This is the golden advice. Never, ever speak to anyone about anything important if they contacted you. Call, text, email, whatever. End it and you contact them.
It doesn’t matter if it’s the bank, power company or telco. Even if HR called me or the CEO. Hang up, call them back. It adds 5 seconds to ensure all is good
Depends on the bank.
Some make it almost impossible to get past their IVR, which always claims to be able to help you with any issues you might have (as long as the issue is wanting to know your balance and last three transactions).
This bears repeating. It's so simple to check in using another known-good contact method, and btw phone calls are still cool.
Not to large corporations. Have you called one lately?
It's a minimum of five minutes of bartering, begging and pleading with the IVR to let you speak to a human, and even then a successful outcome is anything but guaranteed.
The confirmation bias is real!
This has become increasingly difficult in my experience. Where calling the local branch I have the actual relationship is just dumped into the IVR. They make it very hard to speak to an actual human being bank employee.
[1]: or something like that, I forget the exact words
If they are behind an annoying IVR they usually know how to get back to themselves.
Of course don't take their word on what number to call, make them point to a part of their website that shows the number.
https://security.stackexchange.com/questions/100268/does-han...
So try to call the bank from a mobile.
Its not really weird if you look at it in context.
People who are not Gen-Z whipper-snappers will recall the era.
Before cell phones, before DECT home phones, before wireless cordless home phones you had fixed phones.
You had a master socket and then, optionally, one or more secondary sockets (depending where you lived, you were either permitted to install these secondary sockets yourself, or you had to call in the telco to do it).
Anyway, so what would happen is that your friend from school would call you up. Inevitably your parent would answer the phone because they were, for example, in the kitchen cooking your dinner.
There would then be a shout across the house "Bobby its Johnny ... AGAIN !".
The call-transfer process would involve your parent hanging up and you picking up the nearest secondary handset.
Hence the exchange needed to keep the A-end of the call live whilst you completed the B-end "transfer".
The same generation of people will also recall the ability to abuse the mechanism to quietly spy on someone else using the phone. :)
"Called Subscriber Held", a feature that was carried into early digital exchanges because people expected it to work in the manner you describe, even though afaik it was designed for the other purpose of keeping the line open whilst operators patched it through, trunk lines picked up the tone, etc.
My grandpa was a something like chief engineer for the West Coast of Scotland phone network. I have so many questions I wish I could ask him these days.
Remember it used to be a switched physical circuit. In the early days the switching was done by people, later it was automated. But you still had a circuit from phone to phone.
When one side hung up, the circuit is still live. Eventually it timed out and the switch disconnected it, but it took a while (don't remember how long). So you could hang up a phone, walk to a different room and pick up another phone and the same call circuit was still live (as long as the other side didn't also hang up meanwhile).
If the dial tone is heard at all, it is for a very brief period, and might be entirely missed. This would make the scam you're describing even more readily achieved.
... the autodial feature may well be waiting for dialtone in order to dial. I've not looked into this and you're probably best off testing this yourself on your own equipment.
Honestly, I’m not sure it matters. They’ve all had such incidents. I read somewhere that about 30% of your fees and mortgage interest go toward fraud mitigation,monitoring, and restitution.
I always live by these rules
- call them back, don’t talk to them
- ask why you need to do anything. It’s exceedingly rare a bank would call you to do something legit there and then. “I will do it later” will help. In fact that’s how I caught the phisher as I noted the aggravation in 1% of his voice.
- use credit cards, not debit cards, for purchases. They have far more protection.
- use all the 2FA and password complexity you can
- never use real info for challenge questions. Never use maiden name of mother etc. you can put “14 green fish” as the answer to the question if you like.
- make sure they are FSCS regulated, and try not to exceed that limit.
- understand FSCS does not cover you most phishing attempts, since the bank will claim they tried to warn you and were not negligent
- use private tabs for bank interactions
Through this experience I have learned not to trust “what we know about you” information they share. Do not underestimate HUMINT. A bank snitch could give up something as seemingly innocent (to them) as your “join date” and it be a lynchpin piece of info for a scammer.
This may all seem obvious to an HM reader. But it’s worth refreshing and reiterating.
The law already is that they should report breaches to the ICO, at a minimum you should report this to the ICO and if you can you should name the bank, possibly right here in this thread so that others have a chance to find out. It's a throwaway so why not use it?
Louder for the folks in the back. All bank cards should be required to print this on them.
1. "Did you make these purchases?"
2. "Yes" -> "Thanks, bye."
3. "No" -> "Thanks, we're disabling your card, and sending a new one to your address. If your address has changed, please pick it up at the branch."
Any deviation from this is a scammer posing as the fraud department. Any attempt to gather any information from you, besides 'Did you make these purchases?' is a scam.
They know who you are, if they didn't, they wouldn't be calling you.
It is clear the bank has had a severe exfiltration event. There are other reports online.
Through the process I learned that in the UK you can call 159 to directly contact your bank fraud dept (most banks) https://stopscamsuk.org.uk/159
I also learnt about the police’s Action Fraud hotline to report cybercrime. https://www.actionfraud.police.uk/what-is-action-fraud
The phisher was very determined. They called back in 15 minutes claiming to be from the bank fraud dept returning my call. Then 2 weeks later they called back claiming to be from Action Fraud.
However prepared you think you are for such an attack, my advice is to have utmost caution for every single call from anyone claiming to be anyone.
I also have a Monzo account. Even if they called me I wouldn’t use this. Hang up. Call them. Don’t let them call you.