News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Happened to EVs? by avgDev on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @03:12PM (#38859174)
That is one of the issues for me. Plus, the only viable EV now for me is Tesla, but they keep making silly decisions and are just an odd automaker.

By silly decisions I mean things like removal of turn signal stalk, removal of parking sensors, lack of a gauge in field of view(y, 3), etc.

I love ability to buy online.

I hate the lack of an online parts catalog where I can purchase OEM parts. This is a big issue for me. I have enough experience to do anything on ICE car myself, engine rebuild included.

The cost of a replacement battery is astronomical. I can replace an engine in an ICE vehicle for $2k.

It also appears that Tesla is more expensive to insure.

Re:What Happened to EVs? by thebruce87m on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @03:26PM (#38859361)
The batteries have an 8 year warranty, by which point it will be cheaper to replace them. You probably won’t have to since NMC batteries will last 1,000 cycles x 200 miles = 200,000 miles. LFP batteries will be 3x that.
Re:What Happened to EVs? by avgDev on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:14PM (#38860023)
What makes you think it will be cheaper to replace them? Tesla recently increased prices on batteries.
Re:What Happened to EVs? by thebruce87m on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:57PM (#38860466)
> Electric vehicle battery prices are falling faster than expected

> Goldman Sachs Research now expects battery prices to fall to $99 per kilowatt hour (kWh) of storage capacity by 2025 — a 40% decrease from 2022 (the previous forecast was for a 33% decline).

https://www.goldmansachs.com/intelligence/pages/electric-veh...

Re:What Happened to EVs? by weaksauce on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @10:32PM (#38862661)
just how cheap do you expect that to get to? right now a model s has a 90kwh battery... that's almost 9 grand to replace in 2025. there will be a floor to this and i don't think it's going to be that cheap. gm et. al. are looking into 200kwh batteries reasonably soon. that's almost 20 grand to replace or the cost of a small ICE car.
Re:What Happened to EVs? by zamfi on Thursday January 04, 2024 @12:45AM (#38863508)
The smart money expects a Moore’s Law kind of curve here for quite some time going forward, given the economies of scale and powerful incentives.

There will be more variability than with Moore’s Law because the raw materials are more expensive, it’s not just about building a fab and then amortizing over billions of parts.

Expect a rough annual decrease of 5-15% in $/kWh for some time. We continue to find new chemistries and electrod materials that bring prices down.

Will there eventually be a floor? Yes, for sure. But we’re not there yet.

Re:What Happened to EVs? by phpisthebest on Thursday January 04, 2024 @11:49AM (#38869234)
The problem here is the retail price on things does not really drop.

using a Laptop as an example, prices of Laptops go UP every year, their price / performance ratio may improve...

So in this example if your 300 Mile range battery costs $15,000 today you may be able to get a 600 mile range battery for $15,000 in the future but you will unlikely be able to buy a 300 mile range battery for $8,000

Re:What Happened to EVs? by zamfi on Thursday January 04, 2024 @01:55PM (#38870803)
In inflation-adjusted terms the retail prices of things absolutely do drop.

Sure, Tesla might choose to only sell a 600-mile range battery for $15k instead of the 300-mile range battery for $8k. But if there’s a market for a 300-mile vehicle that costs $7k less, and that vehicle can be profitably produced, then it will very likely exist.

Re:What Happened to EVs? by uniclaude on Thursday January 04, 2024 @01:10AM (#38863667)
An estimate from a bank isn’t proof that the retail prices will decrease. Savings aren’t always passed down to consumers.
Re:What Happened to EVs? by avgDev on Thursday January 04, 2024 @10:52AM (#38868436)
Again, this doesn't mean consumers will actually get cheaper batteries. Musk himself was promising $5k-$7k battery replacement, yet we saw a price increase.

If we reached Musk's promised numbers then battery replacement would no longer be an issue for me, but when we are talking $15k-$20k then something like a model 3 is scrap for me at 100k+ miles.

Re:What Happened to EVs? by thebruce87m on Thursday January 04, 2024 @05:11PM (#38873006)
Again? Not sure what that means. As for 100k miles - there are cars over that now. Tesla aren’t the only game in town, and BYD is ready to eat their lunch. Competition will drive prices down.
Re:What Happened to EVs? by phpisthebest on Thursday January 04, 2024 @11:46AM (#38869198)
If i had a nickle for every time Goldman Sachs has been wrong I would never have to work again
Re:What Happened to EVs? by FullyFunctional on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:18PM (#38860078)
My 2014 Model S battery has lost less than 10% of the original range. Why would I replace the battery?
Re:What Happened to EVs? by thebruce87m on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @05:15PM (#38860609)
You wouldn’t, that’s not my argument. People talk about the cost of replacing the battery at today’s prices, but in reality you’d be paying the future price. Given the 8 year warranty, expected 200,000 - 600,000 mile* lifetime [0] and the rapid decline [1] of battery prices, most people would never need to replace the battery and if they did, it would be in a future where they are cheaper.

[0] https://zecar.com/resources/what-are-lfp-nmc-nca-batteries-i...

> A key advantage of LFP is its longer life cycle, resulting in less degradation concerns. LFP packs are capable of more than 3000 full recharge cycle counts compared to NMC at around 1000 to 2000 cycles.

* Assume 200 miles of range on one charge at 1,000 cycles for NMC, intentionally lower to avoid controversy.

[1] https://www.goldmansachs.com/intelligence/pages/electric-veh...

> Battery pack prices are now expected to fall by an average of 11% per year from 2023 to 2030

Re:What Happened to EVs? by FullyFunctional on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @05:47PM (#38860888)
Ah, sorry I misunderstood and I think we agree nearly completely. However, while I'm a fan of LFP, especially for UPSes, for cars it's a delicate balance of lower energy density vs longevity. What I can say is the the Li-Ion in my car have held up much better than expected, but I'm also babying them to the extreme, only rarely charge beyond 80% and rarely supercharging. At this point I fully expect to keep my car for 15+ years and never replace the battery.
Re:What Happened to EVs? by thebruce87m on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @06:01PM (#38861001)
LFP batteries are definitely becoming more prevalent. The standard range Teslas in some regions come with them. As you said, NMC should limit the charging to 80% for daily use.

Interestingly for LFP the recommended is 100% so that actually means that a standard range LFP Model Y can get more miles at 100% than the long range can at 80% for daily driving. There’s not much in it but it still feels weird!

Re:What Happened to EVs? by Qwertious on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @11:27PM (#38862992)
The reason LFPs are becoming more prevalent is because LFPs have worse range but are cheaper, and we've reached the tail-end of the cost-vs-range bell curve. Or to put it another way, buyers are much more sensitive to 100miles vs 200miles, than they are 300 miles vs 400 miles. OEMs just don't need the extra range, not if it increases the pricetag.

It also does wonders for the supply chain - the N in NMC stands for Nickel, and most Nickel comes from Russia. The C stands for Cobalt, for that matter.

Re:What Happened to EVs? by Gare on Thursday January 04, 2024 @10:01AM (#38867798)
And Cobalt comes from artisanal mines in Congo that utilize child labor. So definitely another plus for LFP there.
Re:What Happened to EVs? by KMag on Thursday January 04, 2024 @10:53AM (#38868458)
And (no joke) the word Cobalt comes from the belief that Kobolds were defending Saxon silver mines with toxic minerals. We've known for a long time that Cobalt compounds are pretty toxic to miners.
Re:What Happened to EVs? by tooltalk on Saturday January 06, 2024 @11:05AM (#38892524)
80% of cobalt mines in Congo are owned and operated by the Chinese battery companies, such as CATL who also makes LFPs.
Re:What Happened to EVs? by tooltalk on Saturday January 06, 2024 @10:59AM (#38892468)
>> LFP batteries are definitely becoming more prevalen. The standard range Teslas in some regions come with them. <<

LFP batteries are fine (but barely) for entry-level, low-range EVs, or stationary energy storage systems (aka, ESS).

>> As you said, NMC should limit the charging to 80% for daily use. <<

All lithium ion batteries, including LFP, suffers accelerated degradation under high SOC, high C-rates; or in LFP's case, extreme temperature.

>> Interestingly for LFP the recommended is 100% so that actually means that a standard range LFP Model Y can get more miles <<

That 100% SOC charging causes a lot of wear and tear in LFP batteries, but it is still required to recalibrate the BMS to avoid misreading of SOC/range and other associated problems such as cell imbalancing issues. According to Cleanerwatt reports Oct 22, 2022, as a result of 100% charging:

  Tesla LFP Battery 10% RANGE LOSS PROBLEM? | Model 3 RWD https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=suw20wPrbL0
  The brand new LFP batteries will degrade substantially quicker.  There's not long-term retention data for LFP batteries on the market yet, but the trend tends to be substantially faster degradation.  Trends show them stabilizing around that 10% degradation mark in about half the time as non-LFP batteries - around 50,000 miles instead of 100,000 miles."
There is no long-term data yet, though BYD has been making/using much smaller LFP battery packs in their EVs since 2009, but these LFP packs aren't likely to last anywhere near what many LFP faithfuls blindly believe they would last.

The main driver behind LFP's popularity is the cost, especially during the past 2-3 years of COVID-19 which wrecked havoc in the auto supply-chain and inflated prices. China under their massive state subsidy and protectionism (banning foreign battery competitors and cutting all subsidies to EVs with their batteries since 2015) was able to mass-produce them at scale as LFP's share of EV market went from 2% in 2020 to 30% in 2022. China is also very much behind LFP because their ability to export EVs is limited by the fact that other leading battery chemistries such as NCM/NCA are largely guarded by the Japanese and the Korean battery makers -- China ensured that they couldn't get ahead in their domestic market by banning their business very early on and cutting all subsidies to EV with foreign batteries or since 2015 under Made-In-China 2025.

Otherwise, LFP is really a cheap, inferior battery chemistry for EVs.

Re:What Happened to EVs? by dantecesa on Monday January 08, 2024 @01:25PM (#38915994)
If this argument were true: (A) a Prius replacement battery with now dinosaur NiMH tech would have fallen from $4k new to nothing. (B) any existing hybrid / EV would be getting bonkers range improvements w/ updated cell technology.

The best analogy I can think of: a battery cell / chemistry (akin to standardized RAM) is not equal to a battery pack (similar to a motherboard with soldered RAM).

For a variety of reasons (consumer preference, automaker greed?), unlike a bus / plane, a modern automobile is engineered to last 5 - 10 years (200k - 400k miles). The entire industry is predicated on selling new vehicles (much like smartphones, or computers) = no mainstream automaker is going to invest in building, testing, and then certifying a new battery pack to take advantage of new chemistry. You might cite Tesla's work on the Roadster as an example, but I'd argue this is an exception (a sendoff for their original halo car) rather than the norm.

& until we have a vehicle with enough scale, there exists no incentive for aftermarket to invest in building a new pack for a specific car. You could also argue, (& I'll concede) that Model 3 / Model Y might be the first car at scale to attract such investment – although I have doubts given (A) the barrier to entry for a pack is higher than a rando ICE part (e.g. would said company be able to build a BMS that talks to the vehicle?!) & (B) would any aftermarket company even try, given manufacturers will surely go out of their way to prevent this (we've already seen OTA disabling of features on EVs & I don't have to cite all the right to repair fighting that's ongoing…).

Is this a good thing? Absolutely not. Is it how it should be? Also no. But a lot of us (present party included) enable this when we want nice new things.

Until that changes, we're not getting cheaper battery packs for a legacy vehicle.

Re:What Happened to EVs? by toast0 on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @10:40PM (#38862708)
I'm willing to accept that motive batteries will be less expensive in general in the future because of market expansion etc. But does that really mean motive batteries for a specific vehicle will be less expensive?

People in comments are always talking about replacing individual cells from packs, but I don't think that's actually a common service now, and labor and support considerations may not make it a real option either.

(Battery wear seems to be a lot less than people expect as well, more data would be great, but I don't know if that's likely to appear.)

Re:What Happened to EVs? by ohfoydoyd on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @10:21PM (#38862582)
why is tesla the only viable option?
Re:What Happened to EVs? by brightball on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @10:31PM (#38862648)
I’ve test driven most of the competition. They are all much more expensive for a subpar product from what I’ve seen.

IMO the plugin hyrbid market is a much more natural transition and some of those vehicles are becoming very good. The Chrysler Pacifica plug-in minivan is excellent for the price and the BMW X5 plugins are by far the best luxury plugin SUVs that I’ve seen.

You can get good deals on used Pacifica plugins too. Typically in the $20k range.

But we still need a good EV option that is close to $20k brand new.

Re:What Happened to EVs? by sokoloff on Thursday January 04, 2024 @12:03AM (#38863217)
> BMW X5 plugins are by far the best luxury plugin SUVs that I’ve seen

I'm curious if you shopped the PHEV Cayenne to compare? I'm very likely to buy one this month (used) and the few that I've test-driven have seemed pretty great, coming from a 235K miles 2005 CR-V. :)

Re:What Happened to EVs? by brightball on Thursday January 04, 2024 @10:01AM (#38867797)
I didn’t see one in our area when we were looking. That BMW was the nicest vehicle I’ve ever been in. Absolutely blew me away.
Re:What Happened to EVs? by ohfoydoyd on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @10:53PM (#38862801)
I'm not sure I agree with your first statement.

At the low end I would take a Hyundai Ioniq any day over a model 3, and they're comparably priced.

At the high end, I'll concede things are a bit more expensive, but I'll take the barely used Taycan Turbo I got for 70k any day over a new Model S.

Re:What Happened to EVs? by brightball on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @11:00PM (#38862840)
I should have included the Ioniq in the list. It was right up there.
Re:What Happened to EVs? by natch on Thursday January 04, 2024 @10:06AM (#38867845)
No supercharger network.

That made Ioniq dead in the water for us. Not to mention lack of good life changing features we rely on in our Teslas.

If you only drive local, ever, then the Ioniq could work… but why would you get one?

And now that the Model Y price has dropped so much, you should be comparing the features of the no-haggle straight priced Model Y to the features and charger network of the dealer-marked-up Ioniq, not comparing to the Model 3.

Barely used Taycan… lol I wonder why they gave it up? Could it be the poor efficiency? Or that a Model S Plaid is quicker and costs less? Or again the charger network has a small existential issue.

Re:What Happened to EVs? by margalabargala on Thursday January 04, 2024 @10:21AM (#38868010)
> No supercharger network.

Depending where you are in the country, this can be a feature.

Where I live (Oregon), Tesla only bothered to build chargers in the big population centers, while other companies have built CCS chargers all over the place.

If you pick a random geographical location in Oregon it's more likely to be closest to a CCS charger than a Tesla charger.

Tesla wins in other counts like "number of charging stalls" because they built 20 at a time, but you can't road trip to a lot of eastern Oregon with one.

Re:What Happened to EVs? by cevn on Thursday January 04, 2024 @11:22AM (#38868842)
Tesla can still use those CCS chargers tho, so you would only lose chargers by not getting one?
Re:What Happened to EVs? by agloe_dreams on Thursday January 04, 2024 @11:24AM (#38868872)
I mean...a Tesla can use a CCS adapter just fine. Then you get way more than either. That is the advantage.
Re:What Happened to EVs? by margalabargala on Thursday January 04, 2024 @11:55AM (#38869311)
It can, but out of the seven different Tesla owners I know, zero own a CCS charger adapter.

What I've observed is that Tesla owners (this includes my own parents) are so convinced that NACS is superior to CCS (which, to be fair, it has a lot of advantages) that they don't want to use CCS. They'll put down CCS any chance they get, and there's this weird sense of "purity" that they maintain by not using an adapter. Also the adapter costs extra money.

I'm sure that not all Tesla owners are like this, but many of them are, especially people who have owned Teslas for longer.

Re:What Happened to EVs? by natch on Thursday January 04, 2024 @12:40PM (#38869901)
Not all Tesla owners are aware of this option.

I don't own a CCS adapter yet, although I'm in the market for one. Not because I need it, but because it's nice to have even more options. I did drive through Eastern (edit: Central and Eastern would be more accurate) Oregon twice a couple years on the way to Idaho and back, and superchargers worked fine, but it's always nice to get more granular coverage.

Personally that notion of purity seems alien to me. I also have a CHAdeMO adapter and have needed it once (edit: nope, a few times, just remembered charging at the Nez Perce Casino in Idaho), but it is nice to have the option.

Re:What Happened to EVs? by agloe_dreams on Thursday January 04, 2024 @11:58AM (#38869352)
Probably mostly a 'dont need to'. CCS is annoying- you need the apps and/or to swipe a card, there is no integration in the GPS, etc. The Supercharger is like EZpass for charging - you just plug it in -they bill you later.
Re:What Happened to EVs? by margalabargala on Thursday January 04, 2024 @12:04PM (#38869416)
Totally agree that for some reason, the most common thread among CCS charging companies is their inability to make it easy to use their chargers. I have a lot of complaints about Tesla, but the charging experience they've developed is not one of them.

Unfortunately, I have a suspicion that once NACS becomes the standard, all the current CCS companies will simply port their terrible user experience over to NACS rather than having the current experience be standard.

Re:What Happened to EVs? by natch on Friday January 05, 2024 @08:58PM (#38887592)
How is it a feature?
Re:What Happened to EVs? by bombcar on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @11:28PM (#38863001)
The Pacifica is “ok” for the price, with the plugin you lose the best feature and you’re now quite a bit more out the door.

The sienna with a plug would be quite competitive but even that is a bit more than bog standard.

And nobody makes an EV minivan even though it should be a no-brainer.

Re:What Happened to EVs? by bluGill on Thursday January 04, 2024 @09:55AM (#38867725)
> nobody makes an EV minivan even though it should be a no-brainer.

VW makes them, they just won't bring them to the US. They have officially announced they are coming in June, but time will tell. I'm going to look close when it comes - it could save me a lot of $$$ most months (the pacifica hybrid as much lower range on battery and so wouldn't save nearly as much)

Re:What Happened to EVs? by bombcar on Thursday January 04, 2024 @12:28PM (#38869755)
True, but "future minivans" don't help when I needed "now minivans".

And the E-Transit isn't available in a passenger version, I'd've seriously considered it.

Re:What Happened to EVs? by bluGill on Thursday January 04, 2024 @01:04PM (#38870218)
I have been driving a 12 year old minivan for a few years for that reason. Also why I'm watching VW so close right now.
Re:What Happened to EVs? by brightball on Thursday January 04, 2024 @09:59AM (#38867777)
We had one and my wife only had to get gas every 3 months or so. Definitely depends on your use but 35-40 miles a day on battery was plenty for her.
Re:What Happened to EVs? by bluGill on Thursday January 04, 2024 @11:23AM (#38868864)
The newer ones only get about 20 miles or range.

I have looked at them, but my wife is short and so she cannot reach the pedals. We have an older minivan with adjustable pedals that works well.

Re:What Happened to EVs? by brightball on Thursday January 04, 2024 @11:34AM (#38868997)
Really? The 2020 got 35ish
Re:What Happened to EVs? by bluGill on Thursday January 04, 2024 @01:06PM (#38870240)
They dropped the range. Apparently the rules for what qualifies for some rebate changed and so they put in less batteries while also meeting whatever law that was. If you only want the hybrid for rebates then who cares, but if you are looking at them for practical reasons that isn't useful.
Re:What Happened to EVs? by bombcar on Thursday January 04, 2024 @03:29PM (#38871855)
I wonder how moddable these things are (can someone sell aftermarket “bigger packs”) besides just filling the back with those power brick setups.
Re:What Happened to EVs? by brightball on Thursday January 04, 2024 @09:58AM (#38867761)
The best feature? The only thing you lose is the ability to fold down the middle seat, but you can still remove it if you need to haul something large. We had one for 3 years and needed to take the seats out 3/4 different times.
Re:What Happened to EVs? by bombcar on Thursday January 04, 2024 @12:27PM (#38869732)
It's really the defining feature of the Chrysler vans compared to the others, the ability to go from "all seats in van" to "flat empty van" without removing the seats is quite a nice convenience.

And I don't know if you can even get the hybrid in the 8 seat setup, and it's more than $10k more than a somewhat similar Kia.

Re:What Happened to EVs? by stjohnswarts on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @11:39PM (#38863072)
Tesla is the only one I'll buy until any car can use the tesla charger network, others simply aren't very well kept up.
Re:What Happened to EVs? by 2rsf on Thursday January 04, 2024 @06:55AM (#38865908)
Many cars can use the Tesla network now, and you are probably biased to your geographical area. In Stockholm (Sweden) for example the Tesla chargers are located far away from the city center, while there are many third party chargers available anywhere.
Re:What Happened to EVs? by jsight on Thursday January 04, 2024 @09:29AM (#38867398)
In the US, this isn't the case yet. Other makes won't get access to all V3+ superchargers until later this year.

Supposedly, Ford will get it next month.

Re:What Happened to EVs? by Account_Removed on Thursday January 04, 2024 @10:42AM (#38868297)
If access to the supercharger network is the only factor for you, then it may be good choice. When quality or safety are also factors, then the choice is not obvious. How much will Tesla charge you for repairs over the lifetime of the vehicle. How bigger is the chance that you kill or injure your family due to quality issues. Please have a look at the Reuters Investigation below for context. https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/tesla-mu...
Re:What Happened to EVs? by moepstar on Thursday January 04, 2024 @03:02AM (#38864403)
> I hate the lack of an online parts catalog where I can purchase OEM parts. This is a big issue for me. I have enough experience to do anything on ICE car myself, engine rebuild included.

It seems you're not aware that not only the parts catalog is available online for basically everyone [1] but also their repair guides / service manuals [2]?

None cost anything to access, [2] is a free subscription and only costs something if you need their software ("Toolbox") which you can book for a certain time.

[1] https://epc.tesla.com/ [2] https://service.tesla.com/service-manuals

Re:What Happened to EVs? by avgDev on Thursday January 04, 2024 @10:45AM (#38868343)
I am well aware of the parts catalog. I was specific about being able to see pricing.

For me this smells like a dark pattern. Tesla gets you in the car at a reasonable price point but why can't they show part prices online? Or even better sell them online? They are a tech company.

Right now, I can tell you the cost of a part for literally any main stream car with just a simple search. I can tell if the parts in stock or if they are out of stock how quickly I can expect to get them.

Why can't tesla do this, if legacy automakers have been doing this for years?

Re:What Happened to EVs? by agloe_dreams on Thursday January 04, 2024 @11:18AM (#38868802)
I don't actually mind the center screen on mine - it is actually fine and there is no 'wheel overlaps gauge cluster' issue. I also like the 'air directly hits my face though the wheel factor' That said, I'm weirder than most about airflow. The auto wipers suck, there is no dance around it. My issue is that the silly choices seem to be rapidly worsening.

My 2018 model 3 has fantastic parking sensors. The new cars without them will conveniently tell you to stop when the wall is currently sitting on the hood of the car after you hit it. It is a dumb choice that doesn't work. No turn stalk is just why most drivers don't use signals anymore...which sucks. No drive stalk means confusion about drive direction and if the throttle is armed. I ALREADY have this issue in my model 3, it is incredibly easy to end up going the wrong directly rapidly. The lack of creep means that a model 3 in autohold is easy to confuse for a car in park. They really need to make the P icon bigger.

No online catalog sucks, though I think with volume, that will happen via a third party. A big issue is the fact they they did agile changes to cars in a single model year so it is hard to know which part you need in some cases.

Battery - eh. For a comparable ICE vehicle - my old Volvo XC40 - A motor replacement is not massively far off from a battery, easily close to $10K. I hope that solid state batteries make huge jumps.

My tesla was $30/mo more to insure than the XC40 - that is material. I do save more than $30/mo on gas though, but the Xc40 was a 25mpg premium gas car so that is exceptional.