News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Firefox on the Brink? by hs86 on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @09:50AM (#38531533)
I switched over after the Manifest v3 debacle, and after a couple of months, I wonder if the implications of using a browser with a lower market share are overblown.

I haven't encountered any site that misbehaves, and the only missing feature so far is within the Google Drive web app because it uses a Chrome-only extension [1].

Maybe the ongoing standardization of the web shows its effects here, and using a standard-conform niche browser is not that bad anymore.

[1] https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/application-launch...

Re:Firefox on the Brink? by preinheimer on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @01:37PM (#38535077)
Specific problems I've had as a firefox user:

- I can't pay municipal license fees (Site says "Use Chrome")

- I can't use the Vendor management portal for $largePopularTechCompany type company for my small business ("We support Chrome")

- Xero my small business accounting software just doesn't work properly ("Use Chrome")

Re:Firefox on the Brink? by hsbauauvhabzb on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @03:56PM (#38536794)
Some Xero products don’t work properly no matter what your browser is.

For me, Mozilla has bugs or weaknesses in Linux. YouTube chews my cpu (hardware acceleration is broken, at least for me). Tabs ‘freeze’ due to a bug in an X11 lib. Pop up bubbles (do you want to enable gps to this site type bubbles) if visible before switching workspaces appear on all workspaces but cannot be actioned and appear on top.

Mozilla as a company appears to be attempting poor monetisation models like attempting to build social networks etc. I would consider paying them a yearly fee if I thought they’d use money wisely, but at the moment executive appear more interested in vanity projects.

Re:Firefox on the Brink? by pbronez on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @02:14PM (#38548243)
Maybe somebody should fork Firefox and start over with new stewardship.
Re:Firefox on the Brink? by dvngnt_ on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @01:41PM (#38535136)
i assume this is just a user-agent check though i don't expect regular users to know how to switch.
Re:Firefox on the Brink? by zamadatix on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @02:50PM (#38536030)
This is also a double edge sword in that if it's just a user-agent check the site tends to lack a well coded fallback for any functionality that is actually not supported and the page can silently break during usage. Not necessarily a problem for those that already know how to switch, but even just installing an extension for other people doesn't mean the sites are suddenly actually compatible. Sometimes even big sites like Microsoft Teams have this kind of problem for years at a time.
Re:Firefox on the Brink? by amanzi on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @01:42PM (#38535152)
I've used Xero for years with Firefox without issues.
Re:Firefox on the Brink? by crabmusket on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @03:05PM (#38536232)
Same here, though I only use a small subset of Xero features.
Re:Firefox on the Brink? by neltnerb on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @01:52PM (#38535275)
Maybe you can share your configuration? I wonder if you are lucky or they are unlucky.
Re:Firefox on the Brink? by amanzi on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @02:35PM (#38535825)
I run Firefox with uBlock Origin enabled and set the Firefox enhanced privacy settings to the strictest settings. I haven't done anything special to get Xero working - never had any issues.
Re:Firefox on the Brink? by neftaly on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @08:57PM (#38539613)
Are you using Firefox ESR? It usually has worse support then the regular releases.
Re:Firefox on the Brink? by amanzi on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @03:30PM (#38549067)
Nope - the regular version.
Re:Firefox on the Brink? by neltnerb on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @01:45PM (#38535200)
I have had several sites refuse to work properly (American Airlines maybe? It was some airline) with every single add-in disabled and with every security feature I could find disabled.

I am with you that it's super rare, I have only had to open chrome due to it being that bad a few times, usually I just need to disable javascript blocking or enable more cookies. But there are legitimately sites that are just so badly written that they won't take your money if you use Firefox.

I guess Google meet has frozen video for me on Firefox, but I expect Google to intentionally break their website for people not using Chrome after the "DRM Website" thing struck them as a great idea. Using Google products at this point is just asking for more lockin when we should really all know better. At least Zoom is a different company from Google...

But overblown for sure, if I disable javascript blocking and cookie autodelete and temporary containers that keep the site from realizing I already logged in -- pretty reasonable issues -- 99.99% of the issues I have vanish.

Re:Firefox on the Brink? by nightpool on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @02:55PM (#38536121)
I just bought tickets on AA a few months ago with Firefox and didn't have any issues
Re:Firefox on the Brink? by nophunphil on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @05:32PM (#38537849)
Echoing this. Just bought AA tickets through the airline’s website yesterday using FF and it worked.
Re:Firefox on the Brink? by neltnerb on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @07:54PM (#38539137)
It was selecting seats that was too broken to continue, though I mean, I already "worked around" the issue. I tried until it was less work to redo all the manual data entry in Chromium, I usually try pretty hard to avoid using it.

I don't doubt that it works for a bunch of people, others have stated things that don't work and had others say they do work, so something is up. Maybe we're using different versions or operating systems or installation dates with old configuration data.

Re:Firefox on the Brink? by Emanation on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @09:00AM (#38543965)
That was broken for me in their phone app in July
Re:Firefox on the Brink? by mmcgaha on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @02:11PM (#38535521)
I have been using FF as my primary browser for a few years now. I have not found any site that does not work but sometimes I have to turn off uBlock Origin.
Re:Firefox on the Brink? by rozap on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @02:36PM (#38535836)
I agree it seems overblown. I haven't encountered a site that doesn't work. Even google meet and zoom's web client work great.

Not sure what all the fuss is about. It's a great browser. Chrome got very, very aggravating and I've had no problems since switching maybe 4 years ago. Even FF mobile works well.

Re:Firefox on the Brink? by shiroiuma on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @02:41AM (#38541366)
One problem I have is that screen-sharing doesn't work in Messenger video chat. I have to switch to Chromium for that to work, so I have to remember to start the chat in Chromium instead of FF where I have a Messenger tab pinned.
Re:Firefox on the Brink? by aboodman on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @02:56PM (#38536126)
Speaking as a library developer, Firefox is expensive for us to support in https://replicache.dev and https://reflect.net due to lots of long-open bugs, particularly in the storage system. Firefox also generally has the slowest performance which affects us.

I'm not bagging on the team, it's frankly amazing they've been able to mostly keep up, it's just a fact that maintaining a competitive web browser is a gargantuan task that requires a large team and investment.

Re:Firefox on the Brink? by asdff on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @03:01PM (#38536194)
When people say firefox is more performant than other browsers, they mean to say you can use actual powerful adblockers like ublock origin that then make it a totally rigged race against other browsers in terms of real world performance.
Re:Firefox on the Brink? by usr1106 on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @05:28PM (#38537803)
Which is a good thing. Running ads is triple pollution. On the servers, on the browser, and by the manipulated comsumers buying crap they don't need in the first place.

(Yes, I do pay for content I care about.)

Re:Firefox on the Brink? by int_19h on Thursday December 07, 2023 @01:40PM (#38560035)
I think there's a strong argument to be made here that governments should be actively subsidizing (if not directly managing) some implementation of the web standards that is guaranteed to actually be fully conforming to them, accessible etc. The web stack is such a fundamental part of our infrastructure these days that it feels irresponsible to leave it entirely to the whims of the private market - especially one that is dominated by large oligopolies which said governments are already actively investigating.
Re:Firefox on the Brink? by spacechild1 on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @04:08PM (#38536922)
Same for me! I have been always using Firefox as my main browser for at least 15 years and never had any problems. Actually, I don't really understand why so many tech-savvy people continue to use Chrome... Just switch to Firefox, for foxs sake!
Re:Firefox on the Brink? by aendruk on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @06:37PM (#38538479)
Over the last year or so various websites have mysteriously walled me off with 403s and 5xxs only when I use Firefox. I suspect that merely using a less popular browser is tripping some attempted security measure.
Re:Firefox on the Brink? by int_19h on Thursday December 07, 2023 @01:36PM (#38559995)
Part of it is that there are some genuine technical advantages to be had from Blink-based browsers. Most notably, tab process isolation: one tab crashing (and they do crash) generally doesn't bring the whole process down.

There's also UX. Right now I can have proper vertical tabs in Edge by changing a single prominent option in settings, but Firefox is still dragging their feet (yes, I know there are extensions for this, but they add a vertical tab bar in addition to the standard horizontal one, because you can't hide the latter without hacks).

OTOH Firefox has containers, which is arguably a lot more important if you care about online privacy in any serious way. But people don't like to trade away their convenience, especially once they already got used to it.

What we desperately need is a browser based around Firefox implementation of web standards and with all the privacy bells and whistles, but also UI that doesn't constantly tell users that they are "holding it wrong".

Re:Firefox on the Brink? by spacechild1 on Sunday December 10, 2023 @04:14PM (#38595121)
> Most notably, tab process isolation: one tab crashing (and they do crash) generally doesn't bring the whole process down.

Firefox has been doing this for several years now...

Re:Firefox on the Brink? by matteoraso on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @04:35PM (#38537238)
Agreed. Even if Firefox makes up a small part of the market share, any website that serves millions of people will want to support it. Imagine if you have a website with 1,000,000 monthly visitors, and 2% of them use Firefox. Dropping support will mean 20,000 less monthly visitors. This gives us an idea of how much you should spend on support. If you make an average of $0.10 a month per user, you should be okay with spending at least $2000 a month on Firefox. That's a pretty big budget, and it's reasonable to go much higher than that if your website is rapidly growing. The big players like Google and Facebook will also be comfortable supporting Firefox at a loss, since you don't want to bleed users and create market space for a competitor. At most, you lose a few small websites that you probably weren't going to visit anyways.
Re:Firefox on the Brink? by parineum on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @05:19PM (#38537719)
> Imagine if you have a website with 1,000,000 monthly visitors, and 2% of them use Firefox. Dropping support will mean 20,000 less monthly visitors.

It will always be 2% which will always be, at maximum, 2% more revenue. That's probably negligible if you have to support them and there's an opportunity cost to that money. You'd probably be better off spending that money on advertising than Firefox support, especially since Firefox users typically know when a page isn't working, it's probably them and they have a backup solution available.

I used Firefox for a long time but switched because I just got tired of switching all the time and I started regularly using a site that didn't work in Firefox (I don't remember now but I think it was my credit card).

Re:Firefox on the Brink? by riversflow on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @05:30PM (#38537828)
> they have a backup solution available.

Im a decade+ daily driver of Firefox. If a website doesnt support it, I make a mental note that I hate this company now, close the tab, and move on. I don't open it in a V8 browser, i look for an alternative.

Re:Firefox on the Brink? by parineum on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @10:45AM (#38545364)
I was exactly the same way, even to the point of doing the same thing if adblock or privacy extensions broke the site, but there are sites where you can't just move on where you really just have to use another browser.

I've gone back and forth between chrome and firefox for the what has to be close to 20 years. I want to use Firefox but ever since Chrome came out and blew it out of the water with javascript performance, it's always felt a bit clunky even as they've made their own performance improvements. I suspect my future lies with a chromium based browser eventually.

Re:Firefox on the Brink? by berkes on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @02:20AM (#38541265)
> At most, you lose a few small websites that you probably weren't going to visit anyways.

I think this is wrong. It starts with a website to look up train departures that no longer works on Ff. Then the site to buy movie or concert tickets fails on FF. Booking a restaurant, again, requires you to take out chrome.

Which has two concequences. People stop using FF all together because switching all the time is work. And people ensure they always have a copy of chrome around, while fewer and fewer need to keep a copy of FF around.

And so FF spirals exponentially into insignificance.

Re:Firefox on the Brink? by mtVessel on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @04:57PM (#38537505)
Not sure how so many in the thread are using FF problem-free? In the past few years I've encountered more and more sites that don't work properly with FF. Most of the issues are around modals that won't dismiss or even display at all. Other issues I can't identify, but the site becomes unresponsive or some content won't load. I think the Ticketmaster ticket selection page was the last one I couldn't use at all with FF. My cable company's site became Chromium only sometime this year and it still is.

Sometimes the cause is uBlock Origin, so I always try turning it off and refreshing. Rarely it's due to enhanced tracking protection. A few times I restarted FF in safe mode to rule out add-ins. It's always just FF.

Re:Firefox on the Brink? by ImaCake on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @05:30PM (#38537824)
I had some issues with several sites around 2-3 years ago but I haven’t been experiencing them recently.

I guess FF has issues on a fairly small set of sites which some users use a fair bit while most users don’t see those sites at all.

The only site I use regularly which has issues is google earth and the reason why is obvious.

Re:Firefox on the Brink? by alextingle on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @05:38PM (#38537910)
Another FF user here. Very, very few issues.

I had a problem with a shopping web-site the other day. I disabled uBlock origin, and then all extensions, but it still refused to work. I thought I'd finally found one of these mythical "Chrome-only" sites, but no - exactly the same broken site in Chrome, so the site was just totally broken. Nothing to do with FF.

Re:Firefox on the Brink? by 8bitsrule on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @01:05AM (#38540890)
Same here. I used to have more FF problems with .gov sites but in the past 2-3 years, rarely. Now & then I have to manipulate NoScript or uBlock to get some feature working on most sites.

But most of the time, I'd rather ignore those sites anyway. After I have a look at them ... which I tend to do after NoScript show me the huge list of crap they expect me to load just for the 'privilege'. Good developers/orgs just don't do that. Most go into a 'Block list' I mostly use to remind myself not to bother trying. I take my business elsewhere.

Re:Firefox on the Brink? by Ikatza on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @05:07PM (#38537607)
For one, HN misbehaves pretty badly on mobile.
Re:Firefox on the Brink? by zizee on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @05:25PM (#38537776)
It does? In what way? I have used Firefox mobile for years on HN without noticing issues. What am I missing?

Edit: I used Firefox on Android, the issues you describe might be Firefox on iOS, which is a different beast.

Re:Firefox on the Brink? by cjpearson on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @06:04PM (#38538178)
In my experience there are almost never issues. Standardization has gotten much better, and as a web developer I appreciate all the effort the various browser teams have put into ensuring common behavior.

The effort of "supporting Firefox" as a developer is basically opening the app in Firefox and confirming that it works, which it basically always does because the app is built on standardized web features. (Other types of support might be different. e.g maybe you have help doc that tells your users how to clear the site cookies. Do you also want to write instructions for Firefox, Safari, Opera etc?)

The bigger concern is that some day Google might not need web standards. If developers target Chrome rather than the web platform, Google has free reign and no longer needs to compromise with Apple and Mozilla. For example, Mozilla's veto of the controversial Topics API would hold little weight if nobody cares about Firefox support. If Chrome gets to a dominant enough position it could move from embracing to extending quite quickly.

People have different opinions on Google, but even those who believe Google has no ill intentions still feel better if there are some checks and balances. Were Firefox to become obsolete, Apple would be the last one standing. And with the DMA, some are predicting that Safari could soon follow Firefox's decline.

Re:Firefox on the Brink? by int_19h on Thursday December 07, 2023 @01:30PM (#38559919)
The concern is that the standardization process for the web stack these days consists mostly of the big guys (Google especially) throwing out a draft standard, which then slowly undergoes standardization process even as it is already getting used on the web because devs like new & shiny and/or because the added features genuinely do make something simpler. There aren't that many sites that actively break on Firefox because of this, and when they do, it's usually a temporary thing until they catch up, but as you rightly note, this is largely because devs are still forced to contend with users of other browsers. And the more popular Chrome is, the less of a forcing function that becomes, and the more whatever "draft standard" proposals are in Blink become the de facto standard.
Re:Firefox on the Brink? by ryukoposting on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @10:24PM (#38540175)
A handful of Google services are buggy and slow in FireFox. Stackdriver in particular is an absolute shambles. Thankfully I'm an embedded guy so most of the stuff in Stackdriver is hieroglyphics to me anyway.

I can't prove that Google is doing that intentionally, but I wouldn't put it past them.

Re:Firefox on the Brink? by SkyPuncher on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @08:01AM (#38543253)
Outside of some subtle pixel variations, I know of a single bug in our product that is browser specific. Even then, it’s kind of our fault.
Re:Firefox on the Brink? by MrMember on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @03:25PM (#38549015)
I've been using Firefox as my primary browser since 2005-2006ish. A site misbehaving because of it is a rare enough occurrence that offhand I can't remember any time that it has happened.

One issue I do come across occasionally, and I'm not sure if it's Firefox alone or the combination of add-ons I use in Firefox, is sites being overzealous with captchas. I find myself doing 3-5 captchas occasionally just to use a site.

Re:Firefox on the Brink? by hoherd on Thursday December 07, 2023 @10:01AM (#38557102)
webusb is another missing feature, and AFAIK Mozilla has a strong stance against enabling it because of the security implications. This is one of the only reasons I keep a chrome-ish browser installed.