News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sellafield: 'bottomless pit of hell, money and despair' by mschuster91 on Monday December 04, 2023 @12:54PM (#38520511)
The most astonishing part about it is just how many pro-nuclear people here or on Twitter and Reddit ignore the fiscal risks associated with nuclear - not just the obvious aspects of worst-case liabilities or long-term secure storage, but also stuff like this.
Re:Sellafield: 'bottomless pit of hell, money and despair' by snakeyjake on Monday December 04, 2023 @01:19PM (#38520862)
The extreme cost of Sellafield is due to waste and accidents from the UK's nuclear weapons program, not its commercial power generation program.

The vast, overwhelming, majority of waste was created by processing nuclear fuel into plutonium (and other radioactive elements) for bombs. The UK was under enormous pressure in the 50s and 60s to keep up with both the US and USSR so they cut tons of corners to have a domestic bomb.

The article "for some reason" conflates the two: the waste from their nuclear weapons research and development and (extremely minimal) environmental impact of commercial power generation.

Re:Sellafield: 'bottomless pit of hell, money and despair' by teamonkey on Monday December 04, 2023 @03:52PM (#38522872)
And next time we know it will definitely be different. There won’t be any ulterior motives, there won’t be any corners cut or compromises due to cost. We can totally make nuclear generators that don’t have any value to the defense industry - we won’t even take any of their money to build them this time. We’ll make stronger standards and put in political safeguards so the cleanup problem can’t be kicked down the road to future governments. We’ve learned from experience so this can never happen again.
Re:Sellafield: 'bottomless pit of hell, money and despair' by vlovich123 on Monday December 04, 2023 @04:03PM (#38523013)
Nice shifting of goal posts. First it was cost now it’s that defense industry has an interest in commercial power generation. Like maybe. But also countries have no problem creating nukes without commercial reactors so maybe that doesn’t matter so much? There are also reactor designs that result in fuel that can’t be reprocessed into plutonium / weaponry. Not sure the state of that research / if it’s even worth bothering to do so because generating plutonium isn’t that hard in the grand scheme of things and if the defense industry wants to do it they’ll build a reactor anyway, it’ll just maybe cost more. Not to mention that the US has all sorts of nuclear reactors already and they don’t need to rely on commercial ones so much.
Re:Sellafield: 'bottomless pit of hell, money and despair' by snakeyjake on Monday December 04, 2023 @04:59PM (#38523745)
> We’ve learned from experience so this can never happen again.

Yes.

That statement is correct.

Literally, actually, and factually the techniques and technologies used in the 1940s and 1950s that led to the Windscale fire at Sellafield, which is the root of most of the cost are gone. Dead.

The bulk of the cost are the remains of the Windscale Piles (1950/1951) and the Legacy Ponds (1960). Little that people did 70 years ago when it comes to nuclear waste storage and disposal is acceptable or legal today.

What you yourself wrote is true.

Re:Sellafield: 'bottomless pit of hell, money and despair' by trebligdivad on Monday December 04, 2023 @01:26PM (#38520985)
I think to be fair some of it was also due to stuff done in the early days of figuring commercial power out; but that was a long time ago. Sellafield has taught a lot of people what's needed to do it properly.
Re:Sellafield: 'bottomless pit of hell, money and despair' by u320 on Monday December 04, 2023 @02:17PM (#38521740)
Even that was using technology which haven't seen much use outside the UK. They were never truly commercial, supporting the nuclear weapons program was a requirement from day 1 and was the reason for some design choices that was suboptimal for power generation.
Re:Sellafield: 'bottomless pit of hell, money and despair' by whatshisface on Monday December 04, 2023 @02:07PM (#38521598)
Why did the UK want to keep up with the US?
Re:Sellafield: 'bottomless pit of hell, money and despair' by saulrh on Monday December 04, 2023 @02:11PM (#38521657)
Because if you try to depend on the US's nuclear umbrella you end up like Ukraine.
Re:Sellafield: 'bottomless pit of hell, money and despair' by avar on Monday December 04, 2023 @02:40PM (#38522067)
No, the UK was in NATO, and if it didn't develop its own nuclear weapons in could have easily convinced the Americans to give them nukes for deterrence purposes, as the Netherlands, Belgium, Italy etc. did.

The real reason is that the UK (and France) wanted and still want a seat an the big boy's table. I.e. the UN security council etc.

Re:Sellafield: 'bottomless pit of hell, money and despair' by andylynch on Monday December 04, 2023 @03:46PM (#38522806)
Not that easily! The UK felt compelled to (re)build its own, independent nuclear capability after WWII when the Americans cut off technology sharing from the Manhattan Project.

This was especially annoying from an ally which had learned much of the foundation essential to the endeavour from British Tube Alloys research.

France saw this happen and drew a very similar conclusion.

Re:Sellafield: 'bottomless pit of hell, money and despair' by jopsen on Monday December 04, 2023 @03:32PM (#38522643)
> No, the UK was in NATO, and if it didn't develop its own nuclear weapons...

Maybe, maybe not? Until tested it's hard to know if a nuclear umbrella is more than bluff.

That said, with US indifference from 1939 fresh in the memory I can see how they wanted the bomb.

Nuclear bombs from the US were always under US control, even if positioned outside the US.

Re:Sellafield: 'bottomless pit of hell, money and despair' by avar on Monday December 04, 2023 @04:10PM (#38523099)
> Nuclear bombs from the US were always under US control, even if positioned outside the US.

They really weren't, the nominal US control over them was always a figleaf to appease the requirements of Congress.

If you look into the history of US nuclear sharing you'll find that what these NATO countries wanted was independent nuclear capabilities in the event of an emergency. That's what they got in every way except formally on paper.

A relevant excerpt from "Command and Control" by Eric Schlosser:

> [...] Congressman Chet Holifield, the chairman of the joint committee, was amazed to find three ballistic missiles, carrying thermonuclear weapons, in the custody of a single American officer with a handgun. “All [the Italians] have to do is hit him on the head with a blackjack, and they have got his key,” Holifield said, during a closed-door committee hearing after the trip. The Jupiters were located near a forest, without any protective covering, and brightly illuminated at night. They would be sitting ducks for a sniper. “There were three Jupiters setting there in the open—all pointed toward the sky,” Holifield told the committee. “Over $300 million has been spent to set up that little show and it can be knocked out with 3 rifle bullets.” Foreign personnel weren’t supposed to enter the nuclear weapon igloos at NATO bases. But little had been done to stop them. A lone American soldier manned the entrance to the igloos, serving as a custodian of the weapons, not as an armed guard. Once again, security was provided by troops from the host nation, who also moved weapons in and out of the storage facilities. Senator Albert A. Gore, Sr., could hardly believe the arrangement: “Non-Americans with non-American vehicles are transporting nuclear weapons from place to place in foreign countries.”

Re:Sellafield: 'bottomless pit of hell, money and despair' by sgift on Monday December 04, 2023 @03:55PM (#38522901)
Maybe, probably not. Directly after WW2 the policy in the US was to keep the bomb and related technology secret at all costs. Only after UK, France and the Soviet Union showed that the cat was out of the bag the US changed their position to supporting other countries with things like the nuclear umbrella or the "Atoms for Peace" program in an effort to stop proliferation.
Re:Sellafield: 'bottomless pit of hell, money and despair' by Gare on Monday December 04, 2023 @01:06PM (#38520684)
Isn't Sellafield mostly a consequence of rushing to acquire the atomic and hydrogen bomb as quickly as possible? Akin to Hanaford site in the USA.
Re:Sellafield: 'bottomless pit of hell, money and despair' by brightsize on Monday December 04, 2023 @03:25PM (#38522551)
*Hanford.
Re:Sellafield: 'bottomless pit of hell, money and despair' by NikkiA on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @05:49AM (#38529279)
Not really, no.

The Butex process ran at sellafield from 1951 to 1964, only the period of 1951 to 1958 was producing material for the UK nuclear weapons program, after the successful hydrogen bomb tests the UK signed an agreement to a) use US nuclear warheads in UK bombs/missiles, and b) provide the US with plutonium from sellfield in return.

The Purex process, which ran from 1964 til last year at the Magnox plant, and til 2018 at the THORP plant for AGR reprocessing, was the reprocessing process that replaced it, and only ever provided nuclear material to the US*, the UK never used it domestically.

* I'm not 100% sure on this, since several EU nations used Sellafield/THORP to process their waste, I would imagine France at least wanted their plutonium for their own nuclear weapons back, but I don't know to what extent France used sellafield vs their own reprocessing facility in Marcoule

Re:Sellafield: 'bottomless pit of hell, money and despair' by digging on Monday December 04, 2023 @01:03PM (#38520648)
I don't think that's fair. Anti-nuclear comments also widely ignore the fiscal risks and focus on the obvious issues. Most people probably don't know about the financial issues.
Re:Sellafield: 'bottomless pit of hell, money and despair' by cycomanic on Monday December 04, 2023 @01:10PM (#38520726)
I think that's not entirely true. Much of the discussion about nuclear has shifted away from the usual talking points and shifted towards costs.

The primary argument against nuclear made here on HN is cost.

Re:Sellafield: 'bottomless pit of hell, money and despair' by mschuster91 on Monday December 04, 2023 @04:48PM (#38523612)
> The primary argument against nuclear made here on HN is cost.

Because it's the easiest one to make, and most importantly, the easiest one to prove. Talking about cancer rates and whatnot, there's many a way to debate oneself to death about which study has greater trustability... but no way around the numbers: dealing with the waste is expensive, acquiring the fuel is expensive (and incredibly damaging to the environment), constructing NPPs is expensive and a multi-decade project, operating them is expensive, insuring them is expensive (or one runs the Soviet Russia model and has the government/tax payer as the insurance of last resort), keeping them and the fuel secure is expensive (which is an issue with the much-hyped small reactors - a prime target for any terrorist looking for some material for a dirty bomb), and taking them apart is expensive.

Nuclear power is only so "cheap" because of the extremely long life of a NPP and because a lot of the mentioned expensive parts has been externalized or not properly accounted for at all.

Re:Sellafield: 'bottomless pit of hell, money and despair' by hgomersall on Monday December 04, 2023 @02:19PM (#38521769)
The "financial" issues in this context is just a placeholder for "shit loads of resources". As always with spending at the state level, the billions needed are just representative of the opportunity cost.
Re:Sellafield: 'bottomless pit of hell, money and despair' by whywhywhywhy on Monday December 04, 2023 @02:36PM (#38522014)
Maybe we know the full story.

Sad to see this sort of alarmist “journalism” from a publication that aligns with green energy.