However my point is, we should acknowledge that there are some cases that are "right on the edge" and would naturally favor mechanical instead of electronic solutions, but the ability to cheaply enforce proprietary restrictions pushed them "over the edge" to using an electronic solution instead.
In these cases we should indeed consider replacing electronics with mechanical solutions — if not for retrofit, at least for later product iterations.
All the examples I can think of are hundreds of years old and have no serious competition from digital stuff, like eating utensils (for abled people, stabilized spoons seem to be a great invention for those who need them).
What do you consider an edge case that should be mechanical?
Solid state electronics technically _can_ fail but their expected service life is an order of magnitude more than the mechanical stuff. Same with properly done solder joints. If they crack, it's either due to mechanical stresses (e.g. constant reinsertion on battery jacks) or it's a design fault (Xbox 360, PS3 cold solder).
Jokes aside, I think it's more likely that the undersized parts are the revised design, the original being wastefully robust.
I dont mean this cynically, only that no one wants to spend extra on overengineered parts.
DRM is a very modern concept. We originally made electronic solutions to mechanical problems because electronics allows for much more complex and nuanced response to input conditions, as well as the physical advantages of size and complexity.
Some systems are better as simple mechanical devices, but I'd put that number at a very, very low percentage.
Take your washer, dryer, dishwasher, or oven. These things can be purely mechanical, and are generally incredibly reliable when they are mechanical. In modern times, we've computerized these things for very dubious reasons mainly down to user tracking and enforced obsolescence. But adding network connectivity can be genuinely useful. Get a notification when your laundry or dishes are done. Automatically turn off the oven if you forget to when you leave the house. Track the runtime of your dishwasher and get notified when you need to clean the filter.
People would use features like that if it were possible to do so without a proprietary app that barely works, but demands your email and phone number and access to your microphone and camera. Or mandatory firmware updates that slowly degrade performance until you buy a new one.
The number of problems that can be solved mechanically and for which electronics cannot provide any extra value for the user is almost certainly very close to zero.
I think the discussion here is less about "uses any electricity at all" and more "uses internet connected DRM to be actively shitty"
This often requires real-time software calculation of precision timing for FETs that control the motors. Very loosely related to what an ECU does in cars.
I agree this is different to the DRM/internet connectivity stuff, but does disservice to the rest of the electronics and software housed within.
[0] Trapezoidal Control of BLDC Motors Using Hall Effect Sensors
> Hm, I disagree. ...
> *Some* systems are better as simple mechanical devices, but I'd put that number at a very, very low percentage.
We actually agree. Yes the number of cases is small (hence my wording "non-zero"). ;-)I warned everyone I was making a minor point about "subtle cases," right? Both you and eternityforest thought I needed "correction" and pointed out it was a small number of cases, but I already agree. My reasoning process was the same as both of yours, and I came the same conclusion.
But while it's not many cases, we still shouldn't forget it. Imprecise thinking is the mind killer.
If a designer categorically decides (to save time) that we humans should never again revert anything (presumably, that has ever been done electronically, by anyone) back to a mechanical solution, they'll produce a worse solution in certain cases. Probably a lot of cases, actually!
One may counter, "I don't mean anything that's ever been done electronically by anyone, just the ones where electronics are better", but how do we distinguish the two, beyond in obvious cases? Worse yet, if we need to do that analysis anyway, what brainpower is being saved by having a rule to never switch away from electronics? :-\
TL;DR we should resist the temptation to shortcut with a simplifying rule "thou shalt not switch electronics to mechanics", because it neither rules nor simplifies!
Electronics lets us pack in more complexity, giving us a place to compensate for imperfections elsewhere, such as users leaving babies behind in hot cars.
Plus without proprietary restrictions, nearly every vehicle and appliances in the world could probably use the same 5 modules or so for everything, making repairs rather easy.
In general I agree, but I worry this glosses over the subtle cases in the middle.
In a non-zero number of cases, the only reason electronics are "superior" to mechanical solutions is precisely because it's easy to enforce proprietary restrictions. In this subset of cases, it is proper to replace the electronic solution with a (here, superior) mechanical one. .