News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:All the hominins made tools by gumby on Sunday December 03, 2023 @02:08PM (#38509783)
I'm not sure what point is being made here. The article says that we evolved from pre-hominid primate species that used tools (there are non-hominid toolmaking species as well), which I don't think anybody disputes, and doesn't appear to be claiming that that is novel either.

Is the claim that no hominid is known the have given up tool making? That's a hard claim to make (no evidence of absence and so on), and anyway seems like a circular definitional argument (an "only true scotsman" if you will).

The central chart is interesting, but to my (note: non-paleontologist!) eye hardly "striking". Feels like the opposite would be more interesting, though again, hard to be persuasive.

Am I missing something important here? Again, I'm no expert.

Re:All the hominins made tools by svnt on Sunday December 03, 2023 @02:41PM (#38510041)
You’re not missing much, maybe just an implicit and aging position in the field. People have made the argument (in the long line of “this is what makes humans unique” arguments) that our consistent use of technology is what separates us from other animals.

In order to do so they’ve tried to argue that other early primates or hominins apparently outside the human lineage did not. It has been clear for some time to most reasonable observers that this is not the case.

This is just more data that tool use and tool-making are more broadly distributed than the anthropocentrically-fixated would like to admit.

Re:All the hominins made tools by dmix on Monday December 04, 2023 @01:53AM (#38514365)
I looked at some of their examples, such as " accumulative stone throwing" [1] and I don't get how this is a good example of "tool use". It seems like a very thin definition of the term. Maybe I don't understand anthropology and this is and any use of tools at all is bigger deal than it seems.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eVv3IUGPDK8&t=209s

Re:All the hominins made tools by wolverine876 on Sunday December 03, 2023 @03:01PM (#38510224)
The subheading says:

A study of associations between stone tool evidence and fossil hominin remains shows that a wide range of species made stone artifacts.

Perhaps in the context of the field, the hypothesis is more clear. Also, does "study" refer to a particular published study that the author is reviewing, or to this blog post?

Re:All the hominins made tools by adr1an on Sunday December 03, 2023 @02:34PM (#38509984)
Didn't read the article, I was hoping it was a gallery with a time line. Anyway, look for New Caledonian Crows, they make tools (bended hooks). It's the only non primate species that does. Supposedly, to make a tool you have a super accurate model representation in your head on what you want to achieve while elaborating such tool. That is awesome.
Re:All the hominins made tools by solardev on Sunday December 03, 2023 @03:09PM (#38510306)
Edit: Sorry, parent post said "create" tools, not "use". That is less common, and depends on what you consider "creation".

------

I love crows, but it is not true they're the only non primates able to use tools.

Many animals do! Otters, octopuses, other birds, some fish, etc.:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tool_use_by_non-humans?wprov=s...

That belief is an outdated one from people who were too anthropocentric and didn't spend enough time with animals.

Re:All the hominins made tools by simonh on Sunday December 03, 2023 @10:22PM (#38513381)
Making tools, such as bending wire to make a hook in this case, is distinct from just using found objects.
Re:All the hominins made tools by solardev on Monday December 04, 2023 @12:08AM (#38513925)
Yep, that's a distinction the OP made I didn't catch at first, and only subsequently corrected my comment.

Even then, however, elephants have been known to modify branches (https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2002-10036-002), other birds in the same family (corvids) can manipulate wires similarly to the crows (https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.0901008106), dolphins can use shells in non-obvious ways (https://www.wired.com/2011/08/dolphin-fishing/), etc. There are probably more out there that we just never noticed... and it's probably also a matter of degree and circumstance.

Re:All the hominins made tools by simonh on Monday December 04, 2023 @06:21AM (#38515959)
I'm not surprised, brains are incredible, even tiny ones in organisms like insects. Is a bird's nest a tool? There's a continuum all the way up from ant nests to rocket ships.
Re:All the hominins made tools by fuzzfactor on Sunday December 03, 2023 @02:45PM (#38510069)
>All the hominins made tools

I've seen a few fail no matter how hard they try.

Sometimes even at the initial conceptualization, so not all hominids are as smart as they think.

Re:All the hominins made tools by NoMoreNicksLeft on Sunday December 03, 2023 @09:00PM (#38512904)
My god man. Do not be teaching crows metallurgy. You're a species traitor.