News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by wkat4242 on Monday December 25, 2023 @12:17PM (#38764295)
The problem is the investors. They love recurring revenue. Hence data mining apps and closed ecosystems with subscription fees. And bait and switch tactics like Hue where the conditions deteriorate over time (like needing an account now so they can track you better)

Companies don't really want to give us freedom of choice. They just want to take our money. Ideally through subscriptions so they have to do almost nothing for it but can cash in easily.

So all the "special sauce" doesn't have a technical reason but am economical one.

Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by ahaucnx on Monday December 25, 2023 @01:01PM (#38764622)
It's true that the trend in the industry definitely goes towards subscriptions and closed eco systems.

We at AirGradient see that very well that more and more companies force their users into the cloud and some monitors even refuse to show current air quality when not registered to the cloud. Imagine you would need to register your fever thermometer with an app in the cloud before you could measure your temperature...

Part of the problem is not only the investors in Matter but also VC funded smart home equipment manufacturers that are pressured to go down the recurring revenue business model.

At AirGradient [1] we want to demonstrate a counter example. Our fully certified air quality monitors are open source hardware and thus we provide the firmware code and they can be easily re-flashed with whatever software you like to use. With this openness a great community has emerged that maintains integrations to various systems like Home Assistant via ESPHome.

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/

Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by heyoni on Monday December 25, 2023 @04:09PM (#38766127)
I literally just purchased your fully assembled kit a few days ago specifically because all the parts are open source and easy to hack. Right now I’m running Amazon air quality monitors with a homebridge plugin I had to patch myself because Amazon changed their API which broke everything.
Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by dns_snek on Monday December 25, 2023 @01:45PM (#38764959)
Thanks for trying a more customer-friendly approach!

I don't have an immediate need for one of these, but do you have any plans to expand to Europe or work with a local distributor? Inflated shipping cost & time, VAT & customs duties (+additional processing time) and a cumbersome return process if anything goes wrong, makes for a less than ideal shopping experience.

Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by ahaucnx on Monday December 25, 2023 @01:59PM (#38765088)
This is definitely on our radar.

At the moment we still have a lot of dynamics in the product, eg frequent firmware updates on the shipped units and this is why we currently prefer to ship directly.

Once things are more settled down we will look for fulfillment centers in Europe and the US.

Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by shafyy on Monday December 25, 2023 @05:55PM (#38767084)
Hey, I run a small fulfillment company in Germany and would love to help shipping your products. In fact, I just wanted to order your indoor kit yesterday but, as others have said, it's not that straight-forward ordering from the US. Drop me a note at [email protected] and let's see if we can make it work, including the complexity with the firmware updates and so on.
Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by Cockbrand on Monday December 25, 2023 @01:50PM (#38765013)
+1, I just bought an Aranet4, and I’d return it in a heartbeat if I could buy an Airgradient (or three) in Europe without the added cost & hassle.
Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by 9dev on Monday December 25, 2023 @07:04PM (#38767581)
To provide a counter point here, I jumped through all these hoops and happily run an AirGradient sensor here in Germany. While delivery took a while, everything went well in the end.

Thanks to Achim for all your awesome work, by the way.

Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by gausswho on Monday December 25, 2023 @02:12PM (#38765203)
Can you elaborate on the Home Assistant integration? Do you just need to plug in the devices and ESPHome detects them or is there more to it?
Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by ahaucnx on Monday December 25, 2023 @02:26PM (#38765342)
At the moment you need to flash ESPHome onto it (can be done easily via the browser) and then there is a well maintained ESPHome configuration script available.

https://github.com/MallocArray/airgradient_esphome

Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by russell_h on Monday December 25, 2023 @01:37PM (#38764883)
I’ve got one of your pre-soldered kits running ESPHome in my office. It’s a great product, thanks for making it!
Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by snapplebobapple on Monday December 25, 2023 @01:41PM (#38764919)
#metoo. I love it. I wish it did carbon monoxide among other things i havemt thought of yet.
Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by naasking on Monday December 25, 2023 @05:03PM (#38766561)
Aww I wish I had known about AirGradient a few weeks ago. I ended up buying an an Air Things wave plus where I can at least export data to csv.
Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by Hnrobert42 on Monday December 25, 2023 @08:28PM (#38768100)
I have had an Air Things Wave+ for a few years now. It’s great. So at least you will have a solid product.
Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by Larrikin on Monday December 25, 2023 @05:05PM (#38766577)
This is exactly the kind of product worth supporting. It's Christmas Day, so won't be buying today, but I've added this to the list of items for my Home Assistant.

There isn't an HN promo code is there?

Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by wkat4242 on Monday December 25, 2023 @05:28PM (#38766815)
I think I'd seen your product before on HN. It looks nice but like the others say, I'm in Europe so it's a no go for now. Will keep an eye on it though for when you decide to expand!
Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by karlmdavis on Monday December 25, 2023 @06:18PM (#38767271)
Looks perfect for me with one show stopper: no Home Kit support. I love the idea of Home Assistant but do not have the free time to pick up another service to support in our house.
Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by ahaucnx on Monday December 25, 2023 @06:46PM (#38767438)
One of our community members actually added Home Kit support.

See: https://forum.airgradient.com/t/airgradient-integrations/703...

Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by Arkkis on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @12:20AM (#38769126)
You would not happen to have an email subscription list/webform for people from Europe who’d like an alert when you’re available here?

This way you’d get a list of potential customers and we’d get a notification when we’d get an easier option to buy your products.

Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by Flameancer on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @03:10AM (#38769785)
Massive respect to that HA support. I’ve started running HA and it amazes me what is available on some cloud products once you remove the proprietary cloud from them. I used to be a Google home or bust, slowly I’ve been going the cloud agnostic route. Any Android device should work with Google home (for the wife) and both HomeKit + Home Assistant. I say HomeKit and Home Assistant because I really like Apple ease of use and the ability for home assistant to pipe other compatible sensors directly into HomeKit for example, ecobees sensors provide more sensor data via home assistant than they do in their regular app and in HomeKit. Via Home Assistant I can add this extra sensor data directly into HomeKit.
Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by oijwj98j on Monday December 25, 2023 @05:07PM (#38766593)
I would counter this idea its all corporations fault with "the general public doesn't want to rotate a tire, let alone grow a potato."

We socially infantilized each other. Technology plays a huge role in that.

Voices of the past warned that extreme division of labor would result in humans that are lazier, stupider than the dumbest animal. People sit online screeching about the slightest social faux pas, do nothing about intentional destabilization of education, healthcare, and infrastructure by political parties.

We complain that every last mile problem, every edge case we encounter, was not solved already by Big Tech. Never occurs to us to solve them ourselves.

I grew up being taught how to rebuild cars from the frame up, fix houses for people in need struggling in Midwest winters, was mentored in physics, chemistry by college age aunts and uncles, had a grandfather who retired after decades of designing computers for IBM teach me analog circuit designs/implementations, and helped farmers birth/raise livestock, got a couple uni degrees a while back. I'm barely 40.

Meanwhile my office worker colleagues waste time and real resources driving for an oil change. They demand others solve their survival problems for them. Friends struggling in this economy have started chanting "If I'm just going to berated for not working 7 days/week for a rich person, may as well quit and work 7 days/week growing my own food, fixing my home."

Fingers crossed the fiat hallucination Boomers force us into serving is about to vanish with them. Physics does not put an obligation on the future to propagate their rhetoric.

Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by fullspectrumdev on Monday December 25, 2023 @07:40PM (#38767816)
The oil change thing always baffled the shit out of me.

I don’t drive, as it’s been largely both unnecessary and impractical with where I’ve lived in the past decade, but I know how to check and change the oil in a car, among other basic vehicle maintenance tasks. It’s not hard or time consuming.

Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by ShittyKickflips on Monday December 25, 2023 @07:54PM (#38767902)
I live in city and i do not have space to do it. I do not think draing oil is legal on city center. Or wise for that matter. So i drive for oil change, even though i know how to so it
Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by TheCleric on Monday December 25, 2023 @07:58PM (#38767924)
To add to this, where I live you can basically only change your own oil if you own your home as nearly every lease will disallow it if you’re renting.
Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by fullspectrumdev on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @11:10AM (#38772970)
I have never seen such a limitation on a lease anywhere I’ve rented. I’m guessing America?
Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by TheCleric on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @07:49PM (#38777776)
Yes.
Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by wkat4242 on Monday December 25, 2023 @09:44PM (#38768506)
It's a dirty job and usually comes almost free with a service call, including the disposal of the used oil which you have to drive for either way, to bring it somewhere where it may be disposed even if you do it yourself.

When I owned cars I often used to fix issues myself (as I used to drive old ones I've replaced entire window mechanisms and wiring harnesses) but not the oil changes. It's just not worth it. And it's so much easier with a full hoist, I only had portable jack.

Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by fullspectrumdev on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @11:12AM (#38772993)
Ah, I guess if it’s free with regular service calls that makes sense as to why one would outsource the task.

As for disposal: in a fair few places I’ve lived the city has had regular free pickups or drop off locations for “hazardous” domestic wastes such as oil, car batteries, etc.

Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by dartos on Monday December 25, 2023 @09:15PM (#38768362)
I think people are, generally, smarter and more capable than ever. Social media just highlights the dumdums.

IMO the real issue is lack of instilling a sense of agency at a young age.

You were taught how to build cars from a young age. I’m sure you were encouraged to try things yourself along the way. You learned that your actions have a direct impact on the world and that you have the ability to adjust your actions to adjust the impact.

(At least in the US) Education is so retention and information focused that we don’t teach _how_ to apply that information.

Because of this we grow up looking to others for how to do anything, even if we have the know how.

It’s usually not until later in life when people realize their actions can truly have an impact when applied correctly

Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by andreasmetsala on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @04:42AM (#38770267)
> Fingers crossed the fiat hallucination Boomers force us into serving is about to vanish with them. Physics does not put an obligation on the future to propagate their rhetoric.

You could have used a relative educated in economics. Remember that just because you’re an expert in one field doesn’t make you one in another.

Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by kolinko on Monday December 25, 2023 @05:31PM (#38766848)
Isn’t hue on zigbee, so you can use any other app to control the equipment?
Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by baby_souffle on Monday December 25, 2023 @08:57PM (#38768279)
Not all hue stuff. They announced new cameras and some other stuff that’s 802.11 only.
Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by wkat4242 on Monday December 25, 2023 @10:15PM (#38768642)
Only if you buy another gateway that works with that other app. Like many enthusiasts do, yes. Like home assistant. But it's not an option for the average Joe.
Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by api on Monday December 25, 2023 @07:27PM (#38767741)
In many cases non-recurring revenue is barely even acknowledged. It doesn’t matter. Recurring revenue is the only meaningful form from a valuation perspective.
Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by asylteltine on Monday December 25, 2023 @07:42PM (#38767826)
The problem is no one knows what matter is and how thread is in the mix. It’s a confusing standard
Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by uxp8u61q on Monday December 25, 2023 @08:58PM (#38768282)
What do you mean, "no one"? Plenty of people know... Matter is at the application level, thread is at the networking level.
Re:Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled... by asylteltine on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @01:43PM (#38774594)
After I wrote my comment I knew someone would write this. Yes, that’s what it is. Go ask the average smart house enthusiast what it is though.