News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by nwah1 on Sunday November 26, 2023 @11:51PM (#38428196)
The issue with this, that I see, is that these are anecdotes involving highly intelligent people teaching their own kids. And they are reporting it because they are very excited about the success.

I suspect that we are unlikely to hear from those who may have attempted the same, but didn't achieve much success. And I suspect that teaching a random person's child may not yield as much results as teaching the child of a genius like Larry Sanger.

So the only question is whether Larry Sanger's child would've been worse off without this particular type of instruction, and that is a counterfactual that we cannot answer.

I think it could also be the case that the adult intelligence level will not be greatly affected by any kind of learning technique or pace during childhood. But being ahead of your peers in school can help you get better grades and thus potentially more financial success in life.

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by namanyayg on Monday November 27, 2023 @12:01AM (#38428265)
> And I suspect that teaching a random person's child may not yield as much results as teaching the child of a genius like Larry Sanger.

Why do you believe that? Are there any studies proving the nature vs nurture debate? It seems like the techniques followed can be equally applied to all children, e.g. imagine this being officially taught in nursery schools.

> I think it could also be the case that the adult intelligence level will not be greatly affected by any kind of learning technique or pace during childhood

Again, where is this coming from? The child will start earlier and will have more time to learn more advanced subjects than their peers, which could definitely lead to higher intelligence at any given age

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by justrealist on Monday November 27, 2023 @12:14AM (#38428346)
> Are there any studies proving the nature vs nurture debate

Yes, current research has IQ around 80% genetic in middle-class western society (where you don't have to worry about nutritional deficiency as a factor).

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by strix_varius on Monday November 27, 2023 @01:53AM (#38429049)
80% is generally the upper limit that studies have reported, and for teens / adults.

Heritability of IQ presents at a far lower rate for children: around 20%.

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by justrealist on Monday November 27, 2023 @12:13AM (#38428338)
I had the same thought when I learned the kid was learning Hebrew. Kind of a tell.

I mean I don't want to discredit the possibility this helps a lot, let's just be real about the likely baseline.

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by SuperNinKenDo on Monday November 27, 2023 @01:38AM (#38428968)
Frankly kids are language sponges. Just pop a kid in proximity to somebody speaking another language for a couple hours every few days, and they'll start being able to speak it at a basic level after less than a year.

Teaching a kid a language using flashcards is obviously different, but I don't think it indicates some kind of savant status by any stretch.

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by edanm on Monday November 27, 2023 @05:31AM (#38430665)
That's a huge generalization. There are many kids with speech delays, for example.
Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by SuperNinKenDo on Monday November 27, 2023 @05:38AM (#38430714)
Yes. It is a huge generalisation. About the general case. Which is that kids don't have delays. That's why they're called delays. And that is why not having a delay does not indicate savant status.
Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by edanm on Monday November 27, 2023 @06:33AM (#38431094)
Yeah I was just responding to the first of your statement, I agree with the second.

(There are a significant amount of kids with some developmental delay, and it can be disheartening to be the parent of a kid and think you're doing something wrong because "everyone knows" that "all kids pick up languages like sponges", that' the only reason I want to call it out as not being representative of everyone.)

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by SuperNinKenDo on Monday November 27, 2023 @07:06AM (#38431321)
I guess it's true that talking about these things as universal can have rhat effect. On the other hand, and not necessarily disagreeing with you, but playing devil's advocate a little here; sometimes it's important to make clear what normal development does look like so that a parent of a child with delays understands confidently that what they're seeing isn't normal development.

An acquaintance of mine has a son who's clearly delayed, probably autistic, but she's so steeped in "every child is different" rhetoric that she refuses to see the obvious, and it's going to be to his serious detriment unfortunately.

I guess the trick is to describe clearly what is normal while also cultivating a culture in which there's no shame attached to these kinds of delays.

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by edanm on Monday November 27, 2023 @07:19AM (#38431425)
I agree with the gist of your post, I think I'd just say that, when making observations, it's careful to qualify them.

Instead of "kids are like sponges with languages" you can say "most kids are like sponges with languages".

(I'm nitpicking, my comments aren't trying to say you did something wrong - I just wanted to point out that what you said only applies to most kids, not all.)

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by beagle3 on Monday November 27, 2023 @02:29AM (#38429212)
In general, Hebrew with vowels (as it is usually taught to beginners) has well specified pronunciation. The emphasis is usually not written, which does occasionally leave a degree of freedom, but it’s much easier than English with its thousands of special cases (e.g. lower vs power, colonel in American English).

Everyday use does not use the vowels, and you are just supposed to know it or decide it from context - which is harder than in English, even though English has its share of difficulty here (e.g. the two ‘tear’s in “i shed a tear when I saw him tear the contract”)

And in case the missing vowels sound confusing - Hebrew and Arabic put vowels above and below the letters, not inline signaling like English.

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by justrealist on Monday November 27, 2023 @07:03AM (#38431302)
That's not my point, it's that if they are Ashkenazi they are on average starting at 1-2 SD above baseline.
Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by Terr_ on Monday November 27, 2023 @12:12PM (#38434963)
> much easier than English with its thousands of special cases

Relevant comic: https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/pronounce

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by kaba0 on Monday November 27, 2023 @12:22AM (#38428409)
> I think it could also be the case that the adult intelligence level will not be greatly affected by any kind of learning technique or pace during childhood

Judit Polgár’s parents decided to basically test this assumption on their own children - they incorporated chess in their lives from a very early age, and it absolutely shown on their results. Sure, everything has a “nature” element, but the potential from that point can be utilized or wasted, depending on nurture.

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by hattmall on Monday November 27, 2023 @12:24AM (#38428428)
Did they not incorporate it with some of their children? Or what was the control?
Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by kaba0 on Monday November 27, 2023 @12:38AM (#38428557)
Every other children? Sure, it’s not a report in Science, hence the apostrophes around test.
Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by The_Colonel on Monday November 27, 2023 @11:29AM (#38434317)
The part which is usually not mentioned Laszlo Polgar was himself a chess expert (publishing many books on chess) and a renowned psychologist, so very far from being just average parent.

The only result we get is that training a child from early age often gives them a significant edge in some specific field over children getting trained later. But that's a result known from many other sports as well.

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by kaba0 on Monday November 27, 2023 @11:44AM (#38434526)
I mean, the zero hypothesis for pretty much any trait should be that it has both a nurture and a nature component. We do know that results can be improved with nurture, and we also know that results can be significantly diminished as well with it (e.g. children not learning to speak by something like 5-6 years will never be able to). We only have indirect ways to measure intelligence (for example the former case of non-speaking children couldn’t complete an IQ test), so I think it is safe to assume that intelligence can be somewhat influenced by nurture as well.

(Also, I believe it is more common than not for a successful person to not have their children similarly successful, even though they usually go to top, elite schools and has good genetic traits. Of course there are plenty other factors, but I do believe that it points towards to my point)

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by The_Colonel on Monday November 27, 2023 @03:30PM (#38437817)
> I think it is safe to assume that intelligence can be somewhat influenced by nurture as well.

Sure, but how does this experiment prove that? Polgar proved he can severely improve "chess IQ" if child is trained early, but how do you go from there to general intelligence?

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by kaba0 on Monday November 27, 2023 @03:37PM (#38437896)
What is general intelligence? IQ tests also can’t measure that, but chess is definitely at least a good indicator.
Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by The_Colonel on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @03:03AM (#38443480)
I think there is a positive correlation between chess ability and intelligence, but being a world-class chess player doesn't indicate having "world-class intelligence".

The problem is that the null hypothesis was that Polgar sisters will be highly intelligent, because their parents were highly intelligent. But we don't have indications that they would excel in any other intellectual field apart from chess.

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by kaba0 on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @04:54AM (#38444157)
> being a world-class chess player doesn't indicate having "world-class intelligence".

I agree, but if chess ability does have a positive correlation with intelligence, isn’t that enough “proof”, as intelligence itself allows for “excelling in other intellectual fields”?

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by edanm on Monday November 27, 2023 @05:29AM (#38430649)
That doesn't contradict his statement. Just that starting Chess specifically from an early age with a lot of instruction will make you very good at Chess. That doesn't mean anything about their intelligence level.

E.g. almost every famous athlete has been practicing their craft from a young ago, some of them pushed to practice much more than their peers. Some of them are then successful. I wouldn't call any of it proof of their adult intelligence, just skilled at gymnastics/tennis/swimming/whatever.

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by parentthrowaway on Monday November 27, 2023 @12:32AM (#38428494)
This is from my experience as a parent.

It's kind of common sense that spaced repetition is simple enough to be mastered by pretty much anyone. I mean dude, even orange cats can learn by rote repetition.

My son has memorized letters and numbers at least since 1y3mo, and at 2yo now, can sight read many words and verbalize arithmetic that I'm sure many children are doing intuitively in their heads at this age anyway but just cannot express to adults. There's no Anki involved.

We have a grandma caretaker who has the energy for half a day with him and teaches him all this stuff. His afternoon babysitters are very sharp. Like they're expensive, and I've gone through at least 10 babysitters. They all deeply teach the children they've taken care of, and I teach him, and his mom teaches him...

Are you getting it? This is a cultural issue.

Out of the 10 middle class or rich families I know in my community, by comparison, 9 send their kids to daycare; or the family has, shall I say, a kind of nanny that does not value education at all. These are equally educated and distinguished people as my wife and I. The one exception like us, while the parents are very gifted and the child is obviously thriving, the reason they chose not to use the typical, let's say California nanny or daycare situation, is for an ultimately very rare and fringe reason.

People here are going to litigate these specific methods. Dude, go watch what daycare is like for a 1y6m-3y11m. Do you comprehend what an utter shitbox of a time wasting experience it is, and how 1-2 parents per child isn't at all comparable to 4 children per daycarist? I think you agree with me, but Larry Sanger could have definitely nonetheless set back his precocious children through some very common, mindnumbingly stupid experiences adults subject their kids to for the first 2-3 years of their life.

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by AuryGlenz on Monday November 27, 2023 @01:48AM (#38429029)
I don’t think my daughter socializing with other children is a “shitbox of a time wasting experience.”

She enjoys it and learns a lot just being around older children. Probably more importantly, so far it seems she’s on the path to being an extrovert when my wife and I are both introverts that aren’t great at social situations. I think that will probably put her further ahead in life than learning to read or do math a year early.

Also, she only gets to be 2 once.

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by newaccount74 on Monday November 27, 2023 @12:32AM (#38428496)
I tried to teach my kids reading when they were 3, after hearing about early readers on HN. I gave up after a few attempts because they didn't seem to grasp the difference between the letters I started with. I felt like they just weren't ready.
Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by Foobar8568 on Monday November 27, 2023 @01:29AM (#38428919)
Daughter is highly intelligent (everyone says their kids is super, marvelous, gifted until they met her, then they never use these words with me...), I don't remember when she actually started reading but within 2 weeks she could decipher any text (phonic base learning, less than 20min a day), I think she was 3 and a half.

Until that point, she was interested by "reading", "writings" etc but clearly not ready : I was showing the first phonic in the book ( sssss sound ), and she would just say something else, yet I was sure she could recognize words.

So don't blame yourself, a kid is ready when he wants, just expose him to books, read for him etc.

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by lelanthran on Monday November 27, 2023 @12:37AM (#38428543)
> I tried to teach my kids reading when they were 3, after hearing about early readers on HN. I gave up after a few attempts because they didn't seem to grasp the difference between the letters I started with. I felt like they just weren't ready.

More likely that they were ready, and you weren't :-)

It's important to establish the routine and to never deviate from it. It's also important to ensure that the child never interrupts the lesson with something distracting (I always say "We're still in the lesson, we will look at that in a few minutes"). This is important, I found, as once you reach a specific tempo/cadence during a lesson, you don't want to disrupt that tempo.

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by AuryGlenz on Monday November 27, 2023 @01:21AM (#38428857)
Unless you absolutely force them, their interest is a huge factor in what they’ll learn. I started to read when I was 2 (presumably late 2), and my parents did nothing special but read to me. I just wanted to read, I was really into it, and I was able to associate the letters with the sounds.
Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by lelanthran on Monday November 27, 2023 @01:23AM (#38428867)
> Unless you absolutely force them, their interest is a huge factor in what they’ll learn.

Whether you like it or not, at some point you are going to absolutely force them to learn something. Whether that is by sending them to a school, or teaching them yourself.

Most children would rather not spend time on a lesson if they could spend that time playing.

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by Foobar8568 on Monday November 27, 2023 @01:30AM (#38428923)
Incorrect, it depends of the value you pass down to your kids.
Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by lelanthran on Monday November 27, 2023 @01:46AM (#38429016)
> Incorrect, it depends of the value you pass down to your kids.

At some point, they will be unwilling to listen to you, so you have to enforce something or else you won't be passing down any values to them.

Kids don't magically know what is best for them. What we do is we force a routine until it becomes routine and then you don't have to force it anymore.

Brushing teeth? Some nights/mornings the kid will simply say no. Wearing clothes? Sometimes your toddler will simply say no. Eating veggies? Sometimes your kid will simply say no.

Whatever you do to get them to change their mind (cajoling, threatening, bribing) is, exactly, forcing your will on the child.

There is no such thing as raising a child without having to enforce some rules.

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by viraptor on Monday November 27, 2023 @06:45AM (#38431162)
Kind of true, but also, what is a game and what is a lesson/chore is a very fuzzy line. My 2yo spent a long time picking up tree clippings and putting them into the bin, because it was fun and he could wear oversized gloves. Was it work/learning, yes. Was it play, also yes. The trend of gamification is trying to maximise that effect in many scenarios.
Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by lelanthran on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @01:59AM (#38443182)
We try to make everything a game ("Let's see who can remain quietest the longest"), but even the slowest child sooner or later tires of a particular game. This is why I say make it a routine, not a game, because then it's a given, not a negotiation.

So, sure, you can make it a game to brush teeth each night, but then you have problems the night that the kid want's to play a different game with the toothbrush.

Making it a routine avoids that problem altogether.

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by AuryGlenz on Monday November 27, 2023 @12:07PM (#38434876)
True. I just question doing it (too much) at such an early age, if only because every time they play when they're 2 years old they're also probably learning as well. Just last night my daughter was putting Hotwheels down a ramp in different ways, trying to do 2 at once, etc.
Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by lelanthran on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @02:10AM (#38443242)
Sure, but I'm not advocating for "too much".

My toddler has a routine - everyday we have a lesson at a particular point in time. No exceptions.

But ... I use my discretion. The minute he gets bored, or fidgety, or stops paying attention during the lesson (assuming that he wasn't so before the lesson), I end the lesson. I also change up the lesson plan if he seems (prior to even starting the lesson) irritable or in the wrong mood - "Today we are going to draw a picture of a car/toy/garden/etc".

This means that some days our lesson is 5m, some days it goes on for 40m (reare, but it happens), some days we learn to read something, some days we simply stroll in the garden examining bugs and the different colors they come in, some days we learn to write new words.

It's not a game[1] to him, it's a lesson, and it's not the lesson that's important, it's the routine. My intention is not primarily to teach him, it's to normalise the concept of homework before he reaches the point that he gets given any.

And, yeah, the routine is initially forced. Just like brushing teeth. Or bedtime. Or eating vegetables. After a week or too, there's no longer any actual bribing, cajoling, pleading or threatening going on to make him come to the lesson room.

Now, it just happens. Without the initial enforcement, things like lessons, brushing of teeth, baths, etc just wouldn't happen, so even the most progressive minded parent is still going to have to enforce stuff on the kid, whether they like to think of themselves as a non-forceful parent or not.

[1] Games are negotiable, games are optional, games are always fun, games are played at any time. Don't make the mistake of letting the child think of the lessons as a game; it makes it difficult to enforce the routine later. Instead, make the lesson fun, while making sure that the child does not confuse it with "game".

And yes, this is my second child. Calling lessons/learning a game really was an eye-opener for me with the first child.

Re:Spaced repetition for teaching two-year olds how to read by vlovich123 on Monday November 27, 2023 @12:56AM (#38428681)
Usually the problem isn't the kids but the parents. Educating a child that young is a lot of 1:1 work that takes up a lot of time (like many hours a day spaced with breaks in between) & unless you extract joy and satisfaction from seeing a child master basic skills for the first time, you're probably not going to be good at it. There's also logistical difficulties accomplishing that when you have two people working full time.