only smooth movement which is well interpolated by whatever algorithm it is using.)

So what I am saying is, I actually think it is simply the higher fps that accounts for the distracting nature of these tvs (when interpolation is on). Not so much the actual interpolation itself, as I can only rarely detect artifacts.

Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by jsprinkles on Saturday April 28, 2012 @02:13AM (#3902188)
Yeah, that was one of the first things I turned off. It makes action kind of bizarre. My Sharp came out of the box configured to interpolate to 240 Hz (what?).
Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by sp332 on Saturday April 28, 2012 @02:20AM (#3902199)
From a comment on that page, I found this info: http://www.videocandycompany.com/?p=224 Apparently, in order to shoot at a higher framerate, they used a suboptimal aperture. It looks crappy because the exposure is relatively longer, so you get extremely smooth-looking footage.
Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by drucken on Saturday April 28, 2012 @03:52AM (#3902336)
Very informative, thank you.

In short, to me, all this effort is being driven by studio's trying to justify cinema ticket prices by offering big films shot for 3D. Even though the most profitable and successful films have always been 2D and in general movie watchers avoid 3D!

In addition, perhaps Jackson would rather be known for pioneering work than making yet another good film.

Given the choice in aesthetic for film has been driven by culture rather than technology for much of its 103 years, the parties concerned are all taking a big risk...

Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by Gring on Saturday April 28, 2012 @02:37AM (#3902222)
Bad review.

That "video look" he's mentioning is the absence of 24fps artifacts I'm very glad we get rid of.

He could as well just have written "meh, reality has a video look".

Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by shock-value on Saturday April 28, 2012 @03:24AM (#3902288)
No, you're wrong. It has nothing to do with artifacts. Higher frame rates just do not have that "otherworldly" look that everyone associates with high quality cinema. It's a completely psychological effect, but it's nonetheless entirely real and it absolute cheapens the look and is very distracting.

Moreover, anyone who knows anything about film would have seen these problems a mile away upon hearing that The Hobbit is shooting at 48fps. I honestly can't believe these directors were (initially) behind this, but then again they were apparently backers of 3D as well which also has a reputation for cheapening the look, although that is more debatable. I think moviegoers will outright hate 48fps though, rather than just gradually shy away from it as in the case of 3D tech.

Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by Gring on Saturday April 28, 2012 @03:46AM (#3902326)
"otherworldly" is just a nice word for "1920s technology".

Getting closer to reality is a common thread in the arts. As soon as man had a way to move from one-color cave paintings to using colors, he started to use them.

This is the artistic expression that Peter Jackson is going for.

In one of the video blogs he said: "The result looks like where the screen was, there is now a hole in the wall, and beyond that is reality".

Imagine, instead of looking a film of Bilbo, you're transported right there into Middle-earth and it looks absolutely real. Wouldn't that be great? I'm very much looking forward to that experience.

Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by shock-value on Saturday April 28, 2012 @03:57AM (#3902348)
Yes you are right in a way that it looks more "real". But real in the sense that you are acutely aware that it is a staged production when viewing it. The author of this article directly addresses this when he says just that, and also notes that it looks like a behind the scenes featurette.

I have not seen footage from The Hobbit but I have worked with other dramatic content at high frame rates and I know exactly what the author is describing. It's really gonna bug people if they really do release at 48fps.

Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by Gring on Saturday April 28, 2012 @04:52AM (#3902440)
I've seen several Showscan films, and I loved them.

I think the biggest problem is acting. 24fps lays a veneer of "movie look" over all performances. With higher framerates, actors can no longer count on that.

They have to sell it much more, like in a theatre, but with large screen closeups projected on a 20 meter screen.

In a way, it's a new challenge actors never had before. It will be interesting to see whether there are indeed performance differences among the Hobbit actors.

Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by taligent on Saturday April 28, 2012 @03:44AM (#3902321)
Of course this IS the director that took a great story like The Lovely Bones and butchered it into a special effects laden monstrosity.
Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by Metapony on Saturday April 28, 2012 @02:50AM (#3902235)
I doubt it's the framerate. Peter Jackson just isn't the greatest director in the world. That seems more in line with the criticism I've seen.
Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by Hominem on Saturday April 28, 2012 @02:36AM (#3902218)
I'm a bit confused, if the FPS was the issue wouldn't the helicopter shots look like crap as well? Is 48 FPS more optimal for helicopter shots?
Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by geon on Saturday April 28, 2012 @02:54AM (#3902241)
The writer is used to watching nature documenataries made for TV. They have always been shot in 50-60 fps.
Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by gte910h on Saturday April 28, 2012 @08:51AM (#3902822)
People said very similar things when video started getting released on 720p and 1080p resolutions.

I'm going to wait to judge for myself.

Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by jsprinkles on Saturday April 28, 2012 @02:22AM (#3902205)
I'm only a little worried about this. When you ask the lay what "film" looks like and why video looks different, most people cannot quantify what it means (but can definitely tell the difference). "Film" to most people is that slow, deliberate frame advancement of 24 fps, blur and all. Take that away, and it doesn't look like "film" any more; it's just how we're collectively used to it.

This reminds me of, say, Law & Order. The detectives are standing around a monitor, reviewing security tape; medium shot of the detectives, 24 fps. Full screen tape: 30 drop. Back to the detectives, 24 fps. We've all seen that before -- whenever the characters play with a consumer camera or look at a security feed, visually, a distinction is set by accelerating the frame rate. Producers know this. It just shouts "not a professionally-photographed teleplay!" in most peoples' minds now, and I think there will be resistance to rewrite that rule mentally.

While I welcome dramatic entertainment that looks more like real life, I worry that culturally, we're used to 24 fps and it's going to be a begrudging transition. At least HDTV offered a noticeable improvement. Not everybody will say the same thing about more visually real entertainment; entertainment is entertainment for a reason, and we do not want to be reminded of real scenarios in most cases (it's a flight of fancy).

My two cents. Will be interesting to see how this plays out, anyway. Imagine anthropologists discovering threads like this one in thousands of years: "they even quibbled over the frame rate of their time-dilated visual entertainment..."

Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by melvinmt on Saturday April 28, 2012 @02:44AM (#3902228)
I'm not sure the difference has much to do with frame rates but rather with 'depth' by relying heavily on focus in film with blurred backgrounds whereas handheld and security cameras usually lack this depth and show a flattened image.
Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by hej on Saturday April 28, 2012 @01:54AM (#3902156)
Could be culture. We are used to films looking a certain way and TV looking different, everything else could very well be rationaizations. Not that it changes much about the situation, though.
Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by taligent on Saturday April 28, 2012 @02:09AM (#3902176)
It is a cultural, subconscious effect. Higher frame rate content is associated with either real life (sports, news) or bad TV (soaps).

I don't think the content association is the problem. The problem is that most people watch movies to escape from real life. It could be that higher frame rate is used for action movies e.g. Transformers and lower frame rate for dramas but I don't know how that would work.

Oh and any argument about "getting used to it" can be shot down with 3D. The world has had plenty of time to adjust and overwhelmingly still hate it.

Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by zoul on Saturday April 28, 2012 @02:23AM (#3902207)
The problem is that most people watch movies to escape from real life.

As I understand it, the problem is that movies are an illusion and in order for them to work, the viewers must buy into it, which is apparently a bit harder with higher framerate.

Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by agumonkey on Saturday April 28, 2012 @03:04AM (#3902263)
There's also a impressionist dimension to it. Like recent very high definition, very high quality models and organic animation, that all lacks some quality that you'd have with lower older games.

I'd be happy to be proven wrong and enjoy a >24fps movie, but everytime I see one it breaks the magic badly.