News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by vouaobrasil on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @06:21AM (#38362187)
Blogging is writing something to change minds. Twitter is harrassing other people to change their minds.
Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by SekstiNi on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @06:49AM (#38362405)
I've seen this sentiment echoed a lot, and I find it somewhat perplexing as my own twitter experience has been mostly pleasant.

Do people simply not bother curating their follows?

Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by xanderlewis on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @07:50AM (#38362967)
It has become harder and harder to do so, because Twitter (in its default state) now insists on inserting brain-meltingly lowbrow content in between every other post from someone you actually follow. And adverts for low quality iPhone games that are themselves also simply platforms for further adverts.
Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by qzx_pierri on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @08:33AM (#38363372)
This is no longer true. Twitter now has 2 browsing tabs that you can easily swipe between.

The first is a “For you” tab which contains recommended content based on YOUR browsing habits (and a “Not Interested” option to curate, just like Tiktok).

The second tab is a “Following” tab which is strictly tweets from people you follow, in chronological order.

It’s pretty great now. Twitter used to be nothing but quasi activism and rage bait. Now it’s exactly what I envisioned it could’ve been, which is nice.

But stay away from it if you have the reddit mindset of “If I don’t agree with it, it should be banned”, because your feelings will get hurt.

It feels a lot like the internet 10-15 years ago, it’s great.

But I can freely talk about sports and shoot the shit without worrying about triggering an autoban for saying the “badspeak” term or phrase which is currently flavor of the month.

Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by thomasahle on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @10:17AM (#38364749)
Exactly. You can make Twitter what you want. Just never use "For You", unless you hate your time.
Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by xanderlewis on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @10:34AM (#38365011)
I said ‘in its default state’ because although you can try to configure it otherwise it always seems to gravitate back towards being shite. I commend you both for bothering, but I’d rather just use a service that is fundamentally less filled with rubbish. It always feels like fighting a losing battle.
Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by qzx_pierri on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @10:50AM (#38365267)
If you haven’t used it recently, then you wouldn’t understand. But don’t use it if you have such strong feelings about it, it’s still a time sink.

I will say it’s one of the only services of its type that’s no longer a contrived echo chamber though. All opinions can be heard… But only if you seek them.

I’ve posted here before about how I refuse to use Twitter due to its toxicity (in the past), but its recent lack of toxicity has made it very fun and addicting lol

Now, if you’re a positive person who just enjoys tech and cat videos, that’s all you’ll see.

In the past, you could spend hours trying to curate Twitter to be good/positive, but you would still see nonsense.

The biggest improvement is the removal of the feature where completely unrelated content would be pushed into your timeline with a note at the top that said “Your follower [insert follower name] liked this”

So you were at the mercy of what the people you followed also engaged with. Now, you can follow someone who may be on the other end of the political spectrum (who may post cool tweets) - And while you don’t agree with their views on the election, you can still see their tweets without the “Pastor Bob liked this” type post appearing of QAnon bullsh*t.

Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by xanderlewis on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @10:54AM (#38365346)
Well, I’m glad it works for you. My experience is quite the opposite though and it seems like I’m not alone.
Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by oneeyedpigeon on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @07:49AM (#38362955)
It definitely used to be a lot more 'curatable', but in the Musk era, it's become less pleasant on average.
Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by vouaobrasil on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @06:59AM (#38362470)
Well, I think Twitter can actually be a normal place. But the sentiment is about the average, not what it can or can't be.
Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by 0xDEF on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @07:50AM (#38362970)
Even liking a single political post will fill the timeline with blatant political disinfo from the fringes of the political spectrum.

But it was also this bad before Musk.

Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by bryanrasmussen on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @06:27AM (#38362231)
Blogging is developing an argument, Twitter is having an argument.
Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by quickthrower2 on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @06:46AM (#38362369)
Blogging is brain dumping something I thought was interesting I worked on. Slight hope it boosts my career somewhere down the line.
Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by Cthulhu_ on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @07:11AM (#38362577)
Tweeting is brain dumping something while you were drunk. Slight chance it tanks your career somewhere down the line.
Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by kevindamm on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @07:45AM (#38362906)
Blogging is for hit posts, tweeting is for ... something that rhymes with hit posts
Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by philipov on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @09:58AM (#38364457)
You must be thinking of "bit posts", because they're so small :p
Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by quickthrower2 on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @10:41AM (#38365135)
lit posts, quit posts, split posts, nit posts, hiit posts, writ posts, flit posts, reddit posts, whatchamacallit posts …
Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by bryanrasmussen on Thursday November 23, 2023 @01:54AM (#38390130)
it was obviously pit posts, like posts you throw into the everlasting pit of damnation.
Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by orthoxerox on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @08:30AM (#38363342)
No it isn't, to quote Monty Python.

You can't productively argue with someone by splitting your position into 280-character-long bites, each of which can be easily quoted out of context.

Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by brlewis on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @10:10AM (#38364649)
The problem isn't that Twitter is split into small bites. Essays do that with paragraphs and sentences as well. It's that Twitter is not structured in a way conducive to conveying an argument.
Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by bryanrasmussen on Thursday November 23, 2023 @01:53AM (#38390125)
you're not conveying an argument, you're having an argument - which will never be resolved. The best you can hope for is that one of you blocks the other without wasting too many hours of life.
Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by lloydatkinson on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @06:29AM (#38362244)
Don't forget grifting too. Classic example being crypto/nft/dao bullshit.

Then you have devs posting clickbait "hot takes" about the most inane thing you've ever seen or screenshots of code in order to then sell their courses or gain more social influence.

I won't give specific names, but one of these characters rhythms with prime numbers and another rhythms with thesaurus.

Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by ishanhegde on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @06:37AM (#38362308)
I feel more and more disgusted by social media like twitter nowadays. Too much shilling, too much pushing of extereme unhinged ideas, not to mention the crypto bots, and now the only fans, porn bots. You have thousands of popular accounts exaggerating stupid gimmicks like being against seed oils for some reason. There is such an absurd amount of transparent grifting that twitter looks like some sort of fish market.

The moment, twitter added monetization, engagement farming got much worse. Was Social Media always destined to be like this?

Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by JCharante on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @06:42AM (#38362344)
Threads is such an example of this. The first people to sign up to threads wasn't authentic people, it was a bunch of marketing departments going "well, this new social media site is live, we should put our presence on there too" and a bunch of influencers who go "hmm this new platform could be a good way to gain new followers if I post enough content before everybody else gets in on this".

Personallly, I think an anonymous social media could work better. If people view content as content without carying about who published it, then you would get good stuff trending and not a 2am selfie from some random celebrity who at this point is famous for being famous. Brands would also have a hard time because their junk wouldn't get engagement unless it was actually good.

Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by indigochill on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @07:27AM (#38362710)
> Personallly, I think an anonymous social media could work better.

I'm leaning hard in the opposite direction. In my mind, a social network graph that is extremely personal and reflects and behaves like an _actual social network_ is "the way".

I run my own ActivityPub node. There is no reason for anyone to want to join who doesn't know me personally and want to join in just for personal reasons.

Then I federate with nodes that I personally know, not for exposure but because I want to follow their updates and occasionally chat with them about things (e.g. I follow Codeberg because I think what they're doing, particularly with Forgejo, is interesting).

I also _do not_ federate with generic instances like the main Mastodon one because they're not focused/personal enough for my taste (that's where you get the "eh, might as well" crowd").

This does mean I have a low rate of discovery of new stuff, but that's the way real socializing goes as well. Most of your time is spent with people you already know and occasionally either you change contexts and meet someone new or your existing actual social network introduces you to someone new.

That said, there are different use cases for social networks which is more the "publishing" angle that needs a much broader but shallower network (probably same for discovery which is probably just the other side of publishing). I haven't thought as much about these use cases, but it seems necessarily fraught because once you get to publishing, bad actors get interested, even (/especially?) if it's anonymous. I'm not sure there is a solution to that problem.

Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by skydhash on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @08:20AM (#38363266)
Also leaning in the personal direction. The only Meta product I use is WhatsApp (bad telecom services) and status updates from your contacts is interesting enough because you know everyone.

Focused and text based platforms like Reddit’s subreddit and HN are also nice as long as you have moderation that keeps things civil. And no user specific algorithm.

Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by ishanhegde on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @06:53AM (#38362427)
An anonymous social media could work if you moderate it extensively and/or restrict who can sign up in the first place. Not to mention, the need to monetize or support the site.

Creating a good Social Media site is a hard problem IMO.

For all the snark Hacker News gets, I think its not a bad attempt at creating a tech focused social media. Reddit and its many subreddits is something else that works to some extent.

Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by numpad0 on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @09:56AM (#38364427)
I don't think complete anonymity is the way to go. It'll attract clinical psycho people with actual difficulty understanding identities and ethics. I've seen it. They'd have difficulty understanding who posted which, have too little incentives to listen to anything, and openly complain that they would have to follow rules if enforced. All in straight faces.

For a social media to work, some sort of consequences must be forced upon responsible users. Else people quits functioning. I'm guessing that the reward scoring don't have to be exposed to the public, but there has to be something, and forcing users have pseudonymous usernames is a workable implementation.

Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by carlossouza on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @06:43AM (#38362351)
“Show me the incentive and I will show you the outcome.”

Charlie Munger

Re:Blogging is different from tweeting by ChrisRR on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @09:10AM (#38363804)
Tweeting is shouting into the void. You're not interested in getting a conversational response, but interested in how many impressions you make

The twitter UI is just not designed for conversation.