News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by p1mrx on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:11PM (#38755814)
Burning methane is not rational if you value living in a stable climate. The atmosphere doesn't care whether it came from a democratic or autocratic country.
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by lispm on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:29PM (#38756000)
The idea at that time was for electricity production to replace nuclear&coal with renewable & gas (as backup) for some time, until there are other ways to backup renewable. It could (!) have had the effect of CO2 emissions going down in total.
Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by mpweiher on Sunday December 24, 2023 @07:09PM (#38758313)
Except that didn't work.

And even had it worked, the emissions still would have been significantly higher than just going with nuclear.

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by oezi on Monday December 25, 2023 @08:39AM (#38762490)
'just going with nuclear' = just continue dreaming?

Or in other words: when was this ever on the table to go just nuclear?

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by mpweiher on Monday December 25, 2023 @12:14PM (#38764266)
It wasn't in Germany, because Germany has a well-established and well-organized anti-science movement that peddles in magic cures and irrational fears.

As an example, a large percentage of the population believes in homeopathy and most of the health insurers even pay for it(!)

Similarly, what the German public "knows" about nuclear power is mostly patently and even ridiculously false.

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by lispm on Monday December 25, 2023 @01:41PM (#38764923)
Says the one who did not know that Fukushima had six nuclear reactors, with four of them being destroyed.

Nuclear power is a lot "magically thinking". People obsessed with technical solutions are unable to see the other aspects around it: economics, safety, security, public reaction, environment, political, ...

Use a spreadsheet and calculate energy needs, built times, costs, etc. and then try to get a feeling for the impact nuclear will have in the next decades compared to other energy production (coal, renewables, ...). It's not much. I've showed you in another answer the nuclear built-up over the last decades, world-wide. It stagnates mostly.

https://world-nuclear.org/getmedia/332179b1-b865-47cc-a239-7...

Above are real numbers. We are far away from getting 3 times as much electricity from nuclear. Especially given that many of the reactors currently running are several decades old. In the past 35 years nuclear has not expanded at all in west&central europe. Just holding that seems to be a challenge.

For a long time the German engineers lobbied for new nuclear technology. One of the ideas was the brilliant pebble-bed reactor. We build one. It later died a silent death, because it did not work in the real world (maintenance was too costly) and the industry was closing it. We were involved in the EPR (-> Siemens). Which is mostly a failure.

> Similarly, what the German public "knows" about nuclear power is mostly patently and even ridiculously false.

Others will say that about your opinions. I have yet failed to see a convincing argument from you, just the old stuff like that nuclear fuel has not been used to its potential. We heard that argument ten years ago. Twenty years ago. Nothing has happened. How many re-processing plants have been built in Western/Middle Europe in the last twenty years? None. The UK can't even clean up the one it has.

What happened to the Thorium reactors? HN was full of news about them.

What happened to the Small Modular Reactors? Where are they, beyond the ones used in the military? Too expensive.

The technical solutions to make renewable large scale viable are an order of magnitude simpler than the "next nuclear technology" to be developed. Plus they will be easier to deploy.

What is Japan doing with its Plutonium from reprocessing nuclear fuel?

https://www.armscontrol.org/act/2018-10/features/japan’s-mis...

A bunch of countries would be happy to get nuclear technology under the idea that it is to "save the earth", while at the same time they'll want the option for nuclear weapons. In the middle east we have Israel with nuclear weapons. Iran is working for a long time on that, while claiming to develop nuclear power.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_proliferation

That's another reason why a world with lots of countries with nuclear technology is not desirable.

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by mpweiher on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @04:15AM (#38770141)
> did not know that Fukushima had six nuclear reactors,

In common use "reactor" and "power plant" sometimes get equated. Whoop de doo. My apologies for being slightly sloppy.

> Nuclear power is a lot "magically thinking".

No. Hard science. Now the Energiewende. That is a LOT of magical thinking. We'll use intermittent sources and when they are not producing <a miracle occurs> and everything will be just fine!

It turned out that the proper name for the miracle was "Russian Gas". Some "Wende" and not a good idea.

> We are far away from getting 3 times as much electricity from nuclear.

Sadly, yes. 17 years. According to 22 countries.

> For a long time the German engineers lobbied for new nuclear technology.

Yeah, for good reasons. Eventually they gave up, because it is really difficult to counter base emotions stoked by raw propaganda with reason and facts. It's not even a competition.

> Others will say that about your opinions.

I am sure some will say just that. Except I can back up my "opinions" with facts, because they are factual. As can be seen from this exchange.

Anti-nukies know that nuclear reactors take forever to build. Because they only look at the most extreme examples, the outliers. The fact is that nuclear plants take around 7.5 years to build. With a little variation up and down, but consistent over the last 50 years.

That's the actual fact.

https://www.sustainabilitybynumbers.com/p/nuclear-constructi...

(note: the article also does the common thing and not distinguish between nuclear power plant and nuclear reactor)

Anti-nukies know that nuclear is uniquely dangerous, unlike any other technology. When in fact it is either one of the safest or the overall safest energy technology out there, depending on which figures you look at.

https://ourworldindata.org/safest-sources-of-energy

You know what is uniquely unsafe? Hydro power. The largest energy production accident ever was that dam in China. 150000 people dead at minimum, 4.6 million homes destroyed, 11 million people displaced. Nobody knows about it. No anti-hydro activists in Germany demand we dismantle all our dams. No country got out of hydro. The problem with nuclear is psychological, not factual.

Anti-nukies know that nuclear waste is uniquely dangerous and an unsolved problem. In fact, nuclear waste is uniquely manageable and, in fact, managed. There is very little of it, temporary storage is fine, and permanent storage a solved problem, with two sites in existence and a third being built. The problems of nuclear waste are (1) political, with politicians being able to kick the can down the road because it is so technically non-problematic and (2) economic, because fresh Uranium ore is so cheap that recycling is not economical. Fuel cost is only around 10% of the cost of running a plant.

> just the old stuff like that nuclear fuel has not been used to its potential.

That is not an "argument". That is pure fact. We throw away 95% of the fuel.

> How many re-processing plants have been built in Western/Middle Europe in the last twenty years?

Why would you build reprocessing plants if your potential customer is getting out of nuclear energy? You are not making any sense. UK and France have reprocessing plants.

And of course it's even better to build reactors that can use all the fuel. But you would have to invest money into developing those reactors, which wasn't done the last 20 years because people are irrationally scared of nuclear technology and governments pander to fears.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dual_fluid_reactor

German engineers. Had to leave Germany and move to Canada to continue.

> What happened to the Thorium reactors?

Dunno, this one?

https://world-nuclear-news.org/Articles/Operating-permit-iss...

Was originally scheduled to be completed in 2024. They accelerated and finished in 2021, because it is impossible to build nuclear reactors in time, as we all know. Operating license was just granted.

In the West, interest in investing in nuclear was very low. After the disaster of the German Energiewende became more apparent, interest in nuclear energy has gone up markedly. So we're seeing a lot more activity:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molten_salt_reactor#Commercial...

The Chinese also recently turned on their pebble-bed reactor, it is now feeding electricity into the grid. We'll see if they can do a better job of it than Germany did. I am somewhat dubious about that one myself, but again, we'll see.

> That's another reason why a world with lots of countries with nuclear technology is not desirable.

I am talking about the ones who already have it.

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by lispm on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @06:06PM (#38777066)
> In common use "reactor" and "power plant" sometimes get equated. Whoop de doo. My apologies for being slightly sloppy.

It makes no sense here and has nothing to do with being "sloppy". It's a huge difference if one reactor exists or six. It's a huge difference if there are three molten cores or if there is only one. It's much more difficult to deal with four catastrophes on a small site, than with one. It's much more difficult to get emergency backup electricity and emergency cooling for six reactors than just for one. It's much more difficult to deal with six full spent fuel pools on top of these reactors, than with just one. All six need cooling. Several of the reactor buildings were largely damaged from hydrogen explosions. With lots of debry. Lots of space is needed for contaminated water coming from the reactors. Ground water had to be controlled for all reactors. A lot more people are needed. They have only very little time to do work, due to the radiation.

This is the systematic downplaying of risks, effects, and problems on your side.

> No. Hard science.

Energy is not just "hard science". That's the typically technocratic blindness. Energy production has many more dimensions: it costs money, it needs to be insured, there is waste to deal with, there is nuclear proliferation, it is embedded in politics, it creates corruption, it is embedded in a natural environment (for example reactors need cooling), safety, security, and so on.

You are ignoring most of that. That't the typical technocratic magic thinking that the best/most complex technology will solve everything.

The "hard science" thinking, is actually arrogant low-complexity thinking of technocrats.

> The fact is that nuclear plants take around 7.5 years to build.

I thought we debunked that, given that this argument is manufactured. The last 50 years of worldwide reactor are of zero interest, when the data is unevenly distributed. Reactors 50 years ago were built totally different, with different technology (which reactor from 50 years ago is safe against a passenger airplane accident?), in a different environment, ...

We have data for the last twenty years in Europe and that looks much worse.

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by mpweiher on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @09:33AM (#38782261)
Good grief. I don't build nuclear power plants, and even I absolutely know the difference even if I am sometimes sloppy with my terminology Certainly the people building plants know the difference, so just stop it.

> You are ignoring most of that.

No I am not. In fact, I have dealt with that in what I wrote here. You have just chosen to ignore all these facts.

Prime example:

> > The fact is that nuclear plants take around 7.5 years to build.

> I thought we debunked that

No "we" didn't "debunk" that. Because it happens to be true, so there is nothing to debunk. It is just as true if you look at the last 50 years as it is if you look at the reactors just completed in 2022.

You just refuse to look at the actual data, and instead focus on your gut feelings and then cherry pick a few outliers that confirm your gut feelings. Not entirely coincidentally, this is the same "methodology" that's used by other science-deniers to "prove" that homeopathy works.

It doesn't. And nuclear power plants take an average of 7.5 years to construct.

https://www.sustainabilitybynumbers.com/p/nuclear-constructi...

https://www.statista.com/statistics/712841/median-constructi...

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by defrost on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @04:33AM (#38770219)
I've been in primary resources for decades (geophysical exploration) and I am pragmatic about our need for energy being balanced against the consequences of fossil fuels.

We need to pivot away from anything that increases greenhouse gases in the atmosphere and toward means by which to reduce what we've added - changing behaviour, reducing consumption, using more electric, adding nuclear to the mix where practical are all strategies to use.

Everybody is susceptible to "magically thinking".

As much as I like solar, wind, and batteries these technologies at industrial scale have as many issues as does nuclear.

The processing of spodumene for lithium for batteries creates vast amounts of waste acids and radioactive waste, you can look at processing waste in Malaysia from Mount Weld in Australia if you're interested.

This is just something we have to deal with, just as we have to deal with waste from nuclear power.

A great fuss has been made about deaths from an accident at Fukishima, as it should - industrial accidents need to have reduced death tolls.

Very little fuss gets made about, say,

Explosion at a nickel plant in Indonesia leaves at least 13 dead and 46 injured

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/dec/24/explosion-at-a...

just a few days ago .. nickel of course being a big part of our EV revolution.

There are many such accidents, that single most recent one had a greater death toll than the incident in Japan.

It's good to be concerned about the human cost of industry and technology, but do keep a wide, balanced, and proportional eye on what the costs are.

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by lispm on Monday December 25, 2023 @10:28AM (#38763361)
> And even had it worked, the emissions still would have been significantly higher than just going with nuclear.

We have basically started the renewable energy revolution, which will lead world-wide to much faster replacement of fossil fuels.

Nuclear is at best stagnating in authoritarian surroundings (China, Russia, ...). In the west it is struggling (US, France, UK, ...).

Get rid of it and invest the money into the much faster and cheaper growing renewable energy.

Why should we invest more money into nuclear? The industry has since decades not being able to demonstrate safe storage of nuclear waste, it has rising costs, there are no cost effective modern reactors, breeders are dead, the technology is still linked to military use, non-state owned companies are not able deal with the cost problems. All we see are rising prices and time delays. That's not the technology to get carbon neutrality.

UK:

https://www.fr.de/wirtschaft/atomkraft-in-grossbritannien-te...

Years too late, cost overruns, state owned EDF gets all the cost increases (-> French tax payer), Chinese investors not paying, time delays, above market prices, ...

If France would have not made Areva fully state owned, it would have had to close it because of the mounting losses...

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by mpweiher on Monday December 25, 2023 @11:07AM (#38763693)
> We have basically started the renewable energy revolution

We subsidized China's renewable sector with German taxpayer and electricity consumer money. China says thank you!

Alas, renewables are not viable as a primary energy source, due to their intermittency (at best) und unreliability. They need vast amounts of backup.

The dirty little secret of Germany's "renewable energy revolution" is that it only works with lots and lots of backup...and that backup was Russian gas (because Gas plants can ramp up quickly). Or coal.

Neither option is exactly ideal when the purpose of the exercise is to reduce CO2 emissions, and it turns out that Germany, despite many decades and hundreds of billions of investments, has the second dirtiest electricity in Europe. Not the second cleanest, the second dirtiest. After Poland, who just use coal for everything, and are now starting to invest heavily in nuclear.

And of course, the solution is even less ideal when the Gas is coming from a maniacal dictator, who uses that dependency to blackmail. (And who miscalculated that the blackmail would work, and thus invaded Ukraine).

Germany's solution was to reactivate lots of coal and to essentially buy up all the gas on the international market, at sometimes exorbitant prices. But hey, we're rich, so who cares?

Except of course a lot of that wealth is built on industries that are now struggling...and moving.

Furthermore, one country buying up essentially all the gas on the free market is not a scalable solution for multiple countries.

Which is why, after the Ukraine war and its repercussions, basically the entire world re-evaluated nuclear, and found that the mostly imaginary risks and problems were outweighed, dramatically, by the practical advantages.

> Nuclear is at best stagnating in authoritarian surroundings (China, Russia, ...). In the west it is struggling (US, France, UK, ...).

Incorrect.

It is being dramatically expanded all over the world, and the problems with the EPR are outliers, they are not typical. Average time to build nuclear plant has been remarkably steady at 7.5 years since the 1970s (with some fluctuations above and below that line).

> not able to demonstrate safe storage of nuclear waste,

Incorrect.

Storage of nuclear fuel at interim sites is safe and unproblematic. Which is one of the reasons the purely political problem of a permanent site can be kicked down the road by spineless politicians. Technically, safe final storage is completely solved. Finland's Onkalo site just opened, Sweden is also close to completing theirs and Yucca mountain was also ready.

"The Government Accountability Office stated that the closure was for political, not technical or safety reasons."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yucca_Mountain_nuclear_waste_r...

One of the reasons nuclear fuel is unproblematic is that there is just very little of it, because the fuel is so energy dense. For example, just the single Herfa-Neurode site in Germany stores an order of magnitude more of both arsenic (enough to poison the entire world several times over) and heavy metals than there is nuclear waste. In containers that are far less safe. And of course arsenic has no half life, it stays poisonous forever.

Last not least, there would be even less nuclear waste (and it would be even less dangerous) if we actually used up the nuclear fuel. Currently, we use less than 5% of the nuclear fuel we feed into the reactor, and throw away the remaining 95+% after it comes out of the reactor. Unsurprisingly, this 95% of the original fuel still contains a lot of energy, and so that is producing the most radiation.

We should be recycling this, but alas fresh Uranium fuel is so cheap that recycling is at best marginally economical at this point.

And since waste disposal is also not an actual problem (just a political one) there is also no real incentive coming from that side either.

> UK:

Yeah, the EPR is apparently a difficult design to build, and these are the first reactors of that type built, so it is at the start of the learning curve and last not least, we let our know-how on how to build reactors slip away, so we are now re-learning how to do that.

The Chinese already finished their copy of the EPR, and the average time to construct a reactor has remained steady at 7,5 years, including and notwithstanding the outliers.

And yes, if it's 7,5 years including the outliers, that means that a lot of reactors get built much quicker, 5 years and less.

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by lispm on Monday December 25, 2023 @01:28PM (#38764835)
> Germany's solution was to reactivate lots of coal

You have seen the statistics? Coal use for electricity is going down?

https://blog.energybrainpool.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/...

> Storage of nuclear fuel at interim sites is safe and unproblematic. Which is one of the reasons the purely political problem of a permanent site can be kicked down the road by spineless politicians. Technically, safe final storage is completely solved. Finland's Onkalo site just opened, Sweden is also close to completing theirs and Yucca mountain was also ready.

Incorrect. Germany is currently spending billions to clean-up experiments to store nuclear waste (-> Asse II) and the general solution of other nuclear waste in Germany is completely unclear.

> It is being dramatically expanded all over the world

So far without effect: https://world-nuclear.org/getmedia/332179b1-b865-47cc-a239-7...

> We should be recycling this, but alas fresh Uranium fuel is so cheap that recycling is at best marginally economical at this point.

Definitely not, re-processing nuclear fuel is extremely environmentally damaging and technically challenging.

You are bringing up dead horses, which are dead since decades. Nobody will be able to build a re-processing plant in Germany in the next 50 years.

> The Chinese already finished their copy of the EPR

Still, Europe is not in China. If nuclear friendly countries like France and the UK can't build them cost and time effective, it says something for Germany.

Plus: China finished many many more coal power plants.

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by mpweiher on Monday December 25, 2023 @04:44PM (#38766423)
> You have seen the statistics? Coal use for electricity is going down?

Yes, I did. Did you? They first went up for 2 years. Now energy consumption dropped because we are in a recession, due at least in part to...drumroll...high energy prices. Because Germany has the 2nd highest electricity prices in the EU. After only Ireland.

And of course we would expect them to drop at least a bit, because renewables do produce some electricity. Just not reliably, and so we still produce the 2nd dirtiest electricity in the EU, after only Poland, at the 2nd highest prices in the EU after Ireland. Some accomplishment!

And who produces clean electricity? France.

> Incorrect ... Asse.

So which part of the text that I wrote was actually "incorrect"? Who cares about the politically motivated shenanigans in Germany? The world has built 2 final storage sites and a third is close to completion. Claiming this is somehow "unsolved" is simply wrong.

> [Expansion] so far without effect.

Well yes, obviously. The invasion of Ukraine that laid bare the vapidness of the Energiewende happened not even 2 years ago. The cutting off of Russian gas was only a little over a year ago. The political decision-making followed and has just now been announced. Are you expecting this policy change to be implemented in a few days? Seriously?

> re-processing nuclear fuel is extremely environmentally damaging and technically challenging.

Only in anti-nukies scare stories. There are also reactors that can burn the stuff directly. For example the Canadian CANDU reactors, and of course a variety of newer designs.

> Nobody will be able to build a re-processing plant in Germany in the next 50 years.

Where did I say that a re-processing plant will be built in Germany of all places??

> If nuclear friendly countries like France and the UK can't build them cost and time effective

They can. And have done so. But both UK and France believed in the renewables fairy tale and both haven't built a new reactor in, what, a decade or more? And even then the production rate even in France was extremely low. Know how has been lost, the EPR is a difficult design and at the beginning of its learning curve. The only thing that would be surprising is if there were no problems.

That says nothing about nuclear power in principle, because, once again, the average construction time is still just 7.5 years, consistently over the last 50 years or so, no matter how much you want to focus on just the most extreme outliers.

And of course, it also doesn't make any logical sense: do you really believe that something about the universe changed in the last 50 years that somehow has made it impossible to build nuclear power plants when we used to do it just fine?

That idea is so preposterous, it doesn't pass the laugh test, yet it is gospel in EE circles.

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by lispm on Monday December 25, 2023 @08:38PM (#38768146)
> because renewables do produce some electricity.

like >50% this year...

> CANDU

"Diese wurde jedoch von Indien gebrochen; das Land baute mit CANDU-Know-how und -Technologie sein Kernwaffen-Arsenal auf."

Wonderful.

> no matter how much you want to focus on just the most extreme outliers

France is an outlier? OKAAYYYY...

> do you really believe that something about the universe changed in the last 50 years that somehow has made it impossible to build nuclear power plants when we used to do it just fine?

Well, the reactors developed 50 years ago were designed with completely different technology, which is no longer in use and very very different safety standards.

You can see France struggling with the steel...

Additionally in 2022 up to half of their fleet was down for corrosion inspections...

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-edf-flamanville/edf-must-...

That will be cheap...

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by mpweiher on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @03:34AM (#38769919)
> France is an outlier? OKAAYYYY...

The EPR is an outlier.

Once again: the average time to construct a nuclear power plant is around 7.5 years. Now you can focus all your attention on plants that take longer than those, and you can falsely believe that those outliers are the norm.

But that does not change the fact that they are not. The average was, is, and continues to be 7.5 years. The median is actually a bit lower.

https://euanmearns.com/how-long-does-it-take-to-build-a-nucl...

> Additionally in 2022 up to half of their fleet was down for corrosion inspections...

Planned and scheduled corrosion inspections. They have regular inspections, seems like a Good Thing™ to me, which they delayed during COVID. So they scheduled them for the summer of 2022. They always schedule them for the summer because that's when electricity demand in France is lowest.

These days, in addition to demand being lowest, supply is large because summer is when all that over-provisioned PV delivers most...just when other demand is lowest. So a good time to schedule such routine maintenance and inspections.

Because nuclear power can be scheduled. Unlike wind and solar. Which just happen whenever Mother Nature feels like it. Big difference.

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by lispm on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @11:25AM (#38773122)
> which they delayed during COVID

so they could not stick to their typical schedule

> the average time to construct a nuclear power plant is around 7.5 years

That's dumb.

"The average time taken to build 441 reactors operational today was 7.5 years."

Most of the reactors operational today are decades old.

Check how long it takes to build an airport. 50 years ago and now. You can build faster in China (guess why, you can also build coal powerplants very fast in China, even though the air quality is already shit), but not in Europe and the US. None of the EPRs in Europe are built in-time and/or budget. Exactly the opposite, even though the constructing company sits in France and is state owned.

Re:Germany hits 80 GW milestone by mpweiher on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @09:25AM (#38782189)
> could not stick to their typical schedule

They chose not to stick to their typical schedule, prioritizing COVID instead.

> [average construction time of 7.5 years] That's dumb.

Only in the universe of reality-denial. In the Real World™ it is accurate.

> "The average time taken to build 441 reactors operational today was 7.5 years."

Yes. Unlike you, I don't have to look only at the most extreme outliers to make my case. Because my case doesn't need distortion.

> Most of the reactors operational today are decades old.

Yes, they last a long time. Which is good. Alas, since they built so many so quickly and they then didn't expand further and didn't need to replace the existing ones because they last a long time, they didn't keep the expertise of building alive very well. That was bad.

Anyway, if you think that this means construction was only fast in the old days, you would, once a agin, be incorrect.

The reactors finished in 2022 were finished in...drumrolll..around 7.5 years.

And in fact most of the outliers are in the past.

> None of the EPRs ...

And once again, you focus on the currently most problematic design, which also happens to be brand new, so at the beginning of its learning curve...

> ...in Europe ...

...built in the region that has built hardly any plants or reactors in the last two-three decades.

Single examples.

However, hop over to Statistia and you will find, again, that the plants finished in 2022 were finished in around 7.5 years. Just like the ones before.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/712841/median-constructi...

And again, those numbers are consistent:

"Overall, this picture suggests that nuclear plants don’t take a really long time to build (with a few exceptions). Most are built in 8 to 10 years. Many are built much faster."

https://www.sustainabilitybynumbers.com/p/nuclear-constructi...

Are we getting slower?

"The data suggests that the world is not getting slower. Times vary a bit from decade to decade but average times are not slower than in the 1970s or 1980s."

So no, your singular examples notwithstanding we are not getting slower.

Data. Facts.

Have a nice day.