MCAS was not intended to be an anti-stall system.
The only purpose of MCAS was to have the 737 MAX exactly mimick the 737 NG's (previous gen) pitch dynamics so that airlines wouldn't have to retrain their pilots on the 737 MAX.
Commercial pilots are generally pretty good at not stalling planes and understanding flight dynamics, they don't need MCAS to avoid stalling even when the plane pitches up during thrust.
This video is about bledend-wing designs, but it touches on the 737 MAX problem with illustrations,
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=59A8-rKRs-0&t=705s
at minute 11:45 , but it's also worth watching the part at 4:31 , where another illustration explains the forces at work in an aircraft, using a classic 737 as an example.
It is on a different subject but the whole video is very interesting.
That said, it's true the MCAS was intended to address some comments from test pilots during development.
The EA crew did not follow the runaway trim procedure sent to them in an Emergency Airworthiness Directive. The procedure is:
1. restore normal trim with the electric trim switches
2. turn off the trim system
This grand-fathering of 737 is the reason it still does not have fly-by-wire in 2024: it simulates the antique original 737.
Or was misleading people on the invasive nature of the changes always the point? And MCAS is easier to hide than new wings?
> This grand-fathering of 737 is the reason it still does not have fly-by-wire in 2024
The 737 does not have fly-by-wire? Then how does MCAS work?
I thought it was mostly due to the much higher bypass-ratio than burning temp?
"The new two-stage High Pressure Turbine section adds advanced coatings for cooling metal parts that will enable the same metal temperatures as today’s engines despite hotter gas path temperatures."
https://web.archive.org/web/20150418191419/http://airinsight...
The same improvements are being made to electric utility turbines.
https://www.aircraft-commerce.com/wp-content/uploads/aircraf...
737 MAX uses 20% less fuel.
Incidentally, this fuel-efficient design is what lead to the design defect. The fuel efficiency is thanks to larger engine (larger engines burn hotter and use less fuel). To make the larger engine fit under the wing without raising the fuselage, they had to reposition the engine forward. This forward-positioning of the engine causes the nose to pitch up when accelerating quickly (and this can cause stall) and they fixed this defect using software to push the nose down.