News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by mrweasel on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:14AM (#38365614)
Why on earth would Google even suggest such a deal? To get the 4% on the payments made via the Play Store? That seems rather desperate.

4% isn't an amazing deal on payments from Spotifys point of view, and 10% for Netflix seems like in insult for processing payments. Normal payment processors are closer to 1.5 - 2%.

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by eitally on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @12:03PM (#38366424)
Spotify is a long time Google Cloud customer, from the days when Google was essentially buying logos, so it would not at all surprise me to find out that the Play Store deal was tied to a massive GCP commit from Spotify (much like Niantic from the same era). In fact, i wouldn't be surprised if some of the more recent gaming signs from the Cloud business don't also have discount deals with Play.

It's a pretty impressive list of publishers, actually (scroll to bottom): https://cloud.google.com/solutions/games

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by chatmasta on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @12:24PM (#38366794)
I'm not an anti-trust lawyer (or any kind of lawyer), but this feels illegal. It would be one thing if big GCP customers were getting discounts on GCP services in exchange for large commitments. But the Play Store is - at least ostensibly - a separate business from GCP. Receiving discounts in one should not require spending in the other...
Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by willsmith72 on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:16AM (#38365639)
the closed gardens of mobile app stores don't have the regular healthy market competition that normal payment processors do. it's one of my least favourite parts of building for mobile
Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by mrweasel on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:21AM (#38365717)
I'm just questioning the point in offering a "deal" like this to Spotify, when Spotify can just handle their own payments for less. Is those 4% really worth that much to Google that it's outways the risk of others being made aware of how little payments actually cost Google to run.

Now that Netflix knows that Spotify pay 4%, why would they ever agree to anything more?

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by hutzlibu on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:44AM (#38366110)
"Now that Netflix knows that Spotify pay 4%, why would they ever agree to anything more? "

I would suspect, they have a special deal as well.

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by freedomben on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:26AM (#38365780)
This clearly wasn't intended to get out, and predicting that Epic would file suit and then it would leak out of the court would be a hard reason to argue against trying to negotiate business in the moment.
Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by agloe_dreams on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:25AM (#38365771)
I don't think you understand that over at Apple, not paying the 30% is not being on iPhone..period. Not being on the play store is not being on Android for 90% of customers. This is why both are facing major antitrust cases.
Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by mrweasel on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:29AM (#38365822)
Aaah, okay, I was under the impression that you could actually be present on the Play Store as a subscription service and just handle your own payments and that would be perfectly acceptable.

But that makes the deal even weirder, Spotify doesn't have a choice, yet they have a completely insane deal.

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by agloe_dreams on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:32AM (#38365880)
No Spotify = No Pixel Sales.
Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by ogreswamp on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @12:39PM (#38366952)
That is simply not true. You can easily set account creation and payment on your website for "reader apps" if you're not willing to share 30/15% with Apple. (and Spotify & Netflix qualify as reader apps). Apple even allows you to put a link to your website for account creation right in the app (they didn't allow that in the past).

https://developer.apple.com/support/reader-apps

Many companies (like Google) move Apple's subscription fee to end users, so don't feel too pity about them. Just compare YouTube premium cost as an in-app purchase and on the website. €15.99 vs €11.99 here in Ireland.

Google had a choice not to offer the YouTube subscription as IAP and just link people to the website. But the conversion rate for IAP is way higher compared to the website link, so they just punish their users, who pay €4 extra every month.

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by agloe_dreams on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @03:53PM (#38369943)
Reader apps are an extremely specific clause, mostly related to their Ebook price fixing lawsuit. Zero of the apps in discussion here are reader apps.

I should also note, that up until recently, Apple specifically had clauses that you couldn't have the link to the website bit AND they had a 'you can't pass the price onto customers' rule.

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by ogreswamp on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @07:47PM (#38372969)
Reader apps is quite wide category. It includes pretty much all types of content - ebooks, videos, audio etc. Spotify and Netflix falls under it afaik.
Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by agloe_dreams on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:56AM (#38380063)
I have no idea what world you think you live in..but Apple has pretty clearly defined it mostly as Email and Ebook reading. Zero music or video services have ever gotten an exception. Spotify and Netflix have different exceptions called 'backroom deals' that allow them to have an unfair advantage over smaller players.
Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by willsmith72 on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @01:18PM (#38367659)
Most apps aren't reader apps, that's a very special (and relatively new) rule
Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by ogreswamp on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @07:48PM (#38372988)
You're correct, most of apps aren’t. But the subject app Spotify falls under it.
Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by jsnell on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:40AM (#38366019)
Netflix currently pay 0%, getting them to agree to 4% sounds like a pretty good deal.
Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by aalimov_ on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:39AM (#38366006)
While you may have a point about competition, comparing credit card processors and app stores solely on fee structure doesn’t make for an honest comparison because you get to ignore all the other things they do.
Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by bushbaba on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:29AM (#38365841)
Normal payment processors don’t need to maintain the os ecosystem. Arguably Google needs to do the same work as a traditional payment processor AND much more.
Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by bogwog on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:34AM (#38365933)
> Arguably Google needs to do the same work as a traditional payment processor

Unarguably, they don't need to do that. They want to, because a monopoly on payment processing makes a lot of money.

If 4%/15%/30%/whatever is what Google needs to charge to run their payment processing business, that shows that they're extremely inefficient/incompetent, and the market would be more efficient if other companies were able to offer that service instead. Last I checked, Stripe charges 2.9%, which is even less than what Google charges Spotify in this unicorn deal.

EDIT: the same goes for "store infrastructure" or whatever. If Google offered publishers the option to run their own infrastructure for distributing apps/updates/whatever, everyone would take that deal rather than pay Google's nonsense fees.

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by freedomben on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:39AM (#38366013)
Even 2.9% (which is what card payment processors charge as well) is ludicrously high. They make a very, very healthy profit margin with that. One of my greatest disappointments about cryptocurrencies is that they didn't destroy that ridiculousness.
Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by thallium205 on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @01:28PM (#38367867)
The money largely funds consumer protection products such as when chargebacks have to be executed on fraudulent or other disputed transactions on your card. Zero liability guarantees that the card network infrastructure offers consumers come at a cost which is found here. Think of it as an insurance policy paid on every transaction which explains why it has to be a %.

Crypto offers no protections so no fees need to be taken.

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by brookst on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:43AM (#38366065)
Characterizing app store fees as purely for payment processing is so disingenuous it's hard to even engage.

The reality is these fees are for access to an audience. Google spends a lot of money developing Android and creating a storefront that huge numbers of people see every day.

Casting that as "payment processing fees" is like complaining it's outrageous for a farmer's market to charge $200/day for a 10x10 booth because 100sf of parking lot can be had for $10/day somewhere else: you have to willfully misunderstand the business for the argument to make any sense.

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by bogwog on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @12:05PM (#38366453)
I wasn't trying to say that those fees are only for payment processing.

Anyways, to your point about audience: That's BS. The reason Google Play is the dominant store definitely has a lot to do with that, because nobody is going to publish on "My Awesome Android Store" if it doesn't have users. However, the reason they have that audience is because of their anticompetitive tactics. It's all a cycle that feeds into itself, and it's how they're able to become the only game in town and charge literally whatever they want.

Epic has the ability and resources to potentially build a store with enough of an audience to attract more developers and compete with Google Play, but it won't happen as long as Google is allowed to continue acting anti-competitively.

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by freedomben on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:52AM (#38366228)
I'm not GP, but that's a really good point and one to keep in mind.

I suppose the question is, did the farmers market threaten all the other land owners if they allowed a competing farmers market to open up? Or throw metaphorical wrenches in the way to a competitor?

Google's exclusivity agreement makes it much harder for alternatives to emerge. Even with this though, I get that they are funding open source development and need to protect it somehow lest it be stolen (cough by Amazon cough) and made a competing platform. I'm quite unsure where the balance should be.

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by vkou on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @12:05PM (#38366450)
Your analogy is poor.

App store monopolies aren't built on threats. A mall giving an anchor retailer a sweetheart deal isn't threatening nearby malls.

They are, however, built on economies of scale.

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @12:41PM (#38367002)
They're built on excluding competition.

App stores, like payment processors, have economies of scale in the sense that you need a critical mass of users to sign up for them and trust them with their payment info, so you're not going to have a thousand of them, but you could certainly have a dozen. At which point they would have to compete on things like fees and keep each other in check.

But not if each platform has only a single dominant payment processor.

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by freedomben on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @12:49PM (#38367133)
I don't agree the analogy is poor.

Unless I'm mistaken, Google has made threats, such as "if you include a competing app store, then you don't get any of the google apps, google play services, etc, and you can't use the Android trademark.

We saw in the early 00s a proliferation of "Android" devices that didn't have the Play store, and they were mostly DOA

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by vkou on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @01:40PM (#38368047)
An unwillingness to co-operate is not generally considered a threat.

> and they were mostly DOA

Maybe those stores should have invested a few dozen billion dollars in building up a comprehensive first-party app ecosystem that made them attractive to users.

Economies of scale, and all. Nobody's going to your farmer's market, because everyone's going to the mall that has a Walmart.

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @12:36PM (#38366903)
> The reality is these fees are for access to an audience.

This is called a monopoly rent and is the sort of thing antitrust law is intended to prevent, when it's working properly.

> Google spends a lot of money developing Android and creating a storefront that huge numbers of people see every day.

Google gives Android away for free. They choose to do that, and if they didn't then it would lose to a competitor that did, because operating systems are a classic example of somewhere that free software works in the absence of anti-competitive behavior. If Google didn't develop Android then Samsung and Amazon and Canonical and Mozilla would do it, and parts of it would be more like Debian, which would be better.

> Casting that as "payment processing fees" is like complaining it's outrageous for a farmer's market to charge $200/day for a 10x10 booth because 100sf of parking lot can be had for $10/day somewhere else: you have to willfully misunderstand the business for the argument to make any sense.

Does the farmer's market also take actions to interfere with you being able to build your own storefront?

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by freedomben on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:37AM (#38365977)
Your comment doesn't deserve the downvotes (which are supposed to be about whether a comment is good/substantive, not the reactionary "I disagree with this" that it's become) so I upvoted it to balance.

You are of course right that there is more work involved beyond a traditional payment processor. However, 30% of everything?? Even the standard 3% that payment processors take is ridiclously high. It's rent-seeking all around.

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by kmeisthax on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @12:50PM (#38367158)
So, uh... I hate to break it to you, but payment processing is almost as monopolized as mobile app stores are. The fees are not as egregiously high as 30%, but they are still supracompetitive and eat up retailer margins. Payment processing even has similar censorship problems, as evidenced by the campaigns to defund porn companies by cutting them off of payment networks.
Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by agloe_dreams on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:24AM (#38365747)
Because the deal usually is 30%. Negotiating a good rate won't happen when one side says "Make a deal or we keep you out". Google's rate is a 'slice of a watermelon vs all of a grape' angle. Both parties probably worked over the advantages that all your Google payment customers would have one-click subscribe. Google knew they held some of the cards and Spotify knew that going off-play store would harm subs while also harming Google.
Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by ethbr1 on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:45AM (#38366121)
Spotify's size and consequences of not being on the Play Store are exactly why Google would do this.

Google gives no shits if random app developer isn't on Play. And so holds firm on their cut.

Play without Spotify makes a lot of users ask "Why isn't Spotify on Play?" And probably follow-up with "How do I get Spotify? Download another app store? Okay, I'll do that."

So essentially, the money that Google ceded to Spotify was approximately what they thought discouraging users from installing alternate app stores was worth.

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by kleton on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:47AM (#38366151)
Shopify signed a very large and long term GCP contract a while back.
Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by abxytg on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:21AM (#38365712)
Are you serious? The app store standard cut is like 30%.
Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by mrweasel on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:26AM (#38365783)
Processing credit/debit- cards isn't that expensive, 30% is a joke, even if you try to justify it with by saying that it helps pay for the store infrastructure.

Spotify pays no feed to Google when they handle the payment processing themself, via some credit card processor and honestly why the hell should they. So Google decide that in an attempt to get even the tiniest amount of payments to go through them, they'd drop the price to 4%... Why is that so important to them?

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by alwa on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:48AM (#38366172)
I believe the article cited 15% rather than 30% for subscriptions, or 11% if you process your own payments. So [.15, .11] —> [.04, .00], or an overall discount of 11% off subscription revenue they take through the platform.

It sounded to me that, in exchange for that favorable per-subscription rate, Spotify paid $50,000,000 into a “success fund,” whatever that means. $50mm / .11 = $454mm... sounds like they’re basically paying the equivalent of Play Store commission on half a billion’s worth of revenue, without any guarantee that they’ll actually be able to sell that much new growth through Play Store. That feels like sharing the risk in a way that isn’t too out of the domain of reason.

From [0], they added about $2bn in revenue year-on-year in 2022. Although we don’t know the term of this Play Store agreement (or what a “success fund” is), paying an amount equivalent to the normal commission on 1/5 of that total annual growth figure seems like a pretty nontrivial amount to commit.

[0] https://www.businessofapps.com/data/spotify-statistics/

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by Spivak on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @01:07PM (#38367475)
They aren't charging the fee for payment processing, they're collecting the fee via payment processing. I don't understand why people keep making this mistake. Hell even Epic made it and lost horribly when they made it. The fee is a sales commission, you pay it because you want access to the customer base. They are allowed to deliver you literally nothing at all in additional services and still charge you a fee.

The other stuff they provide exists to sweeten the deal.

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by conductr on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @01:16PM (#38367619)
30% is because most transactions, early on, were around $1. And processing fees are usually $0.25 + ~3% = so 28% of the average transaction.

When you start applying that 30% to $15 spotify subs, $50 uber rides, $60 video game, then a bunch of in-app purchases ranging in value; the math falls apart and if you have scale to do it, the negotiated rate makes more sense for those businesses given the average transaction amount.

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by astrange on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @04:45PM (#38370712)
It's 15% now. 30% is only for especially large apps.
Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by ehsankia on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @12:22PM (#38366748)
app stores do a lot more than payment processors though. Maybe not 30% worth, but definitely mote than 1-2%.

The real issue though is that there isn't a good way to handle every app. In a normal world, every app would cost money to buy, and they would only be charged on the purchase prize. But in a world where most apps are free and then there are in-app purchases, there isn't really any other way for those to be monetized but to take a cut of transactions. But obviously these things don't scale the same.

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by littlecranky67 on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @12:24PM (#38366792)
> Why on earth would Google even suggest such a deal?

To prevent Spotify from filing more EU antitrust complaints as they did for the Apple Appstore? [0].

Plus, 4% sounds low, but nominally 4% from all Spotify subscriptions on Android with their imense user base is a very large sum compared to any minor 2-3 person App studio that is charged 20-30%.

[0]: https://www.fastcompany.com/90836299/spotify-vs-apple-eu-app...

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by fomine3 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:10AM (#38375314)
Apple and Google virtually want to be a government in digital content area. 30% is a tax. I understand that something like government work (like operating infra and moderation) is needed in app store, but I don't want two California based companies to be a global government.