Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:...
by kevinventullo on Sunday November 19, 2023 @09:26PM
(#38341424)
I mean, assuming the drug had any impact at all (which seems extremely likely given this was the sole purpose of the treatment), that means at least some of the impacted women did not have children who otherwise would have. This is effectively the same as permanent sterilization.
Honestly, the horror for me almost lies more in the intent of the policy than the impact. Namely, picking and choosing who gets to reproduce.
Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:...
by kevinventullo on Monday November 20, 2023 @12:08AM
(#38342524)
For the women who did not have children that otherwise would have, it is functionally identical to permanent sterilization. Also, in my opinion, the horror here is less about the efficacy of the policy and primarily about the intent behind it.
Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:...
by kromem on Monday November 20, 2023 @12:26AM
(#38342709)
How is now stopping the med and have children in 10 months functionally identical to never being able to have children ever in the future?
Re:Israel's Controversial Treatment of Ethiopian Immigrants:...
by kevinventullo on Monday November 20, 2023 @11:03AM
(#38349807)
Is there any indication that the original policy was to stop after ten months? If the forced contraception is repeatedly administered over a long enough period of time that the women can no longer reproduce, there is no functional difference.
But the outcome between regular administration of a drug that wears off in less than 10 months and surgical interventions that are mostly irreversible permanently sterilizing someone are very different things and not "splitting hairs."
As well, you are deliberately ignoring what the article points to as other factors which might be in part playing into differences in birthrates:
> A 2016 study argued that the rapid decline in fertility rates among Ethiopian Israeli women following their migration to Israel was not the result of the administration of Depo-Provera, but rather the product of urbanization, improved educational opportunities, a later age of marriage and commencement of childbirth, and an earlier age of cessation of childbearing[1].
Was there a decline in birthrates? Yes. Was that in part because of an unethical dosing off a drug without informed consent or under coercive conditions? Probably.
Is that still a world of difference from permanently sterilizing a population? Yes, very much so.