What does that mean exactly--'gave it to Sun'? He was a Sun employee at the time. It's silly to say the Java code he wrote while working at Sun was given to Sun by him. Likewise, it's silly to say that then by extension when he went to work for Google he just took his code with him and gave it to Android.
"Q. Why did you use the same rangecheck() function in Timsort as was in arrays.java?
A. It's good software engineering to reuse an existing function.
Q. But why use the exact same code?
A. I copied rangecheck() as a temporary measure, assuming this would be merged into arrays.java and my version of rangecheck() would go away.
[Discussion of Timsort dates and Android work dates.]"
private void RangeCheck(int index) {
if (index >= size)
throw new IndexOutOfBoundsException(
"Index: "+index+", Size: "+size);
}
If this were the basis of Oracle's copyright claim, any judge in the country would have tossed the case on summary judgement.Fun fact: Java's ArrayList RangeCheck function has had a brutally stupid misfeature for over a decade (yes, I had posted it as a bug -- ignored) which prevented its add(), set(), and get() methods from being inlined. I kid you not.
To wit: these methods all call RangeCheck, which potentially throws an exception, along these lines (here's get(i) in pseudocode):
RangeCheck(i)
if (i >= maxLength) throw exception about i
get(i)
RangeCheck(i)
return array[i]
Until recently methods which threw exceptions could not be inlined. Thus even if get(i) was inlined, you'd still have to call an uninlinable RangeCheck(i) call every time.This was trivially fixable:
ThrowException(i)
throw exception about i
get(i)
if (i >= maxLength) ThrowException(i)
return array[i]
This has never been fixed. Recent improvements in HotSpot have rendered it moot though, as HotSpot can now inline the RangeCheck call. But for almost a decade ArrayList has been approximately 1/4 the speed it should have been for most common calls.Google-Sun court docs reveal long Java licensing dance
For more than five years, Google sought to license Java or acquire rights to the language before Sun got into the hands of Oracle or IBM.
http://news.cnet.com/8301-1035_3-57417898-94/google-sun-cour...
The more amusing bit is that the incriminating code snipped in Oracle's slides goes the other way: the code is in Java because Josh Bloch (the Google employee who checked it into Android) wrote it in the first place and gave it to Sun. So the same TimSort implementation got carried with him into Android. There may still be a copyright question if he actually assigned ownership to Sun, I guess. But suing the author over the use of open source code he gave you in another open source project is... yeah.