Edit: Doesnt the existence of uutils already contradict that?
2) you can modify them no questions asked
3) thus you can get shit done
4) you can’t keep the changes you needed to make to yourself so the next one after you can start at 1)
I don’t see issues here
Actually you can even keep the changes. You only have to share the sources if you are publishing compiled binaries.
Like, let's extrapolate that you mean "Apple and Sony profited from FreeBSD and didn't contribute back, and that's bad". Let's assume that the strongest possible version of that statement is true.
How does that ever translate to "a Rust port of GNU coreutils under MIT license is bad"? If Apple and Sony haven't contributed to GNU coreutils in ~30 years, they're not going to start now, MIT alternative or not. There's not going to be an Apple executive who's thinking "We've held out as long as we could, but now we're going to need to start integrating coreutils in MacOS and contributing changes back... wait, no, these Rust suckers released a MIT version, I guess we can keep being greedy!".
The more copyleft code there is out there, the less choice there is for company executives to go for the proprietary solution. As a user and as an employee, you probably should care about that. As a BigCorp executive getting an indecent salary from the proprietary code that your employees wrote but that does not belong to them, of course you will not like copyleft. But most people are employees.
I take this as effectively equivalent to "you're unable to give consent" and/or "you don't have agency."
But that's the kind of mindset you're likely dealing with here.
No, it is not free enough.
It is indeed paradoxical, but you have to remember that we are not dealing with the natural world, we are dealing with a world with copyright in place.
If the GPL is viral then copyright is a zombie. You can whack it once, but it will never stop coming back. GPL has to be viral because of the zombie-like nature of copyright. It's a hack and a pragmatic solution but defeating copyright for software entirely would be the ultimate solution.
We are standing on the shoulders of copy-left giants, while patented nonsense and enshittification is hitting pretty much everywhere.
I think you are ignoring the incentive structure ruling the markets. Without strict control against the next sociopath and the next and the next, its just a matter of time even for uutils to get embraced.
Sarcasm aside, I don't see how the existence of this code or its hypothetical adoption would hurt anyone. Ideology isn't worth following for its own sake, there has to be a mapping to physical reality, and any mapping that interprets a rewrite of coreutils as bad because it's too permissive is extremely suspect to me.
Like, what does the GPL infectiousness even protect here? Coreutils is decades old. Are we worried Microsoft is going to EEE it?