Re:The Psychology of Poverty: Where Do We Stand? [pdf]
by sokoloff on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @08:06PM
(#38777895)
There’s little doubt that becoming an adult with little educational preparation and scarce financial resources is very much harder than being well-equipped with both. I don’t think GP is disagreeing with that, but rather with the premise that poor people in 2027 are poor because there was nothing they could do in 2024, but rather that with an amount of devoted and concerted effort, some can lift themselves out in 2027 well above where they entered 2024.
You’re making a “b” argument. GP is making an “m” argument, while acknowledging the effect of “b”.
Re:The Psychology of Poverty: Where Do We Stand? [pdf]
by thfuran on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @08:50PM
(#38778206)
>but rather with the premise that poor people in 2027 are poor because there was nothing they could do in 2024
That is an argument that no one in this thread has made. Poverty is obviously not inescapable.
Re:The Psychology of Poverty: Where Do We Stand? [pdf]
by wolverine876 on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @12:07PM
(#38783991)
> Poverty is obviously not inescapable.
It may depend on what you mean. It's not inescapable to some - they escape it. It maybe inescapable to others; most don't escape it.
Re:The Psychology of Poverty: Where Do We Stand? [pdf]
by thfuran on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @07:31PM
(#38788572)
That I didn't win the lottery last time I bought a ticket doesn't mean I couldn't have.
Re:The Psychology of Poverty: Where Do We Stand? [pdf]
by wolverine876 on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @11:48PM
(#38790170)
It doesn't mean you could. Also, if your chance of something is 1 in a billion, does that meet any meaningful definition of 'possible'?
[...]
>I find "pre-existing wealth and opportunities" a much lazier answer
How is this consistent? It seems self-evident that if one person faces issues that the other didn't and those issues require "an absurd amount of effort" to overcome, the first person was at a significant disadvantage.