Who knows? Maybe you want to retroactively look at shit peopke received and decide on new crimes.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utah_Data_Center
But since PRISM was exposed ~10 years ago, they have had to resort to using FISA court to scrape data
\s
[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2016/08/1...
So a gov finds that IP address 7.8.9.0 received one of these notifications at 12:34. They then see that 7.8.9.0 is one of ATT’s addresses. They go to ATT and learn that address was used by their customer onionisafruit at 12:34 and the device was 5ms away from tower A.
You have captured the device of some group member, and you want to investigate his associates, but you don't know who they are. So you ask Google and Apple: Make a list of all of the devices that have received a push notification sent by <list of messaging apps> where those devices have received at least 200 notifications within 50ms of a notification received by this device. (You will have to make Google or Apple share the list with the target timings with the other)
That will give you a list of everyone who is in a group chat with your target, regardless of whether or not the messages were deleted or encrypted. Now you tell Apple/Google to give all the data on those accounts. You will probably find enough in their Gmail/location history/browsing history to identify nearly all associated people without ever bothering to look at IP addresses.
This also works if you get into a chat with your target. You send some messages and then have Google/Apple identify their device via timing, then identify all their associates.
Apps notifications can trigger if you enter a "protest zone" for example then gov will know everyone who was there.
I would like to see this interaction…
The most insidious part: "Because the system actually monitors the regions, you don’t need to request always permissions for your app"
No mobile, no identification, obscure any way to uniquely be identified.
> - targeted users(s) following “foo” on X app
It seems "X app" means just any placeholder app (not the new Twitter rebrand), although I might be wrong.
One notable corollary is, the shittier the mobile browser webapp implementation is, the more they want to push people onto their app. See: Facebook, Twitter, Reddit, etc.
Yelp is the gold standard in this regard, blithely pretending that they can't show you any photos (or is it more than a few photos? I avoid yelp on mobile so much I can't recall). It's probably the right move for them, because the photos are 99% of the reason I ever want to use Yelp. Reviews can be outright lies or simply written by people ~~with no taste~~ whose tastes are not simpatico with mine, but photos don't lie*.
* well, nowadays I guess they can
The location is always the same.
Seems like this is what is being implied:
Given:
- users with notifications enabled
- have X app installed
- targeted user(s) reside in USA
- targeted users(s) following “foo” on X app
When:
- issue FISA warrant for all smartphone users that received notifications in regards to “foo” user
Then:
- able to pull all Apple/Google accounts that match this criteria
- able to get real addresses and names
- can crosscheck names with other details to narrow down suspect
Or maybe it’s something even worse where notifications somehow leak location data