News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by Gring on Saturday April 28, 2012 @02:37AM (#3902222)
Bad review.

That "video look" he's mentioning is the absence of 24fps artifacts I'm very glad we get rid of.

He could as well just have written "meh, reality has a video look".

Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by shock-value on Saturday April 28, 2012 @03:24AM (#3902288)
No, you're wrong. It has nothing to do with artifacts. Higher frame rates just do not have that "otherworldly" look that everyone associates with high quality cinema. It's a completely psychological effect, but it's nonetheless entirely real and it absolute cheapens the look and is very distracting.

Moreover, anyone who knows anything about film would have seen these problems a mile away upon hearing that The Hobbit is shooting at 48fps. I honestly can't believe these directors were (initially) behind this, but then again they were apparently backers of 3D as well which also has a reputation for cheapening the look, although that is more debatable. I think moviegoers will outright hate 48fps though, rather than just gradually shy away from it as in the case of 3D tech.

Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by Gring on Saturday April 28, 2012 @03:46AM (#3902326)
"otherworldly" is just a nice word for "1920s technology".

Getting closer to reality is a common thread in the arts. As soon as man had a way to move from one-color cave paintings to using colors, he started to use them.

This is the artistic expression that Peter Jackson is going for.

In one of the video blogs he said: "The result looks like where the screen was, there is now a hole in the wall, and beyond that is reality".

Imagine, instead of looking a film of Bilbo, you're transported right there into Middle-earth and it looks absolutely real. Wouldn't that be great? I'm very much looking forward to that experience.

Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by shock-value on Saturday April 28, 2012 @03:57AM (#3902348)
Yes you are right in a way that it looks more "real". But real in the sense that you are acutely aware that it is a staged production when viewing it. The author of this article directly addresses this when he says just that, and also notes that it looks like a behind the scenes featurette.

I have not seen footage from The Hobbit but I have worked with other dramatic content at high frame rates and I know exactly what the author is describing. It's really gonna bug people if they really do release at 48fps.

Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by Gring on Saturday April 28, 2012 @04:52AM (#3902440)
I've seen several Showscan films, and I loved them.

I think the biggest problem is acting. 24fps lays a veneer of "movie look" over all performances. With higher framerates, actors can no longer count on that.

They have to sell it much more, like in a theatre, but with large screen closeups projected on a 20 meter screen.

In a way, it's a new challenge actors never had before. It will be interesting to see whether there are indeed performance differences among the Hobbit actors.

Re:The Hobbit Underwhelms At 48 Frames Per Second by taligent on Saturday April 28, 2012 @03:44AM (#3902321)
Of course this IS the director that took a great story like The Lovely Bones and butchered it into a special effects laden monstrosity.