"Please don't fulminate."
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38807378.
The Sackler family's opioids, for example, have caused untold damage, and they made billions from it. They were able to offset the cost of all of that onto the society.
How do you propose not punishing people with addictions while somehow never giving out hard drugs without a prescription - since addictions are by their definition destructive and Dr’s shouldn’t be giving prescriptions for things that are known to cause problems for someone?
Are we discussing legality, morality, what should be legal, or what should be moral? I agree that would be bad morally, and shouldn't be legal, and currently isn't. My original comment was regarding how the process currently works, and why. It was also to explain that any concern of privacy regarding prescriptions comes more from the department of health/board of pharmacies than it does from 3rd partys providing documents, as the documents arent invading privacy anymore than what already happens.
> The states should keep their noses out of this and in effect all drugs should be made legal.
The whole "your right to swing your fist ends where someones face begins" thing applies here. The problem with some heavier drugs, and their addictive nature, comes in how it effects others. When something is so addictive that a person would sell their own child to acquire more of it, maybe we should limit access to that thing. Ive known a lot of addicts professionally and personally. They come in various degrees of wanting help. Some are in denial, some would do anything to kick the addiction. Some don't care at all and would fight to refuse any help under any circumstance. Its a super complicated issue, "Just legalize all of it", and "Just criminalize and punish all of it" are both equally shortsighted solutions.
> we should make it trivially easy to get help I agree 100%
> it should be trivially easy for a pharmacy to check if a doctor did indeed prescribe something without raping the privacy of everyone involved
It is, and they do. They call the doctor, he says "I didnt write this". Then he gives me a list of people who filled prescriptions he didnt write. The biggest invasion of privacy of unaffected people is when we have a confirmed suspect, we see what other doctors he filled a prescription for, and then go through that list with the new doctor to see what is and isnt legit.
So yeah, at some point in a table of a few hundred people I probably saw some names of people who were a doctors patient, and that they have a prescription from him. I've been inside their privacy just as much as the receptionist at the doctor's office and the pharmacy tech at the CVS
Nope. Invading privacy is invading privacy. Just because something is happening today does not make it okay and acceptable
> call the doctor
Is this the 70s? Call the doctor? Do you call the doctor for every prescription?
Here is a wild idea: we have tjis thing called the internet and this other wild thing called PKI. Give the doctor a certificate pair and they digitally sign every prescription. You don't ever need to talk to the doctor, you just need to pull their public certs.
Since we're doing privacy, give the chumps that need the prescription a cert pair and encrypt their shit + make it a crime to store any of their PII at pharmacy level.
Without it being an even worse situation where they get a Trojan from opening random emails or surfing for porn, and then all the sudden 100k valid appearing prescriptions for controlled medications all the sudden show up in pharmacies across the country?
Thats not what I was trying to say. My point was that the state already has this data, and I've already seen it before I get a copy of the data from the pharmacy. If you're concerned about the privacy of the data, you should consider the root issue of warrantless access to the PMP by investigators. Anything I get from the pharmacy is just a piece of paper that says the same thing that I already had from that
> Here is a wild idea: we have tjis thing called the internet and this other wild thing called PKI. Give the doctor a certificate pair and they digitally sign every prescription. You don't ever need to talk to the doctor, you just need to pull their public certs.
This is a great idea in theory, but currently has some problems. Some of them probably could and should be addressed, some not.
- Old people who dont want to learn. The PMP lets doctors get a list of every prescription filled in their name in a spreadsheet. You can sort and filter by where it was filled, patient name, type of medication, etc. Of the doctors Ive dealt with, maybe 10% knew about this and used it. A few learned about it from me, got excited, figured it out, and used it to its fullest extent. Most just went "yeah okay" and ignored it because spreadsheets are too complicated.
- Where are we storing this? Can only the doctor do it? From only one computer? Can his receptionist call in the prescription? Can anyone else access that computer? Basically is there any way at all for fraud to happen? What if its the doctor whos the one doing it? Ive seen pharmacists say "Were getting a lot of suspicious prescriptons from this one doctor" who was just flat out selling them to people who had no problems. E-scripts are a thing, and ive seen cases where nurses and receptionists hop onto the system to write illegal scripts.
> Since we're doing privacy, give the chumps that need the prescription a cert pair and encrypt their shit
My mom thinks opening chrome dev tools is going to get her arrested for hacking a website. Please dont put the onus of key pair encryption on her in any way
> + make it a crime to store any of their PII at pharmacy level Im not sure if its a legal/regulatory requirement, or just a moral thing, but Pharmacists are highly trained, with a Doctorate in what they do, and they catch things. Whether its a Doctor wrote the wrong script, or a potentially lethal contraindication between meds. Them having records of what else a person is on is a legitimate medical use case. There may be ways to keep this sort of data without PII, but it would be another concern to address.
There are dozens on things that should of been done better - but they disenfranchised those who could of helped the most.
I don't have the data that I would like to have on funding for treatment and education there, but I'd like to see real case studies that could inform other places to get ahead of the issues rather than give up.
It baffles me, if someone homeless in my community gets housing, that doesn't make me feel aggrieved for having to pay for mine. Yet we spend more money per person on homeless services that fail to get them housing than we would spend just... paying for apartments for them, because it would be unfair to do so.
The core compromises essential to getting it done were the usual “states rights” revenue split and later limiting state liability by abusing social security disability. There’s alot of overhead dollars that fund state operations so it is difficult to effectuate change - by design.
Things like addiction support are aligned with mental hygiene and Medicaid, so you really need to destroy your life until the safety net kicks in. If you live in a place like Mississippi, they’ll try to ship you north or push you towards SSDI (ie the Federal budget). In states that are less bleak, the community standard for disability is lower, and usually rehab is covered in some way by Medicaid.
The other thing that’s different about addiction vs regular healthcare is that the person needs to be ready. I worked for years with a gentleman who beat alcoholism and became a counselor. He was only able to get by it after harming one of his children accidentally.
Step 1. drain the old oil
Step 2. pour in the new oil
If you skip step 2 and damage your car, it doesn't mean oil changes are an unmitigated disaster. It means you didn't fucking do it right!
If this is your defense you're in trouble. Take for example the mythical "checks and balances" that are supposed to keep elected representatives under control. How is that working out?
US == freedom and democracy! Until you see the fucking army mobilized to protect the capitol like we are some banana republic where the dictator in charge decided they would like to remain in power. This also is not possible in the US, right?
You might argue it’s not the same thing, but the effect is definitely the same: the law changed and people went from unchargeable to chargeable
What you’re arguing against is absurd. Regardless of the existence or lack thereof of a relevant statute of limitations, ex post facto laws have nothing to do with prosecution of acts that were already illegal at the time they were committed. It may not engender respect for the law or respect for lawmakers to remove the statute of limitations after the time has already passed, but I side with those who the law has already failed: victims of those who break the law to the detriment of victims.
If justice delayed is justice denied, then the statute of limitations is a double-edged sword that makes a mockery of the law and of those victims of the law’s failure to be enforced; the original victim is victimized again by denying them their just reward: justice itself.
Similarly, we collectively also suffer as a society when lawbreakers aren’t held responsible for their actions, which further foments contempt for the law, by allowing a state of affairs that is demonstrably unjust.
Your example is ex post facto, but it doesn't even have to be that egregious. State A makes it illegal to leave the state with the intention of having or facilitating an abortion. Because CVS operates nationally, cops in State A can go to a CVS locally and pull records of a CVS in State B filling a prescription for a medication that is sometimes, but not always, used for abortion. They can then use that to build a case for prosecuting the person in State A.
States do not have the authority to regulate travel across borders. The supreme court would strike this down 9-0, as the implications would be enormous.
https://www.nbcnews.com/health/womens-health/idaho-most-extr...
This bill establishes parents as having full legal authority over their minor children and no one else.
As such, it does not really apply in the same way as a blanket travel ban. Parents have always been given preferential dominion over their children.
Regardless, the law only needs to be on the books to lead to needless pain and suffering of women, as we’ve already seen in Texas and elsewhere.
The states should keep their noses out of this and in effect all drugs should be made legal. If you do have a problem (ie an addiction) we should make it trivially easy to get help instead of burning resources to investigate these. As far as abuse goes: it should be trivially easy for a pharmacy to check if a doctor did indeed prescribe something without raping the privacy of everyone involved. As a matter of fact, why the hell does it take 30 minutes to fill a prescription in 2023?