News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by anonreeeeplor on Saturday January 06, 2024 @08:13PM (#38897351)
Before this comment section fills with people self diagnosing themselves as geniuses: I feel this.

I can write dozens of pages of highly analytical and technical text without making mistakes in real time. I can speed read complex texts and memorize them with a high degree of precision.

From the “language” perspective I feel highly gifted and unusual. Not so much on the mathematical side. I almost have a disability with mathematics.

I have taught myself advanced skills and switched careers multiple times without the required degrees. Worked at the top companies in the world with PhDs and others.

However. I feel constantly discriminated against and treated like I am stupider than I am. And when people listen to me talk, they get incredibly threatened.

It has taken me years to understand that being around me and listening to me talk, reason and analyze is THREATENING to people.

I have had situations where, even after a few meetings where I felt I was just “talking about how things are” the other person left HATING me.

The way I express myself is perceived almost like being hit with a physical object. I believe I have Aspergers (have tested very highly for it).

I will tell you - it is INCREDIBLY CAREER LIMITING.

I have given up trying to work in the normal world. It just doesn’t work for me. The pattern always repeats - I join a company, I get targeted and singled out and ganged up on.

If you are like me it is like being incredibly advantaged while being incredibly disadvantaged at the same time.

It’s like being Usain Bolt except your sprinting lane has an obstacle course in it while everyone else gets to run in a normal lane.

The obstacle course is DELIBERATELY put there. It is human nature to instantly identify existential threats: People who are unusually more talented than them and take them out.

I have learned, and am adapting.

Unfortunately, if you want to succeed in this world you have to play a set of games, these are games that I really don’t want to play.

If I have to play them, I am going to try to play outside the system.

I have realized that all the advice which most people follow that works for them does not work for me.

I do things completely differently and have to come up with my own strategies about how to operate.

Here is the other reality: If you are very talented and gifted, NO ONE WILL NOTICE AND TELL YOU.

That sounds completely weird but it is true.

No one in my entire life, aside from a few offhand comments, took me aside and went: “uhhh…you are in a completely other category than these people and do not belong here. Do this instead.”

Instead it is the isolation - I do not understand why no one wants to interact or include me, and it happens very fast. Most people get a whiff and go “I have no idea what to do with this and don’t want to be around it.”

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by iandanforth on Saturday January 06, 2024 @08:18PM (#38897375)
So what do you do now? Also have you connected with others with Asperger's?
Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by anonreeeeplor on Saturday January 06, 2024 @11:54PM (#38898565)
Right now I am starting my own.

I generally gravitate towards the most autistic market niches imaginable. Usually areas which combine multiple autistic topics together that attract the weirdest people imaginable.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by mcherm on Saturday January 06, 2024 @08:29PM (#38897458)
Yeah? Well I, for one, would like to spend more time engaging with people like you. Some of the obvious steps are helpful (eg: "read Less Wrong" was an excellent step some years ago). But I would just like to point out that there ARE some people who would like to interact with those who are very bright and a little bit focused.
Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by IggleSniggle on Saturday January 06, 2024 @09:11PM (#38897705)
Yeah, totally. In fact, when I encounter someone who speaks and behaves like they are on the spectrum, it's a positive signal to me that: they probably aren't going to like me because I'm ADD and careless, but I'm going to love working with them because they are likely to complement my weaknesses.
Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by anonreeeeplor on Sunday January 07, 2024 @10:21PM (#38907858)
Word
Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by lupusreal on Saturday January 06, 2024 @08:34PM (#38897477)
> I can write dozens of pages of highly analytical and technical text without making mistakes in real time. I can speed read complex texts and memorize them with a high degree of precision. From the “language” perspective I feel highly gifted and unusual. [...] And when people listen to me talk, they get incredibly threatened

If your language skills are as advanced and analytical as you claim, then you should apply that innate skill to the problem of finding ways to communicate without making people feel threatened. For instance, tailor (limit) your vocabulary for your audience and don't correct other people's inconsequential errors. And of course refrain from telling people about how brilliant you are.

If you can't manage the above, then maybe you should recognize that you're not actually as brilliant as you think. This realization could give you a bit more humility and that in turn could help you interact with other people.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by anonreeeeplor on Sunday January 07, 2024 @12:07AM (#38898637)
I can’t, it requires theory of mind which I don’t have. The concept of a “this person is a This so you talk to them like That.”

I don’t have it.

Also:

I have worked with quantum physicists with multiple degrees from Harvard / Stanford / Yale etc and realized I am in the same room as and same conversations as them.

These are the upper .01% of the talent pool and my intelligence has got me to that level.

You can’t pull that off by being a complete dumb ass. I have done it over and over and over.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by RAM-bunctious on Saturday January 06, 2024 @10:08PM (#38898041)
I'm not saying your comment is without merit, but regardless of how talented or analytical one is, language use is something of a subconscious process and it takes mental effort to consciously tailor it. Maybe not to the same degree as fixing bad handwriting, but it's the same idea.

It also takes emotional regulation to refrain from correcting someone's factual errors. While someone with higher intelligence may be better at understanding and analysing emotions theoretically, this doesn't always translate into practical emotional management skills.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by latentcall on Saturday January 06, 2024 @09:43PM (#38897896)
> don't correct other people's inconsequential errors

This is a big one I feel. My best friend has Asperger’s and does this from time to time. A recent example is I was telling him about a Thule roof rack I got for my car. I pronounced it Thool, and he interrupted me and said “actually you should know it’s pronounced Tooly”.

It didn’t bother me, but we have a pact that I point out gently when he does things like that. It’s an inconsequential error because it doesn’t really matter how it is pronounced. And some people may find it rude or “know it all” to be corrected like that over something like that.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by anonreeeeplor on Sunday January 07, 2024 @12:08AM (#38898645)
My problem is going on rants about highly abstract topics and theories and ideas, or innovating more than “I am supposed to.”
Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by DaveExeter on Saturday January 06, 2024 @10:15PM (#38898079)
Give him a copy of "How to win friends". I think this is discussed in Chapter 1.
Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by traverseda on Saturday January 06, 2024 @10:40PM (#38898193)
>If you can't manage the above,

Sure, but it can get exhausting over time.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by riwsky on Saturday January 06, 2024 @09:09PM (#38897694)
lmao that u felt qualified to advise on non-threatening communication, dude
Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by lupusreal on Saturday January 06, 2024 @09:40PM (#38897882)
Lmao, I'm not here to make friends. I see a guy sniffing his own farts and am telling him off. If he's as great as he thinks he wouldn't have the problems he complains about.
Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by screedauthor on Saturday January 06, 2024 @10:26PM (#38898127)
You are indeed correct. Imagine writing a whole screed “I’m so smart but everyone else doesn’t think so and they’re wrong”. Imagine being serious about it.
Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by WalterBright on Saturday January 06, 2024 @08:37PM (#38897500)
If I may help - I am not Asperger, but I know several and have worked with them. I am also "on the spectrum", as are a big chunk of my friends and family. Based on these experiences, it is not that others feel threatened. It's just that we don't have very good social graces, and others find that off-putting. But there is some good news, we can get better:

Me: I read "How To Win Friends And Influence People" by Dale Carnegie when I was a teen, and it changed my life.

Other: (laughs) It obviously didn't work because you're terrible at social graces!

Me: Yeah, but you didn't know me before I read that book!

So there is hope, but reading a book won't work miracles. It's a lifelong struggle with me to learn social graces.

A nice side effect of being "on the spectrum" myself is I enjoy working with people like that, including Aspergers, because I understand where their lack of social graces comes from and it doesn't bother me in the least.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by anonreeeeplor on Saturday January 06, 2024 @11:29PM (#38898433)
The books that have helped me the most have been about office politics and how and why people get jealous and who does well and why.

The best book I ever read was “stealing the corner office.”

I know people who are naturally intuitive and empathetic. They look at another person and go: “oh she is angry because her cat is sick.”

And I go “how the fuxk did you know that?”

More normal people have a sense sort of like this. I do not have this at all. The behavior and emotions of people are this continuous mystery.

If some VP is super angry, I can’t understand why.

Someone with more normal understand goes: yeah he is under a lot of pressure so that is normal just be more relaxed etc.

Corporations are confusing.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by sokoloff on Saturday January 06, 2024 @08:49PM (#38897561)
Life is hard for everyone. I think it’s dramatically easier in some ways for people with particular talents.

Beautiful people have certain things easier but others harder. Highly intelligent people are the same way. I think it’s like playing the game on easy mode but has some random side quest every so often.

I’d surely not wish the ending of Flowers for Algernon on myself just in order to avoid the quests.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by anonreeeeplor on Saturday January 06, 2024 @11:42PM (#38898513)
I spent more than a decade being suicidally depressed.

I only learned about Aspergers way later in life due to YouTube and realized it explained everything about my problems and alienation.

From some of the coaches on YouTube, they talk about how this is a pattern that shows up a lot with Aspergers - At some point people get so fed up with everything about life, relationships, work and schools not working specifically for YOU.

Aspergers individuals have a particularly hard time with jobs, it is very common for them to have employment challenges.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by Zeetah on Saturday January 06, 2024 @08:49PM (#38897563)
From your writing it is clear that you think very clearly and have good awareness.

I hope you succeed in finding a place where others compliment you, and you them and are in a team with a lead who supports you. I've been in, asked let a few such teams and we did amazing things.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by anonreeeeplor on Saturday January 06, 2024 @11:52PM (#38898562)
Thank you.

I am extremely empathetic and honest. Most middle management at most companies optimizes for non-creative yet industrious which turns highly competitive over pettiness.

I just can’t see myself doing it anymore. Especially after what happened to me at my last role.

I had my naïveté taken advantage of.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by WalterBright on Sunday January 07, 2024 @12:50AM (#38898846)
> I had my naïveté taken advantage of.

If it's any consolation, that happens to everybody.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by wharvle on Saturday January 06, 2024 @08:51PM (#38897575)
> I can write dozens of pages of highly analytical and technical text without making mistakes in real time. I can speed read complex texts and memorize them with a high degree of precision.

> From the “language” perspective I feel highly gifted and unusual. Not so much on the mathematical side. I almost have a disability with mathematics.

I feel this. “Rough draft? LOL why? I can write a perfectly-structured paper beginning-to-end without having to re-arrange so much as a paragraph, and I don’t make grammatical errors or spelling mistakes that I don’t catch instantly. What’s the point of all these ‘writing steps’?”

Around age 35 I started occasionally making errors in typed text, and not noticing until re-reading it. Leaving out words. I started substituting homophones! I never, ever did that at all, before! Aging sucks.

[edit] I feel, specifically, the brilliant-at-language and hindered-at-math thing, that is. The rest of this, I’d say you’re a fair bit brighter than me. I just took to language naturally very early and have crazy-good spatial reasoning. I feel dyslexic trying to read math, though. I do OK as long as things are algorithm-focused, which is why I can have a career as a programmer, but when it’s equations and proofs, forget about it.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by anonreeeeplor on Saturday January 06, 2024 @11:30PM (#38898437)
Hyper verbal.

Word engineer.

It’s less respected and talked about in tech but a very real capability.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by sshine on Saturday January 06, 2024 @09:31PM (#38897821)
> Around age 35 I started occasionally making errors in typed text, and not noticing until re-reading it. Leaving out words. I started substituting homophones! I never, ever did that at all, before! Aging sucks.

I had perfect grammar and spelling until ~30. Then it went downhill.

It coincided with dating more illiterate women. So I always attributed this development to letting go of an attention to detail that went unnoticed: What's the point of writing or speaking correctly when nobody around you can tell the difference?

It might be age rather than environment, although I doubt it. I also don't really mind.

My code hasn't become less type-safe.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by tayo42 on Saturday January 06, 2024 @08:55PM (#38897599)
> I have had situations where, even after a few meetings where I felt I was just “talking about how things are” the other person left HATING me.

If you mean this in a way where your saying hard truths or telling it like it is, then yeah, its annoying to listen to. Especially without it being asked for.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by anonreeeeplor on Sunday January 07, 2024 @12:05AM (#38898632)
I feel that in corporate it is generally understood you are to play out a role given your social rank.

If you are X, you are not allowed to ask about Y topic etc.

People with Aspergers do not perceive these boundaries and open topics they are not supposed to or are “above their pay grade.”

Status blindness and career limiting.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by CM30 on Sunday January 07, 2024 @08:56AM (#38901202)
To be fair, this could also be said about everyday life too, which is also why folks with Aspergers (like myself) tend to struggle. Social norms seem to basically down to "don't speak out unless absolutely necessary, especially not against authority figures"

Easy and logical for more tribalistic folks that live in terror of becoming outcasts, but not remotely reasonable for people who don't/can't live in this restrictive setup.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by teenthrowaway88 on Saturday January 06, 2024 @08:56PM (#38897603)
I concur with some of my sibling comments but decided to reply to you directly. I hope you give yourself some slack. My advice is simple and terse. Express yourself more tersely. Listen maybe more than you speak. Write your feelings and reactions down instead and then throw it away. Maybe choose to raise those opinions effectively another time. It's direct advice but I hope it helps. That's my take based on what you've written here.
Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by gedy on Saturday January 06, 2024 @08:59PM (#38897624)
You sound similar to some of my experiences, high IQ though I don't have Asperger's.

So I would say I agree with many people in power need to be "the smartest person in the room" and will do their best to derail or ignore you, which limits your success.

But to your comment about isolation and no one wanting to interact with you, TBH that's most probably Asperger's or your personality, not that you are some genius that people are jealous of.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by anonreeeeplor on Sunday January 07, 2024 @12:03AM (#38898623)
You are correct, I have very little urge to talk to people.

I have absolutely nothing in common with most people and it feels like very little to talk about, and I am extremely impatient with them.

Isolating and ruminating is the alternative I guess.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by fallingknife on Saturday January 06, 2024 @09:17PM (#38897745)
> I have had situations where, even after a few meetings where I felt I was just “talking about how things are” the other person left HATING me.

This is very familiar to me. There are things nobody talks much about because they are obvious and everybody knows them already. There are also things that nobody talks about because everyone is lying to themselves about it and actually believe are not true (though some part of their brain unconsciously knows it). If you aren't one for the lies, you can mistake one of the latter for the former, and you will think that you are just stating the obvious, but really you just stepped on a landmine. Has happened to me many times.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by anonreeeeplor on Saturday January 06, 2024 @11:57PM (#38898587)
I remember specifically having my first meeting with a Director of a large account at my last job.

I was really excited by it and was rattling off a list of ideas and tactics and strategies for how we could open the account.

His face turned bright red and he started SCREAMING at me.

At that point I was like “oooohk I did the thing again.” And backed off and didn’t interact with him.

After that he was a total asshole to me and started spreading rumors about me.

He felt extremely threatened I gather that he had been running this account for years and I could walk in and imagine a number of new approaches.

If I did it now I wouldn’t be so direct.

I have ideas all the time and most like do not want to have discussions like this because … they don’t have ideas themselves.

Corporate middle management are generally non creative and “brainstorming” just pisses them off.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by WalterBright on Sunday January 07, 2024 @01:00AM (#38898901)
Once there was a truck driver maneuvering his gigantic semi on narrow street. I thought I'd be helpful and offer suggestions. He interrupted me and told me to bugger off.

Ok, I backed off and then watched.

The guy moved that truck around like a ballerina. It was a pleasure watching him handle it, a true pro.

The lesson for me was to not tell someone you just met how to do their job. It's a lesson I've had to learn many times.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by nyssos on Saturday January 06, 2024 @09:32PM (#38897836)
> However. I feel constantly discriminated against and treated like I am stupider than I am. And when people listen to me talk, they get incredibly threatened. It has taken me years to understand that being around me and listening to me talk, reason and analyze is THREATENING to people. I have had situations where, even after a few meetings where I felt I was just “talking about how things are” the other person left HATING me.

Have those people actually told you this, or is it a conclusion you came to on your own? I ask because your comment pattern-matches quite strongly for me to "mildly autistic person who doesn't realize they're constantly making failed status plays". Here are a few lines that stood out

---

> I can write dozens of pages of highly analytical and technical text without making mistakes in real time. I can speed read complex texts and memorize them with a high degree of precision. From the “language” perspective I feel highly gifted and unusual.

"I'm highly gifted and unusual" is much stronger than "I'm a good technical writer."

> It’s like being Usain Bolt except your sprinting lane has an obstacle course in it while everyone else gets to run in a normal lane.

As before, but even worse. Usain Bolt is the fastest sprinter in the world. He's quite literally one in eight billion. You are not.

> I have taught myself advanced skills and switched careers multiple times without the required degrees. Worked at the top companies in the world with PhDs and others.

Having worked with PhDs is not impressive in itself. There are thousands of college sophomores who can say the same.

There are workplaces that carry some serious cachet (though bringing them up unprompted will burn most of it), but vague references to "top companies" won't cut it, and makes me think it's less "fellow at Microsoft Research" and more "software engineer at Microsoft". Which is a fine thing to be - but also a perfectly normal thing to be.

---

If your coworkers are getting the same vibe I am, then they're treating you like you're stupider than you really are because you come off as someone who wants to be seen as smarter than they really are. They're annoyed, not threatened.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by anonreeeeplor on Saturday January 06, 2024 @11:49PM (#38898544)
Yes, I am annoying and that’s why they hate me. :) You are correct.

And also my output is 20x higher than theirs.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by fallingknife on Saturday January 06, 2024 @09:57PM (#38897996)
> "I'm highly gifted and unusual" is much stronger than "I'm a good technical writer."

Did you stop to think that maybe that was his point?

> s before, but even worse. Usain Bolt is the fastest sprinter in the world. He's quite literally one in eight billion. You are not.

Or that he didn't mean that literally he is the best in the world?

> I have taught myself advanced skills and switched careers multiple times without the required degrees

This is legitimately impressive and obviously requires intelligence in the top 1% at minimum. Does it really not occur to you that smart people know they are smart just like people who are good at anything else know they are good at it, and not just trying to make themselves sound smarter than they are?

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by nyssos on Sunday January 07, 2024 @09:58AM (#38901712)
> Or that he didn't mean that literally he is the best in the world?

Obviously not, but I think OP does sincerely think he's smart enough that he should stand out as exceptional to most of the people he meets - and I think he's probably wrong. Most educated professionals will know dozens of people as talented as him. The people OP is hanging around will know far more, assuming he's describing them accurately: in a room full of

> quantum physicists with multiple degrees from Harvard / Stanford / Yale

having a 1-in-100 intellect is less than table stakes. There are millions of people that smart in the US alone, and most of them do not share OP's difficulties.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by Verdex on Saturday January 06, 2024 @09:35PM (#38897847)
I've got a similar problem but for a different cause. I'm guessing that my intelligence is normal, but my theory of mind instincts are probably better than average. I get a very good idea what people want on an individual by individual basis.

However, my ability to tap into the social zeitgeist is pretty close to zero.

The end result is that I get along fantastically with most people because I can anticipate what they want. But I get along terribly with people who want me to fit in with the social rules that they are playing by. What they want is for me to act normal. And I don't know what that is.

It manifests very similar to what you're describing. After a relatively short period of time certain people get very tuned off by me and they become easily frustrated by my actions.

My theory is that they're diligently playing by the social rules and then I come in, break all of the rules right in front of them, and then I get a mostly positive reception because it's what most of the room wanted anyway (just done in kind of a funny way).

I don't really have a solution.

[At least for me things get really interesting whenever I interact with sales people. As far as I can tell like 90% of that profession runs on everyone following the appropriate social scripts. I barely understand them so thus far I've not encountered a sales tactic that actually works on me. Occasionally they get really desperate as their best plays get met with awkward silence or declining their bad deal. The flip side is that they don't understand me either so asking for what I want doesn't seem to work. I just have to hope I'm able to find something that makes do. ]

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by anonreeeeplor on Saturday January 06, 2024 @11:34PM (#38898469)
I left a job where I tried my hardest to make it work.

The last few jobs in a row I entered with a specific, singular objective: “I vow I am not going to get into conflicts with people again.”

I try my hardest, and it doesn’t work.

A big problem is I hyper produce and hyper focus. I am juggling 18 balls and the “get along with people” ball eventually drops and when it does, it’s game over.

I have extreme capabilities for work but it also exhausts and overwhelms me.

I get extremely exhausted from thinking all the time, I am highly obsessive and always running my engine chewing over things mentally.

So I never rest.

And what inevitably happens is that I make social mistakes, and when I do - That’s the start of the end.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by at_a_remove on Saturday January 06, 2024 @09:46PM (#38897921)
I had some schooling struggles, exacerbated by being moved double digit times while I was still single digit in age, noting the wildly differing levels of standards for a given grade and subject between state to state, even school to school, and of course I didn't fit in. They told me I had a college level reading ability when I was in second grade (what does that even mean?) and I had memorized the orbital periods and rotations of the planets (back when Pluto was still one and we thought Mercury tidally locked to the Sun), and I had the periods of brief interests: take a box and attempt to manipulate it through all of the shapes it could assume by its folds; count to ten thousand; decide I was going to read an adult dictionary and hit the encyclopedia for anything which thrilled me; odd constructions of permanent magnets, wire, rubber bands, and Tinkertoys to touchlessly transfer force; arranging a box of crayons by hue, and, when thwarted by the limits of a simple circle, using the aforementioned Tinkertoys to hold layers of paper so I could also arrange by saturation. I relentlessly asked adults about all of the mysterious things in my world until they got miffed or shoved a book at me. After a while I turned my inquiries to my social difficulties and found much to learn. The first was that I lived around people and in people and that was my environment, the way a mole lives in the ground. The second was that people lied almost constantly and the point of it was that they wanted you to believe certain things because it was convenient to them for you to have misapprehensions about the world. Some of the lies were about more concrete things: how the presents got there, how babies happened, and the like. More lies were social like what do people actually like.

The third thing was: it turns out that people don't like different. Moved? Got a different accent than the rest of the children. But also? Don't be smart. Fit in. You can act bright, bright enough to help with another kid's homework, but you have to hide the rest of it, as it induces a mixture of envy and fear. Having a grown person in medical school say "You're terrifying" because you casually let slip your immediate apprehension of something which had baffled them means that kind of reaction never leaves. So as much as people mouth litanies like "Being different is okay!" the differences they mean are surface things like the coloration of your eyes or your skin, differences as the Mr. Potato Head model. And so that "helps with homework" turns with age into someone who ends up doing some very dull work, often of inappropriate import. Inappropriate, because you can see further down the line at what would be more important or impactful rather than this task you've been handed, as mindless as another sheet of multiplication problems of decades prior.

One of the equilibrium states is quietness, uttering little of surprise, imitation as protective camouflage. People will still figure out that you're smarter than the average bear, but you get fewer monkey gang-ups and reaping of the tall poppies. Fewer, but not none. Even my oldest friend has muttered "I hate you" three-quarters in jest -- but one-quarter not -- when I casually pick up some skill at which he has been slaving away over years. I've often wondered what the other paths look like and if they are more rewarding in some fashion, but more importantly, if they are any less fantastically lonely, the loneliness of the mutant.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by anonreeeeplor on Sunday January 07, 2024 @12:01AM (#38898612)
You have the same output as me.

It’s like an open faucet with words and stuff spilling out, and ideas, strategies, facts etc.

Elon Musk has talked about having a similar experience of just raw ideation to a degree that it is unpleasant.

My ideation cannot be shut off.

I walk multiple hours today just thinking obsessively and planning, iterating, ideating.

I can’t sit still, the activity of my brain is unpleasant I am just ruminating all the time.

Doesn’t happen to normal people - I think their brains are usually calmer - more in a neutral mode.

The end result is that when I do get engaged, and get into work, I tend to get extremely burned out. You can’t have this level of super output without burning out.

This is autistic melt downs / burn out I only learned about from YouTube.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by SamPatt on Sunday January 07, 2024 @10:25AM (#38901952)
>Inappropriate, because you can see further down the line at what would be more important or impactful rather than this task you've been handed, as mindless as another sheet of multiplication problems of decades prior.

This is where it's easy to get into trouble. You can either accept the task, which leaves you unfulfilled (and eventually burned out), or you can question the usefulness of the task, which superiors often view as insubordination or otherwise threatening.

It seems like working for yourself is the only way out of this, except perhaps working on a particularly well-managed team.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by SamPatt on Saturday January 06, 2024 @09:59PM (#38898004)
>Here is the other reality: If you are very talented and gifted, NO ONE WILL NOTICE AND TELL YOU.

I haven't had this experience. In any group dynamic that lasts long enough, there's usually at least a few folks making self-deprecating jokes about their intelligence in comparison, or someone explicitly asking for advice "from the big brain" or something similar.

Humor is usually involved, but I'm assuming that's just a way to make a potentially socially risky observation in a more acceptable manner.

Recruiters / management are sometimes more comfortable making blunt assessments of intelligence / talent than peers. To an extent, that's part of their job, so never having gotten that feedback professionally would seem odd.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by anonreeeeplor on Saturday January 06, 2024 @11:38PM (#38898491)
I personally hit a wall a long time ago and only started making progress when I began to hire coaches to offer neutral 3rd party feedback and are incentivized to actually help you.

My experience is most people in highly competitive environments are peer competitors in some form . The VP above you doesn’t want you to rise and take their job. Your peers don’t want to be surpassed.

Everyone wants to keep you in a certain box.

If you are able to jump completely out of the box ahead of everyone by 10 miles, no one is going to want that.

You will only get negative feedback and told to stop. Or worse.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by jaybrendansmith on Saturday January 06, 2024 @10:28PM (#38898144)
If you can, start your own company. Ideally in tech. When you're the boss, they have to deal with you.
Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by novok on Sunday January 07, 2024 @12:54AM (#38898871)
> I believe I have Aspergers

Don't self diagnose, really please just get a proper assessment by a good neuropsychologist. I had a suspicion that I had ASD, and I found out I had ADHD instead which surprised me. And part of ADHD is ignoring social cues subconsciously. If you end up having ADHD, OCD and anxiety for example, there are medications for that can change your life.

Even if the diagnosis ends up being some sort of ASD, ASD is a diverse condition with many subparts, so understanding how the machine of you works will be helpful. You also get an IQ test so you know what kind of gifted you are and there are books and therapy programs that can help you manage all of the diagnoses. Instead of giving up on the world and going full NEET, understand yourself first.

Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by mmyrte on Sunday January 07, 2024 @03:04AM (#38899462)
I read it not as a self-diagnosis but as "I have tested positively, and moreover I believe in the veracity/adequacy of the test".
Re:A Tale of Two Teenagers and the challenges of gifted stud... by novok on Sunday January 07, 2024 @02:53PM (#38904550)
But why would they phrase it like that unless the veracity is in question. I doubt they would phrase it like that if they spent 12 hours in a neuropsych's office vs. use something like this online test, which is not enough on it's own: https://embrace-autism.com/raads-r/