Re:Oracle v. Google judge to decide whether APIs are Copyrig...
by nknight on Sunday April 22, 2012 @02:17AM
(#3874161)
If this were the basis of Oracle's copyright claim, any judge in the country would have tossed the case on summary judgement.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Oracle v. Google judge to decide whether APIs are Copyrig...
by tryke on Sunday April 22, 2012 @02:29PM
(#3875613)
It doesn't even check for underflow!
Re:Oracle v. Google judge to decide whether APIs are Copyrig...
by SeanLuke on Sunday April 22, 2012 @06:32PM
(#3876336)
To do so would be meaningless, since arrays already do that.
Fun fact: Java's ArrayList RangeCheck function has had a brutally stupid misfeature for over a decade (yes, I had posted it as a bug -- ignored) which prevented its add(), set(), and get() methods from being inlined. I kid you not.
To wit: these methods all call RangeCheck, which potentially throws an exception, along these lines (here's get(i) in pseudocode):
RangeCheck(i)
if (i >= maxLength) throw exception about i
get(i)
RangeCheck(i)
return array[i]
Until recently methods which threw exceptions could not be inlined. Thus even if get(i) was inlined, you'd still have to call an uninlinable RangeCheck(i) call every time.This was trivially fixable:
ThrowException(i)
throw exception about i
get(i)
if (i >= maxLength) ThrowException(i)
return array[i]
This has never been fixed. Recent improvements in HotSpot have rendered it moot though, as HotSpot can now inline the RangeCheck call. But for almost a decade ArrayList has been approximately 1/4 the speed it should have been for most common calls.