News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by AndrewKemendo on Sunday December 17, 2023 @06:09PM (#38677357)
“In all honesty, it was the Debt Crisis that ended the Roman Republic. There was a Sovereign Debt Crisis during the Roman Republic period resulted in a dictatorship and a debt default.

…

Therefore, we find that the debt crisis was correlated with a separatist movement – which we are beginning to see worldwide starting in Europe, but will eventually become a contagion in the United States as the conflict between left and right erupts after the November elections.”

Timing was pretty bang on if you consider Jan 6th as a turning point

https://www.armstrongeconomics.com/history/ancient-economies...

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by serf on Sunday December 17, 2023 @07:15PM (#38677795)
>Timing was pretty bang on if you consider Jan 6th as a turning point

of all the things happening around that same time-frame, the Jan 6th events seem to have been some of the least impactful, aside from just being a huge talking point in these type of "world is decaying" conversations

the media decided to report on that event in such a way as to draw more outrage than the other stuff -- but looking back the other stuff seems to have created a larger last impact; BLM/lock-down/pandemic/WFH/disaster-recession/George Floyd/Rittenhouse/social-distancing, just about any affect of that time period seems to have created deeper scars than the Jan 6th stuff.

now, Jan 6th stuff drew a lot of public outrage -- the sanctity of the office and so on and so fourth -- but real social and physical trauma that has lasted into today? There were more important events during that time-frame in that regard, personal opinion.

If you're just counting physical violence/death/injury then there are more severe events to consider unless we're weighing stuff like "a politician's life is more valuable than a bystander" type rationalization.

and to be clear : i'm not even debating the whole fall-of-Rome premise, i'm just saying that as an individual that witnessed this whole history it feels as if there was greater chinks in the armor than the Jan 6th events.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by vharuck on Sunday December 17, 2023 @07:32PM (#38677918)
It's unfair to compare the single event on January 6th with every BLM protest, or every state's implementation of lockdown and the resulting clashes, etc. I'm appalled by January 6th because the representative for my district accepted his win in the November elections, went to D.C., and then voted to throw out all votes for my state as being dubious. The riot, building-storming, and literal lynch mob were the natural outcomes of months of cynical choices by politicians to control the government in spite of democratic elections. It's not a thing to let slide.
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by rayiner on Sunday December 17, 2023 @08:04PM (#38678101)
What state are you from? January 6 didn’t register for me at all, and I grew up in the area and work in DC. I grew up in Virginia, with a very Jefferson heavy curriculum. “The tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots and tyrants,” and whatnot. I wonder if that has something to do with it.
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by dctoedt on Monday December 18, 2023 @04:39PM (#38688709)
> January 6 didn’t register for me at all, and I grew up in the area and work in DC.

YGBSM

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by AndrewKemendo on Monday December 18, 2023 @10:03PM (#38691280)
Whose blood exactly is it refreshed with?

Also maybe let’s break that toxic cycle instead of continuing it

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by rayiner on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @07:27AM (#38707865)
“Patriots and tyrants.” It’s right in the quote.
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by AndrewKemendo on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @09:46PM (#38716448)
Right I think implied in my question is “who decides who is who?”

Certainly the native populations and black slaves didn’t have much voice here.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by peyton on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @09:54PM (#38716503)
The natives were heavily armed and owned tons of slaves. A prevailing view was slaves were foisted on the colonists by King George III through a combination of debt and the trans-Atlantic slave trade, so a big goal of the Revolution was ending that trade. Of course Jefferson was wrong, and chattel slavery continued.
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by ethanbond on Sunday December 17, 2023 @07:23PM (#38677849)
> now, Jan 6th stuff drew a lot of public outrage -- the sanctity of the office and so on and so fourth -- but real social and physical trauma that has lasted into today? There were more important events during that time-frame in that regard, personal opinion.

You should listen to some Constitutional law folks talk about this stuff. We are crashing headlong into a legitimate constitutional crisis because of January 6 and the resultant cases.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by AndrewKemendo on Monday December 18, 2023 @10:02PM (#38691276)
Honestly, these responses have been staggeringly depressing
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by wizerdrobe on Sunday December 17, 2023 @06:36PM (#38677549)
Why would you consider January 6 protests to be the turning point specifically? It was neither particularly violent nor a first regarding violation of norms. There was no attempt at rallying armed forces in a coup d’etat.

Could just as well consider something like the Tea Party circa 2010 a turning point in separatism.

For the modern era, at least.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by SpaceL10n on Sunday December 17, 2023 @06:57PM (#38677680)
Mobs of people storming the Capitol is a violation of norms. Are you sure you are okay?
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by rayiner on Sunday December 17, 2023 @08:11PM (#38678152)
This is America. This shit happens. A mob just tried to storm the White House last month: https://www.jpost.com/international/article-771751. The Capitol just happens to have no real security (it never had—my wife used to sneak into the Congressional subway system all the time). It’s been bombed at least twice.
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by dctoedt on Monday December 18, 2023 @04:42PM (#38688749)
So you're equating a few outliers trying to get attention, with an armed mob of thousands — summoned, dispatched, and then egged on by the sitting POTUS.

JFC.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by nec4b on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @04:09AM (#38693437)
Are you trying to say if only a few outliers bomb a building is somehow ok? Or because they were far left terrorist its nothing to worry about?
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by dctoedt on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @06:47AM (#38694451)
> Are you trying to say if only a few outliers bomb a building is somehow ok?

No. That's false-dichotomy thinking, along the lines of, "It HAS to be either A or B, and it's not B, so it MUST be A."

> Or because they were far left terrorist its nothing to worry about?

No. They're both bad. But:

1. The BLM rioting was mostly spontaneous and rag-tag, whereas Jan. 6 was orchestrated by the then-Commander in Chief of the U.S. armed forces, aided and abetted by his acolytes in and out of government (including outsiders such as the Proud Boys); and

2. The societal risks to democratic governance differed enormously. Unlike the BLM rioting, Jan. 6 could conceivably have played out like the October Revolution in the Russia of 1917, where an armed Leninist minority seized power and displaced the Kerensky provisional government that had itself taken control in the wake of the February Revolution. [0]

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/October_Revolution

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by nec4b on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @07:15AM (#38694630)
>> The BLM rioting was mostly spontaneous and rag-tag

Sure they were. I wonder why they are otherwise organized and have leadership and full approval of the party which is currently in power?

>> The societal risks to democratic governance differed enormously. Unlike the BLM rioting

Unlike BLM rioting or bombing of the capitol by the far left terrorist they didn't do any property damage or attack other people on the street.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by dctoedt on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @05:13PM (#38702549)
> I wonder why they [BLM rioters] are otherwise organized and have leadership and full approval of the party which is currently in power?

I don't think you can support that contention with, y'know, evidence. Keep in mind that some — not all — of the so-called BLM arson incidents were later found to have been done as false-flag operations by far-right extremist types [0] or as plain old insurance fraud. [1]

[0] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/oct/23/texas-boogaloo...

[1] https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/minnesota-trump-support...

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by nec4b on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @04:13AM (#38706748)
What do you mean without evidence? You are contesting BLM has leadership? They have a website, you can check it out. Regarding the democratic party support, there are a lot of videos from cnn and other networks interviews where visible member give their support to BLM.
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by dctoedt on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @06:40AM (#38707545)
You're painting with a broad brush: "BLM" ≠ "rioting."

EDIT: From a 2020 Trump Administration report: "President Donald Trump has blamed leftwing extremist groups for instigating nights of looting and violence in cities across the United States, but an intelligence assessment offers limited evidence that organized extremists are behind the turmoil. [¶] In part of a June 1 internal intelligence assessment of the protests seen by Reuters, U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) officials said most of the violence appears to have been driven by opportunists." [0]

[0] https://www.reuters.com/article/idUSKBN23A1MZ/

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by nec4b on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @10:13AM (#38709516)
>> You're painting with a broad brush: "BLM" ≠ "rioting."

And you don't see yourself doing the same to the "other" side?

>> but an intelligence assessment offers limited evidence that organized extremists are behind the turmoil

"limited evidence"

If you have ever read a book about communist revolutions or by chance even lived in a a country which had a violent leftist takeover of power, you would have recognized the tactics and methods of those takeovers in BLM protests.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by dctoedt on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @10:30AM (#38709735)
At least one of us is delusional, and/or paranoid.
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by dctoedt on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @02:33PM (#38712618)
> And you don't see yourself doing the same [i.e., painting with a broad brush] to the "other" side?

No — I'm making specific accusations about Donald Trump and some of his followers in and out of government.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by dctoedt on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @05:16PM (#38702594)
> Unlike BLM rioting or bombing of the capitol by the far left terrorist they didn't do any property damage or attack other people on the street.

Oh. I guess that makes it OK for the armed right-wing mob to try to seize control of the national government — and to go looking for the sitting VP and Speaker of the House, seemingly with lynching in mind.

(Leftist bombing? You mean by the Weather Underground in 1971, at the height of the Vietnam War? That doesn't excuse it by any means, course, but it's so old as to be irrelevant to today's discussion.)

https://www.history.com/news/us-capitol-building-violence-fi...

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by nec4b on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @04:23AM (#38706790)
You are the one claiming leftist violence is just a fluke, just kids having fun with robbing, beating and arson. At the same time claiming a much smaller right-wing transgression is the end of the world. The are an examples of right-wing terrorist actions that are much much more despicable and truly destructable. Unlike you I have no problem condemning either side when they are wrong.

>> That doesn't excuse it by any means, course, but it's so old as to be irrelevant to today's discussion.

You must be kidding. Should we also not talk about people and ideology that brought us world war 2, since it has been even longer then the Vietnam war?

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by dctoedt on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @06:41AM (#38707559)
We'll have to agree to disagree about that, because obviously each of us thinks the other has his (her?) head firmly jammed up a warm dark place.
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by AnimalMuppet on Sunday December 17, 2023 @07:22PM (#38677848)
wizardrobe didn't say it wasn't a violation of norms. Said it wasn't the first violation of norms. (Mind you, I don't know what specific previous violations wizardrobe had it mind...)

It's like, in Rome, Caesar wasn't the first violation of norms. The Gracchi were. Then came Marius and Sulla. Sulla restored the norms and retired - but the precedent of violating the norms had already been set. 19 years later came the first triumvirate. 11 years after that came the civil war.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by asfdgionio on Sunday December 17, 2023 @06:50PM (#38677632)
>There was no attempt at rallying armed forces in a coup d’etat.

What are you talking about? There most certainly was, and a successful one at that. The mob had firearms and pipe bombs and a wide variety of melee weapons. They smashed their way into the building. Rioters intended to hold lawmakers captive and planned to execute the vice president. Several people died.

The sitting president led a mob to levy war against the United States. The fact that it was ineffective doesn't matter.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by fjgvcjygjvh on Sunday December 17, 2023 @07:14PM (#38677788)
Sure but it was a disorganized mob rather than a real coup attempt.

Of course the Pentagon's reluctance to send in the National Guard until there was an > 0% chance that the governor of Virginia would order an "invasion" (with the consent of the city mayor) was pretty concerning but incompetence rather than some conspiracy seems like more likely explanation.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by ethanbond on Sunday December 17, 2023 @07:25PM (#38677868)
Not true. There was a real coup attempt across several states and a disorganized mob.
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by fjgvcjygjvh on Sunday December 17, 2023 @07:27PM (#38677881)
> There was a real coup attempt across several states

Can you elaborate on that?

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by ethanbond on Sunday December 17, 2023 @07:29PM (#38677897)
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by ipython on Sunday December 17, 2023 @07:33PM (#38677925)
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by asfdgionio on Sunday December 17, 2023 @07:32PM (#38677924)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attempts_to_overturn_the_2020_...

The most important ones are the fake electors scheme, the phone call to Brian Kemp, and numerous attempts to steal or tamper with voting machines.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by eastbound on Sunday December 17, 2023 @07:04PM (#38677724)
> several people died

Care to list which side the people were killed? And were they armed?

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by asfdgionio on Sunday December 17, 2023 @07:29PM (#38677896)
One Union boy died, unfortunately, but we gave better than we got!

The people who were shot were killed to defend the capitol and were given ample warning. Ashley Babbitt, for instance, was trying to break down a door.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by friend_and_foe on Sunday December 17, 2023 @08:58PM (#38678459)
How did he die?

There was only one person shot.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by TMWNN on Sunday December 17, 2023 @11:56PM (#38679379)
>How did he die?

I love how when I ask that same question, people like asdfgionio [1] obviously do a quick search and find (contrary to what they were told immediately afterwards) that no Capitol police was, in fact, killed during the riot. They either shut up or try to double down. I then point to Officer Sicknick's autopsy results and that usually gets them to shut up.

[1] Who I can only describe, based on his comment, as a Union Army LARPer; "We", indeed. (Actual war reenactors go to great lengths to get the uniforms, gear, and battles right; I doubt asdfgionio has ever seen a battlefield not published by EA.) I've seen several other such instances, of Redditors and such bravely proclaiming how "they" will lead another Sherman's march through states that commit the unpardonable sin of voting for the wrong candidate.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by friend_and_foe on Monday December 18, 2023 @12:25AM (#38679514)
Oh that's what that was, a reference to the civil war? I was wondering what he was talking about, "union guy". Man, these guys really live in a different world than the rest of us.

I was curious about it too because as far as I knew nobody else died from it besides the woman who was shot by capitol police. Every time I think I'm about to learn something new about J6 I don't.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by TMWNN on Monday December 18, 2023 @12:33AM (#38679555)
> I was curious about it too because as far as I knew nobody else died from it besides the woman who was shot by capitol police. Every time I think I'm about to learn something new about J6 I don't.

Sicknick's death by stroke the day after the riot was widely attributed to some injury from the incident, despite his having told his family that he had not been injured in the first place. That's why he received the equivalent of a state funeral. That's also why the coroner specifically looked for evidence of trauma causing the stroke, either from a head injury or exposure to tear gas, and specifically ruled out both possibilities in his report. But this still doesn't prevent the gullible from prattling on about how "many" policemen were killed, or that the ravenous mob of rioters were armed with everything but a tactical nuke.

(I think this is also why we haven't yet seen a breathless best-selling account of "The Day Trump Tried to Overthrow the Government", or a Netflix docudrama. Any such work with a pretense of accuracy would have to depict, well, not much beyond 150 idiots invading a public space, refusing to obey Capitol Police's orders, and causing some mayhem until one unarmed rioter is finally shot after an inexplicable delay. No grenades/pipe bombs being detonated, no politicians being lynched, no policemen being fatally beaten by a mob.)

As I wrote elsewhere:

> Had Capitol Police as a whole done their job and used their training and weapons to stop the invaders in the first place, a great deal of trouble would have been avoided while more rioters would have been shot (which I have no problem with). Why they did not do their job is something that I trust will be answered one day.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by vGPU on Sunday December 17, 2023 @07:14PM (#38677789)
And yet the BLM “peaceful protests” that burned and looted parts of well over a dozen major cities is considered perfectly acceptable.

Both of them were ultimately political protests and yet everyone seems to have forgotten about the actually violent one.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by asfdgionio on Sunday December 17, 2023 @07:28PM (#38677890)
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/04/us/politics/republicans-j...

The GOP has officially endorsed political violence and has done so repeatedly. Terrorism is the official party line. Trying to murder politicians is "legitimate political discourse". Trump is still the 2024 GOP front-runner.

Riots are bad. Having a terrorist organization as a major political party is worse.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by friend_and_foe on Sunday December 17, 2023 @09:02PM (#38678484)
OK, now we see just how rational your justification for your position is. Terrorists? It's like when MAGA people call Democrats child molester demon worshippers. Are you even interested in genuine discourse at all?
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by vGPU on Monday December 18, 2023 @01:35AM (#38679839)
Seeing as how he appears to have created the account 6 hours ago to reply to my comment, I would have to say “doubtful”.
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by vGPU on Monday December 18, 2023 @01:32AM (#38679828)
Have you forgotten how many democrats have called for the murder and/or execution of trump publicly?

Give me a break.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by dctoedt on Monday December 18, 2023 @04:44PM (#38688783)
> Have you forgotten how many democrats have called for the murder and/or execution of trump publicly?

Citation, please?

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by vGPU on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @12:55PM (#38698971)
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by dctoedt on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @01:17PM (#38699318)
OK, ya got me: You managed to find one case from 2017 involving one Dem state senator (who was promptly yanked from all her committee assignments after her comment and "chose" not to run for reelection). Oh, and you found a bunch of rants from comedians, actors, and other powerless publicity-seeking hotheads — who can be found in all walks of life and of all political persuasions. Did you find anything in, say, the past couple of years?
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by friend_and_foe on Sunday December 17, 2023 @08:42PM (#38678358)
> several people died.

I was honestly at first reading what you said thinking "oh really, I didn't know that. I need to look into this, sounds like it was way worse than portrayed" until you said that. Somebody having a stroke is not the same thing as someone being beaten to death or shot. Even saying "several people died" demonstrates a disingenuous disposition, you have to deliberately avoid going into detail to make your point. The only person that died as a result of the actions there was a woman named Ashley Babbit who was shot by US capitol police.

Given that, I ask you, with all these firearms and pipe bombs and a real attempt at insurrection, how come nobody fired or detonated them?

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by wizerdrobe on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @05:24PM (#38714455)
He called for peace and then later for the mob to leave.

A generous to the other side reading of events would be it was a suggestive display of power, that he could rally even more later. Kind of like his perfect phone call being pitched as a thinly-veiled mafioso threat.

Real coups attempts involve officers rally elements to decapitate attentive movements, leaders, non-supporters.

In no honest reality was the mob action on the Capitol anything other than a nuisance. A police department from a city the size of DC could put down a majority unarmed mob with less-than-lethal and more-than-lethal assets.

And even if the mob magically overpowers the police department, the Nasty Girls would put them down and the inauguration ceremony would proceed as normal or be ignored and Biden installed as needed.

Your anonymous account and dishonest retelling (the pipe bombs were not at the Capitol) are nothing but a thinly veiled political troll. Go away.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by Raptor22 on Sunday December 17, 2023 @06:49PM (#38677629)
> It was neither particularly violent

Wow. I know perhaps this makes sense from a non-American perspective, but as an American, January 6 was incredibly violent. I think some people forget that this isn't normal.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by TheDudeMan on Sunday December 17, 2023 @07:09PM (#38677751)
How many people were killed or injured?
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by cyberge99 on Sunday December 17, 2023 @11:00PM (#38679100)
Six killed. Numerous injured.
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by Asooka on Monday December 18, 2023 @05:47AM (#38681042)
Where are you getting "six killed" from? AFAIK there was one death and that was a protestor shot by a cop.
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by hasty_pudding on Sunday December 17, 2023 @07:28PM (#38677888)
It's how America became a country. They violated all the norms of England.
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by whythre on Sunday December 17, 2023 @07:08PM (#38677748)
I am an American and I don’t think it was particularly violet. There were 4 deaths. Not 400 or 40 (not like I wanted there to be more). But pearl clutching over some people protesting where they shouldn’t have when Congress wasn’t in session is just silly.
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by katbyte on Sunday December 17, 2023 @08:12PM (#38678160)
violent != deadly?

seemed pretty violent at times, but it wasn't deadly

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by hydrok9 on Sunday December 17, 2023 @08:34PM (#38678308)
as far as coups go, this one was pretty tame
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by TMWNN on Monday December 18, 2023 @12:01AM (#38679404)
>I am an American and I don’t think it was particularly violet. There were 4 deaths.

There was one death. One. An unarmed rioter named Ashly Babbit who was shot by Capitol Police well after the riot's start.

One Capitol Police member, Officer Sicknick, died of a stroke the day afterwards, but the coroner specifically looked for signs of his either being hit on the head, or exposed to tear gas, as causes, and concluded that neither was true.

Had Capitol Police as a whole done their job and used their training and weapons to stop the invaders in the first place, a great deal of trouble would have been avoided while more rioters would have been shot (which I have no problem with). Why they did not do their job is something that I trust will be answered one day.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by tenpies on Sunday December 17, 2023 @08:24PM (#38678255)
I think people also forget that before January 6th we literally had:

* Separatist movements from Antifa and the Left set up autonomous zones within US cities[1].

* Multiple calls for violence from prominent Democrats and other Leftists towards Republican politicians, judges, and a sitting US President [2]

* Billions of damage and looting by Antifa and BLM [3]

* Multiple Antifa and BLM attacks on Federal buildings, including courthouses [4]

I could go on for quite a while, but my point is that any of these events alone is comparable to January 6th. It would have been unimaginable to a 2000s American that any of these things not only take place, but were allowed and even encouraged by a major US political party.

All of these were more violent, damaging, and should carry much stronger legal consequences for the separatists, terrorists, and perpetrators; but because the Democrat-backed groups did it, it is barely even remembered.

---

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitol_Hill_Occupied_Protest

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XG5BcU1ZGiA

[3] https://www.axios.com/2020/09/16/riots-cost-property-damage - this is just for the May to June of 2020 time period.

[4] https://www.justice.gov/usao-nv/pr/five-individuals-face-fed... and https://www.opb.org/article/2021/03/12/protesters-vandalize-... but there are more.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by CamperBob2 on Sunday December 17, 2023 @08:50PM (#38678413)
It's one thing when some local agitators stir up shit and torch a Starbucks or whatever.

It's another thing entirely when the President does it.

(Which I'm sure you'd be braying from the hilltops, had the President in question been named Clinton or Biden or Obama.)

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by SamReidHughes on Sunday December 17, 2023 @09:37PM (#38678673)
Obama incited the Dallas police assassinations in 2016.
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by CamperBob2 on Monday December 18, 2023 @11:28AM (#38684698)
Yeah, and then there was that time he wore a tan suit after Labor Day and triggered the Fox News people something awful.

But yeah, to your point, stochastic terrorism is indeed a thing. Ask your favorite right-wing politician about that, they're the actual experts.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by jauntywundrkind on Sunday December 17, 2023 @11:04PM (#38679124)
None of these were in any way remotely existential threats to actual political stability. Minor protests. The Axios article - a fairly right-ish folk - happily points out that the insurance claims for regional natural disaster like a wildfire season are way higher cost & ongoing, where-as $1-2B estimates over 2 years across the entire nation is not excellent but honestly not bad. And an estimate from a company with a vested interest in exaggerating claims

The gentleman doeth protest too much. The Whataboutisn here is the ridiculous talking points the right wing has had to instill fear & terror in their base. Telling a people they are under attack, that their way of life is in danger, that the cities are all burning & awful: that's propaganda, fear to get folks afraid and concerned and glued to the TV. As known bad guy stated, "All you have to do is tell them they are being attacked and denounce the pacifists for lack of patriotism and exposing the country to danger. It works the same way in any country.

Some of these protests & situations have been tense & ugly & unruly; yes. Their cost wasn't nothing. But there's just so little to fear here. These were mild inconveniences in any broad scope. More generally the false equivalence at large here doesn't sit right with me at all, seems wild. The decorum on the right has severely degraded, to where the party can't even whip itself. The presence of violent & extremist rhetoric is shockingly prevalent & ongoing, from a wide cross section of elected & nominated people. It's inconceivable to imagine a threat from the left now, to see a cycle where the left is broadly working themselves up towards a crisis point. There is no left threat. We've already experienced a major attack from the right & many seem to be campaigning on a platform of only further extremism.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by CamperBob2 on Sunday December 17, 2023 @08:49PM (#38678398)
It's the closest thing we've seen to the Beer Hall Putsch, an event that was also so ineptly-orchestrated as to appear comical to many, that had no immediate effect on most peoples' daily lives, and that also led to grossly inadequate punishment for the perpetrators.
Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by Wytwwww on Monday December 18, 2023 @05:27AM (#38680921)
> we've seen to the Beer Hall Putsch,

Possibly. But the Beer Hall Putsch was a (relatively) highly organized attempt by a militarized organization to a achieve some very specific goals (even though the coup attempt itself was a complete failure since it only took the army a couple of hours to stop it). It wasn't even necessarily such a big deal at the time, the nazis remained an insufficient fringe party for years (until the Great Depression hit).

IMHO Jan 6th was a lot closer to something like the "13 Vendémiaire" just of course with no Napoleon, much lower scale and a lot less violent. In the sense that it was a generic insurrection than an actual coup attempt.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by CamperBob2 on Monday December 18, 2023 @12:21PM (#38685391)
But the Beer Hall Putsch was a (relatively) highly organized attempt by a militarized organization to a achieve some very specific goals (even though the coup attempt itself was a complete failure since it only took the army a couple of hours to stop it). It wasn't even necessarily such a big deal at the time, the nazis remained an insufficient fringe party for years (until the Great Depression hit).

It seems like you meant to start that sentence with "And" rather than "But." January 6 was organized at the highest levels of the executive branch, which is in command of the US military. We can thank our lucky stars that the executive branch was populated by bumbling fools at the time, and that no major economic crisis was in play. But these factors won't always work in our favor as Americans.

It's hard to avoid seeing a disturbing resemblance between the Brown Shirts and groups like the Oath Keepers and Proud Boys. Enrique Tarrio and Ernst Röhm would have a lot to talk about if you locked them in the same cell. They were both betrayed by the personality cults they fought for... which, after all, were chartered to eliminate people like them.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by qwytw on Sunday December 17, 2023 @07:24PM (#38677865)
Except it was the civil war that caused a debt crisis in Ancient Rome and not the other way around. Repaying debts is somewhat hard when most of your productive assets are destroyed or completely devastated.

Debt forgiveness was a common in such cases because back then government didn't really have any other monetary policy tools or ways to stimulate the economy.

Re:The Debt Problem Is Enormous, and the System for Fixing I... by jojobas on Sunday December 17, 2023 @06:46PM (#38677606)
Oh sure, Goths, plagues and total moral decay were not the reason, the debt crisis was.