News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gemini: Google's most capable AI model yet by moffkalast on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @04:02PM (#38549422)
I don't think humans will stay competitive long enough for that to even matter, frankly. It's a no brainer to go for the far cheaper, smarter, and most importantly a few magnitudes faster worker. On the offshoot that we hit some sort of inteligence ceiling and don't get ASI tier models in the next few years then that will definitely do it though.

Companies start going from paying lots of local workers to paying a few select corporations what's essentially a SAAS fee (some are already buying ChatGPT Plus for all employees and reducing headcount) which accumulates all the wealth that would've gone to the workers into the hands of those renting GPU servers. The middle class was in decline already, but this will surely eradicate it.

Re:Gemini: Google's most capable AI model yet by astrange on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @05:39PM (#38550477)
None of this will happen because jobs are based on comparative advantage, and not absolute advantage, which means it doesn't matter if someone else would be better at your job than you are. Because that person (or AI) is doing the job they're best suited to, which is not yours. Other fun second-order effects include Jevon's paradox (which is why inventing ATMs caused more employment for bank tellers, not less.)

I can be very confident about this because it's just about the strongest finding there is in economics. If this wasn't true, it'd be good for your career to stop other people from having children in case they take your job.

Re:Gemini: Google's most capable AI model yet by akoboldfrying on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @09:45PM (#38552207)
>If this wasn't true, it'd be good for your career to stop other people from having children in case they take your job.

Well, in times past, kings have been known to do this.

But more generally, you raise an interesting point. I think your reasoning succeeds at dispelling the often-touted strong form of the claim ("AI can do my job better than I can therefore I will lose my job to AI") but doesn't go all the way to guaranteeing its opposite ("No possible developments in AI could result in my job being threatened"). Job threat level will just continue to depend on a complicated way on everyone's aptitude at every job.

Re:Gemini: Google's most capable AI model yet by astrange on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @10:55PM (#38552653)
Many things could result in your job being threatened. Since I think the kind of AI they're describing would increase employment, I'm equally willing to believe an opposite trend would decrease it.

So that could be productivity decreases, rises in energy prices or interest rates, war, losing industries to other countries…

Re:Gemini: Google's most capable AI model yet by moffkalast on Thursday December 07, 2023 @12:29PM (#38559188)
To quote CGP Grey "There isn’t a rule of economics that says better technology makes more, better jobs for horses. It sounds shockingly dumb to even say that out loud, but swap horses for humans and suddenly people think it sounds about right."

I mean I don't know, maybe you're right and this will Jevons us towards even more demand for AI-assisted jobs but I think only to a point where it's still just AI complementing humans at being better and more efficient at their jobs (like LLMs are doing right now) and not outright replacing them.

As per your example, bank tellers are still here because ATMs can only dispense money and change PINs, they can't do their job but only leave the more complex stuff to be handled by less overworked humans since they don't have to do the menial stuff. Make an ATM that does everything (e.g. online banking) and there's literally nothing a bank teller needs to exist for. Most online banks don't even have offices these days. For now classical brick and mortar banks remain, but for how long I'm not sure, probably only until the next crisis when they all fold by not being competitive since they have to pay for all those tellers and real estate rents. And as per Grey's example, cars did not increase demand for horses/humans, they increased demand for cars/AGI.

Re:Gemini: Google's most capable AI model yet by astrange on Thursday December 07, 2023 @06:42PM (#38563357)
Horses are not labor. You can tell because we don't pay them wages and they don't make any effort to be employed. That makes them capital; when humans are treated that way it's called slavery.

I don't think you should listen to Youtubers about anything, though all I know about that guy is he has bad aesthetic opinions on flag design.

Re:Gemini: Google's most capable AI model yet by moffkalast on Friday December 08, 2023 @03:22AM (#38566598)
Doesn't every capitalist consider humans capital deep down? Who'd come up with a name like "human resources" otherwise lmao.

Besides I don't see the market difference of having to pay to maintain a horse with feed, healthcare, grooming, etc. which likely costs something on a similar order as paying a human's monthly wage that gets used in similar ways. Both come with monthly expenses, generate revenue, eventually retire and die, on paper they should follow the same principle with the exception that you can sell a horse when you want to get rid of it but have to pay severance when doing the same with a person. I doubt that influences the overall lifetime equation much though.

Re:Gemini: Google's most capable AI model yet by astrange on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:16PM (#38572943)
> Doesn't every capitalist consider humans capital deep down?

That's slavery, so only if they're bad at it. (The reason economics is called "the dismal science" is slaveowners got mad at them for saying slavery was bad for the economy.)

> Besides I don't see the market difference of having to pay to maintain a horse with feed, healthcare, grooming, etc. which likely costs something on a similar order as paying a human's monthly wage that gets used in similar ways.

The horse can't negotiate and won't leave you because it gets a competing offer. And it's not up to your what your employee spends their wages on, and their wages aren't set by how much you think they should be spending.

Re:Gemini: Google's most capable AI model yet by nopinsight on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @11:18PM (#38552766)
Comparative advantage assumes that there is capacity limit. The more productive country might not choose to produce widget A because its limited capacity is better used to create widget B. However, if in a few years, there are enough GPUs to satisfy almost all demand for AI labor, there's no need to "outsource" work that AI is better at to humans.

Automation paradox might result in much more demand for AI labor, but not necessarily human labor for the same types of work AI can do. It might indirectly increase demand for human services, like fitness trainer, meditation teacher, acupuncturist, etc. though.

Re:Gemini: Google's most capable AI model yet by spaceman_2020 on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @04:24PM (#38549667)
Well anecdotally, there's been a massive drop in on-campus hiring in India this year. The largest recruiters - the big IT companies (Infosys, TCS, etc.) haven't apparenlty made any hires at all.
Re:Gemini: Google's most capable AI model yet by realharo on Thursday December 07, 2023 @01:10AM (#38553397)
>Companies start going from...

The few companies that will still exist, that is - many of them won't, when their product becomes almost free to replace.