Re:Windows 11 is last in gaming performance tests against 3 ...
by protonboy on Thursday December 07, 2023 @01:01AM
(#38553349)
It's a common misconception that Proton adds any overhead. It's just an alternative implementation. In some aspects it will be faster (and in some other probably slower) because the Linux kernel does things differently from the NT kernel.
I have not run any benchmark but I exclusive use Linux as my gaming platform. I don't play any multiplayer though and I think that's one aspect where Linux is behind. But for single-player stuff it's perfectly fine.
One thing though is that I have to filter out which games I buy by checking on ProtonDB their level of compatibility. But I can play major AAA games just fine.
Re:Windows 11 is last in gaming performance tests against 3 ...
by jraph on Thursday December 07, 2023 @12:57AM
(#38553330)
What added overhead?
There's no emulation, just alternative implementation (kernel, drivers, userspace, including Windows APIs with Wine). I don't play and I haven't looked at the results but it does not surprise me that an alternative implementation can perform better.
Re:Windows 11 is last in gaming performance tests against 3 ...
by dartharva on Thursday December 07, 2023 @01:32AM
(#38553502)
Don't those alternative implementation add a few extra layers of abstraction that must affect performance?
Re:Windows 11 is last in gaming performance tests against 3 ...
by jraph on Thursday December 07, 2023 @02:59AM
(#38553991)
IIUC no, they don't add layers, they replace them. For instance, the Windows APIs are implemented in Windows in DLLs that Wine reimplements.
Caveat for dxvk, as mentioned by iforgotpassword, there's indeed a translation layer there.
Not an expert on the topic.
Re:Windows 11 is last in gaming performance tests against 3 ...
by iforgotpassword on Thursday December 07, 2023 @01:03AM
(#38553362)
Dxvk/vkd3d, although as seen with arc newer cards might actually implement older dx Standards in such a crappy way that software translation to Vulkan is still faster.
Re:Windows 11 is last in gaming performance tests against 3 ...
by RealStickman_ on Friday December 08, 2023 @04:21AM
(#38566977)
Didn't Intel switch to using d9vk on their Arc GPUs because it was faster and less work than fixing DX9 directly?
Re:Windows 11 is last in gaming performance tests against 3 ...
by iforgotpassword on Monday December 11, 2023 @01:36AM
(#38598186)
Yes, and dxvk was actually available for windows before that and people figuring out that even on AMD and Nvidia you can get notable performance boosts in certain games. Intel just did the sane thing of giving up completely since their implementation was never there in the first place, and from what I heard even the hardware not designed with how those older APIs work, which might give them an advantage over the other two.
Re:Windows 11 is last in gaming performance tests against 3 ...
by ParetoOptimal on Thursday December 07, 2023 @01:05AM
(#38553376)
Cyberpunk gets an extra 20 frames on Linux for me versus windows with an nvidia card.
Re:Windows 11 is last in gaming performance tests against 3 ...
by raws on Thursday December 07, 2023 @12:52AM
(#38553302)
Denmark?
Re:Windows 11 is last in gaming performance tests against 3 ...
by robin_reala on Thursday December 07, 2023 @01:47AM
(#38553590)
It’s a Hamlet reference.
Phoronix has also posted a lot of these tests where Linux seemingly performs better than Windows.
I don't have the technical wherewithal to challenge their methodology but it just doesn't seem right that you would add overhead and still outperform Windows on a system barely used by 1% of gamers. It seems like Linux fanatics fantasizing.
I love what Valve have done, thanks to them I am never bored on Linux and never wish I had a windows PC anymore. But something is rotten in the state of denmark.