It's wild to me that people make assertions like this. We can (and should) argue about the effectiveness of smoking restrictions on decreasing cancer and heart disease, but to make the argument that they have no effect is just silliness.
You hear the same arguments from the right whenever gun control, environmental protections or really any sort of government regulation comes up, and from the left (though to a much lesser degree) on the topic of tax rates. We should all be able to agree that any sort of regulation will have a marginal effect, and be able to have a discussion about the level of that effect.
Is this no longer the case?
Systems without regulations ends either with monopoly or towards entropy. To keep system balanced, regulations need to adapt in time. Contrary to this, it is not uncommon in US to think that Constitution is set in stone and regulations are bad.
It's worked out that way in a lot of US states for weed -- the illegal stuff is still around and still cheaper. I read recently that in California, illegal weed is still 75% of the market.
If you're already happy with your friendly neighborhood plug, why change?
I found the the article I mentioned:
https://www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2022-05-22/legal-weed-...
Not exactly encouraging new businesses, but to still go from 0 to 25% that’s not too bad
That's already happening in USA.
https://www.reliasmedia.com/articles/13807-cleveland-clinic-...
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5788708/
And perhaps baselessly, not just testing for tobacco, but any form of nicotine.
I am not saying the fentanyl should be made legal, but its criminalization is a big part of the problem. It is also why it is used so much over other, less risky opioids. Because it is so potent, only small quantities are needed, which makes trafficking easier.
On the other hand, look at cigarettes - everyone agrees they are very bad for you, the packages say it, and you pay an extremely high premium for them over their costs. But no one dies from fentanyl (or whatever) in them because they're a regulated industry. We used to know less about it and let people smoke as much as they want. Now that we have good data on that we raise the social and financial cost of cigarettes to keep them as unpopular as possible.
I'd encourage you to think about this less like eggs and more like the weather. On some level, drugs exist "out there" and people will use them "sometimes." We can't change that. What we can change are the systems that make the already difficult problem of addiction worse by introducing lethal surprises.
No restrictions on sale other than 18+ (I was 24 when I started), and inside public places were only restricted a few years after I came back so I smoked a fair bit in local bars.
Smoking and similar habits are such a wild spectrum you can't prescribe any one thing and restrictions might help some who are prone but aren't really a cure.
Needless to say I started smoking again... I then quit again for a few years... went to northern Africa, and guess what? People literally smoking at the airport, £1 packs of camel, etc...
I haven't had one in a bit now... People think the restrictions don't work, but they absolutely do.