News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reflecting on 18 Years at Google by paxys on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:11PM (#38382816)
Every bit of innovation in the AI space today originated at Google. The company poured probably tens of billions into its Brain division, sponsored and made public every bit of research, and pretty much created the field of modern AI. So what was the outcome? When the employees realized they had struck gold they figured they'd rather go join startups or found their own companies instead, because regardless of the amount of success they achieved at Google they would never 1000x the share price or be the ones calling the shots.

This example is the perfect microcosm of the economics of innovation at large companies. Google/Microsoft/Apple/Amazon and the like have zero incentive to continue to be the companies they were 20 years ago. They don't need to take risks. They don't need to disrupt anything. They instead need leaders like Pichai who will keep the ship steady and keep the shareholders happy, and will keep investing in or purchasing smaller companies that are either a threat or an opportunity for growth, all while keeping their existing revenue streams flowing.

If as an employee you are nostalgic about the "culture" in the early days of such a company then you should realize that it is not coming back, just like the carefree days of your own childhood aren't coming back. Quit and join a smaller company instead.

Re:Reflecting on 18 Years at Google by chubot on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:34PM (#38383154)
Not disagreeing with your larger point, but Google paid $40M+ for the 3 people from U Toronto responsible for AlexNet (according to Cade Metz's book).

Google might deserve more credit than any other company, but there were 20-30 years of innovation at universities beforehand.

Re:Reflecting on 18 Years at Google by foobiekr on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @07:22PM (#38387374)
more like 50
Re:Reflecting on 18 Years at Google by kelnos on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @02:05PM (#38383617)
> Every bit of innovation in the AI space today originated at Google. The company poured probably tens of billions into its Brain division, sponsored and made public every bit of research, and pretty much created the field of modern AI. So what was the outcome? When the employees realized they had struck gold they figured they'd rather go join startups or found their own companies instead, because regardless of the amount of success they achieved at Google they would never 1000x the share price or be the ones calling the shots.

And that's a pretty strong indictment of Google! Googlers who worked on this research and technology believed that they'd have a better chance of doing something life-changing and making some bank outside of Google! While that isn't all that uncommon, it's also something Google could have taken steps to prevent. Better culture, better compensation. It's a huge risk to strike out on your own with something like this; Google could have made it both safer and more lucrative (or at least lucrative enough) to stay. But they didn't.

> If as an employee you are nostalgic about the "culture" in the early days of such a company then you should realize that it is not coming back, just like the carefree days of your own childhood aren't coming back. Quit and join a smaller company instead.

Couldn't agree more. Our brand of capitalism isn't set up to allow for such corporate-culture time travel.

Re:Reflecting on 18 Years at Google by away271828 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @02:38PM (#38384034)
Just the other week had a team meeting that was partly to discuss a possible round 21 of team charter/organization changes. Personally, I basically have bounced around multiple rounds of managers/teams/responsibilities in just the past few years. As the team lead philosophically said, many of you (senior) folks have seen maybe 10x employee growth since you joined and it's just a different company and the old one isn't coming back.
Re:Reflecting on 18 Years at Google by paxys on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @02:47PM (#38384170)
It's not an indictment of Google but every large company in existence. That's just how our current corporate structure works, and is the reason entrepreneurship is a thing.
Re:Reflecting on 18 Years at Google by mepiethree on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:16PM (#38384536)
Yeah, and the other side of the coin is that there are tons and tons of people who left Google to pursue their passions and failed. And the third side of the coin is that there are many people who invented things within Google, were successful in doing so, and have stayed (e.g. Google Meet)
Re:Reflecting on 18 Years at Google by thethethethe on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @05:02PM (#38385779)
> many people who invented things within Google, were successful in doing so, and have stayed

Yeah there are tons of people like this that are L7-L8 collecting around 1M TC. You'll always have a boss but you can carve out a little kingdom for yourself, which is much more appealing to more risk adverse people than starting or joining a startup

Re:Reflecting on 18 Years at Google by com2kid on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @06:08PM (#38386507)
> And that's a pretty strong indictment of Google! Googlers who worked on this research and technology believed that they'd have a better chance of doing something life-changing and making some bank outside of Google! While that isn't all that uncommon, it's also something Google could have taken steps to prevent. Better culture, better compensation. It's a huge risk to strike out on your own with something like this; Google could have made it both safer and more lucrative (or at least lucrative enough) to stay. But they didn't.

For a while Microsoft was infamous for having talented engineers leave, found a startup, and then MS acquiring that startup for a lot of money.

It was, in hindsight, a really great system that worked out well for everyone involved.

Re:Reflecting on 18 Years at Google by sdenton4 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @07:23PM (#38387384)
And then commenters will complain that the company doesn't make anything, and just acquires good ideas...
Re:Reflecting on 18 Years at Google by nvrmnd on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @02:39PM (#38384038)
While it's easy to agree with you, I find that my opinion here has shifted after leaving a large tech company for a seed stage startup. Competing against these giant companies is really challenging, you have to me more than 2x better to get a customer to look at you a second time.
Re:Reflecting on 18 Years at Google by downWidOutaFite on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:40PM (#38383256)
Google is getting beat badly on multiple fronts, even Search, and has pissed away a mountain of goodwill. It's living off of declining 15 year old achievements. I wouldn't call Sundar a steady hand, he has destroyed much more potential than he has created, even if the stock has continued to go up it won't for much longer. I sold a significant position in GOOG a few years ago and I'm certain it was the right call.
Re:Reflecting on 18 Years at Google by paxys on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:43PM (#38383309)
They are getting "beat badly" only if you read tech blogs and not their financial statements.
Re:Reflecting on 18 Years at Google by bane on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:14PM (#38384508)
Microsoft under Balmer did great financially IIR.
Re:Reflecting on 18 Years at Google by paxys on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:37PM (#38384758)
Their stock price was flat for a decade, so no. The company was a wreck financially under Ballmer.
Re:Reflecting on 18 Years at Google by izacus on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @05:55PM (#38386349)
Yeah, and they're still around, relevant and profitable. What's your point?
Re:Reflecting on 18 Years at Google by bborud on Thursday November 23, 2023 @02:40PM (#38396642)
No thanks to Ballmer.
Re:Reflecting on 18 Years at Google by downWidOutaFite on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:57PM (#38383529)
Like I said, I put my money where my mouth is. GOOG's monopoly-fueled glory days will soon be behind it. In tech, if you stand still for too long you will eventually be left behind.
Re:Reflecting on 18 Years at Google by arlongparker on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @05:58PM (#38386380)
Crazy you think that the company who invests the most in AI won’t retain any value in the transition to the space.

People forget. Who owns kaggle, who owns Google collab. Boggles my mind that people think a few AI upshot’s are going to reap all the value. Having a good AI companion that’s integrated into all your suite of tools. That’s the peak.

Re:Reflecting on 18 Years at Google by bbor on Thursday November 23, 2023 @01:40PM (#38395982)
Google colab is ludicrously underfunded, I’m shocked it’s stuck around for so long in the AI space. Tried Gradient recently and it’s like night and day. I can’t imagine how hard it must be to be on the colab team, knowing what features devs want/need and not being able to deliver because the org priorities are whack
Re:Reflecting on 18 Years at Google by infoseek12 on Thursday November 23, 2023 @02:14PM (#38396331)
> Crazy you think that the company who invests the most in AI won’t retain any value in the transition to the space.

They’ll obviously retain some value. Google can integrate more easily and seamlessly with things people are using but that’s a competitive advantage not a moat.

Google’s trajectory has been from innovative market maker, to dominant market leader, to megacorp that has a strong established position that keeps them competitive and relevant, to legacy provider, to kind of irrelevant.

Google’s still strong and significant but every day they are less so.

Re:Reflecting on 18 Years at Google by rr808 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @08:50PM (#38388178)
> When the employees realized they had struck gold they figured they'd rather go join startups or found their own companies instead

Ironically every AI person I know works on some dumb project with the goal they'll eventually get to work in Google/Meta for the big bucks. Maybe that is just a stepping stone.

Re:Reflecting on 18 Years at Google by berkes on Thursday November 23, 2023 @07:24AM (#38391998)
> Every bit of innovation in the AI space today originated at Google.

It all originated at universities.