News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by FirmwareBurner on Thursday December 14, 2023 @08:34AM (#38641154)
You are correct. Building fabs today only for fabbing much older nodes will not be profitable. You have to target 22nm and below otherwise you can't afford to jump in the semi fab ring.
Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by hajile on Thursday December 14, 2023 @08:44AM (#38641219)
TSMC is building a lot of new 28nm production with plans to shut down all their older nodes and move everyone over in the next few years.

GlobalFoundries (formerly AMD fabs) created a brand-new 22nm planar process specifically for older chips as an upgrade to other company's 28nm processes.

Profits seem possible if you approach it the right way.

Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by FirmwareBurner on Thursday December 14, 2023 @10:10AM (#38642165)
We're talking about different things here. I was talking about building new fabs for 28nm nodes and you're talking about TSMC upgrading existing fabs from older nodes to 28nm production.

Of course upgrading an existing older "sunk-cost" fab to 28nm production will be profitable, but not building a new one from scratch just for that same older node.

Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday December 14, 2023 @06:34PM (#38648970)
But now this makes the subsidies angle make more sense: You subsidize initial construction and then the domestic plant remains online indefinitely because the construction is a sunk cost and the incremental cost of upgrades over time is sustainable.
Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by throwup238 on Thursday December 14, 2023 @10:09AM (#38642146)
The math works out a lot better when you’re upgrading pre-EUV fabs or expanding an existing facility. A lot of the gear and setup is mostly the same such as wafer cleaning, HVAC and isolation, etc and the local challenges to setup and labor have been figured out.
Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by ls612 on Friday December 15, 2023 @01:02PM (#38656747)
Whatever is the best they can make a DUV, planar process do will be used for decades to come.
Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by cduzz on Thursday December 14, 2023 @08:47AM (#38641255)
"But I've got a product that's certified with this part that's running on a 40nm process that has these specifications that are deeply tied to features of that 40nm process; things like voltage ranges and temperature tolerances! If you force me to switch to a comparable but not identical part at 22nm I'll have to re-certify my widget with 18 different regulatory agencies!"
Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by Someone on Thursday December 14, 2023 @01:08PM (#38644767)
If those are your needs, you order all the parts you need over your product’s lifetime up-front or get (= pay for) a contract with the manufacturer that makes them promise to sell you the parts for X years (they probably wouldn’t keep producing old parts, but would stockpile enough of them to be able to deliver working ones years later)

(Or you prepare for having to go to eBay for working parts. https://www.nytimes.com/2002/05/12/us/for-parts-nasa-boldly-...)

Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by kjs3 on Thursday December 14, 2023 @06:43PM (#38649055)
There are companies (I've used Rochester Electronics) that both stockpile and manufacture legacy chips specifically for the long tail support situations.
Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by zozbot234 on Thursday December 14, 2023 @08:45AM (#38641229)
You will always have pure analog electronics and other bespoke things that basically don't benefit from anything finer than these nodes. Even for digital chips, it makes no sense to use leading edge nodes for very simple logic where a lot of the area is just contact pads.
Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by janekm on Thursday December 14, 2023 @09:07AM (#38641453)
But you can only really make those profitably for a few industries (military, medical, seismic come to mind). The EU does have the chip fabs for those industries, of course...
Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by phkahler on Thursday December 14, 2023 @10:12AM (#38642189)
>> But you can only really make those profitably for a few industries

I think it's more like they're only profitable if the equipment is already paid for. And even then the margins may be low.

Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by eternauta3k on Saturday December 16, 2023 @01:49PM (#38666703)
Power electronics are a mainstream, very profitable market.
Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by jacquesm on Thursday December 14, 2023 @09:19AM (#38641572)
It's not about what you can do or can't do. It is about what you can do profitably and that's a completely different thing.
Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by voakbasda on Thursday December 14, 2023 @11:19AM (#38643011)
I have to wonder if the ability to profit depends entirely on the established cartel of semiconductor manufacturers. They determine the current prices of chips in the marketplace.

If entering that marketplace requires competing with them, then I am not sure anyone that is not already in the market can ever win. The margins are too low and the startup costs are too high.

Government intervention seems to be the only possible solution, and that option hardly sounds viable when considering that cartel’s collective lobbying power.

Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by cduzz on Thursday December 14, 2023 @11:56AM (#38643598)
I don't think this is a "cartel of semiconductor manufacturers" so much as it's been a "shambolic cluster of organizations running crappy old fabs into the ground producing cheap chips that were subsidized by a prior decade's worth of very expensive products."

I can afford to sell gazillions of chips at $0.08 per chip if I'm running a fab I didn't pay to build. I'm only (barely) paying for the inputs. When Stan, the last guy who understands how to run the widget verifier, or Elaine, the last lady to understands how to run the polishing machine retire, I'll have to close up shop.

Those $0.08 per chip devices have been absurdly subsidized in that a replacement infrastructure to make them would require that they cost $10 per device, and the ecosystem of things built on $0.08 chips isn't viable in a $10 per chip world.

In order to have a fab make $0.03 per unit devices, you first have to have the fab spend 10 years making $300 per unit devices, regardless of the underlying node size of those $300 per unit devices.

Likely you couldn't even go back and make a fab that makes large volumes of 60nm-90nm node sizes at all, for any amount of money, because the equipment to do this (new) hasn't been made in 2 decades and no company is willing to invest the money to make new crappy old equipment.

It's not a nefarious oligopoly as much as a synchronized "run the asset to failure" lifecycle of the infrastructure.

How much does it cost to make a 300 year old tree?

Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by photonbeam on Thursday December 14, 2023 @01:38PM (#38645209)
> How much does it cost to make a 300 year old tree?

Aside from your main point, I found this an interesting thought exercise thinking about cost of air, sunlight, soil, water and then 300 years of security

Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by Qwertious on Thursday December 14, 2023 @09:08PM (#38650311)
I imagine if you're going to grow one 300 year old tree, then your best bet is obscurity. Find a stable very-rural area that's not prone to bushfires, plant one tree and make sure it's doing well for a few years, come back 300 years later, you're done.

If you're not going the obscurity path then you'd really want to scale it up - there's not much difference between security for one tree and security for 100 trees.

Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by cf1241290841 on Thursday December 14, 2023 @05:05PM (#38647976)
>Likely you couldn't even go back and make a fab that makes large volumes of 60nm-90nm node sizes at all, for any amount of money, because the equipment to do this (new) hasn't been made in 2 decades and no company is willing to invest the money to make new crappy old equipment.

I believe your argument assumes that there is a fixed cost to produce even 180nm or 350nm ICs that hasnt changed since the first one was produced.

We still need 300 years for a 300 year old tree, but 25 year old technology might now be relatively easy to build if we start from scratch.

What was high tech then might be relatively easy to solve now. One example might be https://github.com/circuitvalley/USB_C_Industrial_Camera_FPG... being open source instead of a multi year, multi million dollar project.

Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by cduzz on Thursday December 14, 2023 @05:25PM (#38648189)
Yes, my argument is that producing at industrial scales even chunky nodes requires enormous capital expenditures and may be impossible without rebuilding large chunks of an antiquated and abandoned supply chain.

Even if it is 10% the cost of making the each of the individual components involved in making a relatively simple 90nm chip, you're still looking at vast costs.

If you're talking about making 30 chips in a university fab, sure, I'll concede that it is "possible" but if you're talking about propping up an industry built on products that require a herd of standardized "$0.30" parts made on legacy 90nm fabs, that ship has sailed.

Update your BOM and recertify or raise your costs by an order of magnitude.

Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by cf1241290841 on Thursday December 14, 2023 @05:51PM (#38648502)
First off, you are definitively making a very solid point, cost for getting mass production right are a killer once the institutional knowledge is gone. For example, its very visible in the field of battery technologies if i am not mistaken. Going from lead to lithium was a gigantic task and the inertia going forwards hasnt reduced enough at this point.

But realistically this is a matter of going back far enough, to lower the cost far enough? 10% are a good start but to stick to the topic, physical gyroscopes from decades ago are now replaced with MEMS ICs where the reduction in cost is magnitudes more then down to 10%. At a certain point the reduced cost makes it viable. The question is just has it been long enough?

While we wont get 90nm cheap enough, the question is what can we do on a hobby level (vs academia)? Because going from there (neglectable cost and technological requirements) to mass production will at some point be cheaper then the cost of setting up reproducible tooling for older high tech systems.

I am likely still off with 180nm, but there should be a level at which this makes economical sense. A level that gets cheaper to reach with technological progress / time.

Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by zozbot234 on Thursday December 14, 2023 @06:11PM (#38648708)
The problem I see with this argument is that there are plenty of fabs making trailing-edge devices, some of which aren't even that old. It even seems to be part of the established path for countries and locations more generally that seek to bootstrap a semiconductor industry of their own. They get started with the simplest and coarsest nodes, then go finer step by step. Even TSMC got their start that way. So it seems like a pretty robust industry to me, I'm not seeing the argument for a crisis.
Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by cf1241290841 on Thursday December 14, 2023 @06:22PM (#38648847)
Personally i cant follow this line of reasoning. In the end this is an economical argument, as they still buy machines from the same manufacturer. At that point its a matter of being able to deliver and create a market for ICs with the given machines. Which is often achieved through political will and subsidizes to get to that point.

My initial argument is that while you cant compete with ASML products in 2023, you will be able to economically compete with some of their older products once you go back far enough.

Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by jacquesm on Thursday December 14, 2023 @11:49AM (#38643458)
The capital expense on a new fab is crazy. There may be a cartel factor but that usually would work to the advantage of the manufacturers, so that doesn't seem to be the case here.
Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by mardifoufs on Thursday December 14, 2023 @11:50AM (#38643486)
There's no real cartel for older nodes. It's not even really possible considering how many fabs exist and how many players are operating those older fabs.
Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by cf1241290841 on Thursday December 14, 2023 @05:07PM (#38647988)
Number of producers of these fabs is still quite limited though.
Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by cf1241290841 on Thursday December 14, 2023 @02:59PM (#38646467)
Relevant to mention MEMS (micro-electromechanical systems) in this context, which use much older nm tech. Be it digital micro mirror devices¹ or gyros². Or photo/laser diodes.

Given the physical limitations, as well as the problems we have with code base security it might be time to aim for cheaper production of something in the region of 180nm instead.

Looking at how old much of the standard weaponry used today is (TOW 50 years with an actual physical gyroscope, Javelin still 25 years³), the demand from the military alone should cover the initial cost. Especially if you look at the ludicrous prices western countries payed for even dumb artillery shells.

¹ Texas Instruments DMD from a DLP projector from @AppliedScience https://youtu.be/9nb8mM3uEIc?t=428

² Explanation of MPU-6050 from @BreakingTaps https://youtu.be/9X4frIQo7x0?t=664

³ Teardown of both from @lelabodemichel5162 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s7-6hgX7-zQ

Sorry for late edits

Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by Workaccount2 on Thursday December 14, 2023 @08:56AM (#38641335)
There might be an argument then that it would be worth it for the state to take the hit. If shit hits the fan and you have zero semi-manufacturing, then you are going to be pretty screwed.
Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by qwytw on Thursday December 14, 2023 @11:06AM (#38642855)
> If shit hits the fan and you have zero semi-manufacturing, then you are going to be pretty screwed.

I don't really understand this claim at all. Chips are not exactly fungible, unless you force your local companies to use you "state sponsored chips" in their products just being able to produce "chips" wouldn't be that useful. What are you going to do with them?

Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by 15155 on Thursday December 14, 2023 @12:23PM (#38644048)
Guide munitions if needed.
Re:Barcelona Supercomputing Center presents Sargantana: new ... by black_puppydog on Thursday December 14, 2023 @09:18AM (#38641561)
So the cost of building a fab hasn't come down in the last decades, huh? Genuinely asking, is there some^W^W^W what is the "uncompressible" cost in fab-fabbing? I'd totally guess that staff and the building itself are not it?