News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by Baldbvrhunter on Friday December 29, 2023 @05:54AM (#38803707)
Some turbine facts for reference

For a typical onshore wind turbine, the tower can contain approximately 295 tons of steel

The concrete footings are usually 9 feet thick and 60 feet in diameter, requiring about 300 cubic yards of concrete, which is equivalent to 30 to 40 truckloads.

The blades have a 20 year lifespan and cannot be recycled, being made from fiberglass reinforced with plastic, also known as glass fiber reinforced polymer (GFRP). With newer ones also incorporating carbon fiber.

All that said, for a turbine to produce enough clean electricity to offset the carbon emissions produced during its manufacturing, installation, and maintenance, is typically around 7 to 8 months.

Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by cjbenedikt on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:14AM (#38805072)
"....to offset the carbon emissions produced during its manufacturing, installation, and maintenance, is typically around 7 to 8 months." Finally a clear statement. Never found one like that for DAC. Massive steel and concrete buildings and no answer to exactly that question: how long does it take to recover the CO2 footprint of building these structures.
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by Baldbvrhunter on Friday December 29, 2023 @10:21AM (#38805866)
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by Xiol32 on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:31PM (#38809851)
Unfortunely it seems these 'wooden turbines' also use fibreglass blades, which is a shame.
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by mschild on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:14PM (#38810274)
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by adwi on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:35PM (#38809902)
Very interesting. On average how long until financial break-even, in terms of total investment vs value of electricity produced/sold?
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by internetter on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:10PM (#38812298)
Depends on the site. In the best sites, something like 3 years. In the worst sites, never. Usually, something like 6-10 years.
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by CapitalistCartr on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:43PM (#38809983)
Sixty feet in dia. x 9 feet thick is about 950 yards.
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by jetrink on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:51PM (#38810061)
They are more cone-shaped than cylindrical.

1. https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Illustration-of-the-rein...

Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by Faaak on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:47PM (#38810031)
IMHO we should also look at EROI (energy return on investment), which Wikipedia cites [0] to be around ~20, that is a wind turbine will produce 20 times what it cost to make it.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_return_on_investment#Wi...

Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by jauntywundrkind on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:05PM (#38810175)
The point here that the wooden wind turbine is carbon negative is also a good one (where-as steel and concrete are a big carbon positive) is also worth tracking.

I do wish I had a little better idea what the costs of wood were. There have to be nutrients and other resources consumed, that wood takes to produce. I'd love to better appreciate the material flow of wood.

Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by Brybry on Friday December 29, 2023 @05:43PM (#38811105)
Also since it's laminated veneer lumber (LVL) and glued laminated timber (GLT) [1] it's going to have resins/adhesives involved that have an impact as well.

Probably still better than the cement in concrete but I don't have a source for that.

[1] https://www.windpowermonthly.com/article/1660496/windtech-wh...

Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by sandworm101 on Friday December 29, 2023 @07:24PM (#38811773)
By weight, much of that wood is actually glue. The structure is wood fiber held together by chemcial glues. It isnt a tree. It isnt a hand-carved covered bridge. It is an engineered structure filled with modern bits and pieces made out of not-wood.
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by dylan604 on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:44PM (#38810574)
I don't know if your listing these as "fun" facts, or as a means to try to denigrate wind turbines. If it pays for itself in 7-8 months while operating for 20 years that's 3% of its lifespan. That's 232 months of clean energy being generated. That's impressive to me. So I don't know what your intent is here, but I'm on board for all of it as a good thing
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by russdill on Friday December 29, 2023 @05:05PM (#38810803)
That and it's just the lifetime rating for the blades, not the foundation, tower, and hub
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by sandworm101 on Friday December 29, 2023 @07:21PM (#38811760)
I would presume that the tower and its foundations, like a large bridge, are functionally immortal. They sound like they should remain useful for a century or more. In such cases the initial carbon cost of construction shouldn't be much of a factor.
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by gonzo41 on Saturday December 30, 2023 @12:09AM (#38812943)
The reinforcement in the footing will eventually corrode and so will the tower (even with the best preventative maintenance). The sea likes to ablate things. But I'm sure the engineers are building extra life into the foundations so they can replace the blades every 20 years, and do the tower every 40 at last a few times.
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by Baldbvrhunter on Friday December 29, 2023 @05:05PM (#38810804)
honestly - I was compiling the facts thinking it was going to be much more time for ROI and was happy to have my assumptions invalidated.

I'm pro-wind turbine though.

Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by justin66 on Saturday December 30, 2023 @12:32AM (#38813021)
I'm puzzled by these comments. It might take well over a decade for a turbine to truly "pay for itself," depending local energy rates and how the project was financed. If you were to put it in the wrong place, there's no guarantee it will ever pay for itself. (not that a wind turbine was ever built for political rather than hard-headed economic reasons - that never happens!)
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by Baldbvrhunter on Saturday December 30, 2023 @03:17AM (#38813633)
we're just not stating the assumption that we mean "if placed in wind and connected to customers who will pay".

It's not very interesting to be asked "what if it is built without consideration".

Same goes for any capital expenditure, ROI is zero if it is unwanted

Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by justin66 on Saturday December 30, 2023 @12:28PM (#38816917)
I can unpack this a little. Here's my issue with the way the initial post was stated, and that "7 to 8 months," which I can't even. It's not the pro-wind sentiment that I'm taking issue with!

There are at least four major variables here, #1 the cost of the turbine and its installation (and maintenance), #2 the cost of financing, #3 the market value of the electricity that's being generated, and #4 the amount of electricity generated as a factor of how much wind the turbine will encounter.

#1 is where we can all be happy - turbines are getting bigger and cheaper. #2, well, you'll have noticed that interest rates can do some wacky things, and so the amount you'll spend financing your turbines might also vary quite a bit. #3 is an interesting one - we'd really like to build more and more clean energy sources, pushing the cost of electricity to the consumer down, but any given turbine is going to take longer to pay for itself if, after its construction, the cost of electricity continues to drop. Conversely it will pay for itself quicker if prices take off for some reason.

Regarding #4 - I guess it hurts people's feelings to think that turbines might be put in a suboptimal place because of politics, but putting that aside, we'd like to eventually put turbines in as many places as practical, and the difference between how productive a turbine on a mountain ridge or on the high plains might possibly be and a turbine in an urban environment might be is really high. I live near a 2.5MW Kenersys turbine that a company put on its urban campus, largely as a publicity stunt. It's glorious, but it's definitely not spinning as often as you'd like, or as much as it would in a better location.

Using some napkin math that doesn't really bear sharing, I believe it will pay for itself (pay for itself in terms of money spent and return on investment via electricity generated - not something hand-wavey and poorly specified involving carbon) well into the second half of its lifetime. That actually seems fine, it beats their getting all that electricity via the local coal plants, but maybe it speaks to the issue with these hand-wavey numbers: it would have paid for itself much, much faster in a better location. That's okay - as long as the turbine pays for itself over its lifetime, it's all good.

Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by dylan604 on Saturday December 30, 2023 @10:25AM (#38815931)
What a bizarre take on the entire topic and assumes such bad faith on anyone in the thread. What a absolute load of rubbish to assume being built in a non-windy location as an example for a thought exercise. Such a weasel wannabe politico comment - that never happens!
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by justin66 on Saturday December 30, 2023 @11:47AM (#38816598)
Take a pill. And then look up what "return on investment" means.
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by dylan604 on Saturday December 30, 2023 @02:35PM (#38818258)
Again with the assumption people don't know what the conversation is about. Like I possibly don't know what ROI means. What a just total waste of comments
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by justin66 on Saturday December 30, 2023 @03:10PM (#38818613)
I agree that your comments are a waste!
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by ruggeri on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:46PM (#38812456)
I didn’t read the comment as trying to denigrate wind turbines. It says 20yr operation with 7-8mo payback which sounds excellent.

If anything, I think the understated way the grandparent comment presented the facts added to the impact of the final result.

Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by dukeyukey on Friday December 29, 2023 @05:28PM (#38811000)
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by tcbawo on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:11PM (#38812302)
As is often the case, “nobody will do it at market rates” simply becomes “can’t”
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by HPsquared on Friday December 29, 2023 @11:39PM (#38812868)
It basically means "shouldn't be recycled"... Unless there is some desperately compelling reason to.
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by FredPret on Sunday December 31, 2023 @12:52PM (#38825954)
AKA the entire point of the market. Distributed, decentralized decision-making.
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by c048 on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:14PM (#38812310)
A lot of things deemed 'unrecyclable' actually are. It's just that it's usually not worth it.
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by andrewflnr on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:18PM (#38812330)
For planning purposes, "will not be recycled in real life" is indistinguishable from "cannot be recycled".
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by colechristensen on Friday December 29, 2023 @10:17PM (#38812566)
But who cares? If you grind up and bury fiberglass, you’re sequestering carbon and melted sand. I’m fine with this. People intentionally burying carbon do so to celebration when they’re doing it on purpose and selling carbon credits.
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by justin66 on Saturday December 30, 2023 @12:37AM (#38813038)
It's interesting how many things over the years get classified as "recyclable" and the secret is simply "we'll put it in cement."
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by p1mrx on Friday December 29, 2023 @08:14PM (#38812022)
> The blades have a 20 year lifespan

What stops us from making blades with a 60 year lifespan?

Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by dylan604 on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:39PM (#38812424)
it would be interesting if this is a material science issue where UV exposure just breaks things down to the point that after a certain point they are just unsafe from to be spinning at the rates and mass involved. that's a lot of kinetic energy if an unscheduled rapid disassembly were to occur.
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by tuatoru on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:50PM (#38812477)
Yes, it's a material science issue. With stronger materials they would just make the blades longer because the power produced is proportional to the square of blade length (or cube?). Anyway, the blades will be at the limits of material strength (over a reasonable lifetime).
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by rdm70 on Friday December 29, 2023 @10:24PM (#38812588)
I think there is another factor limiting blade length which is blade tip speed which needs to be below the speed of sound by a bit.
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by bluGill on Friday December 29, 2023 @11:28PM (#38812833)
That just limits rpm
Re:Tallest wooden wind turbine starts turning by coryrc on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:44PM (#38812442)
Ablation is one problem, fatigue is another.