News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by jcheng on Monday December 04, 2023 @12:30PM (#38520185)
Not sure why I decided to spend so much time on this on a Monday morning but I've read to page 35, and the picture is much more muddled.

It looks like the FB Archive project gains momentum and launches but Dr. Donovan and the TASC get sidelined along the way (which understandably is very upsetting, you can feel the pain on every page). It does seem clear that the Dean doesn't approve of Dr. Donovan/TASC and he eventually shuts the group down, but if he allows the Facebook project to move forward under other groups that are also within the Kennedy school, then the title of this post is pretty misleading. (Oh, maybe why the actual article title says "initial team" instead of just "team".)

BTW, not a particular fan of Meta, no feelings about Harvard/Kennedy school, never heard of any of these people before except Frances Haugen and Dr. Latanya Sweeney.

Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by macksd on Monday December 04, 2023 @12:54PM (#38520517)
I think sidelining the lead researcher and giving the project to another group is accurately described at "gutting a team". No, they didn't end the project, but the series of events described seems to be insinuating that she could have led the project if she was willing to have her work funded by Facebook, listen to one of their former people, etc. So if that was their goal, and they just got someone else to do the work, is that any better?
Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by tensor on Monday December 04, 2023 @03:29PM (#38522605)
That's not quite what I imagine when I hear the term "gutting a team." Gutting a team is when then very significantly reduce its size and priority. Simply switching leadership of a project isn't gutting a team, it's normal university politics and infighting.

If they are forcing funding by Facebook/Meta, then that does seem like a conflict of interest, but is a quite a different headline.

Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by rrobukef on Monday December 04, 2023 @04:17PM (#38523215)
The sidelining is to show damages to her reputation etc. Page 50 or so starts the description alleging how the administration and the dean gutted her department by blocking, reallocating funds, stopping hiring, and refusing to extend contracts when funds are available.
Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by ImPostingOnHN on Monday December 04, 2023 @04:46PM (#38523580)
From what I gathered, they didn't simply switch leadership, they removed it entirely, along with the person doing the most work, replacing them with nothing, which effectively shut down the project.

Is there someone continuing it that I missed?

Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by jcheng on Monday December 04, 2023 @08:20PM (#38525783)
According to the complaint, "the project" was FB Archive, which Dr. Donovan came up with the idea for and was the only person in the room with the actual source material. The Public Interest Tech Lab was the organization actually tasked with building out FB Archive, which they did, and it shipped: https://fbarchive.org

I think Dr. Donovan's complaint is not that it didn't happen, so much as she was not allowed to play a larger role in it despite having the desire, the people, the funding, and the right--as the person who came up with the idea and the person who provided the material, without which there would be no project. (And then worse, history rewritten to exclude her contributions)

Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by ImPostingOnHN on Monday December 04, 2023 @11:48PM (#38527225)
Who exactly did the university get to replace the lead researcher they dismissed*?

Who remains at the university doing the research halted by the dismissal* of the lead researcher?

* – whether overtly or via constructive dismissal

Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by boringg on Monday December 04, 2023 @04:00PM (#38522964)
FWIW that's definitely not gutting a team. Swapping out leaders makes a big impact but it isn't gutting a team. It could lead to the same outcome.
Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by zbyte64 on Monday December 04, 2023 @05:13PM (#38523905)
Imagine swapping out leaders and expecting the same outcomes. Why even bother?
Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by ajb on Monday December 04, 2023 @05:53PM (#38524320)
An academic team isn't the same as a team in a company though, right? My understanding (which could be incorrect) is that a PI is almost like the CEO of a startup which happens to have the goal of doing research, and operates in the context of a university. A PI is not like a team lead in a company . Each PI-led team is doing research independently of the rest of the department. I have the impression it's not even expected to outlive the PI's employment there.
Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by omginternets on Monday December 04, 2023 @09:37PM (#38526370)
In academia, it very much is the same thing.
Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by cbsmith on Monday December 04, 2023 @02:03PM (#38521540)
Fair, but it raises the question of the motives behind it. It would seem they didn't necessarily have a problem with the research, but rather with the lead researcher. There's complicated issues of academic freedom to parse here, but in principle, if you aren't happy with the work someone is doing, it's not entirely unreasonable that you'd let them go and have someone else pick up the work.
Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by cortesoft on Monday December 04, 2023 @02:20PM (#38521788)
> It would seem they didn't necessarily have a problem with the research, but rather with the lead researcher

This is the entire crux of the issue; do they have a problem with the lead researcher because she isn't good at her job or because she is finding things that their large donor doesn't like?

Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by cbsmith on Monday December 04, 2023 @02:37PM (#38522032)
Exactly. It's easy to presume one interpretation, but it's far from clear.
Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by ImPostingOnHN on Monday December 04, 2023 @02:45PM (#38522132)
Exactly. The evidence* points to the act being corrupt, but the university is free to attempt to convince people otherwise.

* - The researcher being removed without any good cause evident

Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by gcr on Monday December 04, 2023 @10:55PM (#38526926)
Universities don't work that way. There's generally very little oversight over the PI of projects. The university generally wants more projects leading to more publications and grants, not less. Administrators understand that removing a PI generally means abandoning their lab's projects, so it usually doesn't happen.
Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by cbsmith on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @05:59PM (#38538137)
Usually being the operative word.
Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by cporios on Monday December 04, 2023 @01:15PM (#38520799)
Noting that the project and all its documents are publicly accessible to anyone at https://fbarchive.org/.
Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by mjhay on Monday December 04, 2023 @01:29PM (#38521029)
But further work from the same leadership has been discontinued...
Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by stillwithit on Monday December 04, 2023 @03:24PM (#38522541)
Ousted propaganda researcher duped by American propaganda of free speech, and dreams and stuff.

The smarties are just meat suits angling for clout relative to ye olde social memeology. They’re smart because their propaganda says so.

Cheerio, pish posh, my fellow Harvard propagandist. The high minded propaganda is for the outside world! Inside it’s plain old payola.

Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by doctorpangloss on Monday December 04, 2023 @02:09PM (#38521621)
Going out and getting Washington Post, New York Times articles about your issues through "Whistleblower Aid" - it brings to mind Barack Obama's great line:

    When some activists at that meeting said they felt that their voices were not being heard, Mr. Obama replied, "You are sitting in the Oval Office, talking to the president of the United States."
https://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/24/us/obama-says-movements-l...

I don't work in PR, the issues I am politically active over are very local. This researcher paints a big target on her back, in an issue as amply documented as an academic firing, it isn't surprising that things are not cut and dried.

Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by didibus on Monday December 04, 2023 @11:31PM (#38527112)
To be honest, there's a difference between having your issues entertained, versus taken seriously. The former is often done as political theater.
Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by Beldin on Monday December 04, 2023 @01:39PM (#38521175)
> but if he allows the Facebook project to move forward under other groups that are also within the Kennedy school,

Move forward in the direction the dean and Facebook want, or in the direction the original team wanted to explore?

Because it doesn't seem - at all - that the two are equivalent. And it is not misleading to call out replacing a non-bribe-able PI with a susceptible or even already bribed one.

Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by jcheng on Monday December 04, 2023 @03:28PM (#38522594)
I was not nearly clear or explicit enough in my comment, apologies for that. In sections 25 and 26 (page 14), the whistleblower report talks about the origins of the project. Dr. Donovan acquired the entire archive of the Facebook Files, and reached out to Dr. Latanya Sweeney, who she calls her "most trusted colleague":

> I chose to work with Dr. Sweeney because she was the shoulder I leaned on when I needed to decode the politics of HKS. I regard Dr. Sweeney to be brilliant at computer science, the foremost authority on privacy in technology, and had a vision to build the FB Archive on the base of a data sharing platform that she had designed previously.

Donovan's vision was to build "a searchable archive of these documents for the public interest" and hold training workshops for other researchers. So Dr. Sweeney's lab built it, as was the plan; and held training workshops, which was a little hurtful to Donovan as she was not invited into that process.

After the fact, Sweeney summed up her view of their respective contributions in a private email to Donovan:

> The technological IP (design, architecture, and implementation) in FBarchive belongs to the Lab [i.e. Sweeney] alone. No one can claim IP over the original content of course, but the Lab also has IP in the redaction strategy used. Your team contributed the citation reference used to identify each image and document, and of course, you were part of the original concept. This is the kind of details that we will document on the history page.

And implies, like it's not even worth asserting directly, that TASC's contributions are historical, not current. A couple of responses later, Donovan says:

> TASC made many contributions including getting the documents and categorizing them, as well as promoting the archive in public forums, and having my team write testimonies and 1pagers, reviewing abstracts and holding office hours with students and so many meetings.

Dr. Donovan's complaints with the project as delivered seem to mostly NOT be that she wanted it to be different than it was, but rather, that the history page contains blatant lies that minimize Dr. Donovan and TASC's contributions. And also that it is incredibly unjust that she brought this highly valuable asset to the table, and without cause was not only shut out, but basically fired, and her historical contributions scrubbed. (Section 42.)

(To be clear, this is a sad and frustrating tale and if I was Donovan I'd be pissed too.)

Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by ImPostingOnHN on Monday December 04, 2023 @12:46PM (#38520391)
> Dr. Donovan and the TASC get sidelined along the way

this is described dismissively and in the passive voice, but it's an active action, and quite damning.

who sidelined them, and why?

it seems the answers are: the school, because the researchers upset facebook, who was giving the school money

> if he allows the Facebook project to move forward under other groups that are also within the Kennedy school, then the title of this post is pretty misleading

this is misleading: if the research is allowed to continue, it should continue under the researchers who did the research, unless there's a good reason otherwise

Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by klyrs on Monday December 04, 2023 @03:15PM (#38522454)
"The school" is not a person with motive. Dr. Donovan's report strongly implicates the Dean, who maintains a personal friendship with Sheryl Sandberg, as the driver behind these actions. The remaining actors appear to be interest in saving their own necks.
Re:Harvard gutted team examining Facebook Files following $5... by juujian on Monday December 04, 2023 @05:24PM (#38524026)
The picture becomes much more clear later on. The Dean sidelined and reallocated the very generous funding which donors provided specifically for her, while also lying to the donors about this. And then winds down her research even though there is obviously demand for and interest in it. All while stringing her along. She should have been able to take her funding elsewhere if the dean didn't want her around, there is ample precedent for that. The degree of manipulation is unprecedented and amounts to the dean stealing her funding from her/her donors.