News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by light_hue_1 on Sunday January 07, 2024 @02:44AM (#38899346)
I work with a lot of people (both adults and students) who have this kind of intelligence and who are used to being the smartest person around.

I can tell you that your feeling of wasted potential isn't just a consequence of how you were treated. Most people in this situation have it. Even when they are wildly successful by any other standard. Like PhDs from ivies are normal, the number of people walking down the hallway who are billionaires is astoundingly high, etc.

You would be shocked at the self harm, depression, and suicide rate that at this level. All because of this idea of "oh, I could have won a Nobel" (I'm certain that if they had they would find a way to be sad about wasted potential anyway).

The solution is therapy. Don't wait. Just go do it. Just because you're smart doesn't mean that you don't need that kind of help. It might mean that you need it even more!

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by jrgoff on Sunday January 07, 2024 @03:15AM (#38899509)
I'm curious if you have any suggestions for such people to find a successful therapy fit (I'm asking both out of personal curiosity as well as hoping that it will help others)? I'm not in that category of brilliant, but I tried therapy off and on for 10 or 15 years before I started feeling like it really helped. I think part of the problem is that I didn't know what was "wrong" with me - I knew that I had trouble with maintaining romantic relationships and I knew that I was sometimes unhappy (though I was rarely willing to admit to myself how unhappy I often was), but I didn't really know why. And I spent a lot of time introspecting, so generally when I tried therapy out the therapist wouldn't have any real insights that I hadn't thought of already. I didn't dislike my therapists, but generally would give up after a few months of not feeling like any progress was being made.

I'm not sure all of what went into things working out for me in therapy the past couple of years, but I think at least a part of it was shifting into a more emotions based approach. I'm not sure how open to that I would have been when I was younger. My tendency to approach most things intellectually was a very powerful tool, but it wasn't successful at getting to the underlying feelings I was not really aware of. Having more access to those feelings has been overwhelming at times, but also has enabled a lot of ongoing progress on being more satisfied with my life.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by mnky9800n on Sunday January 07, 2024 @04:52AM (#38899905)
I would recommend schema therapy to anyone. It has helped me immensely to understand feelings, thoughts, reactions, and also to decide what is and isn't something I should attend to. Additionally I would recommend dialectical behaviour therapy to anyone. It gives you the skills to interact with the knowledge gained from schema therapy. Lastly, I recommend doing mindfulness training. If you only spend 5 minutes a day it will change your life. I am able to be calm when before I wasn't, able to be thoughtful about others when before I would react, able to focus on a task and organise my day when before I could not muster the executive function to brush my teeth. These things have made my life considerably better.
Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by light_hue_1 on Sunday January 07, 2024 @09:31AM (#38901471)
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy is at the moment the most effective form of therapy we have. It can take a few tries to find someone who you click with.

CBT isn't about someone giving you an aha moment into your own feelings or giving you advice you hadn't thought of (although that does happen). It's more about giving you skills to reinterpret those feelings, their sources, and the actions that result from them. So even if you feel like you introspect and understand how you're doing, CBT can be very effective in being more satisfied with life.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by Yoric on Sunday January 07, 2024 @03:55AM (#38899684)
> I can tell you that your feeling of wasted potential isn't just a consequence of how you were treated. Most people in this situation have it.

Yup. I was reasonably well-treated as a gifted kid (well, still bullied to death, but at least, I had smart + available parents and many opportunities to learn by myself). I still suffer from that.

I do have a few achievements behind my belt. I have a PhD, I have code running on your computer and in low earth orbit. Pretty much every junior developer learns stuff that I (and many, many others) have contributed to create. I raise a kid, I donate blood, money, time to charities. And I can't escape the feeling that I'm wasting my time, that I could/should be doing something greater, and that I'm basically useless as is.

Yes, I probably need some kind of therapy :)

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by operatingthetan on Sunday January 07, 2024 @04:00AM (#38899699)
> And I can't escape the feeling that I'm wasting my time, that I could/should be doing something greater, and that I'm basically useless as is.

Sometimes I feel like humans have a limiter put on them and someday we could 'fix' it. I occasionally get a glimpse of huge ideas that aren't just built on existing stuff, but then it fades and I'm back to the grind.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by hypertele-Xii on Sunday January 07, 2024 @03:45AM (#38899638)
Therapy is not a solution, it's just wasting time dwelling on the problems, which I'm already aware of and struggling to fix. There is nothing a therapist can tell me that I don't already know, and aren't already doing.

I don't self-harm, I'm not suicidal, I'm not even depressed. I'm just so late to the party that the chances of making it shrink ever smaller each year. No therapist can ever turn back time, so no therapist can ever help.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by mnky9800n on Sunday January 07, 2024 @04:56AM (#38899917)
You have a very narrow view of therapy. Modern, research based therapy practice like dialectical behaviour therapy don't really care about your past or whatever oppression you suffered. They give you the skills necessary to interact with your life today. If you are struggling to handle problems yet believe you already know and are doing everything then I would suggest you find some humility.
Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by hypertele-Xii on Sunday January 07, 2024 @07:13AM (#38900590)
> They give you the skills necessary to interact with your life today.

I'm fully interacting with my life today. My life today is not a problem. I'm the master of survival skills for my particular environment - I would've died already otherwise.

The problem is the circumstances that failed to cultivate and extract my potential. The problem was leaving me to fend for myself. The problem was godlessness, immorality, violence, and stupidity.

No therapist can fix that. Ergo, therapy is a waste of time.

> If you are struggling to handle problems yet believe you already know and are doing everything then I would suggest you find some humility.

Can you explain this? Knowing and doing everything is a struggle almost by definition. This struggle I welcome with glee because it's a struggle I choose to endure for the betterment of my quality of life, and through health and productivity, hopefully a benefit to all one day.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by ericjmorey on Sunday January 07, 2024 @07:59AM (#38900844)
Simply from reading your own statements, I can see that you're wrong. I'm probably not as smart as you, yet I can see that you're wrong, but you cannot, why is that?
Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by hypertele-Xii on Monday January 08, 2024 @02:54AM (#38909265)
I'm happy for your alleged ability to see wrongness, but bring into question the validity of merely exclaiming so without any explanation. You didn't just read and see wrongness, you wrote about it without any content whatsoever. Your comment is entirely void of substance.

So how am I wrong, or are you satisfied merely virtue-signaling?

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by mythrwy on Sunday January 07, 2024 @08:37AM (#38901082)
It's great to be smart, but thinking you are smart can become a big problem.
Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by hypertele-Xii on Monday January 08, 2024 @02:42AM (#38909196)
If smartness is so great, how is awareness of it a problem? Your statement appears contradictory, could you elaborate?
Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by light_hue_1 on Sunday January 07, 2024 @09:47AM (#38901608)
I've read what you've written. I won't give you a long argument about why therapy can help someone in you situation because you won't buy it.

But I will say that as someone who spends all day with people that have have his kind of intelligence, therapy is for you. Recontexualizing your life, past and present, as well as your future path is pretty much bread and butter CBT.

Too many smart people have the disease of "I know better, therapy can't help" which is why for example elite institutions have the highest suicide rates. You're falling into that trap, but it's a catch 22, once you're in it, you won't be able to logically argue your way out. Just take the leap and go to therapy.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by hypertele-Xii on Monday January 08, 2024 @02:49AM (#38909232)
My suicide rate is and will forever remain zero, so your continual bringing that up as a reason in favor of therapy is having the opposite effect.

If you truly believed that therapy is for me, you'd be glad to give me the long argument. You already know I won't buy it because you know it isn't.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by mnky9800n on Monday January 08, 2024 @06:12AM (#38910487)
you must be a pleasure to have at parties.
Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by hypertele-Xii on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:12AM (#38965819)
Sure. Back when I partied, people were phoning me up, I took cabs from one party to the next. Every weekend, sometimes multiple parties on the same day. People came to hug me, some even literally said I was an "integral part of their party experience". Something about being easy to be themselves in my presence.

Your attempted ad hominem falls flatter on its face than a pancake mask at a hydraulic press factory. I've not only partied a lot in my youth and was very liked, I was deep in the scene, friends with the crews that organized the parties, the DJs, camera and audio techs, backstage, etc.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by mnky9800n on Sunday January 07, 2024 @05:51PM (#38906053)
Yes I'm well aware of the grandiosity you attribute yourself which covers the hurt and vulnerable child within screaming to not be abandoned, abused, neglected, shamed or isolated. But nobody here will do that to you. This place is a safe place. People only wish you well here given all the comments urging you too bring the critical thinking that this forum is well known for to your own problems. It could be that you don't know everything. It could be that therapy could help you. You simply should try it while heartedly before you dismiss it so eagerly.
Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by hypertele-Xii on Monday January 08, 2024 @03:01AM (#38909305)
> Yes I'm well aware of the grandiosity you attribute yourself

Where is this coming from? I know it's not coming from me because my explicit narrative is precisely that my life lacks these "grandiose" things as you put them, for the obvious reasons I laid out.

Since it's not coming from me, sounds like projection coming from you.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by Ntrails on Monday January 08, 2024 @07:28AM (#38911006)
For the record I read your statements in the same way they do. I might not use "grandiose" but I see what they mean.
Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by verisimi on Sunday January 07, 2024 @02:50AM (#38899388)
Some CBT, quick!