News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by kromem on Sunday November 19, 2023 @04:51PM (#38338595)
For context, this is the drug being discussed:

> Depo-Provera is a well-known brand name for medroxyprogesterone acetate, a contraceptive injection that contains the hormone progestin. Depo-Provera is given as an injection every three months. Depo-Provera typically suppresses ovulation, keeping your ovaries from releasing an egg. It also thickens cervical mucus to keep sperm from reaching the egg.

https://www.mayoclinic.org/tests-procedures/depo-provera/abo...

Given this is a temporary acting drug, and the term 'sterilization' typically refers to at least partially irreversible surgical interventions, the headline is quite misleading and better characterized as "Forced contraception" or - given the available details - "Giving contraception without informed consent"

Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by kevinventullo on Sunday November 19, 2023 @05:14PM (#38338901)
Is the outcome not the same? This is splitting hairs on an egregiously unethical policy.

The investigation also reported an almost 50% decline in the birth rate of Ethiopian women in the prior decade. A government official acknowledged the practice of injecting women of Ethiopian origin with the long-acting contraceptive Depo-Provera in 2013…

…A Channel 10 poll indicated that a majority of Israelis support expelling African migrants from the country, with 56% in favor of the government’s decision to deport the migrants.

Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by mola on Sunday November 19, 2023 @05:30PM (#38339101)
The Ethiopian immigrants are Jews, they are legal immigrants, infact Israel invested a lot to help them reach it and they are citizens. You will not find any poll saying any significant number of Israelis want to expel them.

The African immigrants the poll is talking about, are illegal immigrants, that passed the border illegally, they are not citizens. Some are asylum seekers from Arithrea. The depo-provera scandal was a big deal in Israel, investigated by our press, and government agencies.

This piece is part of an ongoing Iranian campaign to destroy Israel, and make ppl in the west forget about the heinous massacare that happened on Oct 7. Where Hamas terrorists invaded Israel and attacked villages killing whole families in bed, raping mothers Infront of their children. Killing babies. Gauging eyes. Burning children alive. And taking hundreds of hostages, aged 9momth to 90 year old.

Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by richbell on Sunday November 19, 2023 @06:06PM (#38339521)
> This piece is part of an ongoing Iranian campaign to destroy Israel, and make ppl in the west forget about the heinous massacare that happened on Oct 7. Where Hamas terrorists invaded Israel and attacked villages killing whole families in bed, raping mothers Infront of their children. Killing babies. Gauging eyes. Burning children alive. And taking hundreds of hostages, aged 9momth to 90 year old.

Yes, that's terrible. However, your comment is whataboutism that is trying distract from the subject of the article using emotionally charged language.

Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by mola on Sunday November 19, 2023 @06:15PM (#38339635)
No, it is context for the sudden interest in a scandal discussed to death in Israel over 10 years ago. It's not about exposing some scandal, it's about framing Israel as some psychotic evil thing thus legitimizing massacares such that happened on Oct7, and turning public opinion rabidly against Israel

I'll be the last person to defend everything Israel does, but bloodthirsty evil we are not.

Oh, and I'm not using emotional rhetoric, I'm really feeling these emotions. You have no idea what we have been through, and then seeing the barrage of unhinged lies and half truths being thrown against us really is scary and disheartening.

Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by nick_ on Sunday November 19, 2023 @06:29PM (#38339770)
But many Israelis are, even openly, bloodthirsty. This is well documented and trivial to find on mainstream social media platforms. Obviously (though I want spell it out because I genuinely do not want to upset you), the same is true of many Gazans and those who sympathize with their plight.

Please do not, as you just did, imply that to criticize Israeli policies is to legitimize the horrors brought upon thousands of innocent civilians on Oct 7. That is a false dichotomy. Furthermore, a personal endeavour to split every hair on this topic while emotionally compromised will likely lead to a negative mental health outcome.

Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by richbell on Sunday November 19, 2023 @06:26PM (#38339742)
> No, it is context for the sudden interest in a scandal discussed to death in Israel over 10 years ago.

Do you have proof that Iran is responsible for the linked post? If not, I wouldn't consider that providing context.

> It's not about exposing some scandal, it's about framing Israel as some psychotic evil thing thus legitimizing massacares such that happened on Oct7, and turning public opinion rabidly against Israel.

How can you make that claim? Also, turning opinion against Isreal (by highlighting things they've done) and legitimizing killing innocents are not part and parcel. People being informed about both sides of a conflict is a good thing, isn't it?

> Oh, and I'm not using emotional rhetoric, I'm really feeling these emotions. You have no idea what we have been through, and then seeing the barrage of unhinged lies and half truths being thrown against us really is scary and disheartening.

I sympathize with you, but even if it's genuine it's still emotionally charged rhetoric.

Your comment comes across as "this thing that happened 10 years ago doesn't matter because Hamas attacked Israel recently". It's a nonsequitor that makes your sentiment appear disingenuous, even if it isn't.

Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by mola on Sunday November 19, 2023 @06:46PM (#38339945)
When I see people pulling down posters of the hostages. And hear chants for a free Palestine from the river to the sea, I see it as legitimization of the massacre. "Free Palestine from the river to the sea" means no Israel at all, it means the expulsion or genocide of all Jews in Israel. If you know the geography you'll know there is no other way to interpret that chant.

I have no idea what you specifically think or believ, but understand, what we have been through is extremely dark and brutal. And we are not even out of our mourning for the dead, we still have hundreds of people missing. We saw videos of brutalized innocents. This is not "information" for me, it's a tragedy I'm still living through.

The funny sad thing is that the people who got brutalized mostly come from communities who are staunch supporters of a two state solution and ending the Israeli occupation. One of the murdered ran a program for giving gazan children treatments in Israeli hospitals.

I don't know why I'm writing all of this, but understand, I'm not having an intellectual discussion here. This is a tragedy I'm living through. We are in pain here, and it really is hard to cope with that while seeing vile attacks on US campuses, and reading here, this little sanctuary of tech I can enjoy for a bit, thinly vailed libel and half truths. (Not that I blame you specifically.)

Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by enterprise_cog on Sunday November 19, 2023 @09:22PM (#38341394)
You’re just repeating hasbara talking points.

River to the sea doesn’t mean ethnically cleansing, like Israel has done to Palestinians. It means a one state solution, with Arabs and Jews as equals. You choose to interpret it as a call for genocide, but I get why you do: projection.

Quick question: how many of those dead on the 7th were due to IDF attacking Israelis? How many hostages have died from IAF airstrikes?

You talk about brutal videos of the 7th, when you can see the same thing and worse every single day in Gaza. You talk about tragedy when 1000s of kids in Gaza have died and you don’t seem to care. Only Israelis dying matter to you. I wonder why.

Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by kromem on Sunday November 19, 2023 @07:22PM (#38340320)
Is providing medical treatment without informed consent unethical? Absolutely.

But the outcome between regular administration of a drug that wears off in less than 10 months and surgical interventions that are mostly irreversible permanently sterilizing someone are very different things and not "splitting hairs."

As well, you are deliberately ignoring what the article points to as other factors which might be in part playing into differences in birthrates:

> A 2016 study argued that the rapid decline in fertility rates among Ethiopian Israeli women following their migration to Israel was not the result of the administration of Depo-Provera, but rather the product of urbanization, improved educational opportunities, a later age of marriage and commencement of childbirth, and an earlier age of cessation of childbearing[1].

Was there a decline in birthrates? Yes. Was that in part because of an unethical dosing off a drug without informed consent or under coercive conditions? Probably.

Is that still a world of difference from permanently sterilizing a population? Yes, very much so.

Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by kevinventullo on Sunday November 19, 2023 @09:26PM (#38341424)
I mean, assuming the drug had any impact at all (which seems extremely likely given this was the sole purpose of the treatment), that means at least some of the impacted women did not have children who otherwise would have. This is effectively the same as permanent sterilization.

Honestly, the horror for me almost lies more in the intent of the policy than the impact. Namely, picking and choosing who gets to reproduce.

Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by kevinventullo on Monday November 20, 2023 @12:08AM (#38342524)
For the women who did not have children that otherwise would have, it is functionally identical to permanent sterilization. Also, in my opinion, the horror here is less about the efficacy of the policy and primarily about the intent behind it.
Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by kromem on Monday November 20, 2023 @12:26AM (#38342709)
How is now stopping the med and have children in 10 months functionally identical to never being able to have children ever in the future?
Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by kevinventullo on Monday November 20, 2023 @11:03AM (#38349807)
Is there any indication that the original policy was to stop after ten months? If the forced contraception is repeatedly administered over a long enough period of time that the women can no longer reproduce, there is no functional difference.
Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by zoky on Sunday November 19, 2023 @09:12PM (#38341315)
Except it’s not even clear that it was public policy, and in fact most likely wasn’t:

> From the available evidence, it appears likely that some Ethiopian women were given contraceptive injections without fully understanding the potential side effects or their alternative options. However, there is no clear evidence indicating that the Israeli government or humanitarian organizations involved purposefully coerced women into receiving injections in an effort to reduce birth rates—though the narrow scope of the investigation into those claims has been criticized.

It sounds like many Ethiopian women went to the same few clinics (likely because ethnic groups tend to form enclaves) where Depo-Provera was commonly prescribed, and some of the women who were prescribed it were not fully informed of the side effects or the alternatives. In fact, the way this was addressed was to issue a directive to doctors and pharmacies not to refill prescriptions unless the recipient understood the ramifications of taking the medication:

> In response to a letter sent by the Association for Civil Rights in Israel in January 2013 and pressure from a number of female members of Israel’s legislature, Ronni Gamzu—the director general of Israel’s Health Ministry—instructed gynecologists in the country’s four health maintenance organizations to cease use of the long-acting contraceptive injection in question, Depo-Provera, if there were any questions around the patient’s comprehension of the treatment. Gamzu reportedly directed medical providers “not to renew prescriptions for Depo-Provera if for any reason there is concern that [the patient] might not understand the ramifications of the treatment.”

So while some women may not have been fully aware of the side-effects of the medication or been aware of alternatives (perhaps due to language barriers or doctors simply not going into detail as they should have), there is scant evidence that any of these women were unaware that they were taking birth control or did not desire to do so. And there is zero evidence that these injections were in any way “forced”; these women were voluntarily refilling their prescriptions, not being told to take the medication or risk deportation.

This all sounds like somebody with an anti-Israel bias took what amounts to a relatively minor medical ethics issue and twisted it into claims of “forced sterilization”. That’s what’s really unethical here.

Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by kevinventullo on Monday November 20, 2023 @12:04AM (#38342490)
This all sounds like somebody with an anti-Israel bias…

According to the article, the original report aired on the Israeli Educational Television show Vacuum: https://www.timesofisrael.com/ethiopian-women-claim-israel-f...

The anchor interviewed Ethiopian women who said they thought the shots were vaccinations. “The women claimed Israeli representatives from the Joint Distribution Committee (JDC) and the Health Ministry told them that raising large families is especially difficult, that it is for hard people with many children to find work and support their families, and that many landlords would not be willing to rent apartments to large families.”

This is from Times Of Israel, not Al Jazeera.

Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by compsciphd on Monday November 20, 2023 @04:45AM (#38345544)
The original reporting in 2012 was done by the open and free media in Israel who try to improve Israel.

The article posted today by "Chris Jeffries" on medium and then posted here, is meant to be propaganda against Israel in the intent to destroy it.

looking at post history, almost every single post made by that user has been killed here. Most not on Israel. Which would indicate propeganda user without real value.

Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by zoky on Monday November 20, 2023 @06:56AM (#38346757)
> The anchor interviewed Ethiopian women who said they thought the shots were vaccinations.

I'm gonna have to call bullshit here. And honestly, it's kind of racist and sexist bullshit.

1) How does anybody believe that the “vaccinations” they are being given have to be re-administered every three months?

2) Why would these “vaccinations” only apply to women? Do you think the women getting these injections are too stupid to notice that, for whatever reason, their husbands and sons aren't required to get them?

3) Depo-Provera is known to reduce or eliminate womens' periods, as are most forms of birth control when taken constantly throughout the menstrual cycle. Do you really think these women are so out of touch with their own bodies that they wouldn't realize that, hey, something just might be wrong, when they haven't gotten their periods in months or years?

Unfortunately, to believe the story as stated above, you have to accept at least one, and possibly all, of these statements at face value. And I fail to see how anybody could accept any of these statements at face value, unless you believe that Ethiopian (read, “Black”) women are generally less intelligent than the rest of humanity, either due to their gender or race.

I'm not trying to be critical of you personally, because I know it's hard to see things from the perspective of another sociological position. But before ascribing viewpoints to a race or gender other than your own, you really should look at things from their point of view, while assuming that they are at least as intelligent as you are while doing so.

Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by kevinventullo on Monday November 20, 2023 @10:50AM (#38349674)
1. COVID boosters were given every six months.

2. There are plenty of preventative treatments that differ between men and women.

It is clear from the reporting that there was a concerted government policy to encourage Ethiopian women to have fewer or no children. The women themselves said they didn’t understand what the shots did. But yeah, the reporters calling attention to this horrific policy are the racist ones, got it.

Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by zoky on Monday November 20, 2023 @02:15PM (#38352937)
> 1. COVID boosters were given every six months.

That’s still way less frequently than every three months. And honestly, that was a really big deal at the time, and there was nothing comparable before that. A vaccine being required every three months, indefinitely, is implausible. And it’s a stupid plan, too; how would they ensure all of these women were compliant with getting the “vaccine” every three months? Vaccine uptake rates are low enough as it is. The only way to ensure women would reliably continue to get these injections is if they are something they actively want—i.e., birth control.

> 2. There are plenty of preventative treatments that differ between men and women.

You can’t seriously expect tens of thousands of women to be injected with birth control and not have any idea of what’s going on. What about when their periods stop and they’re somehow not pregnant? Oh, gee, that’s weird. Guess my daughter and I better keep going back to get these “vaccinations” every three months that my husband and son don’t need for whatever reason.

> It is clear from the reporting that there was a concerted government policy to encourage Ethiopian women to have fewer or no children.

Apparently you didn’t read the article, because it’s actually not clear at all that there was any such policy. It literally says:

> However, there is no clear evidence indicating that the Israeli government or humanitarian organizations involved purposefully coerced women into receiving injections in an effort to reduce birth rates.

> The women themselves said they didn’t understand what the shots did.

No, they didn’t. Nobody said they didn’t understand that these shots were, in fact, birth control. Some women may not have understood what the side-effects were, or that there were other options for birth control.

> But yeah, the reporters calling attention to this horrific policy are the racist ones, got it.

I don’t see how anyone can in good faith call this a policy, much less a “horrific” one. And, yes, to believe that such a policy could have been successful in its supposed goals requires one to believe that tens of thousands of immigrant women were foolish enough to unquestioningly take these “vaccines” every three months despite the obvious changes to their bodies and fertility. In other words, one would have to hold blatantly racist and sexist beliefs for the story to be plausible on its face.

Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by kevinventullo on Monday November 20, 2023 @04:01PM (#38354693)
Hm, there seems to be contradictory reporting. The TOI article states about the television report:

“Furthermore, many of the women claimed they were never told that the shots were to prevent pregnancy. Rather, they were under the impression that the shots were vaccinations.”

But the detailed investigation from Isha L’Isha (http://isha.org.il/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/%D7%93%D7%A4%D...), which also conducted interviews with the women, made no such claim, focusing instead on the lack of understanding of side effects and alternatives.

Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by zoky on Monday November 20, 2023 @07:07PM (#38356880)
Is it possible that doctors and other officials stressed the importance of family planning and having fewer children to Ethiopian refugees? Almost certainly. Was that appropriate for them to do? That may be debatable, but it hardly rises to any sort of ethics issue.

Were refugees told they had to get vaccinations as a condition for their receiving asylum? Very probably; vaccination is frequently a requirement for asylum seekers in many countries. Were Depo-Provera injections also offered? Yes, we know they were. Were they, like vaccinations, mandatory? There is no evidence that that is the case, and in fact we have several accounts of women electing to stop the injections after getting them for months or years.

Is it possible that some female refugees, many of whom could not read, write or speak Hebrew (or even English) very well at all, were under the mistaken impression that the Depo-Provera injections they were initially offered were part of the vaccine series they were required to take? In theory, sure, or perhaps these women were misremembering the details of what happened while they were in the middle of an incredibly stressful and exhausting situation, and later forgot the distinction between what was required and what was optional. But even in these cases, there is no evidence that the women were forced to continue with the Depo-Provera injections against their will once they realized what they were taking, or even that any of them were ultimately unaware that they were taking birth control.

Does any of this amount to a policy of forced sterilization (or even forced contraception) of immigrants by the Israeli government? That’s a claim that rises beyond irresponsibility to outright dishonesty. But here we are seeing these lies being spread on HN…

Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by kevinventullo on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @12:40AM (#38359815)
I’m literally quoting and linking to original sources and your response is to accuse me of spreading lies.

Your claim that “there is no evidence that the women… were ultimately unaware that they were taking birth control” directly contradicts the TOI quote mentioned above. I don’t know what else to tell you.

Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by IshKebab on Monday November 20, 2023 @02:53AM (#38344180)
Uhm I don't think many people would agree that forced contraception and forced sterilisation are remotely the same thing.
Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:... by kevinventullo on Monday November 20, 2023 @10:54AM (#38349724)
If the forced contraception is repeatedly administered and done over a long enough period of time that the women can no longer reproduce, there is no functional difference.