News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by Draiken on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @08:35AM (#38925990)
Another reason to stop using Google. Don't waste the opportunity!

Switched to DDG ages ago, and even though it's not amazing, it's already better than Google.

Although, if we're honest, searching these days is absolutely atrocious everywhere. Any keyword search will only net you ads or "top X" articles full of SEO garbage most likely written by AI at this point...

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by ravenstine on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @09:45AM (#38926737)
Not necessarily everywhere, or at least not quite as bad as you're suggesting, in my experience.

I used to advocate for DDG, but they've gone so far downhill that I rarely waste my time with it. They've decided to go PG-rated everywhere even if you have safe search turned off. This is a problem because, even if they just want to block porn or illegal things, this can have an impact on legitimate academic research. And yeah, SEO trash floats to the surface, though they aren't entirely in control of this.

Kagi (which relies on Brave Search instead of Bing) has less flotsam to start with, provides lots of great tools to filter out the garbage, and is subscriber-driven instead of advertiser or investor driven.

DDG had potential, but they decided to give into moral panic and coast on their modest success instead of making substantial improvements. They also decided to pull a Mozilla and spend unnecessary effort working on a browser when they should be focusing on their core product. It'd be one thing to make a browser if their core product was actually good, but the best they are offering is a pinky-swear that your searches are private.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by davidcbc on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:10AM (#38927726)
> Kagi (which relies on Brave Search instead of Bing)

This is misleading. Kagi uses multiple external sources including Google and Brave as well as their own internal indexes

https://help.kagi.com/kagi/search-details/search-sources.htm...

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by ravenstine on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @12:26PM (#38928902)
Ah, I was under the impression it was almost entirely the same as Brave. Thanks!
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by the_snooze on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @10:59AM (#38927587)
>Bing

DDG works well enough for me to be my daily driver, but it's absolute garbage for any kind of news search. Bing prioritizes MSN repost spam from dubious sources, so I'm better off going just directly to news sites I trust.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by theshrike79 on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:44AM (#38928244)
I must be weird, because I very rarely search for news. I just go to the sites I trust.

I think the only time I search for news (usually on Google) is to find a reliable article about a celebrity death.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by NoZebra120vClip on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @12:28PM (#38928924)
You can actually find this rather rapidly through Wikipedia.

In fact, you can identify the exact moment when the news about the death leaked, when the first editor adds it to the article. Generally, experienced editors will keep it out until a reliable source is provided, which typically happens quite quickly.

In fact I've found out about a number of celebrity deaths, just by having them on my watchlist.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by bad_alloc on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @08:48AM (#38926104)
For people who don't know them yet: use DDG bangs. For example "!m restaurant [citynmae]" will immediately bring you to Google maps, "!w chemistry" will open Wikipedia etc. Super easy and powerful :)
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by NekkoDroid on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @09:09AM (#38926339)
Setting stuff up for that in any browser worth it's salt isn't too difficult, skipping the entire middleman of any search engine.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by TheCraiggers on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @09:26AM (#38926531)
But it's already set up for you in DDG, so why not use it?

Aside from the fact it's another HTTP request, but these days on the majority of computers and connections, that's a trivial thing.

I'll add that !aw to search the Arch Wiki and !aur to search the AUR are my two most favorite commands.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by AdmiralAsshat on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:26AM (#38927976)
> But it's already set up for you in DDG, so why not use it?

Because if I wanna search Reddit, I'd prefer to have '!r' search directly within Reddit and not litter my browser history with tons of duckduckgo entries like this:

https://duckduckgo.com/l/?uddg=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.reddit.com%...

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by dingnuts on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:36AM (#38928126)
weird example considering just how bad Reddit's internal search is and always has been -- that's a site I've always preferred to search with an external search engine, be it Google, DDG, or Kagi lol

doesn't hurt to have options! to each his own

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by AdmiralAsshat on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @12:02PM (#38928538)
Best example I could come up with on-the-spot, because I already swapped out Google, Amazon, and Wikipedia on my Firefox install for native search engines, and needed to quickly generate search results from a DDG bang so I could show the accompanying history page. :P
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by plugin-baby on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:16AM (#38927816)
> Aside from the fact it's another HTTP request

You’d think DDG could avoid this via JavaScript if they wanted to. Might be better for privacy, if not for their usage stats.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by wharvle on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @12:04PM (#38928555)
Years and years ago I'd configure this stuff in FF, but using DDG effectively auto-configures it for any browser, exactly the same, everywhere, all I have to do is set the default search engine. And it includes some that I do use but probably wouldn't have bothered to configure on my own.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by kevincox on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @12:11PM (#38928683)
Firefox Sync is end-to-end encrypted and will sync your keyword bookmarks across all of your devices. Sure, you have to set them up but it seems worth it to get the ones that work for me, not whatever duck duck go thinks is popular.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by wharvle on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @12:18PM (#38928783)
I've never wanted one and not found it in DDG, or found it named differently from what I'd have named it. Every now and then I try to guess one blind, and I don't think I've ever had it surprise me. And it works in any browser.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by kevincox on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @12:31PM (#38928963)
I guess you are the perfectly average human then. I am not so lucky.

I have `s` to search sourcegraph.com, DDG has !sg. `t` to use Google Translate, DDG has !gt, `i` to search IMDB, DDG has !imd or !imdb, v to search animated images, DDG has !gif, `ni` to search nixpkgs issues which DDG doesn't have (although they do have one for the nix repo at !nr which is pretty impressive. I use `nc` for this). Not to mention personalized shortcuts like searching my company's GitHub organization or JIRA tickets that would never be a public bang, much less have a 2 character shortcut.

I stopped there but it is clear to me that I benefit from making my own short aliases for the searches that I use most. Plus it is nice to not send my logs to a third party and get improved performance.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by eviks on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @09:37AM (#38926650)
It's better to lose the inconvenient ! and use a browser that supports prefixes in the search bar

Then you can "w chemistry" to open Wikipedia with a list of suggestions from the same Wikipedia ("Chemistry (Girls Aloud album)") in the same place

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by rpdillon on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @10:41AM (#38927372)
I think everyone in the thread knows about "search engines" in Chrome and bookmark keywords in Firefox. The crux of the issue is that there are more than 10,000 bang commands in DDG. Setting up even a popular subset in any given browser is a significant investment. It's fine if it's the browser you use 99% of the time, but for those spanning multiple computers, phones, and other devices, simply using bang commands is a strict win.

https://duckduckgo.com/bangs

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by eviks on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:19AM (#38927866)
99% of the time you use <0.1% of the bangs, so setting those up isn't a significant investment. Then there are also the downsides mentioned above (less convenient, no preview, not portable across search engines), so no, it's not a strict win, but an inferior alternative which is superior only in those cases where you can't setup something better
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by hedora on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:31AM (#38928056)
If I went that route, I’d have to set them up on my phone, tablet, laptop, desktop, etc, all of which have different operating systems/web browsers.

I guess I could implement them as a web server, and point all my devices at it.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by eviks on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:55AM (#38928432)
Some browsers sync these settings, so that removes a lot of the complexity. But in general, you're repeating the same mistake. No, you wouldn't have to do that, you'd just set it up on the devices you use the most to get the most convenience in the most common cases, and then use the less convenient option on others.

There is no point in making 100% of your experience worse just because you can't make 100% of your experience better

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by hedora on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @10:15PM (#38935694)
None of the browsers I use across those devices sync settings well. Even if it was 100% firefox, I don't want to trust the cloud, and can't be bothered to set up a mozilla sync server just for this (I don't use bookmarks, and there aren't any other settings I want to sync).

Also, as it is, I make 100% of my experience better by switching all the browsers to a search engine that provides better results than google and has !bang support.

There are at least two such search engines: duck duck go and kagi.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by eviks on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:44AM (#38937036)
To make an actual "better" argument you have to address the aforementioned limitations
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by hedora on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:27PM (#38940918)
> Then there are also the downsides mentioned above (less convenient, no preview, not portable across search engines), so no, it's not a strict win, but an inferior alternative which is superior only in those cases where you can't setup something better

- less convenient: Addressed by my comment.

- no preview: I do not want preview, so this is a bonus. It's also orthogonal, since if the search bar was configured to preview, it could also display bang results.

- not portable across search engines: It already works on all non-terrible search engines because they standardized the bangs.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by eviks on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:01PM (#38941265)
> - less convenient: Addressed by my comment.

Not addressed, Shift+1+w is less convenient than w, try to address that by your comment!

> I do not want preview, so this is a bonus.

Not a bonus since you can achieve the same natively, so again not better

> It's also orthogonal, since if the search bar was configured to preview, it could also display bang results.

No it couldn't? What's your preview link to DDG to show the results of a Wikipedia page for a given search term in the browser?

> - not portable across search engines: It already works on all non-terrible search engines because they standardized the bangs.

Since these don't exist (DDG is very similar to Google in search quality), it doesn't work. But this is personal, so if your needs are narrow enough to be covered just by DDG+Kagi, than you obviously don't need portability.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by wharvle on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @12:07PM (#38928595)
Something this doesn't do that DDG bangs do, is let me append it, or even stick it in the middle of a search. I can just type it wherever my cursor happens to be, other than in the middle of a term. This comes up when I search something in DDG then change my mind and want to use a bang.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by eviks on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @01:19PM (#38929759)
good point, and it's smart enough to ignore when quoted

Wish they also allowed changing the !prefix

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by focusedone on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @10:14AM (#38927081)
DDG was great anyway, but discovering their !bangs was a revelation. Super cool stuff!
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by amelius on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @10:31AM (#38927259)
They should add bang-buttons at the top of their result pages. Didn't find what you were looking for? Just hit one of the bang buttons.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by WhackyIdeas on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:25AM (#38927954)
Been using these !bangs for a while.. also works with bang!
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by alcoholic_byte on Thursday January 11, 2024 @07:47AM (#38951508)
I agree, it is nice and privacy respecting, but I take umbrige with the google-maps. I am not really using Gmaps and I have everyone in my orbit exposed to alternatives. Just because.... like cato used to say...... I believe that Google should be destroyed.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by forward1 on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:49AM (#38928349)
How is DDG "better" than Google? In my experience it serves almost identical results. And it's now served from Microsoft servers, so the argument "it's more private" doesn't really hold water anymore.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by Draiken on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @12:29PM (#38928938)
They don't break their site for Firefox users for starters :)

I do say this as somewhat of a joke, but that's for me a real reason. It's not the first time Google has intentionally screwed over Firefox users.

Even if we believe what they say every time it happens: it's "just a bug". For me it clearly signals they simply don't care. And that's the best case scenario. Worst case they're abusing their market position to drive out competition.

Even if DDG serves requests from MS servers, that's not even close to opting into the Google surveillance machine.

Finally, if what you said holds true about serving basically the same content, then the hostility against Firefox and the fact that you won't be helping this monopoly should already make it "better".

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by JTbane on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:11AM (#38927747)
Unfortunately I'm locked into gmail, migrating away from it would require days of effort and I would never be sure I moved everything.

Also, YouTube is still the best video site despite going full mask-off on adblockers.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by hedora on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:24AM (#38927929)
Fastmail -> settings -> migration -> import

Then set up a gmail forwarding rule.

The full documentation is here:

https://www.fastmail.help/hc/en-us/articles/360058752414-Mig...

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by cobertos on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:30AM (#38928033)
I migrated about 5 different Gmail accounts off of Gmail to FastMail and it wasn't too bad. Though it was at least a day of work across all of them.

I honestly spent more time trying to wrangle the data in all of the other numerous Google services those accounts had data with.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by Draiken on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:34AM (#38928101)
I am in a similar boat with an ages old Gmail account. My comment was originally intended to be only about Google search (I realize now I didn't specify that, lol), but leaving the entire ecosystem is definitely a lot harder...
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by salil999 on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:53AM (#38928393)
Why is this a reason to stop using Google?
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by diggan on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @08:40AM (#38926032)
The only thing that I've found that works properly for my use case (regularly switching between three locales and languages) is Kaggle with the lenses. The only thing missing is disconnecting the locale from the language so I can have proper decimal characters but still search for US-specific things. Right now, I have to chose between having 10,000.10 or 10.000,10 and what language/region I'm searching, together, which is a bit annoying.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by freedomben on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @09:25AM (#38926513)
I think "Kaggle" is supposed to be Kagi but was typoed or autocorrected or something? (If not and you're talkign about Kaggle the ML/AI company, please disregard)

I also use Kagi lenses and it's been good, though for me the killer Kagi feature is being able to uprank/downrank/pin/block domains. Such an obvious and simple feature, such a powerful effect.

There is a psychological barrier to overcome in paying for searches, but once you get past that, Kagi makes a ton of sense. I suspect the reason Google never implemented personalized search results (like Kagi's where you can uprank/downrank domains) is because it's not about what you see, it's about what they show you. i.e. ads.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by diggan on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @10:29AM (#38927239)
You're right of course, supposed to be Kagi, I blame it on a lack of coffee.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by _jal on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @10:43AM (#38927385)
> the killer Kagi feature is being able to uprank/downrank/pin/block domains

Yes! This alone is worth the subscription to me.

And I despise and avoid software subscriptions, Kagi is my third.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by devnullbrain on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @09:22AM (#38926477)
Do you mean Kagi?
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by hospitalJail on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:37AM (#38928143)
Well I was using firefox and google maps.

Apple maps is Yelp spam.

What should I be doing? I was doing research