News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by freedomben on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:52AM (#38366228)
I'm not GP, but that's a really good point and one to keep in mind.

I suppose the question is, did the farmers market threaten all the other land owners if they allowed a competing farmers market to open up? Or throw metaphorical wrenches in the way to a competitor?

Google's exclusivity agreement makes it much harder for alternatives to emerge. Even with this though, I get that they are funding open source development and need to protect it somehow lest it be stolen (cough by Amazon cough) and made a competing platform. I'm quite unsure where the balance should be.

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by vkou on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @12:05PM (#38366450)
Your analogy is poor.

App store monopolies aren't built on threats. A mall giving an anchor retailer a sweetheart deal isn't threatening nearby malls.

They are, however, built on economies of scale.

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @12:41PM (#38367002)
They're built on excluding competition.

App stores, like payment processors, have economies of scale in the sense that you need a critical mass of users to sign up for them and trust them with their payment info, so you're not going to have a thousand of them, but you could certainly have a dozen. At which point they would have to compete on things like fees and keep each other in check.

But not if each platform has only a single dominant payment processor.

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by freedomben on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @12:49PM (#38367133)
I don't agree the analogy is poor.

Unless I'm mistaken, Google has made threats, such as "if you include a competing app store, then you don't get any of the google apps, google play services, etc, and you can't use the Android trademark.

We saw in the early 00s a proliferation of "Android" devices that didn't have the Play store, and they were mostly DOA

Re:Google admits Spotify pays no Play Store fees because of ... by vkou on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @01:40PM (#38368047)
An unwillingness to co-operate is not generally considered a threat.

> and they were mostly DOA

Maybe those stores should have invested a few dozen billion dollars in building up a comprehensive first-party app ecosystem that made them attractive to users.

Economies of scale, and all. Nobody's going to your farmer's market, because everyone's going to the mall that has a Walmart.