News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trust-Based Moderation Systems by _heimdall on Sunday December 10, 2023 @07:47AM (#38591167)
> Then raise the stakes more and consider the US presidential candidate nominations process.

If there was any trust left here, the upcoming election cycle should have already destroyed it. The likely Republican candidate refuses to debate, the Democrats all seem to think the president shouldn't run again but won't stop him or allow a challenger, in all likelihood the two final candidates also won't debate each other, and we're left picking between two candidates that much of the country likely aren't happy with. That's neither democratic or trustworthy.

Re:Trust-Based Moderation Systems by kemotep on Sunday December 10, 2023 @10:09AM (#38591983)
Both parties are still running primaries. None of the races have happened yet so whether Biden or Trump get the nomination isn’t set in stone. In addition to the two major parties, there are several independent and third parties. Because they are not popular enough to win isn’t a condemnation of democracy. That’s how it works.
Re:Trust-Based Moderation Systems by _heimdall on Sunday December 10, 2023 @11:32AM (#38592701)
The Republicans are running a primary, though the candidate with by far the most support isn't taking part. Trump will be on the primary ballot and always loves hearing himself talk on an empty stage, but he's avoided debates entirely. That isn't the fault of voters or the party necessarily, though the party can and possibly should require candidates to take part in the primary process if they want to be on the party's ballot.

The Democrats effectively aren't running a primary at all. There are technically two challengers[1], though there are no debates planned [2]. RFK was running on the ticket and had plenty of support in polls to warrant primary debates, though he's now running as an independent after what he viewed as a refusal by the party to allow a primary process to challenge Biden (his opinion, I can't vouch for inner workings of the DNC).

[1] https://www.reuters.com/world/us/democratic-candidates-runni...

[2] https://deadline.com/feature/2024-presidential-debates-sched...

Re:Trust-Based Moderation Systems by girvo on Sunday December 10, 2023 @05:57PM (#38595878)
> RFK was running on the ticket

As a non-American, who's RFK? Not the long-dead Robert F Kennedy, of course, but my ability to search that acronym pretty much only brings him up

Re:Trust-Based Moderation Systems by _heimdall on Sunday December 10, 2023 @05:59PM (#38595891)
Oh sorry, yeah I shouldn't have gone with initials there! Yes that was referencing Robert F Kennedy
Re:Trust-Based Moderation Systems by girvo on Sunday December 10, 2023 @07:29PM (#38596412)
Oh! I must've really misunderstood your comment, my apologies, I thought you were talking about someone today!
Re:Trust-Based Moderation Systems by _heimdall on Sunday December 10, 2023 @08:03PM (#38596574)
Well I'm failing at writing clear messages today. I was referencing a candidate today, Rover F Kennedy Jr

Honestly I never really think to refer to him as a Junior, his dad was assassinated shortly before I was born, but I should have not only avoided using initials I should have also included the "Jr"

Re:Trust-Based Moderation Systems by actionfromafar on Sunday December 10, 2023 @11:40AM (#38592765)
That's not how it works in a first-past-the-post voting system!

Third parties can not gain traction. (Hence all the effort spent on co-opting and riding one of the existing parties like a zombie.)

Re:Trust-Based Moderation Systems by dartos on Sunday December 10, 2023 @12:34PM (#38593206)
This.

Third parties effectively exists as free research for what positions will be popular next cycle

Re:Trust-Based Moderation Systems by kemotep on Sunday December 10, 2023 @01:09PM (#38593481)
Well at one point the Republicans were a third party. Yes First past the post is terrible, but to say your candidate can’t win without getting the most votes is how nearly all election systems work.

A lot needs to be reformed with regards to voting and election systems in the US but to claim it is impossible for a third party to win is factually incorrect. How else would independent politicians like Bernie Sanders or third party candidates like Abraham Lincoln would have ever been elected?

Re:Trust-Based Moderation Systems by _heimdall on Sunday December 10, 2023 @01:40PM (#38593705)
Agreed that third parties are possible, though it is still worth noting that a third party win would almost certainly result in an existing party being replaced for a different two party system.

The parties in the US have changed around something like 5 or 6 times. In the last 2 or 3 changes the party names didn't change but the parties did fundamentally change. After each shakeup, we've ended up with a two party system that's structurally unworkable for independents to win at the highest level.

Re:Trust-Based Moderation Systems by actionfromafar on Sunday December 10, 2023 @01:35PM (#38593675)
That's not how nearly all election systems work.

Who wins is often not determined on election day, but in coalition making after the election. If you have 5 - 10 parties, it's often not immediately apparent on election night who can gather a majority behind them.

Re:Trust-Based Moderation Systems by mistermann on Sunday December 10, 2023 @11:14AM (#38592529)
Public consensus on Israel-Palestine ceasefire vs the stance of their "democratically" elected, to enact "the will of the people" politicians also reveals the the theatrical aspect as well, even without adjusting for the massive home field propaganda advantage.

How much longer they can keep this illusion running has got to be THE most interesting thing happening at the moment if you ask me.

Re:Trust-Based Moderation Systems by _heimdall on Sunday December 10, 2023 @01:44PM (#38593751)
To be fair, the UN itself is revealing its own theatrical aspects. What would the ceasefire have done at the end of the day? Would the UN kick Israel out if they continue the war despite a UNSC vote? Would the UN somehow force Israel to stop fighting? Would countries go to war with Israel specifically to uphold the UNSC vote?

When push comes to shove the UN has very little power here and is at risk of going the way of the League of Nations if it pushes too hard without having any meaningful enforcement mechanisms.

Re:Trust-Based Moderation Systems by toast0 on Sunday December 10, 2023 @04:35PM (#38595284)
> Would the UN kick Israel out if they continue the war despite a UNSC vote?

Unlikely. Is there even a process for the UN to kick members out? What good would it do anyway? At most, they get demoted to a non-voting member, but probably the US and UK won't both vote against them in the security council, so do they really need a general assembly vote?

> Would countries go to war with Israel specifically to uphold the UNSC vote?

No, but they might enact a no-fly zone, or do a peace keeping mission with lots of possible rules of engagement.

But the UN is really a means for the powerful countries to justify their extraterritorial actions, when there's enough concensus and the other powers don't care enough to turn away the rubber stamp. It does some other important stuff, but if the UN had significant power in the Israel/Palestine conflict, there's a series of adopted resolutions that could have been de facto enforced.

Re:Trust-Based Moderation Systems by _heimdall on Sunday December 10, 2023 @05:50PM (#38595837)
> No, but they might enact a no-fly zone, or do a peace keeping mission with lots of possible rules of engagement

I'm not sure how that would work here. Given that they are primarily Israeli jets in the air, UN member states would need to be willing to shoot down Israeli jets to enforce the no-fly zone.

> if the UN had significant power in the Israel/Palestine conflict, there's a series of adopted resolutions that could have been de facto enforced

Now you got me curious. What are those existing resolutions they could reach for? Is it mainly just enforcement related to economic sanctions and similar non-military actions?

Re:Trust-Based Moderation Systems by toast0 on Sunday December 10, 2023 @06:23PM (#38596048)
> I'm not sure how that would work here. Given that they are primarily Israeli jets in the air, UN member states would need to be willing to shoot down Israeli jets to enforce the no-fly zone.

Sure, but enforcing a no-fly zone isn't going to war. And I'm sure they'd shoot down Hamas jets as well, so it's fair.

> What are those existing resolutions they could reach for?

There's a big list of resolutions [1], resolution 54 [2] from the security council in 1948 ordering everyone to desist from further military action is probably technically still in force and applicable.

In the general assembly, you've got resolution 181 [3] which sets a partition plan for Mandatory Palestine of 1947 which didn't happen. And there's many years of annual calls for Israel to withdrawl from the occupied territories, etc, between about 1967 and about 1984. Unfortunately, many of the Wikipedia links to general council resolutions don't currently work, so I'm relying on titles.

Anyway, if the UN orders a partition in 1947, and it hasn't happened by 2023, but they still say oh hey, do this thing... either the UN doesn't have much power or it isn't willing to use it.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resol...

[2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Security_Coun...

[3] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Partition_Pla...

Re:Trust-Based Moderation Systems by mistermann on Sunday December 10, 2023 @01:57PM (#38593856)
> What would the ceasefire have done at the end of the day?

It would better prove out that the UN is also a psychological operation to a non-trivial degree.

> Would the UN kick Israel out if they continue the war despite a UNSC vote?

The US is the military muscle of the UN, and as far as I can tell, Israel largely controls the US, at least with respect to Israel. Who Epstein worked for, and who has has on tape seems like a relevant aspect of this issue, that hasn't gotten much traction even on TikTok.

> When push comes to shove the UN has very little power here...

The UN, or at least the idea of the UN that has been distributed among the minds of people in Western countries, has massive power. Control people's beliefs and you can control the world, and the US and Israel are both masters at that game. For evidence, I present the conversations that take place on social media, including HN.

> ...and is at risk of going the way of the League of Nations if it pushes too hard without having any meaningful enforcement mechanisms.

Dare to dream! I can't think of any "reasonably" likely scenario how that could come about, but maybe I lack imagination.

I do however think the decades long psy op that Israel and the US have had going in this specific region is at serious risk though. However, I do not underestimate the "Public Relations / Journalism / etc" skills of who we're dealing with - I think one well designed "event" could easily put most people right back into their trance.

Re:Trust-Based Moderation Systems by _heimdall on Sunday December 10, 2023 @02:22PM (#38594086)
> Dare to dream! I can't think of any "reasonably" likely scenario how that could come about, but maybe I lack imagination.

Its definitely unlikely in the near future, though it will die eventually and likely will happen quickly. I don't see many ways that happens soon, though depending how serious UN member states actually consider the war in Gaza, they could walk away seeing either how useless the UN is when one state can veto or when it becomes clear that a UN without teeth is only useful during times of peace.

Re:Trust-Based Moderation Systems by actionfromafar on Sunday December 10, 2023 @07:18PM (#38596350)
I think one overlooked aspect of the UN is that it’s a way to gather a lot of diplomacy in one place. A constant mingling opportunity, if you will. As ugly as it is, still seems valuable to me. Therefore I don’t think it will be easily abolished.
Re:Trust-Based Moderation Systems by _heimdall on Sunday December 10, 2023 @08:07PM (#38596603)
Its one of those things with history that I always wonder about. Was a similar sentiment common shortly before the League of Nations fell apart?

I also don't expect the UN to dissolve anytime soon, but I can't really put any reasoning behind that other than it feeling crazy to think the UN could be gone tomorrow or 6 months from now.

Presumably, if enough nations take real issue with Israel's war they could get frustrated enough with political roadblocks and general lack of accountability and enforcement that they decide to walk away. If a few walk it may not take much for it to quietly slip away.