From legal and career point of view - no one will say that, outside of a courthouse or memoirs published in like 15 years from now.
This points to 2 things - First, it really is only the board who know the details because anyone else would've leaked it. Second, the board has lost faith in the reason because if they thought it was good they'd have leaked it by now.
It alleged that Sam funneled a lot of money to his AI chip company startup.
There’s a world of difference between those two things.
I could understand board concerns about him being spread too thin, but more chip competition would pretty clearly benefit OpenAI as a large consumer of GPU chips, and this is very different than any sort of allegation around mishandling of funds (which has been ruled out by several people anyway).
There certainly appears to be a conflict of interest in Altman trying to create an NVidia competitor, and proliferation of AI, and seeing as he was seeking middle eastern funds it also raises questions about US limits on export of AI tech.
It appears Sam has joined Microsoft instead.
So perhaps it wasn't actually much of a real deal.
Organizations used to do that, from time to time. Maybe some still do.
Or maybe they can't release what the reason was because they don't actually have a good one, and trying to say what their reason was would just make them look either evil or incompetent.
And as long as they're silent, we can't tell which it is. Given how badly this has been handled, though, "incompetent" seems likely...
They certainly could have communicated better, but most of the actually good reasons are stuff you wouldn't expect a board to disclose, like "we told you not to do this large unannounced deal with a publicly listed company that we intend to totally renegotiate" or or "you lied about how much this tech sucks" or "you keep lying about this in-progress initiative we haven't announced yet and don't intend to launch in your departure notice"
It's extremely strange to make it clear the firing is for cause, and to be vague about the cause, and then to issue statements that whatever the cause was it was not related to fiduciary issues or AI safety. It really does amount to "he did something really bad that created a crisis we had no choice but to respond to precipitously... but it wasn't all that bad and we don't want to talk about it" situation.
I think "incompetent seems likely" is the only reasonable conclusion here.
It's hard to think of what they could have said that would have been worse than what they did.
Sam and his allies have been extremely effective at getting their voice out on all the media outlets over the weekend. The OpenAI board, on the other hand, seems to have broken apart already.
oh good. I can skip reading a million HN posts on this drama. Thanks for pointing this out.
Sure, you can argue that they thought they could persuade people Sam had done something bad.... but they haven't even tried! They've said basically nothing specific about what he was doing wrong.
You would've thought they knew if they were going to do it they needed a bloody good reason yet we haven't even heard them try to justify it.