Is there any basis for that? What about overwhelming bills and other liabilities, lack of marketable skills, illnesses (including addictions), lack of opportunities, lack of parenting and education, of food, etc.
The data overwhelmingly says differently: The predictor of success is not psychology but pre-existing wealth and opportunity. Internationally, the difference is even more overwhelming.
In my experience, it is a (condescencing, lazy) fantasy of the wealthy that poverty is just a matter of thinking differently, that anyone can do it because, after all, the wealthy person didn't have those obstacles. I say it's lazy because it doesn't take much examination of the data to see what wealth depends on.
These are all issues that can be overcome with an absurd amount of effort, but are often exacerbated by the psychology of the individual and their surroundings/family/support.
Removing all agency from the person gives them a reason to stay in poverty as it is far more comfortable to know that "i am poor" and not be responsible for it, compared to facing discomfort and climbing out of the pit.
The basis of this is my own experience (as you quoted yours) as I grew up homeless along with my mother and sister. I have lived this life, and I'd be very surprised if you had any real, (non-phoney) experience with what you're talking about. My mother is now dead, I escaped first and am now well off; I am bringing my sister out of poverty by trying to combat those very issues (addiction, lack of skills, education).
In this day and age it is VERY easy to give an abundance of support for addiction, Education is free (via youtube and the like), learning to do things, bill support, financial services. -- The number one blocker is getting her to get up, keep calm, carry on, and get through to complete any single item on that list. I can send her all the money in the world and it doesn't mean jack shit. I bought her a $1500 computer so she can learn about emails, and she hocked it for $300 because she was short for cash one day.
I find "pre-existing wealth and opportunities" a much lazier answer then you'd find everybody would generally trend upwards; which we have to a small margin. But it's most often that rich families meet inter-generational demise.
It is much easier for us all to be poor, than for us to all be rich; we can take comfort that "we just got dealt a bad hand, it's not our fault".
[...]
>I find "pre-existing wealth and opportunities" a much lazier answer
How is this consistent? It seems self-evident that if one person faces issues that the other didn't and those issues require "an absurd amount of effort" to overcome, the first person was at a significant disadvantage.
You’re making a “b” argument. GP is making an “m” argument, while acknowledging the effect of “b”.
That is an argument that no one in this thread has made. Poverty is obviously not inescapable.
It may depend on what you mean. It's not inescapable to some - they escape it. It maybe inescapable to others; most don't escape it.
You are so concerned about respecting agency, but then this also? Like this is so at-odds I’m not entirely sure whether you’re presenting it as an example of how aid to the poor doesn’t help, or an example of how if you’d respected this person’s agency your $1500 spent could have been $1500 in aid instead of $300.
Money doesn't mean anything if you don't know how to use it, neither does a computer for that matter, evidently.
If you're so sure that just giving them money would help, go give your money to someone who needs it.
[edit] to clarify my phrasing, I mean that just because you brought that into the thread, doesn’t make it fair game for the kind of post I made, which was too harsh by a long shot even if it hadn’t been about something personal.
Could you point to someone who has advocated that? IME it's a strawperson.
> is VERY easy to give an abundance of support for addiction
My understanding from people who work in that field is that it's very hard. The evidence seems pretty overwhelming: Lots of addicted people and despite efforts around the country, over decades (centuries?), in communities desperate to solve the problem, nobody has found a way to do it. If you have the answer, you should share it.
YouTube is laughable as support for addiction.
> it's most often that rich families meet inter-generational demise.
Are you saying that children in wealthy families "most often" end up poor?
> It is much easier for us all to be poor, than for us to all be rich; we can take comfort that "we just got dealt a bad hand, it's not our fault".
Who has said that?
Saying "the game is rigged, don't bother playing, wait until xyz happens" is, in my estimation, the issue, because it gives apathy. Poverty and whatever flavour of government benefits are constantly changing: the only way out is through themselves, as hard as it may be.
And like the sibling comment said, I'm coming exactly from this background. I've seen people both get out, and stay in, poverty. This is the only discerning factor that seperates the two.
Nobody said that.
I think it’s far less-true that not-poverty is sustained by psychology. That is, a fair proportion of the not-poor would remain poor if placed in the circumstances of poverty.
This suggests that removing or relieving the circumstances of poverty might also work, at least for some set of those in poverty, even if it is indeed largely (within some substantial boundaries) sustained by a kind of psychology.
We need a basic income.
If everyone implements it, then it's pointless, because currency only works when there's a potential difference (much like electricity).
Basic income detracts from the conversation; we're talking about issues and you've got your favourite solution that is inevitably going to be shoe-horned into the conversation.
No: Just because the butcher and the baker and the candlestick-maker all get a minimal $X per year does not mean that you've created a village of economic clones where trade is dead and currency is pointless.
They will continue to have different ways of making money, different assets, different needs/expenses, different price-preferences, etc.
What does that mean? No prep school, health care, high school, parenting, nannying, family trips to Europe? Are the kids just left on the street?
People I know who have done that stopped supporting kids after college, at least for awhile, or older generations left it to their kid to work their way through college - not a viable option these days. But the first 18 years have all the benefits of wealth.
And anyway, how many families are we talking about? Go to the local rich neighborhood and ask - my guess is you won't find more than maybe 1% or less.
we are talking a small amount. You won't find them in rich meiborhoods, they often live in poor neiporhoods, but the parents have money.
They are not sufficient by themselves, but they certainly help. Experiencing another place is some of the most effective learning people can do. It broadens the mind to possibilities far beyond what's normally around you; it teaches that your personal world is not the world, but just one of very many.
It also enculturates people to a socio-economic class. They can carry on a conversation at the party - or the work lunch or job interview - when people talk about their travels.
I worked so hard for that and I get slapped while the government hands out tax benefits to corporations like they’re beads at Marti Gras.
Poor people can’t afford a good car so they buy a crap one. Why do they need a car? Because they can’t afford to live near the city center where jobs are. Why can’t they take the bus? Shift ends at 1030, last bus at 10. Oh also it takes 2.5 hours on the bus vs 20 min in the car. Which means less time to make money. God help you if you’re in school too. Oh study on the bus. Great. Sure actually did that. You ever study on the bus? It blows.
So yeah, car as soon as you can scrape up a couple grand. Crap car blows a head gasket. Now you’re in the hole for 6 months. Don’t have the savings? Predatory interest rates. Miss a payment because it’s that or miss rent and freeze to death? Now your interest rates are even higher.
Why does poverty exist? Because our system makes it exist. Sure there are psychological reasons, and mental health reasons and addiction reasons, but I tell you what, digging out is hard. Super hard.
If it were less hard to dig out, we’d have a hell of a lot less poverty.
I had to stop my sister from buying yet another $500 shitbox. Told them to get affairs in order and sort out finance to get a proper good car, something modern, and get it insured.
Finally got to a point where we got paperwork going and started filling out forms, and... Well it turns out the partner had $25,000 debt that he was hoping would just go away if he could ignore it (consoles, phones, nikes, et al)
(So in the end I got them a good, used 2019 i30 car, and helped them get it insured, and showed them that this would've been a simple weekly transaction had they had their affairs in order.)
I have a belief that "the system" wants to have poor people around, purposely keep them down. Someone's gotta receive "benefits" to keep the system moving.
This is my way of fighting against the system, LOL.
I'm very glad that these sort of papers come out and are reasoned about. The "psychology" is perhaps the ONLY aspect that keeps poverty going, and it's made worse by people removing agency, introducing pointless stress, and in general just poo-pooing any attempts to climb out of the pit.