News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by Animats on Sunday November 19, 2023 @05:26PM (#38339054)
> In the 1950s, at the height of McCarthyism, 13.4 percent of Americans reported that “felt less free to speak their mind than they used to.” In 1987, the figure had reached 20 percent. By 2019, 40 percent of Americans reported that they did not feel free to speak their minds. This isn’t a partisan issue, either. Gibson and Sutherland report that, “The percentage of Democrats who are worried about speaking their mind is just about identical to the percentage of Republicans who self-censor: 39 and 40 percent, respectively.”

That's a scary number. And it's probably not wrong.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by pavel_lishin on Sunday November 19, 2023 @05:39PM (#38339218)
I certainly keep my mouth shut about certain things, lest the people whose beliefs I find vile and unconscionable (and who view mine the same way) ostracize me, or worse, my child in the community.

Far better to gently feel people out before revealing my beliefs entirely.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by rayiner on Sunday November 19, 2023 @10:35PM (#38341972)
And you gotta socialize your kids to keep their mouths shut too. My daughter (who is 11) attends a progressive school, and she’s intuited that there’s a de-facto racial hierarchy that she’s none too happy about. (She was recently invited to attend a school-sponsored weekly lunch for black girls, but once a month because she’s half white and half south Asian and I guess that’s how the math works out.) I pointed out that she needs to keep her mouth shut about it if she doesn’t want to get cancelled, and she didn’t even fight me on it. She understood.
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by sgu999 on Sunday November 19, 2023 @11:35PM (#38342300)
What a strange society you live in... I don't see how any kind of racial segregation can help the next generation do better than the previous one.

Having to explain to your kid that they can't do X because of their phenotype feels simply wrong.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by iinnPP on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:49AM (#38344951)
Racism has to be a negative for you to feel like that.
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by david-gpu on Monday November 20, 2023 @07:54AM (#38347278)
The elephant in the room is the widespread social acceptance of "girls only" and "women only" clubs/associations/events. To me they elicit the exact same response as "whites only" organizations would, except I've never actually seen the latter IRL.

The saddest part to me is that this form of segregation is championed by people who identify as socially progressive.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by pen2l on Monday November 20, 2023 @02:23AM (#38343886)
I wish rayiner-c.2008 could meet rayiner-2023. So that the former could clue the latter in to how acerbic and off-putting he sometimes sounds, and maybe to chill down a little bit, and to accept and nod to the complicated history of different peoples, and to have compassion and understanding and humility in the face of the very complicated world we live in.
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by forgingahead on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:43AM (#38344884)
His daughter is getting discriminated against, and you have word salad justification for that?
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by rayiner on Monday November 20, 2023 @08:01AM (#38347351)
It was easy for me to have theoretical ideas about culture when I wasn’t trying to raise three mixed kids in that culture.
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by selimthegrim on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @04:55PM (#38370859)
I grew up mixed just fine, we just didn’t have TikTok and smartphones.
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by zlg_codes on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:37PM (#38354312)
A lot of words to essentially say 'you and your family should face discrimination because other people had some bad things that happened to them, or their ancestors, so we're giving ourselves permission to ostracize based on identity'

Bigotry and hatred by another name.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by selimthegrim on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @04:55PM (#38370871)
You realize in the UK no one would bat an eye at that (see Southall _Black_ Sisters)
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by rayiner on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @07:07PM (#38372527)
I don’t see the relation between racially segregated activities in a US school, and a UK non-profit that helps minorities and migrants facing domestic violence. (One that, looking at the Wikipedia page, seems kinda racist insofar as it focuses on domestic violence among Asians specifically, as if there isn’t plenty of domestic violence among white Britons.)

And I disagree that people in the UK wouldn’t take exception to segregating students by race and declaring half south asian people to be 1/4 of a black person for purposes of such activities: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/10/23/right-is-winning...

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by tptacek on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @09:34PM (#38373928)
I live in an ultra-progressive big blue city suburb, spend a fair amount of time in local politics (which revolve around our schools, and particularly equity) and I don't know anyone who wouldn't say that was deeply fucked up. You worry about cancellation, but you could probably get news coverage for that decision. It is deeply not normal.
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by fasthands9 on Sunday November 19, 2023 @06:16PM (#38339646)
I'm not sure the solution. The problem seems to be a less homogenous society with less homogeneous viewpoints, rather than society getting actually less accepting of speech.

It's pretty easy to speak your mind (both then and now) when your opinion is in the majority.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by lapcat on Sunday November 19, 2023 @07:08PM (#38340163)
I'm not sure that it's scary. After all, casual racism and sexism used to be a lot more common in the past. Now people are called out and criticized on those. Is that bad?

The other factor is the rise of internet social media, which didn't exist back then. When people spoke their mind, it wasn't broadcast publicly to the whole world, so there was less fear of backlash.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by patrick451 on Sunday November 19, 2023 @07:18PM (#38340276)
Yes. Just like sexuality, racisism and sexism are part of what it means to be human. They are all natural instincts. Suppressing them is leading to the same sort of dysfunction that sexual suppression lead to in the Victorian age. That said, in the same way it's not healthy for society to be full of sexual deviants, it's also not healthy for it to be full of flaming racists. Moderation in all things, but nothing wrong with a little here and there.
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by lapcat on Sunday November 19, 2023 @07:28PM (#38340387)
> Moderation in all things, but nothing wrong with a little here and there.

Would you say the same about rape, violence, and murder? Those seem like "natural instincts". Nothing wrong with a little here and there?

I would dispute that racism and sexism are "just like" sexuality, and I would also dispute that all "natural instincts", you might call them animal instincts, ought to be accepted and encouraged. One of the great accomplishments of humanity is to rise above our animal instincts and become, at least temporarily, rational and enlightened.

Sex is necessary for the propagation of the species, and when done right, it's consensual to all parties and also pleasurable, harming nobody. Can you say the same about racism and sexism?

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by intalentive on Sunday November 19, 2023 @07:58PM (#38340675)
Not sure how you define sexism, but more traditional patriarchal groups have higher birth rates and more social cohesion. In the long run those traits propagate themselves. The stereotypical cat lady, not so much.

As far as racism, it may not propagate the species but surely it helps propagate those genetically closer to oneself. Isn’t in-group preference pretty common? Don’t need to be EO Wilson or Richard Dawkins to see why.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by lapcat on Sunday November 19, 2023 @08:51PM (#38341154)
> Not sure how you define sexism

How do you define sexism? I'm not sure how the "stereotypical cat lady" is even relevant.

> more traditional patriarchal groups have higher birth rates

I don't think we need higher birth rates at this point, with over 8 billion humans on Earth already.

> As far as racism, it may not propagate the species but surely it helps propagate those genetically closer to oneself. Isn’t in-group preference pretty common?

Romantic preferences are not racism. Would you say that failure to be bisexual is sexism? (Spoiler: it's not.)

It's crucial to recognize, though, that romantic preferences are entirely subjective. If you consider your romantic preferences to be objectively superior humans and those who aren't to your preference objectively inferior humans who deserve a lower rank in society, that would be racism and/or sexism.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by melagonster on Sunday November 19, 2023 @09:12PM (#38341321)
Richard Dawkins said biologists don't offer any indication of ethics. we made by evolution and nature doesn't mean we should live as beast.
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by patrick451 on Monday November 20, 2023 @01:00AM (#38343090)
With no god, why not? It doesn't matter one way or the other.
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by fragmede on Sunday November 19, 2023 @08:21PM (#38340893)
> it's not healthy for society to be full of sexual deviants

I'm under the impression that homosexuality is largely accepted in the western world, and that largely, western society hasn't been destroyed like Sodom and Gomorrah.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by pauldenton on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:00PM (#38353695)
Seeking of suppression of desire and sexual deviants, is that what you would tell to people who want to change their gender? Would you tell them it would be healthier for society if they didn't become transgender?
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by fioiu on Monday November 20, 2023 @09:57PM (#38358446)
They should prepare to be disappointed. A change of name, a change of wardrobe, medication, maybe even surgery - none of this is going to get then what they really want, even if some other people play along with this out of sympathy.
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by grif-fin on Sunday November 19, 2023 @07:49PM (#38340609)
>I'm not sure that it's scary. After all, casual racism and sexism used to be a lot more common in the past. Now people are called out and criticized on those. Is that bad?

Isn't it scary or least worrying that 40 percent of Americans reported that they did not feel free to speak their minds? Or are you implying they belong to the group who participated in casual racism and sexism that used to be a lot more common in the past and now people (majority of the other 60%) are calling them out and criticize them on those hence concluding not scary and perhaps good?

I find it scary too.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by lapcat on Sunday November 19, 2023 @07:55PM (#38340659)
> Or are you implying they belong to the group who participated in casual racism and sexism that used to be a lot more common in the past

Some of them do, yes.

However, "The other factor is the rise of internet social media, which didn't exist back then." In the past, there was no such thing as being afraid of speaking your mind on social media. You were typically speaking your mind in private, among friends and family. This very conversation that we're having now would have never occurred in 1957, or even 1987.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by grif-fin on Sunday November 19, 2023 @08:06PM (#38340766)
I would argue having significant part of a society whether right or wrong in anyone's view having their thoughts not disclosed and represented to the rest of the society should be worrying for everyone in that society.

The history of our nature has shown self-censorship usually erupts by the most radicals of that group which is an uglier problem to have I would think than allowing their right or wrong thoughts to be out in the light.

>The other factor is the rise of internet social media, which didn't exist back then.

This to me only highlights the extend to which we should be worried rather than exaggerating it.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by h2odragon on Sunday November 19, 2023 @08:01PM (#38340712)
Example: "People should be judged by the content of their character, not the color of their skin"

Saying that phrase, went from forbidden, to controversial, to "you're not allowed to disagree," to "you're not allowed to agree" so rapidly.

Someone who actually holds it as a principle has had enemies on all sides at various times. Many of those who find the phrase offensive are not offended because it clashes with their principles, but because it strikes at the status / tribe signal positions they've adopted.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by warkdarrior on Sunday November 19, 2023 @08:15PM (#38340839)
I missed the memo that I am not allowed to agree with that quote. When did this happen?
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by h2odragon on Sunday November 19, 2023 @08:34PM (#38341001)
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/11/colorblind...

https://academic.oup.com/socpro/article-abstract/66/4/503/52...

I quoted MLK (as above) at someone in 2020 and was quite surprised when it uncorked a rant about how that must mean i was a racist and didn't care for the struggles of the oppressed and so on.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by lapcat on Sunday November 19, 2023 @08:57PM (#38341205)
Crucially, MLK said "I have a dream" about "one day" in the future. But MLK wasn't dumb enough to think that people could just magically declare racism to be over now without doing anything to address the social inequities and inequalities caused by centuries of historical racism.
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by h2odragon on Sunday November 19, 2023 @09:26PM (#38341422)
Moving the "colored" seats from the back of the bus to the front, is not doing anything to address the inequities, either.
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by lern_too_spel on Monday November 20, 2023 @01:45PM (#38352457)
Moving seats obviously doesn't address the economic inequalities. That's why nobody (except maybe some conservatives arguing in bad faith) has ever proposed it.
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by pauldenton on Monday November 20, 2023 @02:55PM (#38353598)
Punishing people who were never victimizers and promoting people who were never victims for the sake of equity doesn't address the problems of a single parent household and the consequences it has for children, but that is proposed for the sake of Equity all the time
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by lapcat on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:26PM (#38354142)
Greater equality is not a "punishment". It's simply a necessity for a functional, just, compassionate society.

In any case, we are all beneficiaries or victims of the past. Children don't start from equal positions. "average per capita wealth of White Americans was $338,093 in 2019 but only $60,126 for Black Americans" https://www.minneapolisfed.org/article/2022/how-the-racial-w...

As stated by the linked article, this is actually a vast improvement from 150 years ago. But let's not pretend that the existence of the racial gap wasn't the result of historical factors. Arguing that we're all equal now would just be sticking one's head in the sand and pretending that history didn't exist.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by lern_too_spel on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:38PM (#38354325)
"Punishing people" is an immature way of looking at public policy. When the government uses my tax money to pay for prisons, is that punishing me? The point is that the policy is meant for the public benefit, and we can debate the merits of each policy on their outcomes.

What addresses the problems of a single parent household then? Let's hear your solutions.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by zmgsabst on Sunday November 19, 2023 @08:32PM (#38340984)
When people started saying it to oppose re-introducing systemic racism, such as Harvard being racist to Asian students.
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by Georgelemental on Sunday November 19, 2023 @08:18PM (#38340865)
> I'm not sure that it's scary. After all, casual racism and sexism used to be a lot more common in the past. Now people are called out and criticized on those. Is that bad?

Even if we grant that the rise in self-censorship is entirely due to "casual racism and sexism" (and I don't grant it), wouldn't that meant that 40% of people are secret bigots? That sounds bad, you would rather they be open about their beliefs so you can identify them, no?

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by SantalBlush on Sunday November 19, 2023 @08:37PM (#38341030)
Not if they do that crap in the workplace.
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by lapcat on Sunday November 19, 2023 @09:10PM (#38341301)
> I don't grant it

Neither do I.

> people are secret bigots? That sounds bad, you would rather they be open about their beliefs so you can identify them, no?

I don't know how much of a secret it is. This tends to be fairly obvious regardless of whether people say it openly, and depending on which circles you spend time in, you tend to hear it already in private anyway. Perhaps there are many people who were naive, ignorant, sheltered, and are shocked to learn about bigotry, but speaking only for myself, I'm not at all surprised by the continuing level of bigotry in society, and I knew it before the rise of social media.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by iinnPP on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:56AM (#38345044)
Odd. None of my private conversations are racist or sexist. Turns out I grew up in the short period where all racism is bad. I'm thankful for that.
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by lapcat on Monday November 20, 2023 @06:43AM (#38346639)
> Turns out I grew up in the short period where all racism is bad.

There was no such period. Like I said, it depends on which circles you spend time in (e.g. your family). Sounds like you were just sheltered from it.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by iinnPP on Monday November 20, 2023 @09:08AM (#38348339)
The message is what I'm talking about. I sure as hell wasn't sheltered either, I was as far from sheltered as it gets.
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by breakyerself on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:31PM (#38374738)
There is a dissonance here you aren't seeing.
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by mlinhares on Sunday November 19, 2023 @08:26PM (#38340932)
The fact that in almost 2024 people still don't understand social media is NOT your friends in a table where you can make shitty comments with no consequences still baffles me.

People always have had to separate public and private life, the only differences now is that it seems like they don't understand what is public or private anymore.

I frequently see people making public comments on social networks about their employers or customers that no one should be making, they get fired and then complain there's no "free speech" anymore. The stupidity is really something.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by pauldenton on Monday November 20, 2023 @02:59PM (#38353674)
This just seems like a very natural back and forth You complain on social media about your employer and how they mistreated you They fire you for making them look bad by describing how they treated you Your view of them as a bad employer is reinforced and you warn people not to work for them Their view of you as a bad employee is reinforced and they earn people not to hire you. In both cases people's views are reinforced by reality. Where's the bug?
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by vintermann on Monday November 20, 2023 @06:11AM (#38346318)
Do you think people are equally racist and sexist today as then? Surely not, it would be terrible news if that was true.

It was possible to get ostracized over racism and especially sexism in the 1960s, or even the 1890s, you just had to do worse things to do it generally.

If more people are afraid of ostracism, that suggest ostracism has increased (even) faster than progress on racism and sexism, and that doesn't sound like it can go on forever.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by lapcat on Monday November 20, 2023 @06:51AM (#38346711)
> If more people are afraid of ostracism, that suggest ostracism has increased (even) faster than progress on racism and sexism, and that doesn't sound like it can go on forever.

Ostracism is progress on racism and sexism. It's society pushing back against them.

This is a very long war. Wars are ugly. If you think that racism and sexism will just go down quietly without a fight, well, that's not how it works. When they feel most threatened, that's when they'll make the most noise.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by vintermann on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @03:57AM (#38361142)
> Ostracism is progress on racism and sexism.

It is absolutely not. Ostracism is - at best - a means towards the end, of ending racism and sexism. One of many. It may work, or it may backfire.

> This is a very long war.

If you can't tell the difference between the means and the goal, it's not just a long war, it's a classic forever war.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by lapcat on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @07:18AM (#38362630)
To put it more precisely, I could have said that ostracism is a sign of progress. In large part, ostracism is neither a "rational" means nor a goal: it's an emotional reaction to what the ostracizer views as unacceptable behavior. But it's still a sign that the tide is turning in society.
Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by xyzelement on Sunday November 19, 2023 @08:44PM (#38341092)
I wouldn't dismiss the partisan nature of this. The intolerant minority on the extreme-left that is making it dangerous to speak your mind because they are trigger-happy to label anyone racist/trans-phobic/etc. To that group, a mainstream democrat is just as much an enemy as a republican. So it's no surprise that many democrats don't feel safe voicing their previously mainstream opinions either.

An interesting bottle I see uncorking lately is a lot of mainstream democrats are "waking up" to how far left a relatively small number of people have dragged their whole team, so we'll see what happens there.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by yoniyoniyoni on Sunday November 19, 2023 @09:54PM (#38341661)
I wouldn't even consider these 'extreme left' or 'far left' people to really be on the left, they're like a whole other ideology separate from that.

For instance, someone whose advocacy is fixated mostly around demolishing women's spaces for the pleasure of men, or is obsessed with manifesting racial divides everywhere they look, has really missed the point. They're not even attempting to achieve a society based on egalitarian ideals, all they want to do is set up and maintain new identarian hierarchies.

Re:Why Dumb Ideas Capture Smart and Successful People by jLaForest on Sunday November 19, 2023 @09:23PM (#38341405)
I don't find that number scary or surprising... I'm less likely to overhear racial slurs being thrown around in casual conversation now compared to the past, some selfcensorship is good

Not everyone thinks political correctness is bad