News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by pmontra on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @06:05AM (#38924701)
9 minutes ago:

> Since this has now been posted to HN, I'll be locking this thread. This bugtracker is a work place, not a discussion forum.

We have a bad fame.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by latexr on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @07:55AM (#38925607)
Locking the issue after it has been posted to any large community is the right call.

The respectful users will look at the thread and not comment to not derail the discussion. The fraction of a percent which may have something relevant to contribute probably already did or will find another way to do so if it’s important.

The remaining users will post low quality comments for a while then leave forever. Like a flash mob that invades your home, parties for a few hours, then leaves a mess for the regulars to clean up.

Can’t blame the owner for preemptively locking the door.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by lamontcg on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @08:28AM (#38925915)
> This bugtracker is a work place, not a discussion forum.

that's actually an excellent way to frame what a bugtracker is actually for.

it is about workers getting shit done and its optimized for the people who work the issues.

it isn't optimized for the people posting comments on issues.

and the fact that a lot of users that have never had to deal with fixing software bugs think it looks like a forum website would explain the impedance mismatch that you often see.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by heresie-dabord on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @08:59AM (#38926226)
> it is about workers getting shit done and its optimized for the people who work the issues.

The above phrase also explains why Social Media is not a bug-tracker. ^_^

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by dylan604 on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @10:25AM (#38927189)
Sadly, it seems to be the only bug tracker or method of getting issues noticed by the tech firms with the issues.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by msp26 on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @07:35AM (#38925409)
Well someone did just write "'now you have two problems' b-bazinga. Software engineering is hard."

I don't blame them for the lock.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by tmtvl on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @06:45AM (#38924995)
Our bad reputation is not entirely undeserved, some of us are not as well behaved as others.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by politelemon on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @07:34AM (#38925398)
It's one of those occasional intersections where we are reminded that our reputation within HN comments does not reflect the outside world.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by Uptrenda on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @07:27AM (#38925341)
idk, seems kind of like an unnecessarily asshole type of reply. The way contributors interact with people on a bug tracker also sets the tone for social conduct within the project and making people feel unwelcome is a nice way to ensure they'll never contribute. It's a 1 bil iq move [for an open source project.]
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by jgraham on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @07:56AM (#38925627)
(I work on WebCompat at Mozilla)

There are various people whose job involves triaging issues filed on that repo, and communicating with the issue authors where necessary e.g. to figure out additional steps required to reproduce the reported problem. The point of that effort is exactly because we value reports of site breakage so highly, and want to ensure that people reporting them have a good experience.

Unfortunately when a bug report (not just this in this repo, but almost anywhere) hits (almost any) social media there's a high chance of the suddenly large audience making comments that aren't at all actionable in fixing the issue. In this case it seems highly unlikely that anyone can add additional information that will allow a faster resolution, whereas there was already one off-topic/unactionable comment at the time the issue was locked.

So if we leave the issue open, it has the downside of disrupting our normal workflows, and taking attention away from fixing either the problem at hand, or any other issues that currently require our attention. To me that significantly outweighs the potential upside of leaving it open to "make people feel welcome".

Of course, like many things in life, it's not a mathematical problem where you can derive a correct answer, but a set of tradeoffs based on experience, and therefore reasonable people may come to different conclusions.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by lightedman on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @10:19AM (#38927118)
"There are various people whose job involves triaging issues filed on that repo, and communicating with the issue authors where necessary e.g. to figure out additional steps required to reproduce the reported problem."

And exactly where are the various QUALITY CONTROL testers that should've caught such a dead-simple problem like "This won't work with Google Search" before it ever happened in the first place?

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by denschub on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:58AM (#38928476)
This issue was caused by Google on their server-side, without any relation to a change in Firefox, so I'm not sure why you feel the need to yell at my Mozilla-colleague.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by lightedman on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:53AM (#38951045)
As a quality control technician, I have several tests, including checking against third party resources for compatibility.

If I were a web browser coder, making sure my software worked with the major websites of the internet would be the FIRST thing to test. I don't release until I know it works.

This exact same mindset is why I make the expensive stuff where I work, and nobody else.

I'm also not yelling. That you think text is yelling is quite something I'll never understand from anyone. Two capitalized words isn't yelling.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by Uptrenda on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @01:02PM (#38929496)
Nah, that's bullshit. If someone interacts with your team on whatever medium you go out of your way to be respectful and shouldn't act like stuck up, condescending neckbeards, whose presence is a gift to humanity. I run many open source repos myself and you can bet that when people take the trouble to interact with me I make it my mission to listen to what they say and treat them with respect. I don't expect them to act like robots and neither should you. The way you've all answered here makes me think that you're a bunch of code monkeys incapable of understanding that software is created for human beings and not machines.

>In this case it seems highly unlikely that anyone can add additional information that will allow a faster resolution

Heaven forbid. Sounds like Mozilla is a wonderful and fun place to work. Lmao.

>of disrupting our normal workflows, and taking attention away from fixing either the problem at hand

People aren't going to die if a few off-topic comments are posted. Holy fuck, what is wrong with you.

>To me that significantly outweighs the potential upside of leaving it open to "make people feel welcome".

That's exactly the problem. Acting like regular users have no worthwhile input is unbelievably out of touch and just plain insufferable. Maybe if you listened more to the user you could build a browser that wasn't such a piece of shit. Lmao.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by sdk- on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @07:24PM (#38934403)
> I run many open source repos myself and you can bet that when people take the trouble to interact with me I make it my mission to listen to what they say and treat them with respect.

You clearly look like a very polite person /s

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by jraph on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @07:40AM (#38925454)
OTOH do they need more input from external contributors? They have everything they need. google.com serves '<!DOCTYPE html>' to Firefox and that's the end of the webcompat story. Google needs to fix this. Full stop.

Given this, I can see how this thing can attract low quality comments and have a very low chance of receiving interesting insight.

Now, since we are on HN I'll provide my one low quality comment on this: I guess it's a silly mistake that's not intended, but still feels like another whoops [1].

Also: come on Google, seriously? Don't you have QA for such things?

[1] https://www.zdnet.com/article/former-mozilla-exec-google-has...

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by augustohp on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @07:33AM (#38925384)
Although I agree his words could've been chosen more carefully, they come from someone used to work with computers. Not his forte.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by doix on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @08:28AM (#38925917)
Oh come on. As soon as any issue hits any "social media" site, the comments turn to shit with people inserting their own clever meme or whatever.

The bug is well understood, there's nothing to gain from keeping the issue open and a lot to lose. Getting notifications for "shit posts" is pretty annoying.

_Maybe_ they could have avoided explicitly calling out HN and just said "social media" or whatever. But you're really pulling at straws to get offended here. I don't think their an asshole, I think they're pragmatic.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by bigbillheck on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @08:54AM (#38926167)
A bit of searching suggests that this individual is the same 'robertsdotpm' who posted that "b-bazinga" comment, or at least is closely associated with them.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by temp0826 on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @12:39PM (#38929070)
Not sure why you're getting downvoted. Googlers? Obviously scummy behavior should be highlighted.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by bigbillheck on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @01:05PM (#38929540)
> Not sure why you're getting downvoted

People will upvote and downvote on this site as they please, and caring about it is a recipe for a bad time.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by striking on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @09:28AM (#38926551)
Good catch. No wonder their comment sounded so defensive, they're the bad guy!
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by ben_w on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @07:56AM (#38925626)
"Orange site bad" is a bit of a meme. I even heard it IRL at a hacker space in the last few weeks.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by zozbot234 on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @07:37AM (#38925423)
> ... We have a bad fame.

HN is too orange.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by Andrex on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @01:09PM (#38929601)
I switched it to the same color gray as the background. HN actually provides a pref for this in your user settings.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by doublerabbit on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @04:12PM (#38932171)
A perk for gaining a certain amount of karma.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by Andrex on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @04:49PM (#38932617)
Really? Huh. I've been here 13 years and I'm still learning new things.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by hartator on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @07:40AM (#38925467)
Mozilla elitism.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by jraph on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @07:43AM (#38925494)
Or experience with the internet?

Of course outrageous GitHub issues get low quality comments from HN.

The guy probably reacted like this because of the dummy comment he marked as off topic and probably made the connection.

> 'now you have two problems' b-bazinga. Software engineering is hard.

He might have said the same of Reddit, or any social network. It's pretty reasonable and I think he made the right call.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by denschub on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @07:56AM (#38925625)
You are 100% correct in your assumptions. This isn't my first incident, and it won't be my last. As much as some folks here want to call me an asshole for that, we have a very good understanding of how this ends if we don't lock comments.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by shadowgovt on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @10:50AM (#38927451)
FWIW, good on you for managing the signal responsibly.

I have to smirk a bit every time I see the public do this to themselves. The public: "Why are companies never honest? Why is press-release-speak such a space-alien way of communicating?" Also the public: reacts like this when someone takes a simple, clear action and explains it directly.

(And yes, I know I'm guilty of broad-strokes reasoning lumping everyone in as "the public" and anthropomorphizing that entity. In this context, doesn't matter. Only takes a few bad actors to wreck the signal).

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by bigbillheck on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @08:49AM (#38926114)
> We have a bad fame.

But not one undeserved.

Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by wharvle on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @12:16PM (#38928755)
N-Gate summaries were harsh, but fair. Basically spot on.
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by avgcorrection on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @10:31AM (#38927264)
> This bugtracker is a work place, not a discussion forum.

Well, tradeoffs and whatnot with hosting your bugtracker on the most open code platform on the Web.

    “Conversation limited to contributors until popular site calms down”
Re:Google breaks search for Firefox users because of bad UA ... by lagniappe on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:06AM (#38927677)
at least it wasn't a testicle in an egg cup like that other site