News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by seanmcdirmid on Saturday December 02, 2023 @03:55PM (#38501960)
Actually the lack of minimization of moving parts makes them superior. Friction’s effect on wear and tear is real.
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by schiffern on Saturday December 02, 2023 @04:03PM (#38502020)
Of course I agree with that general principle.

However my point is, we should acknowledge that there are some cases that are "right on the edge" and would naturally favor mechanical instead of electronic solutions, but the ability to cheaply enforce proprietary restrictions pushed them "over the edge" to using an electronic solution instead.

In these cases we should indeed consider replacing electronics with mechanical solutions — if not for retrofit, at least for later product iterations.

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by eternityforest on Sunday December 03, 2023 @01:29AM (#38505296)
The cases right on the edge are real, but not common.

All the examples I can think of are hundreds of years old and have no serious competition from digital stuff, like eating utensils (for abled people, stabilized spoons seem to be a great invention for those who need them).

What do you consider an edge case that should be mechanical?

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by schiffern on Sunday December 03, 2023 @02:07PM (#38509778)
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by asdff on Saturday December 02, 2023 @04:33PM (#38502244)
Electronics have wear and tear too because at the end of the day it needs to run on some hardware. Solder joints are never built to last until the end of time, just to not lead to a lot of repair claims within the warranty period and any longer is an opportunity to cut costs for a future manager.
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by AussieWog93 on Saturday December 02, 2023 @04:51PM (#38502401)
I refurbish a whole lot of ewaste as part of my job, and with a few exceptions any time a device fails it's either the electrolytics in the power supply or something mechanical.

Solid state electronics technically _can_ fail but their expected service life is an order of magnitude more than the mechanical stuff. Same with properly done solder joints. If they crack, it's either due to mechanical stresses (e.g. constant reinsertion on battery jacks) or it's a design fault (Xbox 360, PS3 cold solder).

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by adhesive_wombat on Saturday December 02, 2023 @06:21PM (#38503231)
Or a blown MOSFET that's exactly the right size to work on paper but no more (or is missing ESD protection and blew up a gate).
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by infogulch on Saturday December 02, 2023 @06:27PM (#38503277)
Which is a flaw that could be fixed in the design for future runs and a fix documented for earlier runs.
Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by adhesive_wombat on Sunday December 03, 2023 @04:15AM (#38505869)
Excuse me, a properly sized MOSFET is nearly 5p more and a TVS diode is nearly a penny for 4. Why do you hate profits?

Jokes aside, I think it's more likely that the undersized parts are the revised design, the original being wastefully robust.

Re:Insanity of Modern Automotive Electronics Will Lead to a ... by droopyEyelids on Saturday December 02, 2023 @11:26PM (#38504829)
That order of magnitude longevity gap is a profit opportunity for the component manufacturers, and people are absolutely working to figure out how to make them cheaper.

I dont mean this cynically, only that no one wants to spend extra on overengineered parts.