News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by TaylorAlexander on Friday December 01, 2023 @11:55PM (#38496014)
I remember watching this video a few months ago. As I write this I am debugging open source electronics I designed for our open source farming robot.

It seems like people see the growth in opaque proprietary electronics and they conclude that we should move back to old mechanical systems. But mechanical systems are not always more reliable.

What I really want more people to understand is that electronics are not the issue - proprietary designs are. Open source designs inherently have enough documentation that even if they don't come with some nice service manual, the nerds on the user forum can dig through the schematics and code to sort out what's what.

Unfortunately open source hardware just isn't getting enough coverage for people to really see the value in it, despite the entire internet being built on open source hardware. We need to find ways to communicate the power of open source beyond software. We could have open source modules in cars with open standards. Sure the manufacturers need a rugged PCB that can control lights, read sensors, interact with CAN BUS, etc. But there is no need for that system to be proprietary. We need to build and demonstrate the value of open source hardware to help people understand what is really possible. Because the call to move back to mechanical systems is really just a call to move back to systems that are intuitively understandable, and today's shadetree mechanics can read a forum post as well as anyone else. What we need are open, documented systems. Electronics are not the enemy, proprietary systems are.

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by boznz on Saturday December 02, 2023 @12:07AM (#38496076)
Totally nailed it. Without the information on proprietary systems to repair them or effect the cars re-use (if say doing an EV conversion), the car or anything becomes either a massive reverse engineering problem or landfill once the manufacturer stops supporting it.
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by jacquesm on Saturday December 02, 2023 @12:12AM (#38496094)
Is there a way to support your effort?
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by TaylorAlexander on Saturday December 02, 2023 @01:08AM (#38496366)
Thank you, yes. Here is a blog post with more information about what we are doing [1] and a direct link to our funding page [2]. We are working on moving to a fully donation supported engineering model so our work can be freely available for everyone the world over, and your monthly contributions make a big difference. Also here is our github with our electronics, software, and hardware designs all permissively licensed. [3] Notably our open source dual brushless motor controller design is coming along nicely. [4]

[1] https://community.twistedfields.com/t/join-the-solar-farming...

[2] https://opencollective.com/twisted-fields-research-collectiv...

[3] https://github.com/Twisted-Fields

[4] https://github.com/Twisted-Fields/rp2040-motor-controller

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by jacquesm on Saturday December 02, 2023 @01:20PM (#38500653)
Very neat! Electric goat :)

How weather resistant is it? Is it aware of its surroundings yet (for instance: irrigation installations)? Are any of these in use outside of the people that develop them?

(sorry for the questions barrage but if I didn't live on another continent I'd hop over to help). Nice Al welding btw.

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by TaylorAlexander on Monday December 04, 2023 @04:52AM (#38515448)
It is very weather resistant, our prototypes all live outdoors 100% of the time so it is developed in the rain. We don't get snow where we are so we will need to do more testing in snow as things develop.

It is not yet aware of its surroundings.

We are still finalizing the first version to ship, so currently no other machines are in use outside of our farm. We are working on getting there!

> Nice Al welding btw.

Thank you, though I don't understand. I do all the welding myself by hand. We also have a CNC plasma cutter for cutting parts. It doesn't use AI, just Gcode. :)

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by artificialLimbs on Saturday December 02, 2023 @12:02AM (#38496047)
Say what you will about Musk, but he's making an effort in this regard. He has open sourced a number of goodies with Tesla.
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by conradev on Saturday December 02, 2023 @12:08AM (#38496081)
Isn't Tesla actively hostile towards charging network interoperability?
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by artificialLimbs on Saturday December 02, 2023 @12:09AM (#38496082)
No. They have opened source the schematics for their chargers and welcome other manufacturers to use their charger design.

https://www.tesla.com/support/charging/product-guides

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by conradev on Saturday December 02, 2023 @12:17AM (#38496121)
Open source schematics and a closed Supercharger network until this year, at least in the US. It's hard to separate Tesla's intentions in opening up their charging network from the legislation in both the US and EU incentivizing it.
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by vikramkr on Saturday December 02, 2023 @02:26AM (#38496690)
No they did actually follow through on the charging stuff to the point where NACS is now the new north American standard, which is kind of wild to see given how they've acted before.
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by PinguTS on Saturday December 02, 2023 @05:03PM (#38502534)
Funfact: NACS ist just CCS with a different physical connector. You just need to read and understand the specs.
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by bsder on Saturday December 02, 2023 @12:04AM (#38496055)
Um, last I checked, the repository was a bunch of PDF user manuals.

Has that changed?

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by TaylorAlexander on Saturday December 02, 2023 @01:04AM (#38496342)
Be careful about that. Just last week he lied about open sourcing the original roadster. Musk very clearly said "all design and engineering for the original roadster is open source" but that statement is false. There's a few PCB designs available and one diagnostic program, but there are zero mechanical designs and I suspect there are missing firmwares, among other things. Given these glaring omissions (and Musk is certainly qualified to understand what "all design and engineering" means), I suspect there is a trove of other "design and engineering" documentation that is missing as well.

I believe none of the cars shipping today contain any open source electronics. Teslas are notoriously full of very expensive proprietary electronics. He has indeed released some "goodies" but is nonetheless as bad as every other shipping car manufacturer today.

It is honestly hard to say he is making an effort when he is so blatantly lying about the roadster and his other vehicles are completely proprietary. Not saying he is worse than the other companies, but I can't give him credit for something he is not doing.

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by KennyBlanken on Saturday December 02, 2023 @04:41PM (#38502316)
> Musk is certainly qualified to understand what "all design and engineering" means

I'd say there is a mountain of evidence from SpaceX and Tesla that's not actually true and that he has little to no understanding of anything related to engineering, nor the ability to manage engineering teams effectively; I think he's surrounded by people that are actually talented and do a lot to scrambling to make stuff happen and fix his messes.

The huge 'box' his demanded his team put together, to rescue people from a cave with passages so narrow diver could not wear tanks on their backs? To me that demonstrates he has no ability to analyze a problem at high level and correctly apply the engineering resources available to him.

Examples:

* Dishy, which had basic design flaws, such as a permanently attached power/data cable that if damaged meant you had to purchase an entire new unit

* Hyperloop.

* SpaceX's repeated failures, which they spin as "it's okay, we meant to fuck up, we got data!", including the disaster where his insistence on launching on 4/20 resulted in substantial vehicle damage (5-8 rockets failed), heavy damage to the facility, a 380 acre wide debris field (so severe you could see debris landing in the ocean from an aerial shot well outside the launch danger zone), a forest fire, and heavy damage to a car (parked within the "hazard area.")

* Musk's repeated production-related issues at Tesla, and his insistence on automating as much as possible even when experts in their field who work for him tell him it's not possible

* Repeated demonstrations of engineering incompetence at Telsa. The Model S drivetrain units used to be disposable and would be quietly replaced during routine service at anywhere from 10-30k miles. They still can't make a Tesla with proper body panel gaps. People have found bits of wood/wire/duct tape holding their Tesla's guts together. For years Model S's couldn't be driven in heavy rain or through large puddles without water ending up in the drive units. Windows randomly shattering while cars are parked in driveways and garages. Etc

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by allenrb on Saturday December 02, 2023 @07:09PM (#38503502)
Stop, just stop. I’m not going to reply to the points I’m unfamiliar with but this crap about SpaceX has to be answered (“someone is wrong on the Internet!”)

SpaceX operates what, by reasonable measures, is probably the most reliable launcher in history. That’s the Falcon 9. They are absolutely capable of reliable space operations.

Their two test flights of the Starship stack are test flights. Perhaps a better term would be R&D flights. They’re building something way outside the envelope of what’s ever flown before. If they followed the approach taken by big government contractors and/or classic NASA, we might expect them to fly around 2042 after spending many billions of taxpayer dollars. (Exhibit A, SLS). What you see is a company taking risks to advance the state of the art.

Be thankful or be ignorant but please, please don’t be loudly and proudly wrong!

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by petertodd on Saturday December 02, 2023 @05:35PM (#38502842)
> The huge 'box' his demanded his team put together, to rescue people from a cave with passages so narrow diver could not wear tanks on their backs? To me that demonstrates he has no ability to analyze a problem at high level and correctly apply the engineering resources available to him.

The solution they came up with for those kids was extremely risky, involving drugging them and hoping they didn't drown in their face masks. It had never been done before in cave rescue history, and no-one really knew if it would actually work.

Cave passages can be widened. It's actually quite common for cave rescues to involve widening passages. It's also relatively common for cavers to do that in general as part of ordinary exploration - I personally have helped widen an impassibly narrow passage with explosives myself. And yes, this is done underwater too.

If the drugging solution had resulted in a kid drowning, there is a very good chance that the submarine solution would have been used.

> Dishy, which had basic design flaws, such as a permanently attached power/data cable that if damaged meant you had to purchase an entire new unit

That sounds like a typical engineering/marketing decision: rather than coming up with a tricky waterproof connector, just seal it permanently and sell the user a new one if they break it. Starlink as a whole has been very successful.

> SpaceX's repeated failures, which they spin as "it's okay, we meant to fuck up, we got data!", including the disaster where his insistence on launching on 4/20 resulted in substantial vehicle damage (5-8 rockets failed), heavy damage to the facility, a 380 acre wide debris field (so severe you could see debris landing in the ocean from an aerial shot well outside the launch danger zone), a forest fire, and heavy damage to a car (parked within the "hazard area.")

SpaceX is probably the most successful aerospace company in history., and they have some of the most reliable orbital rockets in history. Obviously their focus on meeting schedules and iterating is working for them. They just launched Starship again with even more success, and will probably do so yet again in a few more months. I really don't think SpaceX themselves care about occasionally spreading some debris around, setting some trees on fire, and damaging a car in the designated hazard area. There's lots of rocket engineers that have managed to destroy their own cars because their rockets failed and debris hit the employee parking lot.

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by buildbot on Saturday December 02, 2023 @11:29AM (#38499728)
Aren’t they still violating linux’s GPL license?
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by hommelix on Saturday December 02, 2023 @02:24AM (#38496680)
You are right on openness. This is key to understand and fix broken machines. Mechanical designs used to be more open too. We bought tractors in the 1980's and these would come with a workshop manual with parts list and disassembly / assembly instructions, with tools list and torque requirement.
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by TaylorAlexander on Saturday December 02, 2023 @02:58AM (#38496835)
You're right. Televisions used to be more repairable too. I found a microfiche reader by a dumpster and for fun ordered a lot of 100+ microfiche cards from an old TV repair shop on ebay. Zenith for example published detailed repair manuals including detailed steps for recalibration, parts lists, schematics, annotated PCB layouts, and more. These were for repair shops not the average person, but modern TV companies don't even produce those materials anymore.
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by trilbyglens on Saturday December 02, 2023 @03:25AM (#38496995)
Nope they are far cheaper to just throw away and replace. It's a terrible system.
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by TaylorAlexander on Saturday December 02, 2023 @05:19AM (#38497528)
Honestly I only think it’s cheaper to replace because we’ve made repair more expensive than it needs to be. I’ve fixed two TVs that stopped working with a few dollars of capacitors and my own time. That’s much cheaper than buying a new TV! But I had to go digging through forums when manufacturers could have provided this information. Instead they refuse ti share info and charge extreme prices for repairs where they will just throw out an entire board with one bad component which would cost 20 cents on its own.

I agree it’s a terrible system I just wanted to clarify that the “it costs less to throw it out and replace” narrative is only true so long as we make it true.

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by benj111 on Saturday December 02, 2023 @04:06PM (#38502045)
Even within a non repairable system, it could be improved so much.

Why can't we have dumb screens that I can plug my Amazon stick or whatever into.

My girlfriend's TV actually crashes and randomly resets. Presumably because they cram a load of functionality in, and don't test (not so) edge cases.

Just give me a dumb screen, if I want $fancy new streaming app I can just buy a single or whatever, if the dongle breaks, I replace just that.

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by kQq9oHeAz6wLLS on Saturday December 02, 2023 @04:37PM (#38502284)
Buy a computer monitor. Sadly, that only works up to a certain size, and price will not be your friend.

Alternatively, a projector and quality screen.

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by bitwize on Saturday December 02, 2023 @07:01PM (#38503469)
Alternatively, order a Sceptre dumb TV from Wal-Mart's web site.
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by happytiger on Saturday December 02, 2023 @04:26PM (#38502198)
The key is that mechanical designs cannot be copyright locked and you cannot build a closed ecosystem and demand insane prices for access to that ecosystem.

I feel like open source isn’t the point, it’s the solution. The point is that proprietary lock in creates artificial scarcity and allows protectionist rackets, and open source AND all mechanical systems counter this ugly consumer deleterious product choice that is incentivized by the market effects of protectionist proprietary ethos.

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by saulrh on Saturday December 02, 2023 @05:47PM (#38502960)
Reproducibility of mechanical objects is only the case in the modern day! It used to be that reproducing mechanical parts was difficult enough that a particularly sophisticated part could be just as locked-down as a particularly sophisticated bit of software is today.

For an illustrative example, imagine that a part on your tractor suddenly becomes a bit of twisted, wrecked metal.

These days? You ask someone else with the same tractor to send you some pictures, pull their part out and measure all the holes and their positions and tell you what the bearing surfaces are made of, you scrape off some slivers of your wreck and assay them to figure out what alloy it's made out of and how it was heat-treated, you go and machine a test piece or two on your mill and try it, you buy a bit of bronze bushing off mcmaster and it works, etc. Maybe someone else has already done this and published a CAD model and instructions! We have solutions for this.

Back then? You have no designs. You have no way to communicate with other people who have a complete working part. You might be lucky enough to remember what bits the part connected to if you'd looked at it before. You may have some idea what the intended geometry was, but you're never going to figure out that the geometry is actually just a few degrees off right angles because that keeps you out of a complicated kinematic singularity that blows up the part every time you turn left. You can guess at some of the materials, but systematic classifications of iron-carbon alloys don't exist so all you can say is "it's some kind of steel". Even if you figure a lot of this out, there's no real way to write it down or share it with people because a lot of the terminology for representing this stuff simply doesn't exist. Even if you make a functional part, its expected lifetime is months rather than decades.

The original creator, by comparison, can just buy a new block of their supplier's "Alloy Number 5", throw the forging dies back on the presses and stamp out a blank, slap the blank into the jig that presents every hole to the drill press at exactly the right angle, put the part through their proprietary heat-treat process, and then ship you the result. Those dies and jigs and heat-treat protocols are exactly the same kind of proprietary protection that a git repo full of source code is today.

If you look at hydraulic and pneumatic fittings, you can see elements of this lock-in still extant in the modern world. Everyone had their own thread sizes and thread geometries for their own tools, getting them to interoperate was impossible unless you had the right adapters, and you could not make the right adapters unless you were a dedicated specialist in hydraulic fittings. You were locked in to your tools provider's pneumatic toolchain in exactly the same way that people are currently locked in to their current power tool brand because they own $50k in tools and battery packs that agree that they're made out of a specific manufacturer's 18650s with specific voltage drop and internal resistance and etc etc etc. (go watch the torque test channel's segment on battery adapters a bit, it's enlightening! - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WgJI8Ikrd6Y).

(if you watch enough of Forgotten Weapons, you'll also hear things like "X bought the design for Y gun but it took them 3 years to transfer the tooling and get it up and running" - that's the stamps and jigs and heat-treats and everything that I was talking about earlier, and if those tools were destroyed a gun generally became totally unmanufacturable and had to be redesigned from scratch to continue production, and those redesigns frequently failed to perfectly reproduce the original!)

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by mikewarot on Saturday December 02, 2023 @06:58PM (#38503455)
You've never heard of tracing attachments for lathes, or Pantograph mills. Copying things and making parts to fit goes back well before the industrial revolution, it used to be the way all things mechanical were made.

If there's enough time and budget, anything, even crashed things from other worlds, can be repaired. I've seen replacements made for the bull gears that hold up Bascule bridges in Chicago, and I've repaired atomic clocks... people improvise, adapt and overcome issues like the odd broken part.

The only limits are artificially imposed, by governments and market capture. I'm currently helping a friend repair a National HRO-500 receiver, likely made before I was born. It's amazing that they managed to build a synthesized general coverage receiver with Germanium transistors (the old ones are NOT reliable, nor anywhere near interchangeable, even with the same part #), but it's getting repaired after 60 years of service.

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by eternityforest on Sunday December 03, 2023 @01:39AM (#38505331)
At that level of effort entire electronics systems might be replaceable too.

If a washing machine circuit board breaks (It probably won't, so e mechanical thing will), I could probably swap everything to run on a PLC if I really had to.

I wouldn't have a clue what to do if the mechanical timing stuff broke, other than cleaning it and swapping it for a PLC if that failed.

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by walterbell on Sunday December 03, 2023 @07:42AM (#38506661)
> anything, even crashed things from other worlds, can be repaired

stories welcome :)

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by mikewarot on Sunday December 03, 2023 @12:21PM (#38508738)
I keep hinting, to the various TLAs* watching the internet, that I'm willing to sign disclosures, and help fix things / reverse engineer them, if they need me to. But nobody shows up at my door, telling me I need to help my country. ;-)

I'm hoping Barry-1[1] works, and pushes into a higher orbit (increasing the Semi-Major Axis on the graph), without propellant. If it works, it shows our "laws" of physics are wrong, and forces us to refine our understanding.

For me, that marks a turning point, and a start down the road to being an Interstellar species.

* Three Letter Agency, i.e. NSA, NRO, DOE, etc.

[1] https://celestrak.org/NORAD/elements/graph-orbit-data.php?CA...

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by coldtea on Saturday December 02, 2023 @07:12PM (#38503522)
How far back are we talking about? Because even in the 60s and 70s enthusiasts could create all kinds of parts for, say, cars, on their garage workshop.
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by schiffern on Saturday December 02, 2023 @03:43PM (#38501870)
>they conclude that we should move back to old mechanical systems. But mechanical systems are not always more reliable.

In general I agree, but I worry this glosses over the subtle cases in the middle.

In a non-zero number of cases, the only reason electronics are "superior" to mechanical solutions is precisely because it's easy to enforce proprietary restrictions. In this subset of cases, it is proper to replace the electronic solution with a (here, superior) mechanical one. .

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by seanmcdirmid on Saturday December 02, 2023 @03:55PM (#38501960)
Actually the lack of minimization of moving parts makes them superior. Friction’s effect on wear and tear is real.
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by schiffern on Saturday December 02, 2023 @04:03PM (#38502020)
Of course I agree with that general principle.

However my point is, we should acknowledge that there are some cases that are "right on the edge" and would naturally favor mechanical instead of electronic solutions, but the ability to cheaply enforce proprietary restrictions pushed them "over the edge" to using an electronic solution instead.

In these cases we should indeed consider replacing electronics with mechanical solutions — if not for retrofit, at least for later product iterations.

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by eternityforest on Sunday December 03, 2023 @01:29AM (#38505296)
The cases right on the edge are real, but not common.

All the examples I can think of are hundreds of years old and have no serious competition from digital stuff, like eating utensils (for abled people, stabilized spoons seem to be a great invention for those who need them).

What do you consider an edge case that should be mechanical?

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by schiffern on Sunday December 03, 2023 @02:07PM (#38509778)
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by asdff on Saturday December 02, 2023 @04:33PM (#38502244)
Electronics have wear and tear too because at the end of the day it needs to run on some hardware. Solder joints are never built to last until the end of time, just to not lead to a lot of repair claims within the warranty period and any longer is an opportunity to cut costs for a future manager.
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by AussieWog93 on Saturday December 02, 2023 @04:51PM (#38502401)
I refurbish a whole lot of ewaste as part of my job, and with a few exceptions any time a device fails it's either the electrolytics in the power supply or something mechanical.

Solid state electronics technically _can_ fail but their expected service life is an order of magnitude more than the mechanical stuff. Same with properly done solder joints. If they crack, it's either due to mechanical stresses (e.g. constant reinsertion on battery jacks) or it's a design fault (Xbox 360, PS3 cold solder).

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by adhesive_wombat on Saturday December 02, 2023 @06:21PM (#38503231)
Or a blown MOSFET that's exactly the right size to work on paper but no more (or is missing ESD protection and blew up a gate).
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by infogulch on Saturday December 02, 2023 @06:27PM (#38503277)
Which is a flaw that could be fixed in the design for future runs and a fix documented for earlier runs.
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by adhesive_wombat on Sunday December 03, 2023 @04:15AM (#38505869)
Excuse me, a properly sized MOSFET is nearly 5p more and a TVS diode is nearly a penny for 4. Why do you hate profits?

Jokes aside, I think it's more likely that the undersized parts are the revised design, the original being wastefully robust.

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by droopyEyelids on Saturday December 02, 2023 @11:26PM (#38504829)
That order of magnitude longevity gap is a profit opportunity for the component manufacturers, and people are absolutely working to figure out how to make them cheaper.

I dont mean this cynically, only that no one wants to spend extra on overengineered parts.

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by infogulch on Saturday December 02, 2023 @06:47PM (#38503396)
But if the electronic design is open then what's would be the point of forcing an electronic solution when its inferior? The hypothetical is that electronic designs are open instead of closed.
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by samtho on Saturday December 02, 2023 @08:36PM (#38503994)
It’s easier to fix with off-the-shelf parts (blown capacitor, damaged MOSFET, etc) than a part in which is manufactured for and by the automaker (e.g. variable valve timing component).
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by calamari4065 on Saturday December 02, 2023 @11:36PM (#38504861)
Hm, I disagree.

DRM is a very modern concept. We originally made electronic solutions to mechanical problems because electronics allows for much more complex and nuanced response to input conditions, as well as the physical advantages of size and complexity.

Some systems are better as simple mechanical devices, but I'd put that number at a very, very low percentage.

Take your washer, dryer, dishwasher, or oven. These things can be purely mechanical, and are generally incredibly reliable when they are mechanical. In modern times, we've computerized these things for very dubious reasons mainly down to user tracking and enforced obsolescence. But adding network connectivity can be genuinely useful. Get a notification when your laundry or dishes are done. Automatically turn off the oven if you forget to when you leave the house. Track the runtime of your dishwasher and get notified when you need to clean the filter.

People would use features like that if it were possible to do so without a proprietary app that barely works, but demands your email and phone number and access to your microphone and camera. Or mandatory firmware updates that slowly degrade performance until you buy a new one.

The number of problems that can be solved mechanically and for which electronics cannot provide any extra value for the user is almost certainly very close to zero.

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by nudgeee on Sunday December 03, 2023 @10:09AM (#38507571)
Just to add to your first point, many washers feature digital control of motors at the very low level, especially for BLDC motor types. This can reduce noise, increase efficiency and longevity of a motor. This requires electronics and software for precise timing control.
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by calamari4065 on Sunday December 03, 2023 @10:16PM (#38513341)
Eh, I think that's a different thing. The line between machine and electronics is pretty blurry when you get down to it. Is an LED attached to a mechanical switch electronics? What if the switch controls a transistor that switches the light? A relay? A CPU? What if it's an incandescent bulb on a mechanical timer? The distinction isn't super clear, and a lot of electronic circuits are much less complex and more reliable than a mechanical replacement. Is that good or bad?

I think the discussion here is less about "uses any electricity at all" and more "uses internet connected DRM to be actively shitty"

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by nudgeee on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @09:19AM (#38612374)
Indeed, I get the gist of the message, however I’m just highlighting how much advanced electronics and software drive something as ‘mundane’ as a washing machine motor to improve its efficiency [0].

This often requires real-time software calculation of precision timing for FETs that control the motors. Very loosely related to what an ECU does in cars.

I agree this is different to the DRM/internet connectivity stuff, but does disservice to the rest of the electronics and software housed within.

[0] Trapezoidal Control of BLDC Motors Using Hall Effect Sensors

https://www.ti.com/lit/an/sprabz4/sprabz4.pdf

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by schiffern on Sunday December 03, 2023 @01:58PM (#38509700)

  > Hm, I disagree. ...

  > *Some* systems are better as simple mechanical devices, but I'd put that number at a very, very low percentage.

We actually agree. Yes the number of cases is small (hence my wording "non-zero"). ;-)

I warned everyone I was making a minor point about "subtle cases," right? Both you and eternityforest thought I needed "correction" and pointed out it was a small number of cases, but I already agree. My reasoning process was the same as both of yours, and I came the same conclusion.

But while it's not many cases, we still shouldn't forget it. Imprecise thinking is the mind killer.

If a designer categorically decides (to save time) that we humans should never again revert anything (presumably, that has ever been done electronically, by anyone) back to a mechanical solution, they'll produce a worse solution in certain cases. Probably a lot of cases, actually!

One may counter, "I don't mean anything that's ever been done electronically by anyone, just the ones where electronics are better", but how do we distinguish the two, beyond in obvious cases? Worse yet, if we need to do that analysis anyway, what brainpower is being saved by having a rule to never switch away from electronics? :-\

TL;DR we should resist the temptation to shortcut with a simplifying rule "thou shalt not switch electronics to mechanics", because it neither rules nor simplifies!

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by eternityforest on Sunday December 03, 2023 @01:17AM (#38505244)
Electronics separate form and function. The behavior can be anything we want with almost no extra cost. Plus, we can make module and reuse it in thousands of products with only code changes.

Electronics lets us pack in more complexity, giving us a place to compensate for imperfections elsewhere, such as users leaving babies behind in hot cars.

Plus without proprietary restrictions, nearly every vehicle and appliances in the world could probably use the same 5 modules or so for everything, making repairs rather easy.

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by coldtea on Saturday December 02, 2023 @07:03PM (#38503478)
>But mechanical systems are not always more reliable.

They are however always more sustainable, more easily (and often locally) repairable, and so on...