tofu isn't green?? welp, my life is a lie
That (I thought) it didn't melt was the one thing holding it back from being a true vegan cheese[0] alternative to me.
[0] Process for making {cheese, tofu}: take {milk, soy milk}, add some acid to make the proteins coagulate, then draw the rest of the owl to get your sliceable high-protein block of controllable firmness and flavour.
I wonder if anyone's tried adding lactose to soy milk and using cultures and rest of the process as if to target a particular traditional cheese.
I'm not saying the result would be vegan, I don't know if there's a vegan source or way of manufacturing lactose, but just for interest.
Most cheese is not made with acid but with enzyme called rennet, which is typically found in stomachs of cow's for example. Now, there is synthetic rennet which is used in the cheese industry widely, which is vegan. However, rennet doens't work with plant-based milks. We've done a lot of experiments to find a replacement enzyme for rennet that would coagulate soy milk with a similar result as animal-based cheese, but didn't get any great results.
The cheeses made with acid are usually softer (e.g. ricotta). For a while we manufactured and sold a plant-based cheese made with soy milk that was very similar to ricotta. Not bad, but a far cry from the animal-based version.
I still think it's possible to find a way to make plant-based cheese without needing to synthetically create vegan casein. As other commenters have mentioned, many of the vegan cheeses currently available are based on either coconut oil, cashew, or almonds (or a mix of these). For some use cases, this works suprisingly well (e.g. if you live in Germany, get the vegan Feta from Edeka's own brand. It's the fucking best). But then again for some use cases, they don't (e.g. the melting behavior is usually not very good). I think they've gotten a lot better in the past 5 years and I don't miss animal-based cheese anymore as a vegan. I also think there's a local maximum here with these coconut oil, almond and cashew based cheeses though.
Edit: Confused lactose with casein, updated to reflect that
Lucali's in Brooklyn, New York is using it for their vegan pizza. Are they doing some crazy food science / chemistry?
Water, Coconut Oil, Potato Starch, Tapioca Starch, Soymilk Powder, Kappa Carrageenan, Calcium Phosphate, Vegetable Color, Salt, Pea Starch, Natural Flavor, Lactic Acid.
It looks like no "crazy" food science is involved. Like many other vegan cheeses, it's primarily based on coconot oil (fun fact: ingredients in ingredient lists must be ordered from largest percentage of weight to lowest).
Have you tried it? Is it good?
https://www.tesco.com/groceries/en-GB/products/302277589
To me, a true vegan cheese alternative has to tick all the boxes that cheese ticks at the same time, not a separate product for each box you want to tick.
So what I do in practice when I want a vegan sandwich is a thin-ish slice of smoked tofu[0] instead of vegan cheese, before adding lettuce or cucumber or whatever.
When I want a vegan pizza, however, this particular tofu isn't very melty. It tastes great even cold, like cheese, but no melt.
Most days I'm only eating vegetarian, not vegan, but if I can get a good melty tofu that fits in a similar gap for both diet and flavour even as a simple topping (let alone as a more complex part of the recipe as in, say, quiche) then that makes it easier to eat vegan on more days.
[0] https://shop.rewe.de/p/rewe-bio-vegan-raeucher-tofu-2x175g/8...
I'm only going to accept vegan cheese as a full substitute for real cheese when it ticks enough boxes, and one of those boxes is the nutritional values (the others include flavour and how it behaves when cooked, including melting vs. browning).
That's why I specifically noted that I'm interested by the prospect of melty tofu, as tofu is the closest substitute I have right now on the nutritional value.
Maize, rice, potatoes, and wheat have more than you might expect given they're more famous as carbs. Wheat can be processed to extract the gluten, which is a protein, which you may also know by the name "seitan".
It doesn't "melt" in the sense that it softens and becomes stringy when heated (eg. Mozzarella), but you can "dissolve" this kind of tofu in water, or at least you can make it a sauce-like consistency by adding water.
It has vaguely cheese-like flavor, more akin to the softer, ripened cheeses or the blue cheeses, but not so much the harder cheeses like cheddar.
Should be widely available, try it some time. Usually it's not directly eaten, but more of a condiment or for adding flavor to a dish in a similar way as soy sauce.
Why? American farmers are great at growing soybeans. They even grow varieties that are exported to Asia specifically for making tofu.
There's an old story about when Honda first set up factories in Ohio, they still shipped the engines from Japan. After a while they got tired of returning the containers back empty, and went in search of something they could fill them with. In the end, they hired local farmers to grow specific soybeans that were desired in Japan - every engine crate from then on returned to Japan with those beans inside.
Just as with those Honda engines, it's easier to start by rerouting some of the output of an existing factory than having to stand up a whole new factory from scratch.
It might very well turn out that for most of these regional specialty tofus, there's not enough demand in America to make local production economically viable, but there could still be a niche for a specialized tofu importer that can provide small quantities of many different varieties.
Asian style:
- (Seattle) Northwest Tofu: https://maps.app.goo.gl/omGVAsunK79BH1SYA
- (Cupertino, CA) Sogo Tofu: https://sogotofu.business.site/
American/fusion style:
- (Arcata, CA) Tofu Shop: https://www.tofushop.com/
- (Chicago) Phoenix Bean: https://www.phoenixbean.com/products.html
- (Nationwide) Nasoya: https://www.nasoya.com/about-us/
- (Nationwide) Wildwood: https://wildwoodfoods.com/
- (Nationwide) Hodo: https://www.hodofoods.com/
Wholesale distributors of fake meats:
- (San Jose, CA) Ecovegan: https://ecovegan.com/
- (NYC) Lily's Vegan (former May Wah): https://www.lilysveganpantry.com
--------
IMO Sogo Tofu and Northwest are worth going out of your way to try out if you're ever in the Bay Area or Seattle. They're just wonderful.
> It’s nice to meet you. I’m working on promoting Chinese tofus in the States. If you’re not familiar, China has over 20 types of tofus. They taste nothing like conventional white blocks. Some are bready. Others taste like aged cheese. Some bake up like pastry crust. Others melt.
> I’m writing a book to teach western cooks how use these ingredients beyond Chinese cooking. I’m also building a team to import and sell these ingredients to western supermarkets. If you’re excited about this project, let me know here. I’d love to find ways to collab.
http://georgestiffman.com/